San Antonio vs Austin vs in between for rentals? (2021)

San Antonio vs Austin vs in between for rentals? (2021)

Investor · San Jose · Member since 2020 · 10 posts · 11 votes

Hi All, 

I am looking for investment property along the Austin to San Antonio I-35 corridor. The range I am interested in is $200k to $300k property. I am open to either getting more in appreciation (e.g. Austin), or cashflow (San Antonio). However, if it is in Austin the rental income will need to be enough to cover all the expenses (including management fee) for it to work for me. 

So far, my conclusion is rent, as of Feb 2021, its pretty similar in the price range I am looking for in Austin, San Marcos/New Braunfels and San Antonio (Rent all around $1500-$1795 range depending on areas for $200-$300k property) 

Austin: Seems like you have to be willing to go $300k and above but the rent doesnt seem to increase with it, so either you need to put much more in downpayment or be willing to chip in each month for expenses, as an investor. 

New Braunfels/San Marcos: I am considering this area, but I dont know much about it yet. My theory is, as Austin becomes unaffordable, people will move to New Braunfels/San Marcos areas so in my opinion it will appreciate better than San Antonio, with similar cash flow for rental income since price is similar to good areas in San Antonio


San Antonio: 
You get more rental income for San Antonio, I feel that appreciation maybe less for New Braunfels/San Marcos, and less so than Austin. 

Please spark a debate!!! :) Love to hear what you think if you are familiar with Austin to San Antonio area. The realtor I worked with seem to only know either Austin, or San Antonio, so I cant get a full perspective comparing Austin, San Antonio and the in-between rentals. 

Thanks!

Chilann

5Reply
339 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Austin & San Antonio, TX · Member since 2021 · 35 posts · 199 votes
5y

San Antonio 100%. I'm an Austin native and currently living in San Antonio & have been here for about 4 years now - the growth here is rapid these days (just announced 2nd largest growing city in the nation). It's such a large city with so much potential and yet still very affordable investment properties - depending on how much work you're looking to do. Large population will results in a desirable vacancy rate. 

I have dozens of friends I grew up who are constantly telling me they're ready to get out of Austin - the first place they're considering is San Antonio. I think there will be a mass wave of folks moving down I-35 slowly but surely as they look for new opportunities - If you think back to what Kyle/Buda were 10-15 years ago compared to today it's hard to deny the crowds moving further and further south. Same thing going north of Austin with Pflugerville, Round Rock, Hutto, Georgetown, Liberty Hill, Leander areas as you move North/Northwest from Austin. The population is just widening the circle. 

San Marcos is a college town, and NB is still very small with limited activities for people looking for the big city vibes. In my opinion, San Antonio is a real estate gold mine for the future of what San Antonio will be, partially due to the migrations from Austin but there are a lot of pros about this market. 

See this reply in the discussion

34 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Brad LarsenPro Member
    Property Manager · San Antonio and Austin, TX · Member since 2016 · 377 posts · 380 votes
    4y

    We manage about 1100 properties in SA & Austin and every in between. Happy investors everywhere. Definitely looking in the right place(s). People from all over North America have been inquiring about SA specifically. 

  • Jordan MoorheadBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Austin, TX · Member since 2015 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4y

    @Chilann Chan I really like San Marcos, it's still reasonably affordable and a pretty easy commute to both Austin and San Antonio

  • Ryan KellyBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Austin, TX · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4y

    @Chilann Chan for your price range below $300k, the Austin metro is pretty much out of reach. I agree with others who say to focus on San Marcos and the south. You will find far more options that meet your criteria.

    Ryan Kelly Group - Keller Williams5112 Reviews
  • Real Estate Agent · Austin, TX · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 941 votes
    4y

    @Chilann Chan you can cashflow a SFH in Austin if you change your rental strategy from yearly leases to monthly.

  • Member since 2021 · 11 posts · 13 votes
    4y

    @Chilann Chan We just sold one and are about 2 weeks our from listing our second flip in SA. During the process we actually came across and met with another investor who does ABNBs there in SA. Definitely got us interested in and researching the STR aspect there. Always up to meet and discuss with other investors. @Dustin Thomas

  • Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2021 · 12 posts · 8 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Andy V.:

    San Antonio 100%. I'm an Austin native and currently living in San Antonio & have been here for about 4 years now - the growth here is rapid these days (just announced 2nd largest growing city in the nation). It's such a large city with so much potential and yet still very affordable investment properties - depending on how much work you're looking to do. Large population will results in a desirable vacancy rate. 

    I have dozens of friends I grew up who are constantly telling me they're ready to get out of Austin - the first place they're considering is San Antonio. I think there will be a mass wave of folks moving down I-35 slowly but surely as they look for new opportunities - If you think back to what Kyle/Buda were 10-15 years ago compared to today it's hard to deny the crowds moving further and further south. Same thing going north of Austin with Pflugerville, Round Rock, Hutto, Georgetown, Liberty Hill, Leander areas as you move North/Northwest from Austin. The population is just widening the circle. 

    San Marcos is a college town, and NB is still very small with limited activities for people looking for the big city vibes. In my opinion, San Antonio is a real estate gold mine for the future of what San Antonio will be, partially due to the migrations from Austin but there are a lot of pros about this market. 


    Great insight Andy, this is very useful information for an out of state investor like myself. Sending you a request to connect!

  • Austin, TX · Member since 2013 · 47 posts · 12 votes
    4y

    @Chilann Chan In San Antonio I think there's an opportunity for you to have the best of both worlds. Appreciation and Cashflow if you're open to the idea of AirBnb. SA is very STR friendly and homes are still reasonably priced with a high occupancy rate for running a STR. Especially if you're within an Uber ride to some of the main attractions like The Alamo, River Walk, The Pearl, etc. I currently self manage a few Airbnbs in various markets and currently have my eyes set on SA as my next place to purchase a few homes. I'd be happy to share any knowledge I have if you decide to go that route. Good luck on your journey.

  • Investor · Arlington, VA · Member since 2021 · 9 posts · 9 votes
    4y

    Thanks @Account Closed! 

    That is right. We are listing 1118 W Summit in just a few weeks. I was shocked at the rise in home listing prices in just the 5 months we have been following the market. We have recently become interested in STRs in SA too. Good to know it is STR friendly.
    @Ashlie Greising do you primarily co-host? We should chat sometime. I would love to learn more what youre up to. 

    @Lex Wilridge @Qasim Naeem @Ashton Cleveland

  • Austin, TX · Member since 2013 · 47 posts · 12 votes
    4y

    @Dustin Thomas They are properties I own that function as full-time Airbnbs. I'm the main host for each and manage them myself. Let's chat soon, I love the STR game.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.