I’m curious how people are handling the first pass on flips right now. Not the final rehab budget, just the early screen where you decide whether a deal is even worth chasing harder. Comps are usually the easier part for me, but the slower part is deciding whether the repair side is clear enough to justify more time, especially when photos are weak, access is limited, or contractors are already busy.
For those of you doing this regularly, what usually gets a property from “quick look” to “worth a walkthrough / deeper scope”? Is it mostly spread, age/systems, contractor availability, experience, or something else?
I'm screening 20-30 deals a month right now, and honestly the first pass is about 80% market analysis and 20% intuition on the property. What I'm really looking for is whether the spread is there on the repair side -- not perfect estimates, just whether the math could work.
For me it's this: pull comps for the area, figure out realistic ARV, then do a quick drive-by if I can. From photos alone, I'm looking for obvious structural red flags -- foundation cracks, roof that needs full replacement, water damage that goes deep. If those aren't present and the price-to-value gap is actually 20%+ after accounting for rough repairs, that's worth a walkthrough to me. The time I waste is usually on properties where the spread was never real to begin with.
Contractor availability is real though. I've passed on deals because my guy was booked 4 months out. At that point you're just fighting time and carrying costs. What market are you working in? That probably matters more than anything -- some areas you can get estimates in 2 weeks, others it's 6 weeks and the market moves.
I go with familiarity aka I have done something 90-95% similar in similar market, similar work scope. So my past experience and estimate can help me make a quick decision. More uncertainty, more margin is needed for me to worth chasing. Also, there always be a few or more competitions when a deal is worth it,, which is another sign. I use my own money and I always have more than 1 exit strategies so I don't really reply on contractor walkthrough at all. My case may not be a good representation of this substack because I don't do flipping for a living. Flipping happens to be just something good to have on the side.
The spread is everything. I look for deals that can pencil out at 70% ARV or better BEFORE the contractor walkthrough. If the math doesn't work on the back of an envelope -- purchase price, estimated rehab, holding costs, exit costs, profit margin -- then no amount of detailed scoping is going to fix it.
On the initial screen, I'm mostly eliminating deals. Age and systems matter (roofs, HVAC, electrical, foundation), but honestly most properties you'll look at have predictable rehab needs. The real question is: can I buy it at a price that leaves room for my contractor to underestimate and me to still make money? If I need everything to go perfect, I skip it.
The contractor walkthrough isn't about deciding to buy. It's about validating you haven't missed something obvious. Weak photos, limited access -- that's when it's worth paying $300-500 to get professional eyes on it. But before that, your own due diligence with comps and ARV should tell you whether the spread exists.
When you're screening deals from photos and descriptions, what's your go/no-go threshold on the initial spread?
Typically I'm not paying for a contractor quote. If you're going to do that might as well get a home inspection. For first pass before under contract try to have your agent do some of the legwork. Get them to do a FaceTime or walkthru video and send lots of photos. Hopefully seller is helpful as well. They should at least be able to answer some basic questions like age of roof, age of mechanicals, etc. I think you should be more concerned at this stage with actually getting it under contract before diving into a ton of due diligence and potentially wasting time of contractors. You can get an inspection period and re negotiate price if repair costs come in higher, or back out if they're too high or seller won't budge on price.
Typically I'm not paying for a contractor quote. If you're going to do that might as well get a home inspection. For first pass before under contract try to have your agent do some of the legwork. Get them to do a FaceTime or walkthru video and send lots of photos. Hopefully seller is helpful as well. They should at least be able to answer some basic questions like age of roof, age of mechanicals, etc. I think you should be more concerned at this stage with actually getting it under contract before diving into a ton of due diligence and potentially wasting time of contractors. You can get an inspection period and re negotiate price if repair costs come in higher, or back out if they're too high or seller won't budge on price.
The photos and preliminary comps tell you a lot, but you're right that the repair picture is usually the blocker. Here's what I use as a first-pass screen: age of major systems (roof, HVAC, foundation, electrical, plumbing), whether you can visually identify structural issues from the listing photos, and what the neighborhood's floor plan typically rehabs for.
If the photos are weak or you can't get a contractor's time, that's actually your biggest signal. A busy contractor in a hot market means deals are moving. That said, I've never paid for a walkthrough on a property that didn't pencil first on comps and a rough math on systems. The math has to work before you're even thinking about driving over there. If a property needs a 50k rehab to hit your number and the comps don't support it, you're chasing it.
One thing that changed my screening: I started looking at days-on-market and absorption rates for similar properties in that neighborhood. Fast-moving comps mean the area rehabs well. Slow-moving ones mean either your numbers are off or the neighborhood has headwinds. That tells me whether it's worth digging deeper.
What's your typical spread target on the flips you're looking at, and are you finding that contractors are bottlenecking your deal flow right now?
I’m curious how people are handling the first pass on flips right now. Not the final rehab budget, just the early screen where you decide whether a deal is even worth chasing harder. Comps are usually the easier part for me, but the slower part is deciding whether the repair side is clear enough to justify more time, especially when photos are weak, access is limited, or contractors are already busy.
For those of you doing this regularly, what usually gets a property from “quick look” to “worth a walkthrough / deeper scope”? Is it mostly spread, age/systems, contractor availability, experience, or something else?
This is the most expensive filter to get wrong. Here's what kills the most deals before walkthrough: wrong spread. I see investors pay 00-800 for a contractor estimate on a property that only has 15-20K equity built in. That contractor shows up, finds one surprise (foundation, roof, outdated electrical) and suddenly you're upside down. The first pass is all about math, not details.
Before ANY paid walkthrough, I need: purchase price, estimated ARV, and preliminary rehab range. If the spread doesn't work with your highest reasonable rehab estimate, you don't walk it. Period. That kills 70% of deal flow right there. Age and systems matter, but only if the numbers already work on a high estimate.
The other thing: access and photos tell you more than you think. If photos are weak or access is impossible pre-offer, that's a signal. Could be the seller hiding something, could be a nightmare property. Either way, low-cost solution first -- make an offer with walkthrough contingency. Let them accept it or they don't. That way you filter out the dead deals before paying the contractor.
Are you running into a lot of weak-photo properties in your market, or is it more about contractor timeline availability that's slowing your first pass?
I kill 80% of deals before I call a contractor. Here's my screen: (1) purchase price to comps -- does the math work at 15-20% below current market value? If no, stop. (2) Age and systems -- is this a 1950s house with original electrical, or did someone update foundation/roof/HVAC in the last 15 years? Systems matter more than cosmetics. (3) Bones -- walk the outside, look for foundation cracks, sloping floors, roof condition. Photos help, but you learn more from the YouTube Street View 360 tour and Google Earth timeline if the property's old enough.
The contractor walkthrough happens only if all three pass. Why? Because at that point, you're not paying a contractor to tell you the property is bad -- you already know it's probably good. You're paying them to scope the unknowns and refine the budget.
On availability -- yeah, everyone's busy right now. But contractors that are TOO busy might be skipping steps and burning through budget faster than you expect. I'd rather wait two weeks for a diligent contractor than rush with someone who's overbooked and cutting corners on the estimate.
What's your typical buy-to-active-reno timeline looking like? Are you batching multiple walkthroughs in one market visit, or are properties scattered?
I'm screening 20-30 deals a month right now, and honestly the first pass is about 80% market analysis and 20% intuition on the property. What I'm really looking for is whether the spread is there on the repair side -- not perfect estimates, just whether the math could work.
For me it's this: pull comps for the area, figure out realistic ARV, then do a quick drive-by if I can. From photos alone, I'm looking for obvious structural red flags -- foundation cracks, roof that needs full replacement, water damage that goes deep. If those aren't present and the price-to-value gap is actually 20%+ after accounting for rough repairs, that's worth a walkthrough to me. The time I waste is usually on properties where the spread was never real to begin with.
Contractor availability is real though. I've passed on deals because my guy was booked 4 months out. At that point you're just fighting time and carrying costs. What market are you working in? That probably matters more than anything -- some areas you can get estimates in 2 weeks, others it's 6 weeks and the market moves.
Good question, and Bo's 80/20 framework is how I think about it too.
My first pass before spending any money or anyone's time:
1. Comps first, always. If I can't find 3 sold comps within 0.5 miles in the last 6 months that support my target ARV, I'm out. I don't care how cheap the property is. No comps = no confidence in the exit, and lenders won't like it either.
2. The "photo test." I can usually eliminate 60-70% of deals from listing photos alone. What I'm actually looking for isn't the cosmetic stuff (paint, flooring, fixtures) — I'm looking for the things photos accidentally reveal:
- Cracks above door frames or windows = potential foundation issues
- Stained ceilings = active water intrusion, not just old damage
- Sagging roofline visible from exterior shots = structural, not cosmetic
- Baseboard removal or cut drywall in photos = someone already found a problem and stopped
If I see structural red flags in photos, I either negotiate a much deeper discount or walk. Cosmetic-only rehabs are the only ones worth chasing in this rate environment.
3. Days on market context. A property sitting 90+ days in a market where similar homes sell in 30? There's usually a reason. Could be price, could be access issues, could be title. I check the price history first — if they've already dropped 2-3 times, the seller is motivated and the deal might actually be there.
4. Drive-by before walkthrough. I never pay for a contractor walkthrough without driving by first. 10 minutes in the car tells me about the neighborhood, the lot, the exterior condition, and whether the property matches the listing. I've killed deals from the car because the lot was on a busy road, backed up to commercial, or had grading issues the photos didn't show.
The thing that gets me from "maybe" to "get the contractor out there" is when the spread works even with a conservative rehab estimate. I pad my initial number by 20% before I even call anyone. If it still pencils at that padded number, it's worth the walkthrough.
To Bo's point about contractor availability — that's become the binding constraint. I've started asking contractors for availability windows BEFORE I even identify the property. Knowing I have a crew available in 3 weeks changes which deals I pursue.
It's best to assume full gut and work backward. This way margin loosens, doesn't tighten.
There's a thread going on right now in another section where the investor is in way over their head because they went with best case scenarios and it wasn't.
Where would you rather be? Run numbers with a 25k budget and actually need 75k? Or run numbers with 75K and only use 25k?
The flip game right now is most definitely taking down more people than it is making. Entry points are too high, construction costs are high, execution risk is high, exit risk is high. Targeted returns are small relative to risk. It's like flipping a coin and winning 1:1 when you're right and losing 1.5:1 when you're wrong. The risk is way out of whack but all the books, podcasts, and success stories (of which they're are, no doubt). People flip houses and make that nice clean 50 ball. It happens. Just like if someone tells me they're gonna play in the NFL, I'd say never gonna happen, yet it happens all the time.
I'd say to any people flipping out there, there's 2 strategies that will really help you:
1) Buy as low as possible. It will usually require cash or a private relationship with fast cash. You can enter the bridge loan with rehab after the fact and get cashed out plus get rehab funds. You still use the power of cash and the aid of debt.
2) Don't use a GC. Run the subs yourself. Learn the order of operations. Get relationships with sub contractors for all the trades needed. You hold the money, you control the speed, quality, personnel.
Do those two effectively and you can make money,
It's best to assume full gut and work backward. This way margin loosens, doesn't tighten.
There's a thread going on right now in another section where the investor is in way over their head because they went with best case scenarios and it wasn't.
Where would you rather be? Run numbers with a 25k budget and actually need 75k? Or run numbers with 75K and only use 25k?
The flip game right now is most definitely taking down more people than it is making. Entry points are too high, construction costs are high, execution risk is high, exit risk is high. Targeted returns are small relative to risk. It's like flipping a coin and winning 1:1 when you're right and losing 1.5:1 when you're wrong. The risk is way out of whack but all the books, podcasts, and success stories (of which they're are, no doubt). People flip houses and make that nice clean 50 ball. It happens. Just like if someone tells me they're gonna play in the NFL, I'd say never gonna happen, yet it happens all the time.
I'd say to any people flipping out there, there's 2 strategies that will really help you:
1) Buy as low as possible. It will usually require cash or a private relationship with fast cash. You can enter the bridge loan with rehab after the fact and get cashed out plus get rehab funds. You still use the power of cash and the aid of debt.
2) Don't use a GC. Run the subs yourself. Learn the order of operations. Get relationships with sub contractors for all the trades needed. You hold the money, you control the speed, quality, personnel.
Do those two effectively and you can make money,
"Don't use a GC. Run the subs yourself. "