I have a two year old shingled roof on a rental house in Dundalk, MD (Rowhome). This past Saturday a section of the shingles blew off. We had winds in the 30-40 mph range (gusts). The roofing company does not want to honor the repair under warranty. I didn't see any other homes on the block with missing shingles. I could understand if we had near hurricane level winds, but gusts 30-40, I think the shingles should stay in place. I have a pic, can't figure out how to post it though. Would you push them to cover the repair as part of the warranty? I do have a 10 year warranty, but they say it's for leaks, not shingles being blown off due to wind.
I don't know how anyone can say that's an incorrectly installed shingle based on that picture. Shingles can whip around, crease and break off in a number of ways with strong winds.
We're not saying it based on that picture. We're saying it because the roof is only 2 yrs old and the wind gusts were only 30-40mph. Properly installed, they should be able to withstand winds twice that speed. It appears they were either short-nailed (3 nails instead of 4) or applied using a nailgun with the pressure set too high (over-driven).
@rob gribben: Having seen the pic, it's odd that they wouldn't just come and fix it. It wouldn't take long. If you were closer, I'd come do it for you!
@Mike Reynolds, thanks for the advice Mike.
Rob, Did a patch of shingles blow if in an exact square like it looks like in the picture? If so this won't be the last time. Installation would appear to be a major issue and there inst any easy fix :/
The patch of shingles blew off in the square that you see. I am thinking of having another roofer that a friend referred me to, inspect the roof installation. If there are issues, I write the installer a letter and give him a deadline to make repairs, if he doesn't, then I pay another roofer to make the repairs, and take the original guy to small claims, and file a complaint with MD licensing division. I'm also concerned about future issues with the roof.
So, I think I will send a certified letter to the company owner to get their attention. I left out the company name, don't want to be accused of slander..... But, any suggestions or comments based on what I have below, hit me back:
This letter is in regards to a roof installation that your company completed at 411 Pembrooke Blvd in Baltimore, MD on April 30, 2013.The roof came with a 10 year warranty, for which I have a receipt from your company. On Saturday November 14, a neighbor at 413 Pembrooke Blvd contacted me stating that there were several shingles blown off of my roof and into the surrounding neighbors yards. I contacted XXXXXX Roofing that same day requesting repairs under warranty as soon as possible. I finally was able to get you to make the repairs on Wed Nov 18, the day before we were expecting a major rain event. Had the repairs not been made, there would have been significant water damage to the property.Had water damage occurred, I would have had to take action against XXXXXX Roofing for the damages. Wind gusts on November 14 were in the 30-40 mph range, nowhere near strong enough that shingles should have come loose.There were no other houses in the neighborhood that had shingles come loose.
I am very concerned about the installation of the roof at this property. My concerns are as follows:
1) The overhang off of the edge appears to be extreme. My understanding is that the shingles should be cut flush to the edge.A drip edge is supposed to be installed at the roof edge, and shingles cut flush with it.
2) The shingles that came off, did so in almost a perfect square. I am really concerned that the fasteners were either driven too far into the plywood, or not enough fasteners were used to secure the shingles to the roof.
3) The roofing felt appears to be installed in the wrong direction. My understanding is roof felt should be installed across the roof width, and not along its length. The photograph that I have of the missing shingles, clearly shows the felt paper was installed along the length (top of ridge to gutter) of the roof.
I am requesting that XXXXXX Roofing take these immediate actions to prevent further problems with this roof:
1) Carefully inspect the roof fasteners to ensure all of the roof shingles are secure
2) Correct the excessive overhang of shingles off of the roof edge
3) Inspect the roof at 6917 Gough St (Eastwood installed a new roof on this property for me on April 24, 2013) for similar issues and take corrective actions to ensure no shingles come loose at this property either.
Please understand that both roofs are only a couple of years old, and if there are future issues and XXXXXXX Roofing does not act promptly to return my phone calls and honor their warranty and make the repairs, I will be forced to use another roofer to make the repairs, and then take action against XXXXXX Roofing to recover my costs for repairs.
Sincerely,
Robert F Gribben Jr.