Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2013 · 10 posts · 1 vote
Zillow seems to have a tremendous amount of information about available properties. Looking for houses to flip, do you really need access to the MLS or is monitoring Zillow just as good?
@Renee Munro Not accurate at all. Zillow uses an algorithm to estimate what the comparable sales are. For a general overview of a given subdivision as a whole, it's a decent tool. For determining the ARV of a specific property its near worthless.
Couldn't you ignore the Zestimate and just use Zillow's property info and similar sold properties nearby to calculate your own comps? Or are there still advantages to the MLS?
Redfn has all the details, old sold MLS, Price History, Pending/Contingent/Active/Reactivated/Price Change status, etc.
Trulia is better than Zillow as it shows good deals at the top. like recent price changes new listing etc. But Zillow has ZEstimates, which are very useful and I also love their Q&A section.
Also Zillow and Trulia has information on private auctions like Williams, Hubzu,Auction.com, etc.
MLS data is provided by the realtor. Zillow's property info is generally data mined through various public records databases. Also users can update what Zillow displays. I'd recommend you use both data sources as guidelines for your valuation, setting your expectation. A 4 BR house with unfinished basement is different than a 4 BR house with 3 BR upstairs and 1 BR in a finished basement. In this case MLS might report 4 BR and Zillow might report 3 BR. Ultimately, you will (or should) actually tour the property to get the full picture.
+1 to Keerthi recommendation on Redfin. If it's available in your market, I highly recommend it as a source for MLS data.
Wait Redfin now pulls actual data from the MLS now? Can you get leased comps too? I just hopped on redfin.com to try it out but its very confusing and Im not sure how to pull comps, is there a tutorial?
+1 to Keerthi recommendation on Redfin. If it's available in your market, I highly recommend it as a source for MLS data.
Wait Redfin now pulls actual data from the MLS now? Can you get leased comps too? I just hopped on redfin.com to try it out but its very confusing and Im not sure how to pull comps, is there a tutorial?
Not exactly sure if I understand what you're looking for, but redfin allows you to search recent sales. (Click "More Options", and then "Sale Records" in the bottom left). You probably want to use that "More Options" tab to filter down on your criteria. If you're looking at multifamily houses, those will generally have the income and expense figures that were originally part of the MLS listing.
+1 to Keerthi recommendation on Redfin. If it's available in your market, I highly recommend it as a source for MLS data.
Wait Redfin now pulls actual data from the MLS now? Can you get leased comps too? I just hopped on redfin.com to try it out but its very confusing and Im not sure how to pull comps, is there a tutorial?
No, Samatha.
Redfin does not have rental listings or leased comps.
Redfin is a RE Brokerage agency focussed only on buying/selling, they do not do rentals. People without agents look at it and sometime call Redfin agents who are paid salary not commission. So they do get money form this. They made the software from MLS data. But only for buying, selling. Redfin is already must be paying a lot of money for the MLS data, why would they give out rental info when they do not work on rentals.
My partner on a fix/flip used the MLS to get comps. We compared them to the recent comps that were on Zillow and Trulia, and found them to be same.
I agree that the Zestimate isn't accurate but the recently sold properties are.
Kelly P. is correct. When on Zillow, pull up the house you are researching. Go down the right side of the page until you see similar sales. Click on similar sales. These are the same sales prices that are found on the MLS or county website. I have cross checked them numerous times. The difference will be that in a half mile radius, the MLS may show the data for 10 houses sold while Zillow will show maybe 5 houses sold during the same time period. So you will have less comps, but they are accurate nonetheless.
It's not quite that new. Overall I found it to be quite underwhelming in my market, it often is unable to find a good portion of the comps at all, and the comps it does report tend to have inaccurate sales numbers. I have verified extensively through the MLS.