I analyzed 7,042 Miami-Dade tax deed auction records - here's what actually works

I analyzed 7,042 Miami-Dade tax deed auction records - here's what actually works

Member since 2026 · 1 post · 0 votes
I've spent the last several months pulling apart Miami-Dade County tax deed auction data - purchase prices, resale outcomes, hold times, flood zones, property conditions - and turning it into something usable. Thought I'd share some of what I found, since a lot of the "advice" on tax deed investing is either outdated or based on one person's single deal.
This is based on 222 verified resale outcomes from Miami-Dade tax deed auctions. Not projections. Not Zillow estimates. Actual recorded sales after someone bought at auction, did whatever they did with the property, and sold it.
The numbers that actually matter
Median ROI: 12.49x. But that number is misleading on its own.
The median profit across those 222 resales was about $167K, with a median hold time of around 304 days. Sounds great on paper. But averages hide a lot. Here's what the data actually shows when you break it down:
1. Not all cities perform the same - not even close.
Miami Gardens, Opa-locka, and Florida City consistently show up with higher flip rates and stronger returns. These are areas where acquisition prices at auction tend to stay lower relative to after-repair value, and where there's enough transaction volume to actually find comps.
Meanwhile, some of the "nicer" zip codes in Miami-Dade - Coral Gables, Pinecrest, Key Biscayne - rarely produce viable deals at tax deed auction. The opening bids are already high because of the tax basis, and competitive bidding pushes them past any reasonable margin.
If you're new to Miami-Dade tax deeds, focus on where the math works, not where you'd want to live.
2. The sweet spot on acquisition price is lower than most people think.
The strongest returns cluster in the sub-$50K acquisition range. Once you start pushing past $75-100K at auction, the margin compression is real. You're competing with better-capitalized buyers, the properties tend to need less work (so less value-add opportunity), and your downside risk grows.
The sub-$30K parcels have the widest spread between purchase price and resale, but they also carry the most condition risk. Vacant lots in that range can be strong if you understand the local zoning and demand, but structures under $30K often have serious problems - code violations, environmental issues, or they're in flood zones that make insurance costs a dealbreaker.
3. Hold times are longer than the YouTube crowd suggests.
The median 304-day hold isn't an accident. Tax deed properties come with title clearing requirements (quiet title actions in Florida typically run 3-6 months), then rehab or permitting if it's a structure, then listing and closing. If someone tells you they're flipping tax deed properties in 90 days, they're either skipping steps or stretching the truth.
Plan for 10-12 months on a realistic timeline. Some of the best returns in the dataset came from 12-18 month holds where the buyer cleared title, did modest rehab, and sold into an improving market.
4. Flood zone parcels aren't automatic no-gos, but they require different math.
About 30-40% of Miami-Dade parcels sit in FEMA flood zones. A lot of new buyers see "flood zone" and walk away entirely. Some of those buyers are right - a structure in AE zone with no elevation certificate is a money pit for insurance. But vacant land in flood zones can still work if the end buyer is building new construction to current code (elevated, compliant). The key is knowing which parcels are in which zones before you bid, not after.
Mistakes I see new buyers make repeatedly
Overbidding because they anchored to Zillow. Zillow's "Zestimate" on tax deed properties is frequently garbage. These are often distressed, title-clouded, code-violated properties. Running your numbers off Zillow is how you turn a potential 8x return into a 1.2x return - or a loss.
Ignoring the real cost of quiet title. In Florida, you need to file a quiet title action after purchasing at tax deed auction. Budget $2,500-4,000 in legal fees and 3-6 months of time. This isn't optional - it's a requirement for marketable title. I've seen people buy at auction, realize they can't sell or finance the property without clear title, and then scramble. Build it into your numbers from day one.
Not checking flood zones before auction day. This one is basic, but I still see it. FEMA flood zone designation affects insurance costs, construction requirements, and resale value. Check it before you bid. Not after. Miami-Dade has enough non-flood-zone parcels that you don't need to gamble unless you've done the analysis.
Assuming every parcel is buildable. Vacant lots look cheap at auction, but not all of them are buildable. Setback requirements, platting issues, utility access, wetland designations - these can all kill a deal. Always check with the county before bidding on vacant land.
Where I'm at now
I ended up building a dashboard to score all 7,100+ active tax deed parcels in Miami-Dade by equity potential - grades from A+ down to F - because doing this manually in spreadsheets was eating my life. It pulls in Street View, flood zones, city-level flip rates, and the verified resale data I mentioned above. It's at miamidadetax.com if anyone wants to check it out (there's a free trial).
But honestly, even without a tool, the core lesson from this data is simple: do the work before auction day, not after. Know your target cities, know your price bands, know your flood zones, and budget for quiet title. The deals are there - Miami-Dade runs one of the largest tax deed auction programs in the country - but the margin lives in the preparation.
Happy to answer questions if anyone's working Miami-Dade tax deeds or thinking about it.
0Reply
444 views

2 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Miami, FL · Member since 2016 · 199 posts · 65 votes
    7mo

    Hey! very cool , would love to have a conversation. Going to message you.

  • Don KonipolBusiness Member
    Investor · The Woodlands TX / Avon, CT · Member since 2009 · 6k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    7mo
    Quote from @Terry Rayment:
    I've spent the last several months pulling apart Miami-Dade County tax deed auction data - purchase prices, resale outcomes, hold times, flood zones, property conditions - and turning it into something usable. Thought I'd share some of what I found, since a lot of the "advice" on tax deed investing is either outdated or based on one person's single deal.
    This is based on 222 verified resale outcomes from Miami-Dade tax deed auctions. Not projections. Not Zillow estimates. Actual recorded sales after someone bought at auction, did whatever they did with the property, and sold it.
    The numbers that actually matter
    Median ROI: 12.49x. But that number is misleading on its own.
    The median profit across those 222 resales was about $167K, with a median hold time of around 304 days. Sounds great on paper. But averages hide a lot. Here's what the data actually shows when you break it down:
    1. Not all cities perform the same - not even close.
    Miami Gardens, Opa-locka, and Florida City consistently show up with higher flip rates and stronger returns. These are areas where acquisition prices at auction tend to stay lower relative to after-repair value, and where there's enough transaction volume to actually find comps.
    Meanwhile, some of the "nicer" zip codes in Miami-Dade - Coral Gables, Pinecrest, Key Biscayne - rarely produce viable deals at tax deed auction. The opening bids are already high because of the tax basis, and competitive bidding pushes them past any reasonable margin.
    If you're new to Miami-Dade tax deeds, focus on where the math works, not where you'd want to live.
    2. The sweet spot on acquisition price is lower than most people think.
    The strongest returns cluster in the sub-$50K acquisition range. Once you start pushing past $75-100K at auction, the margin compression is real. You're competing with better-capitalized buyers, the properties tend to need less work (so less value-add opportunity), and your downside risk grows.
    The sub-$30K parcels have the widest spread between purchase price and resale, but they also carry the most condition risk. Vacant lots in that range can be strong if you understand the local zoning and demand, but structures under $30K often have serious problems - code violations, environmental issues, or they're in flood zones that make insurance costs a dealbreaker.
    3. Hold times are longer than the YouTube crowd suggests.
    The median 304-day hold isn't an accident. Tax deed properties come with title clearing requirements (quiet title actions in Florida typically run 3-6 months), then rehab or permitting if it's a structure, then listing and closing. If someone tells you they're flipping tax deed properties in 90 days, they're either skipping steps or stretching the truth.
    Plan for 10-12 months on a realistic timeline. Some of the best returns in the dataset came from 12-18 month holds where the buyer cleared title, did modest rehab, and sold into an improving market.
    4. Flood zone parcels aren't automatic no-gos, but they require different math.
    About 30-40% of Miami-Dade parcels sit in FEMA flood zones. A lot of new buyers see "flood zone" and walk away entirely. Some of those buyers are right - a structure in AE zone with no elevation certificate is a money pit for insurance. But vacant land in flood zones can still work if the end buyer is building new construction to current code (elevated, compliant). The key is knowing which parcels are in which zones before you bid, not after.
    Mistakes I see new buyers make repeatedly
    Overbidding because they anchored to Zillow. Zillow's "Zestimate" on tax deed properties is frequently garbage. These are often distressed, title-clouded, code-violated properties. Running your numbers off Zillow is how you turn a potential 8x return into a 1.2x return - or a loss.
    Ignoring the real cost of quiet title. In Florida, you need to file a quiet title action after purchasing at tax deed auction. Budget $2,500-4,000 in legal fees and 3-6 months of time. This isn't optional - it's a requirement for marketable title. I've seen people buy at auction, realize they can't sell or finance the property without clear title, and then scramble. Build it into your numbers from day one.
    Not checking flood zones before auction day. This one is basic, but I still see it. FEMA flood zone designation affects insurance costs, construction requirements, and resale value. Check it before you bid. Not after. Miami-Dade has enough non-flood-zone parcels that you don't need to gamble unless you've done the analysis.
    Assuming every parcel is buildable. Vacant lots look cheap at auction, but not all of them are buildable. Setback requirements, platting issues, utility access, wetland designations - these can all kill a deal. Always check with the county before bidding on vacant land.
    Where I'm at now
    I ended up building a dashboard to score all 7,100+ active tax deed parcels in Miami-Dade by equity potential - grades from A+ down to F - because doing this manually in spreadsheets was eating my life. It pulls in Street View, flood zones, city-level flip rates, and the verified resale data I mentioned above. It's at miamidadetax.com if anyone wants to check it out (there's a free trial).
    But honestly, even without a tool, the core lesson from this data is simple: do the work before auction day, not after. Know your target cities, know your price bands, know your flood zones, and budget for quiet title. The deals are there - Miami-Dade runs one of the largest tax deed auction programs in the country - but the margin lives in the preparation.
    Happy to answer questions if anyone's working Miami-Dade tax deeds or thinking about it.
    How do you know what the “profit” was?  Do you have access to all expenditures beyond the purchase price? 
    Private Mortgage Financing Partners, LLC
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.