New to real estate in the Cleveland Area

New to real estate in the Cleveland Area

New to Real Estate · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2020 · 3 posts · 4 votes

Hi all,

My wife and I recently moved back from the Bay Area (grew up on the East Side) and purchased a 2 bd 2.5 bath in Ohio City this Fall. Our plan is to hold onto this property and eventually rent (in 3 - 5 years). In the future, our plan is to invest in a Duplex on the West/South West Side (Brooklyn, Parma, etc.) in 2021. 

I would love any thoughts on: approach/philosophy of investing in NE Ohio; perspectives on where the market is headed in Cleveland (from research it appears like a stable area that could even appreciate with systemic impacts of COVID); areas to consider moving forward.

Thanks so much! 

Cam

3Reply
69 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2018 · 214 posts · 270 votes
6y
Originally posted by @Cam Wilk:

Hi all,

My wife and I recently moved back from the Bay Area (grew up on the East Side) and purchased a 2 bd 2.5 bath in Ohio City this Fall. Our plan is to hold onto this property and eventually rent (in 3 - 5 years). In the future, our plan is to invest in a Duplex on the West/South West Side (Brooklyn, Parma, etc.) in 2021. 

I would love any thoughts on: approach/philosophy of investing in NE Ohio; perspectives on where the market is headed in Cleveland (from research it appears like a stable area that could even appreciate with systemic impacts of COVID); areas to consider moving forward.

Thanks so much! 

Cam

Hey Cam, welcome to the site. I am also originally from Cleveland, and currently I live in the Bay Area (occasionally I feel tempted to move back to Cleveland as you did... but then I remember what January can be like and that notion is quickly extinguished). Despite the distance, I have been investing in the Cleveland area for years. I currently own 8 rental properties there.

I've gathered a ton of information on investing in the Cleveland area, and would be happy to share it with you if you are interested. It includes, among other things, a comprehensive map of the Cleveland area, grading each tract from A+ down to F, with a consistent, objective and transparent methodology using publicly available data rather than a broad-brush subjective approach. As a Cleveland native you already probably realize that Cleveland and its suburbs have a huge range of quality when it comes to neighborhoods, and this can be one of the [many] things that makes or breaks you. Feel free to add me as a connection and drop me a private message if you'd like to see this info. 

As Brian said, the Columbus guys will peddle their wares to you on here hard and heavy (they already have started, it seems), as they seem to equate population growth [driven largely by annexation literally all the way out to corn fields] as the end all be all and ignore legitimately important things such as per capita GDP, or a comprehensive view of the full MSA. (It's exceptionally hilarious when they pull out the "Columbus is now a bigger city than San Francisco!" card.) And most likely Mr. Wise will show up at some point to proudly tell you about his map too. But that said, keep in mind that investing in real estate is only partly investing in a location and an asset per se, and is largely about running your own business... the results you will experience will stem more from how you run your business than anything else in most cases... so get scrappy and become your own expert, and DEFINITELY be careful about whose advice you trust, especially if the advice-giver stands to make a buck off of you!

See this reply in the discussion

22 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Columbus, OH · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Cam Wilk:

    Hi all,

    My wife and I recently moved back from the Bay Area (grew up on the East Side) and purchased a 2 bd 2.5 bath in Ohio City this Fall. Our plan is to hold onto this property and eventually rent (in 3 - 5 years). In the future, our plan is to invest in a Duplex on the West/South West Side (Brooklyn, Parma, etc.) in 2021. 

    I would love any thoughts on: approach/philosophy of investing in NE Ohio; perspectives on where the market is headed in Cleveland (from research it appears like a stable area that could even appreciate with systemic impacts of COVID); areas to consider moving forward.

    Thanks so much! 

    Cam

    Welcome back to Ohio! Im sure you'll find things have changed quite a bit! I live and invest in Columbus so I can't tell you much about Cleveland, I have heard that Cleveland is more of a cash flow play while Columbus is more of an appreciation play. I can speak to that as my and my friends investments have more then doubled in the last couple of years!

  • Remington LymanBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2017 · 6k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Cam Wilk:

    Hi all,

    My wife and I recently moved back from the Bay Area (grew up on the East Side) and purchased a 2 bd 2.5 bath in Ohio City this Fall. Our plan is to hold onto this property and eventually rent (in 3 - 5 years). In the future, our plan is to invest in a Duplex on the West/South West Side (Brooklyn, Parma, etc.) in 2021. 

    I would love any thoughts on: approach/philosophy of investing in NE Ohio; perspectives on where the market is headed in Cleveland (from research it appears like a stable area that could even appreciate with systemic impacts of COVID); areas to consider moving forward.

    Thanks so much! 

    Cam

    If you purchase in Cleveland I would focus on cash flow as much as possible. There is not a lot of appreciation happening there due to the declining population and job growth. Columbus, Ohio is the exact opposite. Medium cash flow and high appreciation.

  • Realtor · Oakland, CA and a Real Estate Investor with Multi-Family Units and a Self Storage Facility · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    Be careful Cam............you asked about Cleveland, but you'll get a ton of responses from Columbus Realtors :-)

  • Rental Property Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2018 · 214 posts · 270 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Cam Wilk:

    Hi all,

    My wife and I recently moved back from the Bay Area (grew up on the East Side) and purchased a 2 bd 2.5 bath in Ohio City this Fall. Our plan is to hold onto this property and eventually rent (in 3 - 5 years). In the future, our plan is to invest in a Duplex on the West/South West Side (Brooklyn, Parma, etc.) in 2021. 

    I would love any thoughts on: approach/philosophy of investing in NE Ohio; perspectives on where the market is headed in Cleveland (from research it appears like a stable area that could even appreciate with systemic impacts of COVID); areas to consider moving forward.

    Thanks so much! 

    Cam

    Hey Cam, welcome to the site. I am also originally from Cleveland, and currently I live in the Bay Area (occasionally I feel tempted to move back to Cleveland as you did... but then I remember what January can be like and that notion is quickly extinguished). Despite the distance, I have been investing in the Cleveland area for years. I currently own 8 rental properties there.

    I've gathered a ton of information on investing in the Cleveland area, and would be happy to share it with you if you are interested. It includes, among other things, a comprehensive map of the Cleveland area, grading each tract from A+ down to F, with a consistent, objective and transparent methodology using publicly available data rather than a broad-brush subjective approach. As a Cleveland native you already probably realize that Cleveland and its suburbs have a huge range of quality when it comes to neighborhoods, and this can be one of the [many] things that makes or breaks you. Feel free to add me as a connection and drop me a private message if you'd like to see this info. 

    As Brian said, the Columbus guys will peddle their wares to you on here hard and heavy (they already have started, it seems), as they seem to equate population growth [driven largely by annexation literally all the way out to corn fields] as the end all be all and ignore legitimately important things such as per capita GDP, or a comprehensive view of the full MSA. (It's exceptionally hilarious when they pull out the "Columbus is now a bigger city than San Francisco!" card.) And most likely Mr. Wise will show up at some point to proudly tell you about his map too. But that said, keep in mind that investing in real estate is only partly investing in a location and an asset per se, and is largely about running your own business... the results you will experience will stem more from how you run your business than anything else in most cases... so get scrappy and become your own expert, and DEFINITELY be careful about whose advice you trust, especially if the advice-giver stands to make a buck off of you!

  • Rental Property Investor · Brooke Park Drive · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    Check out Columbus OH. Much better than Cleveland. Very historical as well Christopher Columbus was born there.

  • Real Estate Agent · Westlake, OH · Member since 2014 · 186 posts · 165 votes
    6y

    @Robert Matelski's advice is spot on. Here is a chart that I pulled from the MLS that shows average sales prices in CLE in the area that goes from West Blvd to the Cuyahoga River. This is the "lower west side" which includes Ohio City and some more moderately priced areas. You can reach your own conclusions about appreciation in CLE based on facts and statistics like these rather than relying on statements from someone who doesn't live here. Even with this appreciation and crazy market (multiple offers on most listings), housing prices are still at the point where buying makes far more sense than renting. There seem to be more retail buyers at the low end of the market right now which is creating new opportunities for investors looking to liquidate properties.

    I tell my clients that there is no right strategy or area.  Its a matter of fit with your personality and lifestyle.  For example, if you have a demanding job with travel (when things get back to normal) you may be better off with A or B type properties with a lower return and less management hassles.  On the other hand, if you have time and a little bit of badass in you low C and D properties might be a good fit and get you a higher return.  Also how much risk you are comfortable with, how much discretionary income you have, how long you plan to stay in the area....all those things should factor into your strategy.  

  • New to Real Estate · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2020 · 3 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Robert Matelski very helpful and feel you on the Cleveland winter! I went shopping yesterday and felt like I was preparing for war.  

    As for the Columbus peddling, I definitely see what you mean. Fortunately I am used to it as I went to Ohio State and get no shortage of perspectives from buddies in Columbus. Its definitely an interesting market with the population growth averaging in the top 3 - 5 for urban areas nationally but I completely agree with your sentiments: population growth isn't everything (i.e. Columbus is a massive city geographically so gotta take into account per capita metrics).

    I will message you separately to continue the convo on Cleveland. Thanks again!

  • New to Real Estate · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2020 · 3 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Don Petrasek I cannot thank you enough for the statistically grounded perspective and recommendations. 

    I have been trending towards the A and B type properties in the short term with my work schedule and to get the ball rolling. In the long term, I do want to diversity as well as work on the badass part (far from there now). There are a handful of neighborhoods in south west Cleveland that I have done some analysis of - C and D properties- to invest in down the road and potentially utilize the BRRR method.

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Robert Matelski:
    Originally posted by @Cam Wilk:

    Hi all,

    My wife and I recently moved back from the Bay Area (grew up on the East Side) and purchased a 2 bd 2.5 bath in Ohio City this Fall. Our plan is to hold onto this property and eventually rent (in 3 - 5 years). In the future, our plan is to invest in a Duplex on the West/South West Side (Brooklyn, Parma, etc.) in 2021. 

    I would love any thoughts on: approach/philosophy of investing in NE Ohio; perspectives on where the market is headed in Cleveland (from research it appears like a stable area that could even appreciate with systemic impacts of COVID); areas to consider moving forward.

    Thanks so much! 

    Cam

    Hey Cam, welcome to the site. I am also originally from Cleveland, and currently I live in the Bay Area (occasionally I feel tempted to move back to Cleveland as you did... but then I remember what January can be like and that notion is quickly extinguished). Despite the distance, I have been investing in the Cleveland area for years. I currently own 8 rental properties there.

    I've gathered a ton of information on investing in the Cleveland area, and would be happy to share it with you if you are interested. It includes, among other things, a comprehensive map of the Cleveland area, grading each tract from A+ down to F, with a consistent, objective and transparent methodology using publicly available data rather than a broad-brush subjective approach. As a Cleveland native you already probably realize that Cleveland and its suburbs have a huge range of quality when it comes to neighborhoods, and this can be one of the [many] things that makes or breaks you. Feel free to add me as a connection and drop me a private message if you'd like to see this info. 

    As Brian said, the Columbus guys will peddle their wares to you on here hard and heavy (they already have started, it seems), as they seem to equate population growth [driven largely by annexation literally all the way out to corn fields] as the end all be all and ignore legitimately important things such as per capita GDP, or a comprehensive view of the full MSA. (It's exceptionally hilarious when they pull out the "Columbus is now a bigger city than San Francisco!" card.) And most likely Mr. Wise will show up at some point to proudly tell you about his map too. But that said, keep in mind that investing in real estate is only partly investing in a location and an asset per se, and is largely about running your own business... the results you will experience will stem more from how you run your business than anything else in most cases... so get scrappy and become your own expert, and DEFINITELY be careful about whose advice you trust, especially if the advice-giver stands to make a buck off of you!

    haha......This guy, firing from all angles. You should start referring to The Ultimate Guide to Grading Cleveland Neighborhoods as the standard that all of these other maps are compared to.

  • Realtor · Oakland, CA and a Real Estate Investor with Multi-Family Units and a Self Storage Facility · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    @Cam Wilk.  Before you hire a PM in Cleveland make sure part of your vetting process is actually the vibe you get when talking with them on the phone.  This can’t be emphasized enough..... not just email.... but actual phone conversation.

  • Rental Property Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2016 · 653 posts · 769 votes
    6y

    Since you're from Cleveland you know better than anyone that the market is entirely dependent on where you buy. Plenty of areas are better for cash flow and others for appreciation. It's like much of real estate, the best strategy depends on what you want to accomplish. 

    A couple of the properties I bought in 2017 have increased over 50% and they are in the lower-end "cash flow" areas. I still consider it having been a pretty significant risk that I took, but it's paid off. Though, if I had bought in other areas, the dollar amount of appreciation on more expensive properties would have done just as well. 

    Just be cautious of the age of properties out here. A lot of properties are over 100 years old now and just come with their own sets of problems. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2018 · 61 posts · 27 votes
    6y

    Welcome back @Cam Wilk ! Nice move getting into the Ohio city property and buying as opposed to renting! I love Ohio city and Tremont as they as super close to downtown without all the traffic (not so much with covid though)

    I currently am house hacking a duplex in Old Brooklyn as you mentioned in your post.

    If you ever wanna chat about it or the experience I’ve had using this strategy, feel free to reach out. I sent you a connection request!

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2016 · 25 posts · 29 votes
    6y

    Welcome back! My wife and I actually moved here from California (me=socal her=sonoma county) to Cleveland in order to focus on real estate investing. I live near Gordon Square and we have been able to get started much quicker that anticipated. 

    Why do you want do a multi unit instead of single family homes? I like SFH because i can make all utilities the tenant's responsibility. With MFH you have to carry the water and sewer, which is not always bad but just another variable. Parma and Brooklyn are solid areas, I also like Euclid, Mayfield, and Lyndhurst for great B class tenants.

  • Investor · Member since 2020 · 12 posts · 3 votes
    6y

    How is the appreciation in Cleveland Brian?

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2019 · 33 posts · 55 votes
    6y

    Mr. Wilk: In no particular order:
    a). Two key factors when evaluating potential returns: the property taxes in the municipality and the Point of Sale requirements. Cleveland (the city) is generally has the lowest property taxes and has no point of sale requirement. Shaker Heights has high taxes, and the PoS requirement is an escrow of 150% of the estimated costs to repair. Most of what I look at for investing is in Clevland proper.

    b). You have to decide where in the market you want to be in terms of tenancy: low income, moderate, or high. The better returns are in the low income space; the investment is much lower, with rents ranging from $500-$1000 per month. The more expensive the property, the lower the ROI.

    c). I separate properties into three categories:Raw state, moderate repair, turnkey. Raw state are properties that are in need of major rehab. You can buy these for almost nothing (sometimes for nothing), but you will have to invest in rehabbing them. Moderate repair are those properties that require mostly cosmetic attention, and turnkey are ready-to-go. The advantage to raw state properties is that you have control over the rehab process, so you can factor in future maintenance - instead of carpet, you can use vinyl flooring, for example, or deal with lead mitigation upfront. Raw state properties have the highest risk, but offer the highest returns if you can control costs. The other side of that are turnkey: there, you are buying a rehabbed property, sometimes with tenant in place. You have no knowledge of the quality of the repairs, nor do you have any say in the tenant in place.

    d). Inspect, inspect, inspect. The disaster areas (so to speak) are the places you cannot see. If you are buying a raw state property, you might assume that since you're going to rehab the whole thing inspections are not necessary. Nay nay! Camera the sewer/drain lines. Run a house around the perimeter of the house. Bring your contractor in during inspections to give estimates. You need to account for every potential expense before you buy. For turnkey properties, its even more important - camera the lines, because the rehab probably didnt bother with them. have the contractor check the property for quality of repair.

    e). Be aware of the Cleveland Lead safe initative! Starting in March 2021, all pre-1978 properties in cleveland have to pass a lead inspection. If you are buying to rehab, you can address this, but if you are buying turnkey, be aware of this ordinance. 

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2012 · 771 posts · 252 votes
    6y

    @Cam Wilk Welcome to BP and welcome back to Cleveland!

  • Investor · Member since 2020 · 401 posts · 86 votes
    6y

    What is the difference between Cleveland to Indianapolis in appreciation and cashflow? 

  • Cleveland · Member since 2020 · 16 posts · 5 votes
    6y

    @Bob Galivan  - great points. a) POS can eat your estimated buy in for sure unless you are well cash capitalized on the buy side b) spot on c) very good guidance, especially for 1st timers or out of state players d) AND EVEN WITH inspections....you easily add a $10-25K repair tab turkey bomb expense to your portfolio.  
    (think unexpected major plumbing service connection problems or the ever dreaded foundation 'issue'). 

    @Don Petrasek - good insight

  • Columbus, OH · Member since 2015 · 3 posts · 3 votes
    6y

    @Cam Wilk Back in CLE!? Welcome home! I’m still down in Columbus, but I’ve been looking at turnkey opportunities up north for a little while now. I’m usually up for the holidays and randomly throughout the year. Hmu and we can link at some point to talk newbie real estate!

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 239 posts · 224 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Robert Matelski:
    Originally posted by @Cam Wilk:

    Hi all,

    My wife and I recently moved back from the Bay Area (grew up on the East Side) and purchased a 2 bd 2.5 bath in Ohio City this Fall. Our plan is to hold onto this property and eventually rent (in 3 - 5 years). In the future, our plan is to invest in a Duplex on the West/South West Side (Brooklyn, Parma, etc.) in 2021. 

    I would love any thoughts on: approach/philosophy of investing in NE Ohio; perspectives on where the market is headed in Cleveland (from research it appears like a stable area that could even appreciate with systemic impacts of COVID); areas to consider moving forward.

    Thanks so much! 

    Cam

    Hey Cam, welcome to the site. I am also originally from Cleveland, and currently I live in the Bay Area (occasionally I feel tempted to move back to Cleveland as you did... but then I remember what January can be like and that notion is quickly extinguished). Despite the distance, I have been investing in the Cleveland area for years. I currently own 8 rental properties there.

    I've gathered a ton of information on investing in the Cleveland area, and would be happy to share it with you if you are interested. It includes, among other things, a comprehensive map of the Cleveland area, grading each tract from A+ down to F, with a consistent, objective and transparent methodology using publicly available data rather than a broad-brush subjective approach. As a Cleveland native you already probably realize that Cleveland and its suburbs have a huge range of quality when it comes to neighborhoods, and this can be one of the [many] things that makes or breaks you. Feel free to add me as a connection and drop me a private message if you'd like to see this info. 

    As Brian said, the Columbus guys will peddle their wares to you on here hard and heavy (they already have started, it seems), as they seem to equate population growth [driven largely by annexation literally all the way out to corn fields] as the end all be all and ignore legitimately important things such as per capita GDP, or a comprehensive view of the full MSA. (It's exceptionally hilarious when they pull out the "Columbus is now a bigger city than San Francisco!" card.) And most likely Mr. Wise will show up at some point to proudly tell you about his map too. But that said, keep in mind that investing in real estate is only partly investing in a location and an asset per se, and is largely about running your own business... the results you will experience will stem more from how you run your business than anything else in most cases... so get scrappy and become your own expert, and DEFINITELY be careful about whose advice you trust, especially if the advice-giver stands to make a buck off of you!

    This post should be stickied as mandatory reading material before anyone creates a thread asking about Cleveland.  

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2019 · 33 posts · 55 votes
    6y

    Not sure what about that post is special. First, the idea of grading neighborhoods (as another post pointed out) is akin to redlining neighborhoods. Someone not from Cleveland is going to look at the infamous map and decide that the D and F areas are out of bounds - who would invest in a low income area? The very idea!!!

    ROI is the holy grail of investing. If you can get 15% ROI in a supposed "F" neighborood compared to 8% in a supposed "B" neighborhood, which one are you going to pick? Cleveland has an image problem in part due to that map. Over the past month or so, I've looked at three porfolios and two multi-family buildings, all in D and F neighborhoods that, following rehab - would yeld more than 10% ROI.

    One of the problems that exists in Cleveland is the presence of absentee owners who are focused solely on ROI. I "attended" an online presentation targeted at French investors that promised 16% gross returns, and presented pictures of some properties plucked from Zillow. One property manager I work with had some experience with these "investments" a couple years ago. He exited that relationship after getting bombarded with calls from foriegn investors demanding their money - they netted less than 5% after the expenses, commissions, and other fees were extracted. I have another friend who works with several tenant advocacy groups who deals with this stuff all the time. Out of town investors purchase properties through local "brokers" and extract every penny of revenue without further investment in the property, then exit the market by abandoning the property to the city.

    Focusing first on ROI, then on the area where the property exists with the idea of even a modicum of improvement to the home - and thus to the neighborhood - is a solid investment strategy, in my book. it's what we are pursuing. Investing in a community without some desire to improve that community is not a very worthy strategy, IMHO.

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Ari Hadar:

    What is the difference between Cleveland to Indianapolis in appreciation and cashflow? 

     Pretty similar. 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.