Many people on BiggerPockets (at least on the podcasts) have credited their start to investing in real estate to reading Robert Kiyosaki’s book Rich Dad Poor Dad; myself included. However, there are also some investors who disagree with his philosophies. I would like to open up this post to anyone familiar with Kiyosaki’s investing principles taught in any of his books to debate his teachings.
Which of his teachings do you feel are sound teachings and which are unsound in your opinion? I would like to invite everyone into the conversation but I would like to extend a specific invitation to @Omar Khan, @Jay Hinrichs, @Mike Dymski, @JD Martin, @Joel Owens, @Steve Vaughan, @Sterling White, @David Greene, @Dave Van Horn, and @Ben Leybovich.
Thanks to all who care to share their opinion on the subject.
I don't view Rich Dad Poor Dad so much as an investment book, but more a lifestyle/self help book. It tells you to invest, but doesn't spend a whole lot of time talking about actual investments.
-You can learn from both dads. He compares the two "dads" and saying how the poor one focuses on the "wrong" things. Financial IQ, interpersonal communication, sales are all great skills, but he downplays, at least to my memory, things like science, math, history ect, in favor of the money making "hard" skills. Looking at the truly successful people, they all study things outside their profession and have many "mental models" to base their choices on. Biology, physics, history, math, ect, even at a basic level can teach us a lot.
-Data doesn't lie. Getting a bachelor's degree, means on average, you'll make more than if you have a High School Diploma. Same for Masters vs bachelors. That's not a guarantee, but it increases your odds of making a higher income. He ignores the fact that his rich dad's success could be an outlier.
-What is wrong with working hard, living below your means, saving money? If you don't have the skill set of the "Rich dad" maybe that is your best bet for success? After all The Millionaire Next Door, did a pretty good job laying out that's how most people got a net worth of seven figures. Unpopular opinion here but, starting one's own business and investing full time is not for everyone. Heck, buying investment property isn't for everyone. Capitalism can be a brutal place.
A fun read for someone who may not have had the opportunities to think/learn about money as a tool rather than an end in and of itself, but not a wonder book that changes the world.
What an excellent thread! There are some really good (and opposing) ideas about the legendary (or infamous) Kiyosaki. I will say that RDPD significantly changed my mindset, and I'm very grateful to have read it because it motivated me to take action. However, I would say The Richest Man in Babylon and Think and Grow Rich had a much bigger impact on my current financial landscape. There have been several very good recommendations listed above, and I've added several to my ever-growing list. I love hearing various perspectives because it forces me to think. I wish more individuals would receive information with an open mind and apply that knowledge to their own specific situation.
@Account Closed This guy has turned into just another brand that needs to stay relevant and will pitch any idea that gets him headlines or airtime. He's taken pop econ to levels that prey on people with little to knowledge macro or micro principles to sell his books and courses. The people he associates with are other people how have to sell their brands. Do you see Seth Klarman giving seminars at the Ramada by the airport? No, he's busy running the sixth most profitable edge fund on the planet.
P.T. Barnum ("step right up folks and see the two-headed calf") has met his match. Only in America can we make them this well.
Kiyosaki's genius is being able to get people involved with financial literacy. The challenge with financial matters, however, is that both money and drugs light up the same area of the brain (Mind Over Money [PBS Passport required]). As humans, we can't help ourselves. Investors like Warren Buffett have learned to be greedy when others are fearful and fearful when others are greedy, but that mindset takes a while to develop.
Kiyosaki's message for the entrepreneurial mindset is echoed by Steve Jobs' 2005 Stanford Commencement Address (which contributes to the "billionaire college dropout" myth in Silicon Valley because Jobs might be an outlier). While Jobs has always had his group of fans, he was also perceived as a jerk by much of Silicon Valley throughout his career. In the end, he won (you can't argue with success). Whether Kiyosaki is an icon or a punch line is a matter of debate.
If you want to do some binge viewing (4 hours) and see how financial history keeps repeating itself, The Ascent of Money (2008) by Niall Ferguson is a good video to watch.
@Account Closed
One man's opinion here, but Kiyosaki's genius is that he sells the idea that if you read/listen to his way of thinking you can beat everyone one else. The titles of his books point this out: Unfair Advantage, Why "A" Students Work for "C" Students and Why "B" Students Work for the Government ,Rich Dad, Poor Dad. They all have an in group out group component. Us vs them; a marketing tactic that takes advantage of human's mental need for competition and positive self-image.
Warren Buffet doesn't have a monopoly on disciplined thinking and yes we can help ourselves. Plenty of people have trained their minds to work around the flawed process to get above average results. Exhibit one, world class poker and bridge players like Richard Zeckhauser, Vanessa Selbst, Phil Hellmuth, Annie Duke, Phil Ivey, ect.
The problem is, it's hard work to overcome biological programing. It is far simpler to have someone tell you what you should do. Kiyosaki has filled that niche and filled it well, just like Dave Ramsey. If you buy into their system whole hog you don't even need to worry about finding a CPA, they do that for you.
I'd submit that he is a proponent of entrepreneurship in name only. His entire business model revolves around getting enough people to follow his teachings and consume his products, whether they be books, seminars, coaching, or advisors.
@Account Closed
One man's opinion here, but Kiyosaki's genius is that he sells the idea that if you read/listen to his way of thinking you can beat everyone one else. The titles of his books point this out: Unfair Advantage, Why "A" Students Work for "C" Students and Why "B" Students Work for the Government ,Rich Dad, Poor Dad. They all have an in group out group component. Us vs them; a marketing tactic that takes advantage of human's mental need for competition and positive self-image.
Warren Buffet doesn't have a monopoly on disciplined thinking and yes we can help ourselves. Plenty of people have trained their minds to work around the flawed process to get above average results. Exhibit one, world class poker and bridge players like Richard Zeckhauser, Vanessa Selbst, Phil Hellmuth, Annie Duke, Phil Ivey, ect.
The problem is, it's hard work to overcome biological programing. It is far simpler to have someone tell you what you should do. Kiyosaki has filled that niche and filled it well, just like Dave Ramsey. If you buy into their system whole hog you don't even need to worry about finding a CPA, they do that for you.
I'd submit that he is a proponent of entrepreneurship in name only. His entire business model revolves around getting enough people to follow his teachings and consume his products, whether they be books, seminars, coaching, or advisors.
I agree with you about Kiyosaki's genius, but he doesn't have a monopoly on how to suck people into his "special insider secrets" ecosystem.
One person I fell for back in the 1990s was Ken Roberts. Luckily, I only used money I could afford to lose because I lost it, but I earned the equivalent of a PhD from the College of Hard Knocks. The market was very efficient at collecting my tuition payments.
If you go in all the way with Van Tharp, you'll take several years and spend tens of thousands of dollars on his training. If your goal is to manage a billion-dollar hedge fund, the deal is probably a bargain. But Tharp also says his books are all you really need, so for less than $100 and many hours of self-study, I'm up to speed on this methods (I have no desire to manage a hedge fund).
If people just read Kiyosaki's books, they will likely get what they need (awareness and motivation). But the secret is to stop after his books and not fall for his larger ecosystem. I would feel better about the guy if he actually said this in his books rather than try to up-sell everyone to buy his more expensive offerings.
@Shiloh Lundahl After seeing your name pop up in a Blog, I threaded back to your original question and since we almost did a deal together last year, I was interested to hear what you had to say.
I have not read the Kyosaki book, but I have played the Cashflow game with a Meetup group several times. I concur with your takeaways from Kyosaki's book as to the mindset of the Poor, Middle Class and Wealthy.
What I also find fascinating is that as an owner of Class C/D properties which create my living, it is imperative I understand ALL mindset classes. My tenants are typically "poor." I used to try to educate them on the power of passive income but it fell on deaf ears. In Maslow's Heirarchy, they will always be focused on safety needs and cannot see beyond the next paycheck which comes from answering to someone else's rules. As such, I instead revert to immediate acts of kindness such as gift cards at the holidays.
Without rambling on, as others have commented, Rich Dad / Poor Dad is great on concepts. The Cashflow game puts those concepts to work and is effective at changing mindsets. Real life patience, delayed gratification, diplomacy and eventual risk-taking can start with higher learning (college) and I would recommend that to anyone. It provides a good base for goal-setting and achieving.
@Barry H. thanks for your input. I often wish that I had gotten some of those deals that we looked at last year but I the timing was off a little for me and I was practicing self restraint even though as I look back now they were pretty good deals.
I think RDPD is a GREAT TOOL! Is a highly skilled ice sculptor going to use a children's plastic pumpkin carving tool? Of course not, but that doesn't mean the children's pumpkin carving tool is lacking in its value it provides children in learning how carve and shape a pumpkin!
I use RDPD as a "sunday school lesson" instrument for those with low or non-existent financial IQ's. It's a beginner's book and a great one at that! It is easy to read, understand, and apply. Does anyone have a better book that you would use to introduce someone to the world of investing that isn't too direct and technical? A "starter book" (which I believe is EXACTLY what RDPD amounts to)...? My go to starter books are: RDPD, Millionaire Next Door, and The Automatic Millionaire Homeowner!
Most of the folks commenting about how it's a pile of rubbish should focus their critique on a title more recently published. How about Unfair Advantage, or We Want You to be Rich?
I've been thinking about starting those soon, so I'd love to see some feedback on the quality of information provided in those books.
@Sam Josh you are looking at it from a middle class mindset. Robert Kiyosaki is showing what a wealthy mindset looks like. There is nothing wrong with what you are describing. And I am sure the people you are describing “are doing extremely well.” But the really wealthy play at completely different levels. It’s like the high school state champions are the best high school team but if they were to play the worst NBA team, they would lose terribly because they are playing on a completely different level. Rich Dad Poor Dad is about teaching people how rich people think not the middle class that “are doing extremely well.”
@Sam Josh you are looking at it from a middle class mindset. Robert Kiyosaki is showing what a wealthy mindset looks like. There is nothing wrong with what you are describing. And I am sure the people you are describing “are doing extremely well.” But the really wealthy play at completely different levels. It’s like the high school state champions are the best high school team but if they were to play the worst NBA team, they would lose terribly because they are playing on a completely different level. Rich Dad Poor Dad is about teaching people how rich people think not the middle class that “are doing extremely well.”
When I Google "Rich Dad" I come up with Richard Kimi, who didn't start out life wealthy. If this result is true, the Rich Dad started out poor and became rich as an entrepreneurial investor in hotels. He earned his wealth one hotel guest at a time.
People like to read the biographies of wealthy people because they allow us to live vicariously. For example, I enjoy the various biographies of Warren Buffett who started out life poor and became rich as an entrepreneurial investor (beginning as a child delivering one newspaper at a time). John Templeton started out life poor and became wealthy ("Investing the Templeton Way").
The genius of the Cashflow game is it's use of neuro-linguistic programming (which some have discredited as junk science), which is the same technique Tony Robbins uses with his firewalking shtick. The first time I played Cashflow, the four of us playing the game got out of the rat race by going in together on a hotel deal. I was elated because it seemed to suggest the numbers behind passive income generation really work. If something helps you conquer your fears of money or hot coals, it's useful.
RDPD might be a way to go, but it's not the only way to go. RDPD might get people's attention (which is good), but going in on a hotel deal with three other strangers could also be a disaster. Building wealth by buying gold and going heavily into "good debt" might also work, but in the wrong market, it could be a disaster. RDPD is misleading because it doesn't warn about these potential downsides.
@Account ClosedI too like hearing stories of how things got started. I really liked Shoe Dog:the Phil Knight Story the founder of Nike. That was a very inspiring book for me.
I agree that Rich Dad Poor Dad is not a how to book. For me it was the beginning of a mindset changing book. I hope that people can see it that way rather than use it as a how-to manual. Because I could see how that could get a lot of people into trouble.
@Sam Josh which quadrant are the people around you making these fortunes? The E, the S, the B, or the I quadrant?
I'll answer for myself. I'm a retired Silicon Valley cubicle dweller right out of the Dilbert comic strip.
I'm in the I (investor) quadrant now. I spent most of my life in the E (employee) quadrant. I spent a short period of time in the S (self-employment) quadrant and failed, but learned a lot from the experience. I've never been in the B (business owner) quadrant and knowing myself as I do, I don't believe I would do well in the B quadrant.
When I started investing in the stock market in the early 1990s, my financial advisor at a major brokerage firm advised me (correctly, in my opinion) to fund my retirement accounts (IRA and 401K) fully and invest an additional 10% of my salary in a taxable account. I was also a homeowner at the time (real estate) because the American Dream pushed my buttons. I bought the biggest house I could afford because that was the conventional wisdom then, not realizing there were other alternatives that would have let me achieve financial independence much sooner than I did ("live and learn").
I never ran a business as a kid (lemonade stand, deliver newspapers, whatever). I doubt I would be successful doing these kinds of activities. Some people just aren't cut out to start a business and expand it to the size where a manager runs the day-to-day operations so the owner can work ON the business rather than IN the business. Instead, people like myself can get a good education (thanks to Sputnik in the 1950s and my skill at math and science), exchange our time and skill for a steady paycheck, and take advantage of the incentives Congress established (tax-advantaged retirement accounts) to allow us to build wealth. People who do hands-on real estate also have benefits (1031 exchange, home capital gain exclusion). I'm told people worth more than $50 million can start their own foundations and hire the experts needed for sophisticated asset protection.
Dogbert: "I always thought you beavers were busy all the time".
Beaver: "That's a common stereotype. I'm actually quite lazy".
Dogbert: "How do you build your beaver home?"
Beaver: "I rent"...
I think that all of his advice fits into one of two categories: obvious or wrong.
Obvious- “you shouldn’t spend all of your money, you should invest some”.
wrong- you should become an expert in forex trading and use your profits to buy gold.
Wrong- index funds and tax advantages accounts are the devil
wrong- it doesn’t make sense to hold cash because it is fiat currency.
it is astonishing to me how many people consider him an inspiration.
@Max Briggs it seems that you are unimpressed with Robert Kiyosaki’s philosophies on money and investing. What do you have better to offer?
I have a personal finance blog that goes into detail on that. I’m not sure if bigger pockets allows me to post links in the forum, but if you dm me I can send you the link if you are truly interested. None of the advice I would give would be radically outside of mainstream personal finance:
1. Maximize your income
2. Live below your means
3. Invest the rest of your income in a combination of retirement accounts, post tax accounts, index funds, and real estate (reit’s, crowd funding, or rental properties according to your needs).
4. Maximize you risk/return position through diversification
5. Rebalance as your risk posture changes or market conditions change (for example real estate came much more attractive after the housing market crash, so expected returns went up, so jump on it).
Most people earning decent money can use that plan to reach financial independence within 20-30 years of work. People that make more and make quitting the rat race a priority can do it much faster.
There’s more detail in the blog, but that’s the executive summary.
Robert Kiyosaki gives lots of advice that can derail a financial future, such as his advice to avoid tax advantages retirement accounts or dumping lots of money into gold.
I have a personal finance blog that goes into detail on that. I’m not sure if bigger pockets allows me to post links in the forum, but if you dm me I can send you the link if you are truly interested. None of the advice I would give would be radically outside of mainstream personal finance:
1. Maximize your income
2. Live below your means
3. Invest the rest of your income in a combination of retirement accounts, post tax accounts, index funds, and real estate (reit’s, crowd funding, or rental properties according to your needs).
4. Maximize you risk/return position through diversification
5. Rebalance as your risk posture changes or market conditions change (for example real estate came much more attractive after the housing market crash, so expected returns went up, so jump on it).
Most people earning decent money can use that plan to reach financial independence within 20-30 years of work. People that make more and make quitting the rat race a priority can do it much faster.
There’s more detail in the blog, but that’s the executive summary.
Robert Kiyosaki gives lots of advice that can derail a financial future, such as his advice to avoid tax advantages retirement accounts or dumping lots of money into gold.
@Max Briggs Following your investing formula, how long would it take to transform 300k into 1 million, just following your average projections minus commissions?
it would depend on your risk tolerance and asset class preferences.
With US equity valuations as high as they are now I’d expect low average returns over the next 10 years or so.
If you invested in A combination of overseas developed and emerging markets and financed cash flow real estate I think you could realistically see returns above 10%. If you wanted to go all in on financed self managed real estate deals you could probably do even better. But using 10% assuming no external contributions you are probably looking at doubling your money every 7 years and getting to $1.2M in about 14 years.
You could cut a lot of time off that if you are continuing to contribute to the investment over that time period.
@Max Briggs What if you were more of an active investor in your system? How long would it realistically take then?
I don’t know if I’d call my advice a system. It’s more like pointing out that conventional personal finance advice is far better than anything that speed out of Robert Kiyosaki’s mouth.
But to answer your question, I'm not sure exactly what you mean by active. If you mean day trading or actively managed funds then it will take you longer than what I quoted before, because commissions and fees will eat into returns. If you mean that you are willing to actively manage rental properties, then I'd say that you probably have the potential to receive 15%-18% annual return. I have three rentals that return about 18% CoC right now, if you count return on equity they're even higher than that. Assuming you have similar deals wherever you are looking to invest you may be able to do that too. With an 18% RoR you'd double your money every 4 years and reach 1.2M around 8-10 years from now.
Rich Dad is a great initial motivator but is by no means a great guide
for real estate investing. That was the first book I read and it
motivated me to start looking into real estate. He is, like most gurus,
extremely light on details. Gurus become famous because of some
initial "success" (and I use that term very very lightly). Their real
success comes from convincing others that they have all the answers.
Then they make all their money off of their books and speaking
engagements and workshops. Then their advice is so outdated because
they haven't even invested in the thing they are talking about for years
because they don't have time or need to anymore. They now travel the
country profiting off of their supposed success in real estate but what
they really should be telling everyone is "I make all my money off of
you people in the crowd...not real estate". But I guess that wouldn't
be such a great idea for them to say.
@Max Briggs got it. I think that’s where the disconnect is for me. I struggle with being patient. I don’t want to wait 8-10 years to quadruple my money. I want to do it in 3 years. The other difficulty that I have is trusting others to care for my money as much as I do. I’ve never found anyone to do that. I like to have control of my investments other than just buy and sell. And I like to use leverage and advanced strategies such as lease options.
I think your advice is probably great for the average investor and I think Robert Kiyosaki’s advice is probably bad for the average investor. I think the lesson he tries to teach is - Don’t be average.