When do you stop putting money into a rehab?

Question

I've noticed more and more with investment properties is that there's a difference between making a property better and spending money on things that actually matter to the next buyer or tenant.

It's easy to get caught up in wanting everything to be perfect, especially when you're already in the middle of a renovation. But not every upgrade is going to make a meaningful difference in the end. I try to look at the property as a whole and prioritize the things that affect functionality, durability, tenant appeal, and resale value before getting into cosmetic extras.

That said, knowing where to draw the line isn't always black and white. Sometimes a relatively small upgrade can make a big difference in how a property shows or rents likewise a very costly upgrade has very little impact on rents.

How do you decide when an upgrade is worth doing versus when it's better to leave it off the scope?

Divin Kanyama · Answer

@Aiden Avtgis I try to separate upgrades into three buckets: must-do items that protect safety, function, or the building; market-required items needed to compete with nearby rentals or sales; and optional improvements that are mostly personal preference. The first bucket gets funded, the second has to earn its place, and the third is usually cut.

For each discretionary item, I ask: Will it raise achievable rent or value, shorten vacancy or selling time, reduce future maintenance, or prevent another round of labor later? Then I compare that benefit with the full installed cost—not just materials—and the expected hold period. If the return depends on an optimistic rent premium or a buyer noticing one specific feature, it probably does not belong in the base scope.

One useful guardrail is to set the finish level from real comparables before construction starts, then require evidence before upgrading beyond it. I also favor improvements that are durable, easy to replace, and broadly appealing over highly customized finishes. The goal is not the nicest property possible; it is the right property for that renter, buyer, and price point.

Aiden Avtgis · Answer

@Divin Kanyama I love the three-bucket approach, especially setting the finish level based on comparable properties before the work starts. Solid advice. It's easy to get caught up in making a unit nicer than it actually needs to be when you're in the heat of a remodel. I'm going to add this to my scope of work template to incorporate with future investments.

Aiden Avtgis · Answer

@Jaron Walling I've noticed the cost of quality luxury vinyl plank has gotten pretty crazy in some areas, partly because it's become so popular. When I have to replace flooring, wood-look tile frequently ends up being the better option cost-wise. And I just can't bring myself to trust laminate that isn't waterproof in a rental, anywhere in the house! Between spills, leaks, and everyday wear and tear, it can turn into a much bigger expense down the road. I'd rather spend a little more upfront on something that's going to hold up from one tenant to the next.

Caleb Brown · Answer

Always look at comps and if it's needed. Some things are "nice" but won't matter.

Simon W. · Answer

Divin's three buckets and Amr's tracking idea work well together. I'd track every rehab line by bucket from day one, because most of what you spend gets capitalized into the property's basis and depreciated over time, while true repairs can generally be deducted right away.

With that in mind, say you add a $4,000 optional finish upgrade. On a 27.5 year schedule that's about $145 a year of depreciation, so the tax benefit is small and slow. If it doesn't raise rent or shorten vacancy, the tax side won't rescue it.

The tracking also tells you what each upgrade really cost and what rent it earned. Vladimirs' who-pays-for-it test is much easier to run when you have that data by property.

Amr Magdy · Answer

@Aiden Avtgis what settles it for a lot of owners is their own history. If you log each upgrade, what it cost, and what the unit rented for and how long it sat on every turn, after a few properties you can see which upgrades actually moved rent or vacancy in your area and which ones just felt good.

Vladimirs Veiss · Answer

The rule we used: an upgrade stays in scope only if we can name who pays for it, the tenant through rent, the buyer through price, or us through lower maintenance. Everything else is taste.

Durability items (roof, water, electrical, windows) always stay; cosmetic upgrades compete for what's left. The trap is mid-project: once the walls are open, everything looks cheap "while we're at it". Anything that comes up during the job gets photographed, checked against the original scope and priced at the same rates, and then it has to pass the same "who pays for it" test.

Aiden, do your tenants in Cleveland actually pay more for finishes, or mostly for location and condition?

Drew Sygit · Answer

Too many investors rehab to their personal living standard, but will NOT be living in the property.

Need to research and "Maintain to the Market".

Jaron Walling · Answer

@Aiden Avtgis From a single family BRRRR or flip prospective it depends on your target renter/buyer. We completed a flip last year and went overboard on the renovation. I did 20% of the work and added some touches to the property. I studies the comps religiously so I knew my product would stand out. It was our first true flip and I did go over budget by $10k but we remained profitable and learned a lot. Long story short if I had choose to BRRRR I would've deleted so many projects! I would have keep the hardwood floors unfinished, cut back on the kitchen budget (materials), and reduced the scope of work to a degree. Probably would have put us back in line with the budget but then it wouldn't have looked as great as a flip. It's always a catch-22.

Flooring is annoying. I've given up on laminated plank in kitchens and baths. Probably common sense to others reading my response, but I've installed it and it's destroyed by water damage in <2 years. Only install 100% waterproof, click and lock, vinyl flooring or tile in those areas. In C/B- class neighborhoods we only do tile in the shower and kitchen backsplash. Everything else is vinyl or original hardwood flooring.

It's been said in the forums and on podcasts but if you're buying distressed properties you should be able to flip a BRRRR. Is that ideal for real world, wear-in-tear, in a rental? Absolutely not but in our market that's what works. We could sell or create equity and CF a rental if we buy correctly. In the current market, higher interest rates, and economic uncertainty I would not target a flip. Prices are compressed badly and weak appraisals are around the corner.

Jaron Walling · Answer

Agreed!

When do you stop putting money into a rehab?

When do you stop putting money into a rehab?

Most Popular Reply

10 Replies