Lender · Lakewood, WA · Member since 2021 · 149 posts · 44 votes
We talk a lot about finding the deal.
But what happens when the original exit strategy starts looking less attractive halfway through the project?
Maybe the market changes. Maybe the finished product isn’t getting the response you expected. Maybe the property makes more sense as a rental than a resale.
A strong investor isn’t necessarily the person who never changes the plan.
Sometimes it’s the person who recognizes when the plan needs to change.
Have you ever changed your exit strategy after buying a property? What triggered the decision?
I call it the Pivot all investors need to be able to pivot. Or should have a plan B.
couple of my real world deals:
4 acres in rohnert park CA bought for 27k was going to flip it quickly for 75k in 96/97 would not perc so was not buildable at the time I knew the risk when i bought it but it was so cheap.. So instead of just making 10k or 20k on it I held it with the idea the city would grow out to me and bring sewer. Well that happened and in 2000 sold it to a developer for 2.2 mil.. Net profit 1,150,000. on a 27k purchase.
Bought a foreclosure In Portland Metro area. U know high risk.. when talking to the lady that owned the house and seeing what a family mess she had I was not looking forward to being on the news and evicting her and her 4 disabled children ( severly disabled).. Turned out she owned the 3 acres behind it and I knew that was in the UBG ( urban growth boundry so some day right ) we swapped the bare land for the house she now had the house free and clear ( I paid 155k for it at auction) I thought ok this is going to take 3 to 5 years to get my money back ( keep in mind we dont borrow money for real estate at these price points so its free and clear no lender to worry about etc) well not 2 months goes by after we make the trade and a developer is doing a land assemblege and I sold it to him for 900k cash at close and NEtted 750k.
Now those are some of the good ones.
Bad ones:
07 had 400 plus HML out against my guidance lines market crashed guidance lines called was forced to mark to market and lost about 10mil.. Just like pretty much every other HML in the US at the time.
Lesson always have a pivot so when I regrouped and started over in 2012 making loans again and building new construction I wrote into my construction loans if the market turns as long as I have equity I had the open to term them out for 5 years and rent them. On the private financing we simply do not use credit lines we use cash so there is no fear of cash calls like what happened to me in 08.. I am a 10th of the size company that I used to be but hey stress is 90% less than having 30 to 100 million in loans out there LOL
The trigger is usually a number that came in off plan, either an appraisal under the ARV or listings sitting while rent comps hold up. You're right that changing course is a strength, but it only works if the second exit was priced before closing. A flip that turns into a rental has to clear a DSCR refi sized off market rent against the new payment, and under roughly 6 months of seasoning most DSCR lenders size it off the lower of appraisal or purchase plus documented rehab. The short-term loan's maturity and extension fees keep running the whole time. The investors who pivot calmly ran both exits on day one. The plan can change, the math behind it shouldn't. Were your pivots planned at purchase or forced by the refi math?
That's a great point. Running the numbers for both exits before closing can make a huge difference, especially when holding costs and loan maturity are involved. It's one thing to have a backup plan, but another to know whether the numbers actually support it. I like your point that the plan can change, but the math shouldn't. Have you found that more investors are starting to consider the rental exit upfront, or do most still focus primarily on the flip?
Siahna, this is an important conversation, and I agree with Noah — the pivot itself isn't the failure; the failure is not having run the second exit before you bought. On my side, the trigger I see most often is time on market. A flip that was supposed to sell in 30 days is still sitting at 60, the carrying costs are stacking up, and suddenly renting starts looking more attractive than another price cut.
The other trigger is the appraisal. When the finished value comes in below what the flip needed, holding and renting can be the better path — but only if the rent covers the payment after the refi, which is why that second set of numbers matters from day one.
The investors who pivot well are the ones who priced both exits before closing. The plan can change; the math behind it shouldn't.
Absolutely agree. Time on market can really change the equation, especially when carrying costs continue to add up. Sometimes holding the property makes more sense than accepting a lower sale price, but only if the rental numbers support that decision. It really comes down to understanding both exits before committing to the deal. Do you think investors tend to overlook the rental potential because they're too focused on the expected flip profit?
I call it the Pivot all investors need to be able to pivot. Or should have a plan B.
couple of my real world deals:
4 acres in rohnert park CA bought for 27k was going to flip it quickly for 75k in 96/97 would not perc so was not buildable at the time I knew the risk when i bought it but it was so cheap.. So instead of just making 10k or 20k on it I held it with the idea the city would grow out to me and bring sewer. Well that happened and in 2000 sold it to a developer for 2.2 mil.. Net profit 1,150,000. on a 27k purchase.
Bought a foreclosure In Portland Metro area. U know high risk.. when talking to the lady that owned the house and seeing what a family mess she had I was not looking forward to being on the news and evicting her and her 4 disabled children ( severly disabled).. Turned out she owned the 3 acres behind it and I knew that was in the UBG ( urban growth boundry so some day right ) we swapped the bare land for the house she now had the house free and clear ( I paid 155k for it at auction) I thought ok this is going to take 3 to 5 years to get my money back ( keep in mind we dont borrow money for real estate at these price points so its free and clear no lender to worry about etc) well not 2 months goes by after we make the trade and a developer is doing a land assemblege and I sold it to him for 900k cash at close and NEtted 750k.
Now those are some of the good ones.
Bad ones:
07 had 400 plus HML out against my guidance lines market crashed guidance lines called was forced to mark to market and lost about 10mil.. Just like pretty much every other HML in the US at the time.
Lesson always have a pivot so when I regrouped and started over in 2012 making loans again and building new construction I wrote into my construction loans if the market turns as long as I have equity I had the open to term them out for 5 years and rent them. On the private financing we simply do not use credit lines we use cash so there is no fear of cash calls like what happened to me in 08.. I am a 10th of the size company that I used to be but hey stress is 90% less than having 30 to 100 million in loans out there LOL
Wow, those are some incredible examples! The Rohnert Park deal especially shows how patience and recognizing the bigger potential of a property can completely change the outcome. I also appreciate you sharing the difficult side of your experience. Having a backup plan is important, but building flexibility into the financing itself is another level of preparation. Your approach to adding a term-out option to construction loans is an interesting lesson from what happened in 2008. Do you think more investors and lenders today are building those kinds of protections into their deals from the beginning?
I made a boo boo on Rohnert park math our Net was 2,150,000.00 NOT 1,150,000.00
I do not most folks today did not live through the GFC and have no clue how bad it really was for us folks that got hammered by it.
Term outs on construction loans are generally only going to work with Local community banks and bankers you know.. Would never work for nationwide type construction lenders that are using brokers to bring them deals..they sell their paper and the hedge funds are not going to buy paper with those type of terms.
Its why if I cant get a construction loan from my go to community banks I wont do the project. have to have the back up plan agreed to in writing in the prom note.
Its kind of like the though process in that great Movie the BIG SHORT who would have though mortgages could be toxic and allowed unreal returns to short the mortgage market they did because no one anticipated it would pivot like it did.. I also negotiated term outs for my Guidance lines were I had 3 years to unwind those if they called and all but one of my banks called them.. those are the Lines of credit HML use to fund todays flippers and BRRR investors I had about 40 mil of those and all but 5 mil got called but we did have some time to work through all the defaults all of us lenders were dealing with in those days. other HML who did not have those provisions basically went out of business.. And in a way so did I I went from 25 employees and 60 loans a month down to just me and one other and doing maybe 5 deals a month .. But I survived just barely though and my thoughts of buying a Jet for the company and selling the company to my top employees by 2010 went right out the friggen window.. its was a massive humbling event. Not many folks on BP will talk about this or want to talk about it since it was so terrible and traumatic for those of us that had worked for decades to build these business and then see it all come crashing down. Just like the folks that worked on wall st. you saw in the Movie one day great job making big dollars next day unemployed and 75 year old companies were toast and folded.
You're making a decision based on the information you have today, but things can change. I've seen deals where the original plan changed and the investment still worked out fine because the operator was willing to adjust instead of forcing the original strategy. For me, the important question is whether the new plan still makes sense financially. Changing direction isn't necessarily a bad thing. Refusing to change when the numbers no longer work is where I'd be concerned.