Bush Proposes Stimulus Package of 1% of GDP - Thoughts

Bush Proposes Stimulus Package of 1% of GDP - Thoughts

Joshua D.Pro Member
BiggerPockets Founder · HI · Member since 2008 · 16k+ posts · 5k+ votes

President Bush today proposed an economic stimulus package amounting to 1% of GDP. His ideas included:

Immediate implementation
No Tax Increases
Bolster business and consumer spending
Tax rebate check
No Spending Projects

Anyone have any thoughts?

0Reply
31 views

18 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Raleigh, NC · Member since 2008 · 91 posts · 0 votes
    18y

    Considering that about 2/3 of the recipients spent their entire check within 2 weeks the last time they handed these out, it can be a good thing to give a quick boost to the economy

    but to be clear, short term solutions do not solve long term problems. Federal Spending must be reduced CONSIDERABLY, and taxes must also be reduced PERMANENTLY, e.g. the Death Tax, Corporate Tax, Capital Gains tax, and a STRONG reduction in income tax across the board, but focusing a larger cut on the 25-33% tax bracket. To go from a 15% to a 25% tax bracket is the single largest jump in any tax rates, and things need to be reduced and flattened out

  • Real Estate Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2008 · 1k+ posts · 447 votes
    18y

    Keep in mind that an economy is, very simply, money in motion.

    Consumer Joe, gets his $800 rebate check. He immediately rushes to the electronics store to buy that flat screen TV he doesn’t need, but hey, it’s found money. Why use it for unimportant things like the electric bill. The TV costs $2500, but $800 is a nice down payment.

    Consumer Bill is the salesman who sold Joe the TV. He gets his commission check and goes to the local casino (this is Vegas). Blackjack dealer Betty gets a few tips from Bill as he loses that check.

    Betty takes her tips and heads to the bar to drown her sorrows over a few shots of tequila. She leaves what is left of her tips for Ralph, the bartender who is working a second job to make ends meet.

    Ralph gives his meager earnings to his wife, Amber, who is desperately trying to stave off foreclosure after their ARM ratcheted upwards.

    The shareholders of the electronics store and casino, as well as the bar owner, invest their profits. Joe can’t make the payments and the TV is taken away by the repo man. Bill can’t understand why he can’t get ahead and blames everyone but himself as he sits in the casino losing his money. Betty winds up in AA. Ralph and Amber lose their home to foreclosure and wind up on welfare.

    The economic numbers are up and the politicians crow about the success of the stimulus package. But, surprise, new numbers released after the election show that the economy is worse than before. How could that happen?

    The politicians should just leave everything alone. But they can’t help themselves, especially in an election year.

    8)

  • Joshua D.Pro Member
    OP
    BiggerPockets Founder · HI · Member since 2008 · 16k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    18y

    Lets not forget that a good amount of the money spent on that TV is not coming to the US, but going to the foreign countries that put it together. Considering that we don't manufacture anything here anymore, I wonder what percent of such a package would end up overseas......

  • Raleigh, NC · Member since 2008 · 91 posts · 0 votes
    18y

    I don't really think rehab702 is necessarily always the case, but those people sure can bark the loudest...

    I am pretty certain that if I get a check from the govt, it's going into my Etrade savings acct and earning 5.05% APY. Provided they don't go bankrupt this year (big possibility)

  • Joshua D.Pro Member
    OP
    BiggerPockets Founder · HI · Member since 2008 · 16k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    18y
    Originally posted by "arneyd":
    I am pretty certain that if I get a check from the govt, it's going into my Etrade savings acct and earning 5.05% APY. Provided they don't go bankrupt this year (big possibility)

    I closed my account when I heard about their exposure to subprime. If they don't go bust, someone is going to buy them out. Either way, I didn't want to be stuck and unable to access my money for however long it took to get things figured out......

    Sorry to digress here.

  • Raleigh, NC · Member since 2008 · 91 posts · 0 votes
    18y
    Originally posted by "biggerpo":
    Originally posted by "arneyd":
    I am pretty certain that if I get a check from the govt, it's going into my Etrade savings acct and earning 5.05% APY. Provided they don't go bankrupt this year (big possibility)

    I closed my account when I heard about their exposure to subprime. If they don't go bust, someone is going to buy them out. Either way, I didn't want to be stuck and unable to access my money for however long it took to get things figured out......

    Sorry to digress here.

    They're FDIC, and I don't have >$100k, so I'm covered.

    How long do you expect it would take to actually get the money back if they do declare bankruptcy? I can't imagine it would take any longer than a normal withdrawal transaction. It's all online.

    I also have an ING Direct account. If you want to transfer any money there let me know, there's a $25 signup bonus for you in it, plus a $10 referral bonus for me. It's simple, I just send you an email and it's good.

  • Joshua D.Pro Member
    OP
    BiggerPockets Founder · HI · Member since 2008 · 16k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    18y
    Originally posted by "arneyd":

    They're FDIC, and I don't have >$100k, so I'm covered.

    How long do you expect it would take to actually get the money back if they do declare bankruptcy? I can't imagine it would take any longer than a normal withdrawal transaction. It's all online.

    I don't know the details, but I do know that it is not that simple. Sure, FDIC protects you, but that doesn't mean that you'll be able to pull your money out when you want to. It took me several weeks to get my money out when I transfered it to another bank. I can only imagine if they declare bankruptcy how long it will take the government to sort through all of the accounts and get you your money.

    I wouldn't count on having it very quickly.

  • Rental Property Investor · Mercer Island, WA · Member since 2008 · 22k+ posts · 14k+ votes
    18y

    So, what do you do? You're money has to be somewhere. Buy gold and bury it in the back yard? Cash in the mattress?

    Jon

  • Real Estate Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2008 · 1k+ posts · 447 votes
    18y
    Originally posted by "Wheatie":
    So, what do you do? You're money has to be somewhere. Buy gold and bury it in the back yard? Cash in the mattress?

    Just like a house is only worth what someone will pay for it, a dollar is only worth what people think it is. The truth is that our currency is backed by nothing other than the “full faith and credit” of the US Government. That is a scary thought. The truth is that if foreign countries didn’t have the need to trade with us the currency would collapse. The whole system is a house of cards. Tangible assets are the only things that have any real value. In a real crisis a loaf of bread is worth more than any precious metal because, after all, you can’t eat gold.

    8)

  • Loveland, CO · Member since 2008 · 1k+ posts · 123 votes
    18y

    I wouldn't worry too much about accessing the money in the event the bank "fails". Long before they ever get to the point of accessing the FDIC to make good on your "deposits", the "Fed" arranges a shotgun marriage between your bank and another "stronger" bank.

    I went through this in the '80s in Houston. This was before (actually a prelude to) interstate banking. At the time TX didn't even have branch banking. We never noticed a hiccup in our dealings with our bank, different name, different format for the statement but no change in the balances.

    Wait, wait, WAIT!. It hasn't been two weeks since GWB was bragging about how strong the economy was, despite the $1.00+ per gallon gas tax implemented over the past 18 months. So how come things are so bad now we need a "stimulus"?

    all cash

  • Real Estate Coach · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 36 posts · 1 vote
    18y
    Originally posted by "Wheatie":
    So, what do you do? You're money has to be somewhere. Buy gold and bury it in the back yard? Cash in the mattress?

    Jon

    One of the best books on the subject is "What Has Government Done To Our Money?" by Murray Rothard -- Amazon link: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0945466447?ie=UTF8&tag=theweafor-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=0945466447

    Murray was the foremost "free market" economist in the world prior to his death in 1996 -- he was a peer and friend of Greenspan before Greenspan went over to the "dark side." I had the pleasure of studying under him during my undergraduate years.

    All the best!

  • Raleigh, NC · Member since 2008 · 91 posts · 0 votes
    18y
    Originally posted by "Rehab702":
    Originally posted by "Wheatie":
    So, what do you do? You're money has to be somewhere. Buy gold and bury it in the back yard? Cash in the mattress?

    Just like a house is only worth what someone will pay for it, a dollar is only worth what people think it is. The truth is that our currency is backed by nothing other than the “full faith and credit” of the US Government. That is a scary thought. The truth is that if foreign countries didn’t have the need to trade with us the currency would collapse. The whole system is a house of cards. Tangible assets are the only things that have any real value. In a real crisis a loaf of bread is worth more than any precious metal because, after all, you can’t eat gold.

    8)

    I don't think it's a scary thought at all. I think it's amazing how the economy works and I also think people need to realize that a 'recession' does not equal a 'depression' does not equal 'end of the world'

    It's actually quite uplifting to read so many threads about how people still make a decent buck in this market even though the housing market isn't as great as it has been in the past. And we all know it's going to come back, so now I think is a great time to buy!

    The dollar has slipped, but it's not going anywhere. Stay positive!

  • Real Estate Investor · OH · Member since 2008 · 4k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    18y

    Translated into English, that means it's backed by the government's ability to tax you and me into oblivion!

    As for the economic stimulus package -- IT'S AN OUTRAGE. Landlords are going to get screwed. I'm a victim, I'm a victim!!! (hey, somebody's gotta be the victim). I heard Chuck Shumer say that he wants the stimulus package to go to payroll taxes. What a crock! How does that help us underpriveledged landlords? We don't pay payroll taxes! I'm a victim!!!! I'M A VICTIM!!!! :protest: :protest: :protest: :protest: :protest: :protest: :protest:

    Mike (Citizens for the Equal Treatment of Landlords, Victims Advocacy Group)

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.