a. I am researching potential of converting my 5+ bedroom home in central florida to either STR or MTR. focusing first on MTR vs STR. Would appreicate any assistance on how to research or resources to look into.
b. Also where do snowbirds (seniors who come to florida) during the winter months look for MTR housing
I had two clients try to MTR setup both said way too much work and stopped after a while. One leased it to a company that does MTR subleasing which worked better but I believe still ended up just switching to self managed LTR for the next year.
Anitha, with 5+ bedrooms I’d first work out who needs that much house for a month or more: an extended family, a relocating household, or several people traveling together. Then compare homes serving that same group, rather than smaller snowbird condos. For the listing, bedroom and bathroom layout, steps, parking, laundry, and the kitchen setup would all matter for a longer stay. Which part of Central Florida is the house in, and would you rent the whole home together?
the city is auburndale. Yes thinking of renting the whole home together. I would assume renting per room is high maintenance unless I can find the correct tenant cohort..
That helps, Anitha. I’ve managed larger family vacation homes, and I’d get a cleaner to walk this one before settling on the setup. Five bedrooms’ worth of linens, bathrooms and kitchen inventory needs a clear reset plan even with fewer turnovers. Is the home already furnished, or would you be starting from scratch? That changes how much work there is before the first longer stay.
Anitha, I run most of my Florida units as a mid-term/short-term hybrid, so here's how I'd research it.
Check real mid-term demand first. I use Furnished Finder to gauge demand in a market before I move a unit to 30-day minimums. Then search Airbnb for 30+ night stays near your address to see who you'd be competing with and what they charge.
Think about who needs 5+ bedrooms for a month. Matthew's right that it's usually not a snowbird couple. My snowbird booking was on a smaller 1-bed/1-bath in a North Florida market, which fits that pattern. Larger homes tend to fit insurance replacement housing, relocating families and work crews. One of my longest stays was a construction crew that extended four times and stayed 90+ days.
Price it between two numbers. The floor is what the home would rent for long-term. The ceiling is what it could gross as a short-term rental. If the monthly rate you need is close to the STR number, few monthly guests will pay it. If it lands well above LTR rent after furnishings and utilities, mid-term can work.
Check the rules before anything else. In a lot of Florida, the 30-day line changes how your city, county or HOA treats a stay. Confirm what's allowed at your address both under 30 nights and at 30+.
You also don't have to pick just one. Most of my calendars carry 30-60 day minimums, and short stays only fill the gaps between monthly guests.
Location matters too, but for a home this size, think about what nearby demand looks like in groups. Being near a hospital alone doesn't mean much for 5+ bedrooms, since most travel nurses want a smaller place to themselves. Where it can work is several nurses traveling together on the same contract dates who want to share one house. Same with a work crew on a nearby job, or a family relocating for a new position. Those are the bookings to look for.
Is the house near anything that brings in groups like that: a hospital system that uses a lot of travel staff, a big construction project, or a major employer that relocates people?
Hey Anitha, agent on the Emerald Coast here (Destin / PCB / Pensacola side). Snowbirds on our stretch usually hunt on Airbnb with the 30+ filter on, Furnished Finder, and a lot of word of mouth from last year's stay. For a 5+ bedroom in Auburndale I'd be less focused on the classic snowbird couple and more on families relocating, insurance rebuild stays, or work crews, like John said. Pull Airbnb comps for 30+ nights near you and check Furnished Finder demand before you spend on furniture. And double-check Polk County / city rules on stays under 30 vs 30+, because that line changes a lot of the compliance picture in Florida.
@Anitha Bala thanks. Whole-home is what I'd do too. Renting by the room means more agreements, more turnover and more management for you.
Melissa's checklist on comps and Polk County rules is the right one, so I'll stick to demand. Auburndale sits between Lakeland and Winter Haven, so I'd look for groups coming from a few directions: hospital systems in both cities that use travel staff, warehouse and distribution construction along the I-4 corridor, and families relocating into Polk who need a place while they house-hunt.
One more for your calendar: Sun 'n Fun, the big airshow at the Lakeland airport every spring, really pushes rates in that area, and a 5+ bedroom is a great fit for groups coming in for it. If you go mid-term, I'd try to have a monthly stay end before it, or keep that week open for short stays, so you capture the event rate instead of locking those nights into a monthly price. That only works if short stays are allowed at your address, so confirm that first.
If you share what the house would rent for long-term, people here can help you sanity-check a monthly range. That number is your floor.
@Anitha Bala , let's connect. Between STR and MTR, a lot rides on how often you want to deal with turnovers, and in a 5+ bedroom house, every turnover is real work. Snowbirds only cover part of the year, so think about what you'd want the house doing over the summer.
I'd love to help with the strategy, and connect you with people who'd be good to know. Is the house your main home right now?
I had two clients try to MTR setup both said way too much work and stopped after a while. One leased it to a company that does MTR subleasing which worked better but I believe still ended up just switching to self managed LTR for the next year.
I saw your post about your five-bedroom home in Auburndale. I help property owners evaluate, prepare, and launch short- and mid-term rentals. Since you're still deciding which direction to take, I'd be happy to talk through what it takes to get a home like yours ready and operational.
You've had some great advice here already. John, Melissa and Matthew have covered the demand side well, so I'll add the view from the other side of the booking.
My wife and I have spent the past four years living mostly in short-term and monthly rentals. When we look at a stay of a month or more, we're not just picking a place to sleep. We're picking a place to live and work for a while, so the practical details matter far more than they do on a weekend trip.
For a house your size, I'd write the listing for the exact group you're targeting. A relocating family will want to know about schools, storage and laundry, while a work crew cares more about parking, beds and an easy check-in. Speaking clearly to one group usually beats trying to appeal to everyone.