Why I keep 60 days open after every mid-term stay (one crew extended 4 times)

Why I keep 60 days open after every mid-term stay (one crew extended 4 times)

John RacinePro Member
Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 287 posts · 151 votes

Most of the mid-term advice I see is about landing the first 30-day booking. Some of my best stays came from what happened after the booking: the guest deciding to stay longer.

Here's how I set my calendar. Most of the units I run are a mid-term/short-term hybrid. 30+ day stays are the priority, with 30 to 60 day minimums. Short stays only fill the gaps between them, from a few days up to about two weeks. The setting that's made the biggest difference is leaving a 60-day window open after each mid-term stay, so the guest can extend without having to move.

The stay that sold me on it was a construction crew. They booked 30 days and extended four times, staying 90+ days in total. If I'd stacked another booking right behind their original checkout, they'd have had to pack up and find a second place, and I'd have been back to finding a new guest.

Why it works

  • Mid-term guests rarely know their real end date. Construction jobs run long, contracts get extended, and relocations wait on closings that slip. The dates they book are their best guess.

  • An extension is the easiest booking you'll ever get: no turnover clean, no gap nights, no new guest to vet, and far fewer messages than a new guest.

  • The guest is already settled. Moving mid-project is a real hassle for them, so if the dates are open, they usually stay.

How I run it

  • I don't check in with the current guest about their plans. I let my PriceLabs setup manage the calendar and the window. The trade-off is that I could lose a booking at some point. So far that hasn't happened.

  • Extensions are priced at whatever PriceLabs shows for those dates. I don't negotiate a separate rate.

  • If a guest doesn't extend, those dates still need to fill. That's why my minimum steps down as the open dates get closer, so a leftover gap can take a shorter stay instead of sitting empty.

Where I'd think twice: if your market has a few peak weeks that bring in big nightly rates, holding 60 days open across those weeks might cost more than an extension brings in. That's where seasonality comes in. I lean on the PriceLabs Market Dashboard to see when demand in my market is strong and when it isn't, and I set things up from there.

For those of you running mid-term: do you hold any time open after a stay for extensions, or book back to back and let the guest find another place? And if you do get extensions, how do you price them?

0Reply
271 views

8 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Nadia DaggettBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Tampa, FL · Member since 2019 · 113 posts · 68 votes
    1w

    John, this matches what I keep seeing — the booked dates are a guess, especially for anyone here on a job. I have guests in a house right now who were supposed to check out October 30 and have extended three times because the job keeps running long. Nobody's annoyed about it: they're settled, I'm not paying for a turnover or a gap, and the house stays full.

    I don't formally block 60 days, but my calendars are mid-term first, so there's usually room for an extension to land — and when there isn't, that's the first conversation I have before I take a booking that would box a good guest in.

    On pricing, I keep it simple: the extension prices at the same rate structure as the original stay, run through the platform like any other nights. Guests ask about a break for extending, and I get it, but an extension is already the cheapest booking either of us will ever get — no clean, no gap, no new-guest risk — so I don't discount it on top of that.

    The one thing I'd add: get the extension in writing through the platform or a lease amendment every time, even when it's "just a few more days." The friendly verbal extension is the one that gets messy later.

    • John RacinePro Member
      OP
      Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 287 posts · 151 votes
      1w

      Good point on getting every extension in writing, Nadia. On my end, extensions are priced at whatever PriceLabs shows for those dates, so I'm not negotiating a separate rate. Three extensions on a job that keeps running long sounds a lot like my construction crew. Glad it's not just me.

      Curious, are you managing your pricing with a tool, or setting the rates manually? I find PriceLabs manages it flawlessly and effortlessly for me.

  • Member since 2023 · 7 posts · 9 votes
    1w

    I always leave my calendar open and check with my guest about 4 to 6 weeks before their lease end date. My guests are mostly traveling medical professionals and their contracts usually start at 3 months. My first pair of nurses ended up staying over a year and my current x-ray techs will have been with me for 10 months. They were able to tell me there would not be any additional extensions when we amended their lease the last time, so I will now take bookings. I usually do not raise the rent price for the first extension and will consider it for continuing extensions based on the market, but usually do not. I only have one rental and so do not use PriceLabs.

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 287 posts · 151 votes
    1w

    @Jennifer Frim over a year with your first pair of nurses is a great run. Checking in 4 to 6 weeks out makes a lot of sense when your guests are on 3-month contracts and can tell you where they stand. With one rental, a conversation does the job.

    Most of my guests are work crews, and they often don't know their end date until the job tells them, so I let the calendar handle it. Same idea either way: leave room for the extension before you book the next guest right behind them.

    I like that you don't raise the rent on the first extension. A guest who's been great for 10 months is worth more than a small bump.

    I also saw your note on my other post that every booking in three years has come through Furnished Finder. That's a good reminder that channel results depend on the property and who it serves. Close to three hospitals, that makes a lot of sense.

  • Michael K GallagherBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus OH · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1w

    these are great insights, thanks for sharing.

  • Technology · Marietta, GA · Member since 2018 · 4 posts · 1 vote
    2d

    We look at every stay 30 days before move-out. First question to the tenant: do you want to extend? Nurses get extended more often than you think. If not, we put the empty dates on a list next to every request that fits them and send an offer the same day. A 3-week gap costs more than a small discount.

    • John RacinePro Member
      OP
      Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 287 posts · 151 votes
      2d

      Ingo, the 30-day check-in is a good habit. I handle the same thing mostly through minimum stays in PriceLabs instead of asking for a decision by a set date. The dates after a mid-term booking carry a long minimum, and as checkout gets closer the minimum steps down, to 14 days and then lower. An extension is still possible, and if nobody extends, short stays can fill the gap. Agree that a 3-week gap costs more than a small discount. Work crews are my biggest group, and like your nurses, their end dates move. One crew extended 4 times.

  • Member since 2022 · 81 posts · 44 votes
    3h

    @John Racine do you mind sharing how you structure your pricelabs for MTR? I'm also running an STR/MTR hybrid. I use pricelabs for STR, but am stumped how to get it to work for an MTR? Are most of your MTRs coming from OTAs? Thanks!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.