Realtor · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes
For medium term rental investors who use property managers, what do you look for in your property managers? How do you select who to move forward with? What do you prioritize the most in your decision?
Full disclosure: I co-host short- and mid-term rentals for other owners, so I'm answering from the manager's side. Here's what I'd want an owner to ask me.
1. Do they actually know mid-term, or are they an STR manager who takes the odd 30-day stay? Ask how they price a monthly stay. I price between what the unit would get on a 12-month lease (the floor) and what it could gross nightly (the ceiling). If they can't explain their monthly rate against the 12-month rent, that's a red flag.
2. Who controls pricing, and who's watching it? Quite a few operators use one flat price for mid-term, so there could be some lost opportunity. Mid-term pricing has to account for utilities, mid-stay cleans, gaps, stay length and the season. I use PriceLabs, but whatever the tool, someone has to be reviewing it.
3. What happens to the calendar after a 60-day booking? Mid-term guests rarely know their real end date. A good manager leaves room for an extension and has a plan for filling the gap if the guest doesn't extend.
4. Screening and paperwork on 28+ night stays: ID check, signed agreement, how the deposit is held, and a utility cap so normal usage is included and the guest covers the overage.
5. Whose account is the listing in, and how does the money flow? I work in the owner's Airbnb account with split payouts, so if an owner is ever unhappy, the listing is still theirs. If a manager collects all the payouts and sends you your share, look into how that works in your state. It can fall under property management licensing rules.
6. Does anyone see the unit during the stay? Every mid-term stay I run includes a mid-stay clean every 30 days, so nobody finds out about the unit's condition only at checkout.
If I had to pick one priority, it's pricing and the calendar. That's where most of the money is made or lost on a mid-term.
John covered the big ones. One more I'd add for mid-term: ask how the manager handles the point where a guest stops being a guest. In a lot of states and cities, a stay of 30 days or more can give the occupant tenant rights, which means if someone stops paying or won't leave, you may be looking at a formal eviction instead of a platform dispute.
So ask what agreement they use for 30+ night stays, whether it was written for your state, and what they've actually done when a mid-term guest overstayed or went quiet on payment. A manager who has been through it once will answer that very differently from one who hasn't. Your local rules decide the details, so it's worth a quick check with a local attorney too.
Disclosure: I own One Fine BnB, a vacation rental management company.
I manage furnished homes in Atlanta, and stays of 28+ nights are about half our stay revenue. What owners ask us first: how fast does a lead get an answer (minutes, not hours), who fills the empty weeks between stays, and does the statement split a stay across months, so that May shows only May's nights and the fee follows the same split. Ask any manager you interview to show you a real statement for a stay that ran over two months.