Rental Property Investor · Carlsbad, CA · Member since 2014 · 127 posts · 28 votes
I am currently reviewing the purchase agreement for a 26 unit in Garden City and am trying to line up some of the necessities. I have been getting quotes from companies I found by just googling commercial insurance brokers in the area, but the quotes seem high to me. I have multiple single family homes and duplexes in the same area and I'm paying $35-40/door/month, but the quotes I'm getting are $42 or higher. I was thinking it would be cheaper.
Is that the trend that others are seeing or am I just off base?
Farmers is one of the few big boys that is investor friendly. They can do up to 20 home on personal lines even if they are held in an entity such as an LLC. They have very competitive commercial policies as well. They are kind of a hybrid in the market in that yes they are a captive company, but after Farmers looks at the policy, if they cant do it for whatever reason, then the agent is free to broker it to whatever carrier they want. Many agents have excellent outside lines and specialty lines carriers contacts. So you get the best of both worlds.
They also own foremost who has no restrictions on the numbers of homes you can insure with them. Foremost will insure an LLC or entity on personal lines. They have a hybrid personal lines policy such that you are allowed to schedule up to 36 properties per policy, with no restrictions on the numbers of policies you can have with them. This is very convenient for tracking purposes, just 1 dec. page and it also eliminates services fees on each individual property.