Looking for First Property - Create an LLC first?

Charlotte, North Carolina
First-Time Home Buyer
5moFollow

Looking for First Property - Create an LLC first?

Kelly Beres
New to Real Estate · Charlotte NC · Member since 2022 · 10 posts · 15 votes

Hi All - I'm actively looking to buy my first rental property in Charlotte, NC. My plan is to do a BRRRR and build a portfolio in the next several years. Should I set up an LLC before my first purchase? And if so, any helpful tips in doing so?

Appreciate an insights!

3Reply
660 views

Most Popular Reply

Ryan Coon
Attorney · Spanish Fork, UT · Member since 2025 · 77 posts · 97 votes
5mo

You've waded (perhaps unwittingly) into the age-old and long-debated question of when to form an LLC. As you can see, opinions are all over the map. However, as an attorney who has worked with hundreds of real estate investors to secure their assets, I'll offer my two cents on why earlier is often better.

1. Insurance is a Tool, Not a Shield

You will often hear people suggest getting more insurance instead of an LLC, especially early in your journey. While insurance is a vital tool, I caution against relying on it as your sole remedy.

Insurance policies are full of "carve-outs" that allow providers to deny payouts. From toxic mold and environmental factors to dog bites from "dangerous breeds," I've seen providers walk away and leave investors to foot the bill for catastrophic liabilities. Remember: insurance companies make money by collecting premiums, not by paying out claims. An LLC provides a layer of protection that doesn't depend on a claims adjuster's approval.

2. The Freddie/Fannie "Due-on-Sale" Myth

Many investors avoid LLCs because traditional Freddie Mac or Fannie Mae loans generally require you to close in your own name. While these loan docs contain "due-on-sale" clauses, there is a common misconception regarding transfers.

Both Freddie and Fannie expressly allow you to transfer your real estate to an LLC that is wholly owned by you. This carve-out is explicitly in their guidelines. You can close personally to get the best rate and then transfer the title to your entity without triggering the clause, provided you follow the proper procedure.

3. Small Investors Have More to Lose

There is a myth that you only need an LLC once you have a "large" portfolio. I argue the opposite: New investors need protection more than anyone.

If a mogul with 100 doors faces a catastrophic liability that wipes out three properties, their bottom line is bruised, but their life is unchanged. If you only have two or three properties, a single catastrophic incident can wipe out your entire portfolio and set you back decades. The "little guy" has a much lower margin for error.

The Bottom Line

Liability planning is an individual decision based on your personal risk tolerance. No one on this forum has to sleep on your pillow; you have to decide what level of exposure allows you to rest easy.

Because I spend my days in the nitty-gritty of business structuring, I recommend using an LLC even for your very first property. It's better to have the bucket under the leak before it starts raining.

5Reply
See this reply in the discussion

25 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jay TolugantiPro Member
    Investor · Clearwater, FL · Member since 2025 · 224 posts · 76 votes
    5mo

    I buy my properties on LLC. I have different goals. Please talk to your CPA and attorney.

    since you are starting out, I would recommend below books for you to read/listen:

    Strategy:

    Rich man in Babylon

    Robert Kiosaki

    • Rich Dad Poor Dad
    • Cashflow Quadrant
    • Guide to investing
    • Real book of Real Estate

    Real Estate Journey:

    Ken McKelroy

    • ABCs of Real Estate Investing
    • Advanced book of Real Estate Investing
    • ABC of Property management
    2Reply
  • Julius VincentBusiness Member
    Tax Strategist | CPA, MBA + Wharton FP&A | CFO-Level Planning · Houston, TX · Member since 2025 · 157 posts · 172 votes
    5mo

    Hi @Kelly Beres - I work with a lot of real estate investors on the tax side. An LLC at property #1 is usually overkill, especially for a BRRRR strategy where financing is involved.

    Most lenders won't finance an LLC for residential purposes, so you'd likely need to buy in your own name anyway and deed it over later (which can trigger the due-on-sale clause). All you need is a good umbrella insurance policy, which would cover most of the liability protection people think they need an LLC for. Also, the tax benefits of an LLC for rental property are often overstated. You get the same deductions either way.

    Once you're 3-4 properties in, cash-flowing well, and thinking about longer-term asset protection structuring, an LLC starts to make sense.

    [email protected]281-407-7353
    Horizon Wealth & Tax Advisors510 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    2Reply
    • Jay TolugantiPro Member
      Investor · Clearwater, FL · Member since 2025 · 224 posts · 76 votes
      5mo

      @Julius Vincent I disagree with you. I did two BRRR projects in last 14 months and both are funded by HML and refi with a bank. No one had issue with LLCs.

      0Reply
    • Mendy J.
      Investor · NY · Member since 2026 · 121 posts · 42 votes
      5mo

      @Jay Toluganti you're right LLCs are made for investors, especially when you take out Construction loans for BRRR. I also had the same experience.

      1Reply
  • Julius VincentBusiness Member
    Tax Strategist | CPA, MBA + Wharton FP&A | CFO-Level Planning · Houston, TX · Member since 2025 · 157 posts · 172 votes
    5mo

    @Jay Toluganti - Glad your process with HML is working. But most conventional residential lenders (Fannie/Freddie) still won't finance an LLC, and those make up the bulk of the lending market for first-time investors. HML is a smaller subset of the lending world and comes with significantly higher interest rates, which works when you're planning to refi out quickly, like you did.

    The due-on-sale clause is also very real. Going the HML route and refinancing into an LLC-friendly product (DSCR, portfolio, commercial) sidesteps that issue, but conventional investors who buy in their personal name and later deed to an LLC are still taking on that risk, even if it's rarely enforced.

    So if @Kelly Beres is going conventional on property #1, the LLC-first approach creates more friction than it's worth. If she's going the HML to refi route you described, it's a different calc.

    [email protected]281-407-7353
    Horizon Wealth & Tax Advisors510 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    1Reply
  • Denise SuppleeBusiness Member
    Realtor · Willow Grove, PA · Member since 2017 · 965 posts · 637 votes
    5mo

    @Kelly Beres, most investors don't use an LLC for their first deal, mainly because it's not really needed at that stage. Lenders typically prefer lending to you personally, so you'll get better rates and easier approvals. LLCs become more useful as you scale more properties, more liability, more complexity.

    Spark Rental Co-Investing Club577 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    0Reply
  • Jay TolugantiPro Member
    Investor · Clearwater, FL · Member since 2025 · 224 posts · 76 votes
    5mo

    @Julius Vincent she is talking about doing a BRRR meaning she will buy and rehab. I dont think conventional lenders would touch a fixer upper as it wont apprise to ARV.

    1Reply
  • Len Mazur
    Investor · Dallas · Member since 2025 · 12 posts · 15 votes
    5mo

    Hi Kelly, I started the same as you, and we are up to 6 single family homes in the Dallas area. We formed an LLC, however, ended up getting the traditional 30 year fixed mortgage, and that's only available through fannie/freddie. As @Julius Vincent mentions, those loans won't lend to LLCs.  Numerous lawyers and investors will suggest to get the mortgage and then transfer the deed to the LLC, however, if you look at the mortgage docs closely, you will see that they can call the loan if there is a loan assignment.  Thus, I do not advise to take that risk.

    The question becomes why you need the LLC, and its largely for liability and taxes. You can get that protection through an Umbrella policy on your insurance. Also, you can still establish a schedule C for the LLC. We actually setup the LLC and created a different bank account to keep funds and expenses biforcated and have tenants Zelle payments to that account, but it really doesn't need to be an LLC.

    Also to add, you can have up to 10 rental properties for the 30 year fixed, which I think is the best product to get - if you are planning long term and think we will continue to print money.  You can always refinance as well, but being locked in for 30 years will be great if you can increase rents YoY. 

    Lastly, I'll add that if you want smoother ride, I'd buy in a good school district and set a credit score minimum of 670 as statistically you will have better quality tenants. 

    2Reply
  • Mendy J.
    Investor · NY · Member since 2026 · 121 posts · 42 votes
    5mo

    Hey Kelly. 
    if you plan on doing your first buy a BRRR I would recommend you checking out Construction lenders. There is a lot out there and they are made for investors. and yes, they lend for LLC's.

    most of them are solid when it comes to speed and approval

    2Reply
  • Julius VincentBusiness Member
    Tax Strategist | CPA, MBA + Wharton FP&A | CFO-Level Planning · Houston, TX · Member since 2025 · 157 posts · 172 votes
    5mo

    Agree with @Mendy J.and @Jay Toluganti. LLCs do fit cleanly on the acquisition side as HML into a bank refi is a common BRRRR path. My point was that on deal #1, an LLC isn't imperative. A single-member LLC is a disregarded entity, so the tax treatment is identical to holding personally. The real value is asset protection, which a solid umbrella policy largely replicates at a fraction of the cost and complexity on property #1. And on the refi side, if you're going conventional (not DSCR), Fannie/Freddie still won't lend to an LLC. So you're deeding back anyway. LLCs definitely earn their keep as the portfolio grows; I just wouldn't call them mandatory for a first deal.

    [email protected]281-407-7353
    Horizon Wealth & Tax Advisors510 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    1Reply
    • Mendy J.
      Investor · NY · Member since 2026 · 121 posts · 42 votes
      5mo

      @Julius Vincent I didn't say it's mandatory but I did disagree that LLC can't work and I think LLC should work and I also believe that DSCR loans are the way to go for investors especially After the Construction, when you want to get your money out fast as possible.
      But if someone just buys first primary home or just a Turkey single-family wouldn't be a bad idea to Use Personal name for that.

      0Reply
    • Julius VincentBusiness Member
      Tax Strategist | CPA, MBA + Wharton FP&A | CFO-Level Planning · Houston, TX · Member since 2025 · 157 posts · 172 votes
      5mo

      @Mendy J. - 100% agree. 

      [email protected]281-407-7353
      Horizon Wealth & Tax Advisors510 Reviews
      WebsiteView Page
      0Reply
  • Vontay Callahan
    Real Estate Broker · Lincoln, NE · Member since 2026 · 64 posts · 12 votes
    5mo

    Kelly, you’re getting a lot of good perspectives here — the real answer depends on your financing path and how you plan to scale.

    For a first BRRRR, most investors I work with start in their personal name because it keeps lending simple and rates lower. Once the rehab is done and the property is stabilized, that's when they look at DSCR or portfolio products that do allow LLC ownership without friction.

    The bigger question is what you’re optimizing for right now:

    • Speed + simplicity → personal name + umbrella policy
    • BRRRR with HML/DSCR → LLC can work cleanly from day one
    • Long‑term scaling + multiple properties → LLC structure becomes more valuable as you grow

    You're thinking about this at the right time — just don't let the LLC decision slow down getting into your first deal. The financing strategy you choose will naturally point you toward the right structure.

    If you want, I can break down the pros/cons of each route based on your BRRRR plan and the lenders you're considering, and even run your numbers and help you through the process completely start to finish

    0Reply
  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5mo

    Hi Kelly, congrats on jumping in. This is a great question and one that comes up often. You've already gotten some solid answers here. Like others mentioned from a tax perspective, an LLC doesn't automatically create tax savings. A single-member LLC is typically disregarded for tax purposes, meaning it's taxed the same as if you owned the property in your personal name. The main benefits are liability protection and cleaner organization.

    Buying the first property in your personal name keeps financing simple, then transferring to an LLC later if your lender allows it or once you start building a portfolio. As you scale into multiple properties or partners, that’s when LLCs become more valuable from a structure and risk standpoint.

    If you’re in a position where house hacking is an option, that can be a really good starting point because you could secure more favorable owner-occupied financing and get some hands-on management experience while reducing your living expenses. From a tax standpoint, if part of the property is rented, you’re typically able to deduct a portion of expenses like mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and depreciation based on the rental allocation, while also potentially getting your part of the mortgage covered to help you save to reinvest/upgrade. 

    Early on, keeping things simple and focusing on getting the first deal done usually matters more than perfect structuring. You can always optimize as you grow.

    Building your team is a good place to start, a lender, a real estate agent in your target area, and eventually a CPA who specializes in real estate strategy can help a lot. Good luck and happy to connect!

    [email protected]941-914-7779
    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®5241 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    TaxMD™ | AI-Powered Tax Planning
    WebsiteView Page
    0Reply
  • Ryan Coon
    Attorney · Spanish Fork, UT · Member since 2025 · 77 posts · 97 votes
    5mo

    You've waded (perhaps unwittingly) into the age-old and long-debated question of when to form an LLC. As you can see, opinions are all over the map. However, as an attorney who has worked with hundreds of real estate investors to secure their assets, I'll offer my two cents on why earlier is often better.

    1. Insurance is a Tool, Not a Shield

    You will often hear people suggest getting more insurance instead of an LLC, especially early in your journey. While insurance is a vital tool, I caution against relying on it as your sole remedy.

    Insurance policies are full of "carve-outs" that allow providers to deny payouts. From toxic mold and environmental factors to dog bites from "dangerous breeds," I've seen providers walk away and leave investors to foot the bill for catastrophic liabilities. Remember: insurance companies make money by collecting premiums, not by paying out claims. An LLC provides a layer of protection that doesn't depend on a claims adjuster's approval.

    2. The Freddie/Fannie "Due-on-Sale" Myth

    Many investors avoid LLCs because traditional Freddie Mac or Fannie Mae loans generally require you to close in your own name. While these loan docs contain "due-on-sale" clauses, there is a common misconception regarding transfers.

    Both Freddie and Fannie expressly allow you to transfer your real estate to an LLC that is wholly owned by you. This carve-out is explicitly in their guidelines. You can close personally to get the best rate and then transfer the title to your entity without triggering the clause, provided you follow the proper procedure.

    3. Small Investors Have More to Lose

    There is a myth that you only need an LLC once you have a "large" portfolio. I argue the opposite: New investors need protection more than anyone.

    If a mogul with 100 doors faces a catastrophic liability that wipes out three properties, their bottom line is bruised, but their life is unchanged. If you only have two or three properties, a single catastrophic incident can wipe out your entire portfolio and set you back decades. The "little guy" has a much lower margin for error.

    The Bottom Line

    Liability planning is an individual decision based on your personal risk tolerance. No one on this forum has to sleep on your pillow; you have to decide what level of exposure allows you to rest easy.

    Because I spend my days in the nitty-gritty of business structuring, I recommend using an LLC even for your very first property. It's better to have the bucket under the leak before it starts raining.

    5Reply
  • Joyce Ann MagallanesBusiness Member
    Lender · NY · Member since 2025 · 496 posts · 21 votes
    5mo

    Hi Kelly, we just sent you a message with more details, feel free to check. Thank you. 

    [email protected]646-914-9393
    Venture Estate Group LLC525 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    0Reply
  • Kelly Beres
    OP
    New to Real Estate · Charlotte NC · Member since 2022 · 10 posts · 15 votes
    4mo

    Thank you all so much for your input!! @Julius Vincent @Jay Toluganti @Denise Supplee @Mendy J. @Len Mazur @Vontay Callahan @Ashish Acharya @Ryan Coon

    It is extremely helpful, and I didn't realize this topic has many differing viewpoints/ perspective. I guess as with anything a lot of it depends on your specific situation and goals. I will also talk to my lender as I hadn't really thought about how that changes getting financing. It is all a bit overwhelming but trying to learn things step by step as I work to find the right deal as well. Thanks!

    2Reply
  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4mo
    Quote from @Kelly Beres:

    Hi All - I'm actively looking to buy my first rental property in Charlotte, NC. My plan is to do a BRRRR and build a portfolio in the next several years. Should I set up an LLC before my first purchase? And if so, any helpful tips in doing so?

    Appreciate an insights!

    Hey Kelly, welcome to BiggerPockets! On this one, there isn’t a single “right” answer, but most new investors doing a BRRRR usually end up buying their first property in their personal name first, mainly because it keeps financing way simpler—most lenders want the loan under you anyway, especially on the first deal, and then once you refinance after the rehab you can sometimes move things into an LLC depending on the lender and state rules. If you form an LLC too early, you can run into higher rates, stricter lending requirements, or even lenders not wanting to touch the deal at all, which can make a BRRRR harder to execute. A lot of people instead wait until they’ve got at least one or two deals done, then start building LLC structures for liability and tax planning with a CPA and attorney who can set it up properly for their state. Also worth thinking about insurance either way, since that’s really your first layer of protection. I’d focus more on getting the first deal done right and making sure the numbers work cleanly, then optimize the structure once you’re rolling.
    [email protected]614-300-7535
    Jimmy Lieu, Red 1 Realty4.9120 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    0Reply
  • Basit SiddiqiBusiness Member
    Accountant · New York, NY · Member since 2015 · 8k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4mo

    Personally, I would not focus on getting an LLC unless you fall into one of the folowing scenarios(You can have your own scenario and you should consult with an attorney).

    1. You are buying properties with more than 1 person on title
    2. You work in an industry(I.E. Medicine) that is highly litigious
    3. Your net worth or the value of property has reached above a certain threshold(For me, it is $1,000,000)

    best of luck

    [email protected]917-280-8544
    Basit Siddiqi CPA4.979 Reviews
    View Page
    1Reply
  • Jason MalabuteBusiness Member
    Accountant · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 897 votes
    4mo

    Congrats on starting your BRRRR journey, Kelly. For a first property, an LLC is usually more complication than it's worth. A single-member LLC is a disregarded entity for federal tax purposes, so you end up with the same write-offs whether title is held in your personal name or in the LLC, the tax benefit a lot of people expect just isn't really there. Most conventional residential lenders also won't underwrite a mortgage directly to an LLC, so going that route can mean fewer loan options, higher rates, or deeding the property over later, which can bump into the due-on-sale clause. A solid umbrella insurance policy covers most of the liability concerns people are trying to solve with an LLC, at a fraction of the cost and complexity. Once you've got a few properties under your belt and the portfolio starts to scale, that's when the entity structure really starts to earn its keep. Every situation is different though, so it's worth running this past your own CPA or tax advisor first.

    Malabute & Company CPAs525 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    0Reply
  • Ryan Coon
    Attorney · Spanish Fork, UT · Member since 2025 · 77 posts · 97 votes
    4mo

    Obviously, what type of liability planning investors engage in (insurance, LLCs, etc.) is an individual decision largely based on the individuals risk tolerance. However, I would caution against relying too heavily on insurance, umbrella or otherwise, as one's sole protection. While insurance can be a great tool and has a place in virtually all risk planning, it does come with some serious limitations that shouldn't be ignored.

    The truth is, insurance policies are often designed to exclude the very things you’d actually need them for in a crisis. These "carve-outs" usually target the highest-liability scenarios—the stuff that can actually bankrupt you. Think about things like:

    • Environmental Issues: Toxic mold, lead paint, and asbestos are routinely excluded.
    • Tenant Activity: If a tenant runs a meth lab or a hazardous business on-site, a lot of policies will hide behind "pollution" clauses to deny your claim (and no your lease terms generally aren't enough to waive your liability).
    • Animal Liability: Many policies won't touch incidents involving "dangerous breeds" such as a dog bite from a Pit Bull, Rottweiler, Doberman, etc.

    It’s a bit of a "catch-22"—the insurance often doesn’t cover you for the things you need it for most.

    And let’s not forget that every policy has a payout cap. It is standard practice for plaintiff’s attorneys to find ways to file suits where the damages are intentionally calculated to blow right past your insurance maximum. If a claim is denied because of a carve-out—or if the judgment exceeds your policy limit—your personal assets are the next thing they’ll go after.

    This is exactly why that legal separation via an LLC matters so much. Insurance is your first line of defense, but the LLC is the actual fortress. You want to make sure your personal life isn't tied to a claims adjuster's mood or the fine print in a policy.

    0Reply
  • Erin Bishop
    Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    1mo

    Why are you considering an LLC? I want to flag something before it causes a problem down the road — the thread is mixing up two separate items. As a Divorce and Transition Specialist, I am very familiar with the Garn St Germain Act of 1982 which is not pertinent in your case.

    Conventional loans (Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac) can only be made to a person, not an LLC. If you want the property held in an entity from day one, that needs a different type of loan. The reason to choose a Conventional loan is the terms are usually more beneficial to you.

    Moving title after the loan already exists: This is a due-on-sale question. A conventional mortgage almost certainly has a due-on-sale clause — if title transfers without the lender's consent, they can call the loan due. The Garn-St. Germain Act protects certain transfers from due on sale(death, divorce decree, revocable living trust) — but a transfer into an LLC isn't on that list, even a single-member LLC you fully own yourself. However, Fannie Mae's Servicing Guide (D1-4.1-02) and Freddie Mac's Servicing Guide (Section 8406.4(b)) each contain an express, written exception permitting a transfer to an LLC wholly/majority-owned by the same borrower, without triggering acceleration. Since servicers are contractually bound to follow the applicable guide on loans Fannie/Freddie own, that's a real, documented rule — not discretion. Bottom line: work with a Real Estate attorney and a CPA. Spend the time and money before any potential hurdles arise. Education is important! Before moving title into an LLC, I would confirm who actually holds and services your loan and get any exception in writing. Happy to walk through it together whenever works for you.

    0Reply
  • Ali Najjar
    Lender · NJ · Member since 2025 · 50 posts · 23 votes
    1mo

    I'd generally set up the LLC before closing if the property is going to be held in the LLC, but I'd confirm the lender's requirements first. Some lenders won't lend to an LLC directly for certain residential programs, while others have specific entity requirements.

    Since you're planning to BRRRR, I'd also make sure the LLC structure works with the financing you plan to use for the refinance.

    0Reply
  • Xavier Milsoni
    Member since 2026 · 26 posts · 3 votes
    3w

    yes an LLC will never hurt

    0Reply
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.
Log InJoin for Free