Questions to Ask from new Property management company for out of state investing?

Questions to Ask from new Property management company for out of state investing?

Member since 2023 · 11 posts · 17 votes

Just curious if anyone has a checklist that they go through when evaluating new property management companies for out of state investing?

Any questions you specifically ask? Any red flags that steer you away? Any processes you have in place. 

2Reply
815 views

Most Popular Reply

Interior Decorator · Ulster County, NY · Member since 2020 · 204 posts · 177 votes
2y

I generally would ask the same questions of one that I would be interviewing locally. Check for references, comps on their rental information, sample leases, who is running the company and their background, insurance coverage and what all is included and the fee rates. Additionally though I would ask them about Facetiming. If I am owning a place out of state, a property manager can say anything or photoshop any picture to show me the condition of the house. So I would ask them to be available a few times a year to Facetime a property visit to check the condition of the house.

Also, make sure that you too are up-to-date with the local rental laws in that city, state and county. Don't rely on the property manager to know them and/or follow them. You need to know them inside and out first so you can verify they are handling the legalities in a correct manner because ultimately you are responsible for following the laws.


Lastly, how willing are they to talk to you and how genuine and sincere do you feel when you ask them questions and receive answers. The same intuition you use when meeting someone locally should be applied here. If someone is rushing to get you off the phone, or they are extremely sales pitchy...keep looking.


Congrats on taking this next step! Super excited for you! You got this!

See this reply in the discussion

15 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Interior Decorator · Ulster County, NY · Member since 2020 · 204 posts · 177 votes
    2y

    I generally would ask the same questions of one that I would be interviewing locally. Check for references, comps on their rental information, sample leases, who is running the company and their background, insurance coverage and what all is included and the fee rates. Additionally though I would ask them about Facetiming. If I am owning a place out of state, a property manager can say anything or photoshop any picture to show me the condition of the house. So I would ask them to be available a few times a year to Facetime a property visit to check the condition of the house.

    Also, make sure that you too are up-to-date with the local rental laws in that city, state and county. Don't rely on the property manager to know them and/or follow them. You need to know them inside and out first so you can verify they are handling the legalities in a correct manner because ultimately you are responsible for following the laws.


    Lastly, how willing are they to talk to you and how genuine and sincere do you feel when you ask them questions and receive answers. The same intuition you use when meeting someone locally should be applied here. If someone is rushing to get you off the phone, or they are extremely sales pitchy...keep looking.


    Congrats on taking this next step! Super excited for you! You got this!

  • Member since 2023 · 11 posts · 17 votes
    2y

    Thanks, very helpful!!


    are there specific things you are looking out for on their leases or just to make sure they include what I would want?

  • Michael SmytheBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Metro Detroit · Member since 2023 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2y

    @Jay A. recommend checking out and comparing their websites, then their management contracts.

    CHALLENENGE: most PMCs really only list their services on their websites and brag about how they are better than the competition. 

    The problem with that is YOU, as an investor, have no idea HOW they will perform those services. That's what separates bad from good and good from great PMCs. 

    Yes, most PMCs offer the same services, but the nightmares start when they don't perform those services well!

    Same goes for their management contracts. Don't make the MISTAKE of thinking shorter is better! There's a reason listing & purchase contracts are so long. They're to protect both parties by listing everything that can realistically go wrong and/or has resulted in a lawsuit.

    Well written management contracts should follow the same logic. 

    HOW a PMC will execute their services should be spelled out somewhere - otherwise how will you know they are doing their job correctly?

    Of course, you can also just gamble and go with the cheapest PMC, but you'll usually get exactly what you pay for.

    Logical Property Management4.9463 Reviews
  • Greg ParkerBusiness Member
    Realtor, Contractor, Property Manager · Montgomery AL and Kowaliga, AL · Member since 2017 · 670 posts · 536 votes
    2y

    Get a sample lease management agreement.

    Ask about maintenance upcharges, what amount does not need owner approval? ($400)

    How often do they inspect?

    Response time to your questions.....if they take 2 days to respond to you, they probably take 2 days to respond to a tenant.

    MGM Property Pros LLC
    View Page
  • Member since 2023 · 11 posts · 17 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Greg Parker:

    Get a sample lease management agreement.

    Ask about maintenance upcharges, what amount does not need owner approval? ($400)

    How often do they inspect?

    Response time to your questions.....if they take 2 days to respond to you, they probably take 2 days to respond to a tenant.


     thanks for these wonderful suggestions!

  • Detroit, MI · Member since 2022 · 118 posts · 49 votes
    2y

    Hi Jay! For any property management company that you reach out to, I would suggest asking about their processes and background in that market. They should be able to give you some insight about the market you are looking into as well.

  • Member since 2023 · 27 posts · 5 votes
    2mo

    I'll give you the question I'd ask first, then red flags, then the two documents nobody reads closely enough.

    The question: is your management fee charged on rent collected, or on rent due?

    Some companies bill a percentage of scheduled rent, which means they get paid whether or not your tenant pays. On a vacant unit too, in some agreements.

    Think about what that does to their urgency on collections. You want the fee tied to money that actually landed in the account.

    Second one in the same family: who keeps the late fees? If the company keeps all of them, there's now a small financial reason for your tenant to pay late. (Nobody's plotting. I'd rather not build the incentive and then hope.)

    Red flags, since you asked.

    They can't tell you their average days on market last quarter. Any competent company knows that number. "We rent fast" is not a number.

    Their screening criteria aren't written down and published. That's a fair housing problem waiting to happen and you're the owner, so it lands on you.

    They won't give you references from owners who left. Current owners are curated. Ask for three current and two former, and pay attention to how they react to the second half of that request.

    Nobody answers the phone at 6pm on a Saturday. Renters look at properties on weekends and evenings.

    And the one I'd weight most: the same person who performs the work also signs off that the work is done. That arrangement pays somebody to tell you they did a good job.

    You asked what to look for in the lease itself. Here's what I read for.

    Who is the landlord on the lease, you or the management company? You want your entity named, because if you fire them, you want the leases to come with you.

    Late fee amount and when it triggers. Make sure it's high enough that rent gets paid before other bills.

    Notice requirements to enter, and whether they match your state's law.

    The maintenance section. Does it define what the tenant is responsible for, or is everything the owner's problem by default?

    Lease term end dates. Watch for a lease that expires in December or January, because filling a vacancy in winter is brutal. I write winter move-ins at fourteen or fifteen months so renewals land in spring.

    Pet policy, pet rent, and whether pet rent flows to you or to them.

    Now the management agreement, which matters more than the lease and gets read less.

    The termination clause. How do you leave, how much notice, and what does it cost? Some agreements have a penalty that makes leaving painful, which is exactly when you'll want to.

    The indemnity clause. Read it out loud. Some are written so the owner carries the entire burden in any dispute, including ones the manager caused.

    The dollar threshold for repairs they can make without calling you.

    Whether they mark up maintenance invoices, and by how much. Ask whether maintenance is in-house or contracted out, and if it's in-house, ask how they price against outside bids.

    Whether they charge a fee when a tenant renews, and what work that fee buys. A rent review against current comps, a lease redraft, a walkthrough. If it buys those, fine. If it's a fee for printing a document, negotiate it.

    Two process things I'd hold to regardless of who you hire.

    Keep final say on tenant approval. They can run every other part of the operation. You decide who lives in your property.

    And separate the doing from the confirming on every turn and every repair. A third party shoots narrated video with the date visible, and nobody gets paid until that video exists.

    Last thing. Call more companies than feels necessary. Five, not two.

    You can't call one company, get all your answers, and decide that's the right one. Every answer any single one of them gives you is an opinion. Stack five and the pattern shows up on its own.

    • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
      2mo
      Quote from @Stacy Conkey:

      I'll give you the question I'd ask first, then red flags, then the two documents nobody reads closely enough.

      The question: is your management fee charged on rent collected, or on rent due?

      Some companies bill a percentage of scheduled rent, which means they get paid whether or not your tenant pays. On a vacant unit too, in some agreements.

      Think about what that does to their urgency on collections. You want the fee tied to money that actually landed in the account.

      Second one in the same family: who keeps the late fees? If the company keeps all of them, there's now a small financial reason for your tenant to pay late. (Nobody's plotting. I'd rather not build the incentive and then hope.)

      Red flags, since you asked.

      They can't tell you their average days on market last quarter. Any competent company knows that number. "We rent fast" is not a number.

      Their screening criteria aren't written down and published. That's a fair housing problem waiting to happen and you're the owner, so it lands on you.

      They won't give you references from owners who left. Current owners are curated. Ask for three current and two former, and pay attention to how they react to the second half of that request.

      Nobody answers the phone at 6pm on a Saturday. Renters look at properties on weekends and evenings.

      And the one I'd weight most: the same person who performs the work also signs off that the work is done. That arrangement pays somebody to tell you they did a good job.

      You asked what to look for in the lease itself. Here's what I read for.

      Who is the landlord on the lease, you or the management company? You want your entity named, because if you fire them, you want the leases to come with you.

      Late fee amount and when it triggers. Make sure it's high enough that rent gets paid before other bills.

      Notice requirements to enter, and whether they match your state's law.

      The maintenance section. Does it define what the tenant is responsible for, or is everything the owner's problem by default?

      Lease term end dates. Watch for a lease that expires in December or January, because filling a vacancy in winter is brutal. I write winter move-ins at fourteen or fifteen months so renewals land in spring.

      Pet policy, pet rent, and whether pet rent flows to you or to them.

      Now the management agreement, which matters more than the lease and gets read less.

      The termination clause. How do you leave, how much notice, and what does it cost? Some agreements have a penalty that makes leaving painful, which is exactly when you'll want to.

      The indemnity clause. Read it out loud. Some are written so the owner carries the entire burden in any dispute, including ones the manager caused.

      The dollar threshold for repairs they can make without calling you.

      Whether they mark up maintenance invoices, and by how much. Ask whether maintenance is in-house or contracted out, and if it's in-house, ask how they price against outside bids.

      Whether they charge a fee when a tenant renews, and what work that fee buys. A rent review against current comps, a lease redraft, a walkthrough. If it buys those, fine. If it's a fee for printing a document, negotiate it.

      Two process things I'd hold to regardless of who you hire.

      Keep final say on tenant approval. They can run every other part of the operation. You decide who lives in your property.

      And separate the doing from the confirming on every turn and every repair. A third party shoots narrated video with the date visible, and nobody gets paid until that video exists.

      Last thing. Call more companies than feels necessary. Five, not two.

      You can't call one company, get all your answers, and decide that's the right one. Every answer any single one of them gives you is an opinion. Stack five and the pattern shows up on its own.

      Well, pretty fair list...UNTIL it wasn't. No legit PM will allow an owner to make ANY "final decision" on who will rent the home. That is a major Fair Housing issue just waiting to land in THEIR lap, and against THEIR RE License. Period. 

      Also I will push back on who is named on the lease agreement, owner or PMC. This varies by locale PER LOCAL LAW. Leases, to the best of my knowledge, always "run with the property". A sale or change of management has no effect on tenants, they simply receive proper notice of the change, along with instructions on who and where to pay and contact. No "material terms" of the agreement can be changed until/unless the stated term ends or their is mutual agreement in writing. It IS up to the "new" party to notify the tenants timely, and, in the case of S8, they too must be properly notified.
    • Member since 2023 · 27 posts · 5 votes
      2mo
      Quote from @Richard F.:
      Quote from @Stacy Conkey:

      I'll give you the question I'd ask first, then red flags, then the two documents nobody reads closely enough.

      The question: is your management fee charged on rent collected, or on rent due?

      Some companies bill a percentage of scheduled rent, which means they get paid whether or not your tenant pays. On a vacant unit too, in some agreements.

      Think about what that does to their urgency on collections. You want the fee tied to money that actually landed in the account.

      Second one in the same family: who keeps the late fees? If the company keeps all of them, there's now a small financial reason for your tenant to pay late. (Nobody's plotting. I'd rather not build the incentive and then hope.)

      Red flags, since you asked.

      They can't tell you their average days on market last quarter. Any competent company knows that number. "We rent fast" is not a number.

      Their screening criteria aren't written down and published. That's a fair housing problem waiting to happen and you're the owner, so it lands on you.

      They won't give you references from owners who left. Current owners are curated. Ask for three current and two former, and pay attention to how they react to the second half of that request.

      Nobody answers the phone at 6pm on a Saturday. Renters look at properties on weekends and evenings.

      And the one I'd weight most: the same person who performs the work also signs off that the work is done. That arrangement pays somebody to tell you they did a good job.

      You asked what to look for in the lease itself. Here's what I read for.

      Who is the landlord on the lease, you or the management company? You want your entity named, because if you fire them, you want the leases to come with you.

      Late fee amount and when it triggers. Make sure it's high enough that rent gets paid before other bills.

      Notice requirements to enter, and whether they match your state's law.

      The maintenance section. Does it define what the tenant is responsible for, or is everything the owner's problem by default?

      Lease term end dates. Watch for a lease that expires in December or January, because filling a vacancy in winter is brutal. I write winter move-ins at fourteen or fifteen months so renewals land in spring.

      Pet policy, pet rent, and whether pet rent flows to you or to them.

      Now the management agreement, which matters more than the lease and gets read less.

      The termination clause. How do you leave, how much notice, and what does it cost? Some agreements have a penalty that makes leaving painful, which is exactly when you'll want to.

      The indemnity clause. Read it out loud. Some are written so the owner carries the entire burden in any dispute, including ones the manager caused.

      The dollar threshold for repairs they can make without calling you.

      Whether they mark up maintenance invoices, and by how much. Ask whether maintenance is in-house or contracted out, and if it's in-house, ask how they price against outside bids.

      Whether they charge a fee when a tenant renews, and what work that fee buys. A rent review against current comps, a lease redraft, a walkthrough. If it buys those, fine. If it's a fee for printing a document, negotiate it.

      Two process things I'd hold to regardless of who you hire.

      Keep final say on tenant approval. They can run every other part of the operation. You decide who lives in your property.

      And separate the doing from the confirming on every turn and every repair. A third party shoots narrated video with the date visible, and nobody gets paid until that video exists.

      Last thing. Call more companies than feels necessary. Five, not two.

      You can't call one company, get all your answers, and decide that's the right one. Every answer any single one of them gives you is an opinion. Stack five and the pattern shows up on its own.

      Well, pretty fair list...UNTIL it wasn't. No legit PM will allow an owner to make ANY "final decision" on who will rent the home. That is a major Fair Housing issue just waiting to land in THEIR lap, and against THEIR RE License. Period. 

      Also I will push back on who is named on the lease agreement, owner or PMC. This varies by locale PER LOCAL LAW. Leases, to the best of my knowledge, always "run with the property". A sale or change of management has no effect on tenants, they simply receive proper notice of the change, along with instructions on who and where to pay and contact. No "material terms" of the agreement can be changed until/unless the stated term ends or their is mutual agreement in writing. It IS up to the "new" party to notify the tenants timely, and, in the case of S8, they too must be properly notified.



      You're right on the lease point. Leases run with the property, and I stated that badly.


      What I was actually worried about is operational, so let me say it the way I should have. When you fire a management company, what does your agreement obligate them to hand over? Executed leases. Tenant ledgers. Deposits transferred in full with a written accounting. Application files. Keys.


      Get that spelled out in the management agreement. It's a lot easier to solve before the breakup than during one.


      On tenant approval, you're pointing at a real risk and I'll sharpen what I meant.


      An owner rejecting an individual applicant on a feeling is a fair housing claim forming in real time. Agreed. Nobody should be doing that.


      But the owner absolutely should have a say in the written criteria. Income multiple, credit floor, eviction and criminal lookback windows, occupancy standards, pet policy.


      Published, applied identically to every applicant, no case-by-case anything. Then the manager runs them and the first qualified applicant gets the property.


      Once the standard is set, there's no discretion left for anybody to abuse. That's what protects the license and the owner both.


      Final say on the standard, not on the person. That's the line I should have written.


      I'd rather have that fight with an owner on the front end than discover in month eight that the criteria were looser than I thought.


  • Real Estate Agent · Memphis · Member since 2026 · 632 posts · 363 votes
    2mo

    For an out-of-state property, I’d want to know how they operate when I’m not there to catch problems myself.

    My short list would be:

    • • Walk me through your tenant screening process.

    • • What’s your maintenance approval limit, and when do you get multiple bids?

    • • Do you mark up vendor invoices or use in-house maintenance?

    • • How often do you inspect, and will I get photos?

    • • What happens from the first day rent is late?

    • • What does a normal turnover look like from move-out to rent-ready?

    • • Can I see a sample owner statement and management agreement?

    • • Who will actually manage my property after I sign?

    The biggest red flag for me is vague answers. If they can't clearly explain their screening, maintenance, communication, and reporting processes before they have the property, I wouldn't expect those things to get clearer afterward.

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2mo

    @Jay A. your question is so broad you are getting a lot of fluff in response. Local or Out of State really does not matter. PM is PM; Good Communication is Good Communication.

    First, find out how many units they manage for how many owners, and for how many years. Depending on the market, there may be a wide variety of "PMC's", with widely varying methods and results. In this business, Experience Matters. Large or Small, if the PM that will be in charge of your properties has Sales as primary income source, your service will likely be lacking. You need dedicated PM's. Also, the number and number of years of experience is huge. Anything less than 50 units for at least 5 years, and they still have a LOT to learn. As PM, I averaged around 150 units per year for nearly 30 years, and was still learning something new or different when I retired. The "red flag" is lack of serious, long term experience.

    Every Management Agreement will be different. It is up to you to read and understand before signing. A great PM will provide clear documentation of key processes and guidelines, as well as samples of their Rental Agreement and certain policies. Indeed, you should inquire about various processes that are important to you, such as screening process, late fee/eviction process, inspections, renewals, samples of usual monthly reports, termination of the management agreement, and much more than there is time or space to list here. Make your own list of what is important to you. While these Agreements are somewhat negotiable, with regard to spending caps, reserves, and certain other aspects, reality is that they are not going to change any single entire process to suit you. In most jurisdictions, they are licensed by the State, and are required to follow "all" applicable laws or risk losing their license...their sole source of income. Also, as an Owner, you can choose to use unlicensed, uninsured, and unskilled vendors, but the licensee can not. As a Business, you must act in a businesslike manner since you are serving the Public. Zoning, Taxes, Rules, Regulations, Ordinances, Historical Preservation, all those pesky details matter, and Licensees typically attend Continuing Education Classes every year as a requirement to maintain their active license. This includes mandatory Law Updates, so they do keep with local changes in applicable LL/Tenant/RE related laws.

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2mo
    Quote from @Jay A.:

    Just curious if anyone has a checklist that they go through when evaluating new property management companies for out of state investing?

    Any questions you specifically ask? Any red flags that steer you away? Any processes you have in place. 

    Glad you posted this, Jay! For out-of-state investing, I’d spend less time on the sales pitch and more time figuring out exactly how they operate when something goes wrong. I’d ask how quickly they respond to owners and tenants, how they handle maintenance requests and emergency repairs, whether they mark up contractor invoices, how often they inspect properties, their tenant screening process, how they handle late rent and evictions, and what their average vacancy/turnover looks like. I’d also ask for a sample owner statement and management agreement so you can see all the fees before signing. One of the biggest red flags for me is vague answers around maintenance costs, communication, or fees. I also like knowing who my actual point of contact will be instead of just dealing with a general inbox. When you’re investing from another state, communication and transparency are just as important as the management fee. Happy to connect and answer any questions you have!

  • Adam BartomeoBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2mo

    I always try to make sure that whomever I partner with owns investment properties, specifically residentials rentals. Lawyers, accountants, contractors, property managers, I want them all to have a rental mindset.

  • Coral Springs, FL · Member since 2018 · 498 posts · 120 votes
    1mo

    the biggest thing i look for is how they handle maintenance without calling you for every little thing. my last pm would call me about a $15 fix that shouldve been a quick approval text. ask them what their spend threshold is before they call you, and what happens after hours. if they dont have a clear answer on that, theyre gonna drive you nuts from 1000 miles away.

    also ask how many properties they actually manage in your specific area. someone who runs 200 doors across 3 states isnt giving your single rental the same attention as someone who does 40 units in one neighborhood. the local ones know the contractors, the inspectors, the tenant pool. the stretched thin ones just have a ticketing system.

    one thing nobody mentions - ask how they handle move-out inspections. do they do video walkthroughs? can you see them? i started requiring video on every turn and it saved me from a $2k deposit dispute last year because the tenant claimed damage that was clearly pre-existing.

  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 351 posts · 85 votes
    1mo

    For out-of-state, I care less about the brochure and more about the boring controls. Ask for average days on market last quarter, written screening criteria, who keeps late fees, and whether the management fee is on rent collected or rent due. Get a sample owner statement and the full management agreement before you sign, especially termination, repair approval limit, and how deposits and leases hand off if you leave. In California I also ask how they handle entry notice and the 21-day deposit clock with photos, because those misses land on the owner. If they stay vague on any of that, keep interviewing.

    Real Property Management Optimal 4.926 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.