DSCR or HELOC to finance $700k remodel in

Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 1 vote

My parents have a property in San Francisco currently doing a major $700k+ remodel, including addition of a legal ADU, making a SFR into a legal 2 unit property, likely appraise for over $2 mil in a few months. These 2 units are rented out to family at way below market rent, but to recoup the remodel cost, my parents can restructure the rent numbers to be even $6-$8k total/mo. Was originally considering a traditional HELOC, but now with interest rates going up, wondering if DSCR is more competitive and suitable for this situation. The property is paid off. Plan to use the new loan towards paying for the remodel and OOS real estate.

Can you please explain what the options for the best terms and rates?

0 Reply

209 views

Most Popular Reply

Tim MaloneyBusiness Member

Melbourne Florida · Member since 2026 · 16 posts · 9 votes

HELOC, 100%.

A traditional HELOC will look at your parents' income, tax returns, debts, and available equity. A DSCR loan focuses primarily on the property's rental income, but the current setup presents challenges: your parents own the property, relatives occupy both units at below-market rents, and the major renovation is still underway.

An ADU loan may be available, but it would likely cover only a smaller portion of the funds needed.

For a DSCR or private-money loan, most lenders would want the renovations completed, the property legally stabilized as two units, and documented market-rate rents—typically through arm's-length leases with unrelated tenants.

You could get a construction completion short term loan that will fund the renovations until the property is stabilized but you'll likely run into arm's-length issues there as well.

I would start with a HELOC or a local portfolio bank and compare the rate, closing costs, and flexibility before considering DSCR financing.

[email protected]321-495-6310

Elevrion Capital, Inc.

Website View Page

1 Reply

See this reply in the discussion

6 Replies

Jump to latestLatest

Sort by

Tim MaloneyBusiness Member
Melbourne Florida · Member since 2026 · 16 posts · 9 votes
1d
HELOC, 100%.
A traditional HELOC will look at your parents' income, tax returns, debts, and available equity. A DSCR loan focuses primarily on the property's rental income, but the current setup presents challenges: your parents own the property, relatives occupy both units at below-market rents, and the major renovation is still underway.
An ADU loan may be available, but it would likely cover only a smaller portion of the funds needed.
For a DSCR or private-money loan, most lenders would want the renovations completed, the property legally stabilized as two units, and documented market-rate rents—typically through arm's-length leases with unrelated tenants.
You could get a construction completion short term loan that will fund the renovations until the property is stabilized but you'll likely run into arm's-length issues there as well.
I would start with a HELOC or a local portfolio bank and compare the rate, closing costs, and flexibility before considering DSCR financing.
[email protected]321-495-6310
Elevrion Capital, Inc.
Website View Page
1 Reply
Divin KanyamaBusiness Member
Accountant · Seattle, WA · Member since 2025 · 188 posts · 57 votes
1d
@Aileen Walton With a paid-off property likely worth more than $2 million, I would compare a HELOC or fixed home-equity loan, a conventional cash-out refinance, and a DSCR loan. A HELOC offers flexibility, while a cash-out refinance may provide a more predictable payment. DSCR financing can be useful if personal-income qualification is the concern, but it often carries higher rates, fees, reserve requirements, and possible prepayment penalties. The key issue is the below-market family rent: a DSCR lender may rely on documented rent actually being paid or the appraiser's market-rent schedule, not simply a revised lease amount. It may also be worth waiting until the remodel, permits, and legal two-unit conversion are complete so the appraisal reflects the finished property. Compare written quotes based on rate, fees, loan-to-value, payment structure, and restrictions. A CPA should also review the below-market rental arrangement and use of proceeds, since both may affect the tax treatment.
[email protected]
WEMBO CPA532 Reviews
Website View Page
1 Reply
LaTarence Dunbar
Lender · Washington DC · Member since 2026 · 65 posts · 16 votes
1d
Quote from @Aileen Walton:
My parents have a property in San Francisco currently doing a major $700k+ remodel, including addition of a legal ADU, making a SFR into a legal 2 unit property, likely appraise for over $2 mil in a few months. These 2 units are rented out to family at way below market rent, but to recoup the remodel cost, my parents can restructure the rent numbers to be even $6-$8k total/mo. Was originally considering a traditional HELOC, but now with interest rates going up, wondering if DSCR is more competitive and suitable for this situation. The property is paid off. Plan to use the new loan towards paying for the remodel and OOS real estate.
Can you please explain what the options for the best terms and rates?
Aileen, given that the property is currently free and clear and the remodel is expected to bring the value above $2M, there may be several financing structures worth comparing beyond a traditional HELOC. A DSCR based loan could be an option, particularly if the property will have documented market rents once the two units are completed, while a cash out or other real estate secured structure may also be worth evaluating.
I work with real estate financing and would be happy to connect and take a look at the numbers, including the current value, projected completed value, loan amount, and rental income. If you’re open to it, feel free to connect with me and we can discuss what structure may fit the project.
1 Reply
Gregory AcsPro Member
Lender · MD · Member since 2025 · 148 posts · 54 votes
21h
Aileen, the best option really depends on your parents' long-term goals because a HELOC and a DSCR loan are designed for different purposes. A HELOC gives you a revolving line of credit and can be a great option if you need to draw funds over time during a remodel, but the rate is typically variable. A DSCR loan is generally a fixed-rate mortgage that qualifies based primarily on the property's rental income rather than personal income, making it a popular option for long-term investment financing.
Since the property is owned free and clear and you're adding a legal ADU, I'd also look at the timing of the appraisal and refinance. Waiting until the project is complete and the new rental income can be documented may open up more options and potentially improve the loan terms. I'd be happy to discuss the scenario in more detail and compare HELOC, DSCR, and other financing strategies to see which one best fits your goals.
1 Reply
Aileen Walton
OP
Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 1 vote
20h
Thank you for weighing in. Like to add to original post, that the remodel is currently being paid for with a $300k HELOC loan from 1 family member/tenant's property and $400k from a private lender for the other family member/tenant to pay. The house is in a trust, and in SF, it's better to leave homes to a trust and have family members rent to avoid complicated inheritance taxes. Once the remodel is over, we hope to get home appraised and see if we can get 1 new loan (HELOC or DSCR) to repay both loans and instead of the family members paying their respective loans, to increase their rent to pay for this DSCR loan. Hope to reach out individually.
0 Reply
Stacy RaskinBusiness Member
Lender · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 497 votes
9h
If you are looking for a DSCR loan once the remodel is complete, the DSCR lender will want to be the first position lien on the loan. Since the property is located in CA, the mortgage professional working on the DSCR loan will need a NMLS license in CA. Happy to connect to discuss further.
[email protected]818-770-0340
Bright Skyline518 Reviews
Website View Page
0 Reply

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.