non-vacation STRs in the suburbs, anyone doing it?

Question

Hi all,

I’m researching one STR strategy: hosting guests on non-vacation stays, in either a room or a whole home, in the suburbs of Houston, Indianapolis and Tampa. I’d value a reality check from people on the ground.

Where the supply seems to be -

• Owners who couldn’t sell. Accidental landlords represent 14.2% of Houston’s active single-family rentals (parcel labs )
• Existing listings: around 80 to 650 active short-term listings per suburb, mostly whole homes. Private rooms are rare except in Pearland.

Owners who couldn’t sell. Accidental landlords represent 14.2% of Houston’s active single-family rentals (parcel labs )

Existing listings: around 80 to 650 active short-term listings per suburb, mostly whole homes. Private rooms are rare except in Pearland.

Demand type -

• Stays already run long. the average STR stay is 5.5–8 nights

Stays already run long. the average STR stay is 5.5–8 nights

• Family visits. 48% of Houston’s overnight visitors in 2024 and 41% of Hillsborough’s domestic visitors in 2025 came to see friends or relatives.
• Medical stays. MD Anderson treated 197,000 patients last fiscal year (without including traveling medical pros.) Moving/ relocation. Fort Bend and Pasco counties each added 18,000+ residents in a year (Census).

Family visits. 48% of Houston’s overnight visitors in 2024 and 41% of Hillsborough’s domestic visitors in 2025 came to see friends or relatives.

Medical stays. MD Anderson treated 197,000 patients last fiscal year (without including traveling medical pros.) Moving/ relocation. Fort Bend and Pasco counties each added 18,000+ residents in a year (Census).

Is anyone running an STR built around these guests in Katy, Pearland, Fishers, Carmel, Brandon or Wesley Chapel? What minimum stay do you set? Around what share of your bookings is non-vacation? And which channels bring those guests in?

Jorge Vazquez · Answer

I have 2 STRs and 35 LTRs, and for my STRs I’ve done very well with corporate rentals. In the suburbs, that’s the direction I’d focus on. You typically get longer stays, less turnover, and more consistent demand from relocation, insurance, medical, and business travelers. I prefer furnished 30+ day stays over chasing weekend bookings. The key is making sure the property still works as a traditional long-term rental if needed.

Antoine Clerc · Answer

@Jorge Vazquez Right on. Valued feedback!

Matthew Tregoning · Answer

We operate furnished rentals in Jacksonville and Middleburg. I'd separate the family-visit guest from the relocation guest when testing this. One might need four nights near relatives, the other needs somewhere to live with their dog and two cars for a month. Same house, pretty different listing details and calendar needs. Are you planning to test one suburb first?

Antoine Clerc · Answer

@Andrew Steffens Thanks. Noted the supply limitations related HOAs, it narrows my search further.

Antoine Clerc · Answer

@Don Konipol The student MTRs are a market I'd like to tap into further down the road... if things work out. Let's say if you had a steady share of recurring guests who fit one of your STR properties (its location and the reason they’re in town, like a hospital stay, job move or something specific to your area...), would you give it a try? Thanks for the feedback.

Don Konipol · Answer

Yes, I actually like the furnished mid term rental business. I don’t like the STR business (as a landlord, I LOVE it as a customer) but the 3 month - 6 month furnished rental seems to capture much of the “windfall” profit of STR without the intensive management hassle.

Antoine Clerc · Answer

@Matthew Tregoning Exactly, the needs are different depending of guest context and host / operator setup provided. Ultimately I am working on this topic, to improve the guest-host context matching. Tampa & Houston areas seem like adequate trial grounds.

Don Konipol · Answer

I considered it a few years ago - I had kept two homes I had lived but no longer did in in the Houston area and wanted to see if I could generate greater profitability either with STR or MTR. Specific to my properties and my locations, STR didn’t look like it would work. I ended up doing a furnished MTR with one of the properties and earned a somewhat higher ROI but not enough to make a significant difference. My furnished rental / MTR experience worked much better for the properties I owned near ASU in Phoenix renting to students whose parents were wealthy and willing to spend $3500 + per month for a rental for their child.

Andrew Steffens · Answer

In Brandon and Wesley Chapel your challenges will be finding non HOA opportunity. They exist but probably 80% of the market is HOA that are not STR friendly. You can achieve some success here but these submarkets will be very supply sensitive - 10% more listings being added could put you negative. IMO

non-vacation STRs in the suburbs, anyone doing it?

non-vacation STRs in the suburbs, anyone doing it?

Most Popular Reply

9 Replies