Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 171 posts · 67 votes
A flat 5% or 10% capex reserve is a fine starting point, but on older value-add houses and small multis it hides the thing that actually hurts: two big systems failing in the same year.
Here is the method I use instead:
List every system on the property: roof, furnace(s), water heater(s), sewer line, electrical panel, windows, exterior paint, flooring, appliances.
Note the age and the honest remaining life of each one (from the inspection, not the listing).
Get a real replacement price from a contractor or your own recent bids, not a rule of thumb.
Divide each price by its remaining years. The total is the monthly reserve I underwrite, per building.
Flag any system with under 3 years left and either price it into the offer or ask for a credit.
Two things this changes: a freshly rehabbed property needs a smaller reserve than an old one with the same rent, and a 4-unit with four furnaces needs more than a duplex with two. A flat percent treats them the same.
I keep a separate cash buffer for the surprise, such as a sewer lateral or a collapsed drain, since a schedule only covers what you can see.
How do you set capex reserves: flat percent, per-system schedule, or something else?
BJ Everson | Columbus investor and Realtor with Swiss Realty Group
This is a smart approach, especially for older rental properties where unexpected repairs can quickly affect cash flow. I agree that evaluating each system individually gives investors a much clearer picture of the true costs involved. I work in real estate networking and referrals, connecting investors, property owners, and real estate professionals. Always good to connect with experienced investors and exchange insights.
Per-system is the right call. One refinement: straight-line division smooths out exactly the risk you're worried about. If the roof has 4 years left and two furnaces have 5, the monthly average can look fine while the account still comes up short in year 5.
It helps to lay replacements out year by year for 10 years and check the running balance, not just the monthly total.
Also inflate replacement prices 3-5% a year. A roof quote from today is optimistic by year 8, and that gap compounds across systems.