Disrupting lot rents as the first professional owner in a market — anyone else dealt

Disrupting lot rents as the first professional owner in a market — anyone else dealt

Member since 2026 · 1 post · 0 votes

We're looking at a park about an hour from Sioux Falls, SD. On paper, the town checks every box: average 3-bed apartment rent is north of $1,300, home prices start around $200k+, unemployment is almost nonexistent, and it's a strong local economy with a healthy business base. Population is around 25,000. Rental inventory (both apartments and homes) is very tight — every property manager I've talked to confirms it.

Twenty miles away, we already manage a park in a town with nearly identical metrics, and we're getting $500/month lot rents there.

The wrinkle: every other MHP in this new town is an old, run-down mom-and-pop operation, with lot rents ranging $200-375. Only one had a vacancy — I called on it and the resident said it had just sold. It was a 1970s single-wide listed at $25k, sitting on a $225/month lot.

The park we're evaluating has lot rents at $300 and is owned by a local operator. For this to be a strong deal, we'd need to push rents to $450 over the next few years.

Has anyone been in this position — the first professional owner coming into a market where you need to disrupt the going lot-rent rate for the whole area? How did it go, and what would you watch out for?

0Reply
3,875 views

Most Popular Reply

Laconia, Belknap County · Member since 2026 · 2 posts · 1 vote
6d

Noah's point is the one I'd sit with. If the debt only works at $450, the deal is the rent increase, not the park.

Before you model the phase in, read South Dakota's rules on notice periods for rent increases and lease terms for park residents. The notice period sets how fast $300 can actually become $450, and that changes your first two years of cash. The South Dakota page on MHPRedFlags.com has the citations in one spot.

Also pull the town's council minutes for the last few years. Parks that were first to raise rents in a small town have ended up on the agenda, and it's better to know that before closing than after.

Dave, MHP Red Flags

See this reply in the discussion

4 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2026 · 32 posts · 4 votes
    2mo

    $300 to $450 is a big leap. Phase it in with improvements. Submeter utilities. Fix roads, lighting, landscaping. First increase should be smaller. Show residents the value. Expect pushback

  • Rental Property Investor · Washington State · Member since 2023 · 182 posts · 123 votes
    1w

    Phase it in over two years; three if you can be patient. Don't make major improvements unless necessary. Submeter utilities but push the cost of that out of that endeavor out to tenants. Respond promptly to tenant requested repairs and maintenance issues but don't burn your money on flag poles and playgrounds. You are not a 'mom and pop'. It is a business and you have to turn a profit. You set the market... you can't afford to wait around for grandma and grandpa on the other side of town to do it.

    After three years you continue to raise rents every single year. It should be an annual expectation.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 632 posts · 180 votes
    1w

    Calling every property manager and chasing down that one vacancy is homework most buyers skip, and your $500 park 20 miles away is a real data point. The thing I'd watch is how the financing reads the lot rent jump. The lenders I shop size a purchase loan off the rents in place, so this deal gets judged at $300, not $450. When you refinance later, most want the higher rate showing up in the trailing collections, not just on new leases. The appraiser will also pull lot rent comps from a town where nobody charges over $375. Your other park might count as a comp, but that's the appraiser's call. A rent plan is only as safe as the deal looks before it works. Does it carry the debt at $300?

  • Laconia, Belknap County · Member since 2026 · 2 posts · 1 vote
    6d

    Noah's point is the one I'd sit with. If the debt only works at $450, the deal is the rent increase, not the park.

    Before you model the phase in, read South Dakota's rules on notice periods for rent increases and lease terms for park residents. The notice period sets how fast $300 can actually become $450, and that changes your first two years of cash. The South Dakota page on MHPRedFlags.com has the citations in one spot.

    Also pull the town's council minutes for the last few years. Parks that were first to raise rents in a small town have ended up on the agenda, and it's better to know that before closing than after.

    Dave, MHP Red Flags

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.