CASHFLOW should not pay for CAPEX - change my mind!

CASHFLOW should not pay for CAPEX - change my mind!

Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes

This is a classic new investor trap. Every new investor learns to budget for repairs and maintenance. Its a line item in every calculator or spreadsheet when you are running the numbers. I have always had a problem with that.

First of all, the 5% most investors are using is not enough, except maybe with new construction. Second, you'll never turn a profit this way. You get used to paying for repairs out of cash flow and pretty soon this becomes the norm: cash flow is just paying for everything.

If your cash flow is an average $200/mo and after 6 years you need a new roof, it wipes out all of the cash flow. And 3 years later you need a new HVAC, which wipes it out again. A kitchen remodel may cost you 10 or 15 years of cash flow. And if the building is 60 years old, you'll need to replace these galvanized pipes pretty soon. And the cracked-up driveway.

It gets worse. I spoke with an investor last year who owns 30 duplexes and has been operating them for over 40 years. He's old and wants to retire, but he can't because they are low value 100 year old buildings from the 1920s and even though he does most of the work himself, they are constant money drains.

1Reply
569 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2021 · 788 posts · 509 votes
3d

@Marcus Auerbach - Agree with your sentiments. I think incorporating appropriate CapEx at the beginning of the analysis is a key step. Then, the property should cash flow "above and beyond" all the expenses, including CapEx/reserves. It protects you some, but I think most don't retain enough funding.

See this reply in the discussion

26 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2021 · 788 posts · 509 votes
    3d

    @Marcus Auerbach - Agree with your sentiments. I think incorporating appropriate CapEx at the beginning of the analysis is a key step. Then, the property should cash flow "above and beyond" all the expenses, including CapEx/reserves. It protects you some, but I think most don't retain enough funding.

    • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      2d

      No! That is what everyone is trained to do, but I think it's wrong - at least long term. Short term you have to do what you have to do. But cash flow is meant to be profit; that's the reward for doing all the work.

    • Dan H.Pro Member
      Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
      2d

      @Marcus Auerbach i typically agree with your sentiment but not necessarily here (but I do agree many investors under estimate maintenance/cap ex and seem to use a percentage of rent that is virtually arbitrary). I am in the @Greg Kasmer ‘s camp. I do not consider the cap ex to come out of cash flow because my cash flow projection has already “correctly” allocated for the cap ex.

      Not properly including cap ex in your cash flow calculation is deceiving yourself. If you cannot produce a return with realistic sustained expense projections and accurate projected vacancy then it is not a good investment.

      I run my numbers including cap ex that is derived by using expected lifetimes and expected replacement costs on all items to derive maintenance/cap ex. My cash flow calculation includes vacancy projection, maintenance/cap ex projections, PITI, asset protection, bookkeeping/tax prep. Basically I include everything for sustained rental ownership.

      There are markets with poor appreciation. Those markets need to cover the expenses via the cash flow. The issue is virtually all the high initial cash flow markets do not have good long term cash flow due to poor appreciation. These markets will be challenged to make money in the long term as the long term cash flow will be poor and the appreciation will be poor. I believe this is your primary point.

      But there are other markets that have great appreciation and great long term cash flow (if no value is extracted).

      Most rentals in San Diego are apartments and they average just under 2 BR. San Diego’s median rents:

      - 2025: $2995/month. 2 Beds $3,095, 3 Beds $4200.

      - 2020: $2344/month

      - 2010: $1323/month

      - 2000: $747/month

      recognize if you purchased a unit in San Diego in the year 2000, your rent has increased ~$2250/month. Similar crazy rent increase for purchases in 2010 or 2020. This produces revenue that can cover sustained expenses including cap ex.

      Do accurate and conservative underwriting. Anything else is deceiving yourself.

      Best wishes

    • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      21h

      Interesting historic data @Dan H. But that's my point exactly: there is no way you could have allocated enough for capex with $747 in rent, let alone make a profit. Even if you allocated 10% of rent for capex on top of repairs and maintenance (which nobody does) - it would have wiped out your cash flow.

      You need appreciation to make up for long term building degradation and of course you invest in one of the best markets for that. San Diego home prices went from 220k to 980k in those 26 years, so if it's time for a full remodel (100k in your market?) you have plenty of equity to pay for that.

      It has been said a million times on BP that "you can't count on appreciation, it's the icing on the cake", typically in these words. It's become a mantra for the community and it's totally wrong! Real estate investing without appreciation does not work, you'll loose money long term. You can get away over 5 years without capex, but not long term from 2000 to 2026.

      I looked up Milwaukee rents and they rose from $527 back in 2000 to $1,250 in 2026, so a lot more moderate than San Diego. In the same timeframe median home prices rose from 82k to 232k. (I always feel the need to explain that Milwaukee proper is only the poorer 1/3 or the Milwaukee metro area, the surrounding 2/3 are wealthier). We buy at a little higher price points and the number one question that is always on my mind is "how much will this neighborhood appreciate?"

    • Dan H.Pro Member
      Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
      17h

      >there is no way you could have allocated enough for capex with $747 in rent, let alone make a profit.

      Actually at most market rent points I am allocating more than 20% of average US rents for maintenance/cap ex. Fortunately San Diego does not have average US rents.

      In addition you could have shown positive cash flow when the average rents were $747. I have similar median price as you quoted but use $950k for 2025 (while you likely are using 2026). We may have the same source.

      What you will notice is the rent to price ratio was better using those previous median prices than today, but that median ratio is no where close to what investors are paying for the typical rental. The OO purchases provide a false ratio. I suspect this is true in virtually every market.

      Then add in that the rates were much less prior to q2 2022.

      Prior to q2 2022, with my what most would consider high maintenance/cap ex allocation I could have positive cash flow on virtually all 0.7% monthly rent ratios (cost being purchase and costs to get units to market rent) at high investor LTV and these were not that hard to find. I could find positive cash flow, but was targeting best overall return and 0,7% ratio was minimal positive cash flow.

      Today the rent ratios are worse. You can find 0.7% ratios before value add. A 0.7% ratio after cost to get at least market rent is very challenging in San Diego and then due to the interest rate increases a 1% ratio at high investor LTV typically does not cash flow with my underwriting. I laugh inside when low rent markets state or imply positive cash flow because it has 1% rent ratio. These markets require significantly higher than 1% rent ratio to have positive cash flow when including realistic vacancy and sustained expenses allocations.

      1% rent ratio is a unicorn find in San Diego and has been for many years (in Dec 2020 I purchased a property at over 1% ratio but it previously had a risk that a new law virtually eliminated and that elimination of risk was not yet reflected in the comps).

      One further item, in a few years San Diego’s vacancy rate went from a crazy low below 2% to a slightly low 5%. I used to fill our vacancies at market rent regardless or time of year virtually always at first open house. Nov to Jan is now challenging at market rent and usually takes multiple open houses (write your leases so the lease never ends in Oct to Feb). This higher vacancy rate must be reflected in the underwriting. Small unit count owners should never use a vacancy rate lower than their market vacancy rate in their underwriting.

      So I disagree that prior to q2 2022 that you could not get positive cash flow properly allocating for vacancy and sustained expenses. Today, purchasing off the mls using high investor LTV market financing without a value add in San Diego is virtually certain to be cash flow negative and likely large cash flow negative if properly allocating for vacancy and sustained expenses.

      So historically I disagree with you, but in general I agree with you for today's market. Investors need below value purchase (off market), value add, or below market financing to have any hope of positive cash flow at high investor LTV.

      best wishes

  • Medellin, Colombia · Member since 2026 · 18 posts · 13 votes
    3d

    You should include R&M, vacancies and credit losses (evictions) as provisions in your model. The CoC/profit would be measured after all of these. In real life, you put those provisions apart (may be in a money market) and add them to your initial reserve, so that when the time arrives to make that big expense you have the money ready.

  • Eugenia ChetverechenkoBusiness Member
    Accountant · Chicago, IL · Member since 2026 · 19 posts · 3 votes
    3d

    Marcus, I see your point, especially with older properties where one major repair can wipe out years of cash flow.

    But to me, if a property consistently needs more capital than it generates, the bigger question is whether it's actually a good investment in the first place.

    • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      2d

      That's always a good question, but if you make the timeframe long enough, the answer is almost always that capex will exceed cash flow. Investors don't realize that the first 5-10 years, because while they pocket the cash flow, every component on the property is aging.

      So you can defer for a while, but 10 years will usually get you to a point where you see it.

      A single family rental will need a full rehab every 30 years. We average about 70k for a full rehab, give or take. And in my estimation I will have to do that again in 30 years, because neither roof nor kitchens last thats long. Plus the occasional item in between for components that have a service life under 30 years like water heater and HVAC. If you assume $200 in cashflow x 360 months that's 72k. So it wipes it out clean.

      That's why you need appreciation. Everyone treats appreciation as icing on the cake, but I'd say it is in fact the entire cake! And without long term appreciation you have done all the work basically for nothing.

    • Eugenia ChetverechenkoBusiness Member
      Accountant · Chicago, IL · Member since 2026 · 19 posts · 3 votes
      2d

      Marcus, I see where you are coming from, especially with older properties. But I wouldn't necessarily call appreciation the entire cake.

      If a $70K rehab wipes out 30 years of cash flow, I'd argue that property wasn't generating much of a cash return to begin with, once you account for its long-term capital needs.

      Appreciation and principal paydown certainly contribute to the overall return, but appreciation isn't guaranteed. If the investment only makes sense because we're counting on property values going up, that's a different investment strategy altogether.

  • Property Manager · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2016 · 19 posts · 5 votes
    3d

    @Marcus Auerbach we do pay repairs out of cash flow, but the trick for us is what happens before the first tenant moves in. When we buy, we renovate the whole house to a high finish level, not just the big items but the small things too. With that approach we budget about 7% for maintenance and it holds. If you buy an old house and rent it as is, I agree, the cash flow will end up paying for the roof.

    • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      2d

      Yes we take the same approach, you have a nicer property, rents faster, you get better tenants, less turnover, higher rent and less wear and tear, because they usually take good care of the property. Absolutely worth it. And 7% for repairs is solid on a fully renovated property. But you made my point: that initial rehab did not come out of cash flow. It came out of equity, assuming you bought the property at a good enough price (I usually fail that test, at least a little).

      But how long do you think it will take before you have to do a full rehab again? Milwaukee home prices have doubled over the last 10 years, at least for the metro area. But not every neighborhood has, there are some parts that are basically selling for the same price as they did 10 years ago. And that's where it gets you: see my example of the guy who owns 30 duplxes for 40 years and is basically broke

  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 752 votes
    2d

    Marcus, I agree with the core of it, and here is how I run it. On my Memphis houses, the rent has to cover vacancy, repairs, CapEx, property management, taxes, insurance, and the loan payment, or the deal does not work. A 3-bedroom at $1,395 to $1,950 a month has to clear all of that and still pass the 1% rule against an ARV of $180,000 to $265,000. If I have to skip the CapEx reserve to make the cash flow look good, I am not making the deal better, I am hiding the cost. A rehab does reset some of that clock, and my typical $40,000 rehab does mean fewer big surprises early, but roofs and systems still age. I would rather pass on a deal that only works without CapEx than own a house that eats the cash flow later.

    • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      2d

      And so you are saying you are trying to fund Capex out of cash flow? I don't think that can work.

      Even on your highest rent of $1950 on 265k house your PITI is $1750-ish, so you have about $200 left for repairs, maintenance, vacancies, property management, hopefully some cash flow (profit) - AND CAPEX? So how much do you use for Capex? That can't work. Over any 10-year period, you are losing money. What am I missing?

  • Real Estate Agent · Chicago, IL · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2d

    @Marcus Auerbach

    Agreed, probably very few properties actually cash flow in the long-run when fully accounting for all capital expenditures. Like other businesses, properties periodically need fresh capital to fund larger, one-time or infrequent expenses. Rentals are a great way to store and accumulate wealth over time using financial leverage (loan) and labor (the tenant) to pay down the mortgage and gain the appreciation upside. All it takes is a capital expenditure or two to wipe out years of cash flow.

    An initial knee-jerk reaction to your post title by us investors may be: well the cash flow should pay for the cap ex. But I think most real estate investors know practically speaking in their own experience this is not the reality.

    • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      2d

      Yes "should" is the operative word! The title is of course provocative, but it is also 100% not understood by new investors. They think they fill out the boxes at the calculator and it will work. Actually, now that I think about it, there should be an input for "building degradation" in the calculator; basically, an approximation of component service life. You can still set it to zero, but the reality is, it's not zero. And if you don't have the appreciation to create the long-term equity to pay for it, it will eat up the cash flow.

  • Technology · McKinney, TX · Member since 2026 · 24 posts · 3 votes
    2d

    I'd frame it slightly differently: capex isn't something cash flow pays for later. It's an expense you subtract before calling anything cash flow.

    The flat 5% is the real trap. Pricing each component works better: a $15k roof with 8 years left is $156/mo, an $8k HVAC with 5 years left is $133/mo, and a $1.5k water heater with 3 years left is $42/mo.

    If the deal still works after that, great. If not, that $200 was never cash flow.

    • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
      2d

      This is the correct view. Your “cashflow” isn’t paying for your maintenance, your repairs, or your vacancy just as it isn’t paying for your capex. Your cashflow is what’s left after all your budgeted “deductions” (Because they aren’t really current period expenses I used deductions.)

      This is really a market by market and property by property problem. If you count appliances, ac units or water heaters as capex, that’s the only capex I’ve had in almost 30 years. And it’s been minimal. But that’s the difference between buying 10 year old stucco sided, sloped and tile roofed SFRs in an area with no freeze / thaw, hurricanes or tornadoes. If you’re buying 80 year old, wood sided, asphalt shingled, flat roofed homes in the Midwest you might not go 5 years without capex. That has to be sort of your deduction BEFORE you calculate cashflow. You talk in 30 year periods. But in that period or less you will also own the property outright. That’s just as valuable to me as cashflow.

      Ps. All that being said I would never buy in a market where I didn’t expect appreciation. I’ve made way more from appreciation than rental income. Even a paid off property can “earn” more from appreciation than rental income, especially if you consider it’s tax free. I’ve purchased homes with negative cashflow for those two reasons. They paid off more debt than the negative cashflow and the appreciation can be 25-100% per year if calculated against cash invested. “Appreciation on cash”? Instead of cash on cash.

    • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      2d

      Not incorrect, but based on that math, there are exactly zero deals that cash flow. Depending on your climate 35% to 45% of your home's replacement value (ask your insurance) is components that have a life expectation of under 30 years. Now you can buy a house for 200k in some market, but the replacement value will be more than 200k. The insurance company knows what it costs to replace a burned-down house. But even if it did not burn, you'll have to replace at least 35% of that. When you use that number, you will never find a deal that is cash flow positive or even close to break even. My point is, you need appreciation (equity) to pay periodically for major system replacements. Without appreciation, the math does not work.

  • San Diego, CA · Member since 2026 · 19 posts · 4 votes
    2d

    Dan, I'm an out-of-state buyer looking at older occupied duplexes in Columbus. When you can't see the roof and mechanicals until after contract, do you set the capex reserve from assumed ages or ask the seller for dated invoices first?

    • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      21h

      Why would you not be able to inspect the roof and mechanicals before you make an offer? You have to, a new roof is money in the bank. But you are missing 30+ other things that will become a financial liability. We have a lot of old duplxes in Milwaukee: for a full rehab you are looking at 30k per unit and 40k for the exterior (roof, windows, siding). And that is not even accounting for a new driveway or a new garage. So all the sudden that cheap, old duplex is not so cheap anymore. The way how most new investors "make it work" is by simply ignoring the age of all the components, but they are still there and they are still degrading.

      There is a lot more than roofs: rebuilding a chimney with a broken crown and spalling brick is expensive. (and it adds zero to curb appeal, property value or rent). Replacing cast iron drain lines in a 2 story building is a lot of fun, let a lone the sewer lateral out to the street. At some point the old plaster ceilings won't hold anymore and have to be replaced with drywall. You can tait until they fall on the tenants, but I would not recommend it.

      What makes the issue particularly dangerous in old Midwest markets is that in the neighborhoods that grab the attention of OOS investors nobody has spent any significant money on these neighborhoods in a many decades. EVERYTHING is old. So you are already starting out behind. Once you factor capex into the equation most of of these deals don't look so good anymore.

      For with math: instead of 5% rent everyone is using take 35% of the replacement value and divide it by 360 months. On an old duplex that will come out to about $400 per month. And then keep the 5% for actual repairs and maintenance.

    • Dan H.Pro Member
      Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
      16h

      My market is San Diego and not Columbus/ohio, so what I describe may or may not be accurate for Columbus. From Marcus description it seems like you can do inspections before offer in his market. In my market this is not even the case for SFH, showing markets have variations. It is why my market has a default Due Diligence (DD) time after contract to do inspections and any other DD items.

      If I am purchasing an MF from the mls (note off market often come with no DD or inspections - we closed on Sept 30 on one of these).

      • it is typical to not be able to see the inside until after contract signing. I usually do a drone view to see back area and roof before I make offer.

      • After contract signing you get access for inspections during your due diligence (DD) period. Get the best general home inspector in your market. Any additional cost is justified for the best. Also get the sewers scoped. Anything your rockstar home inspector states needs to be inspected by a specialist (for example foundation, electrical, roofing). Note the general inspector will only call out these additional inspections based on concerns he identified during his inspection.

      • Based on inspections, if you find anything that degrades value, you renegotiate during the DD. I have seen mixed thoughts expressed on roof because it is “visible”. I am in the camp that most buyers are not roof experts or inspectors. So I feel negotiating for a roof with less than 3 years life left or that has damage is fair game.

      • Ideally, for identified big near term cap ex items you receive a discount so that you do not have to have a $10k plus new roof out of cash flow in less than 3 years because this item alone would kill the cash flow. But if you received close to $10k discount/concessions for the new roof then the financial impact is reduced. I personally go for dollar for dollar discount and if I receive push back I request the seller address it. Cap ex requires work, is an impact, and has risks. I only do value adds if they project 2x value added as the cost to cover the effort, impact, and risks. For example on a roof let’s say you get a quote of $10k to strip and replace asphalt shingles. Then they give you a cost for each plywood/osb to replace or (more costly) each shiplap/board to replace. There could be zero, but how often does that happen. The quote is really the floor cost, if roof quote is $10k, I claim over 90% of the time it will be over that price due to underlayment that needs work. So the cost will be higher, you have impact to tenants and you have the effort to hire and manage the contractor(s). If the seller thinks it is zero effort, impact, risk let them do it.

      That still leaves a lot of room in the calculations. For example how old are the windows and how much longer will they last. My calcs show asphalt shingles and tile roofs have similar costs meaning tile costs a lot more but lasts near double asphalt shingles excluding an insurance event. Landscaping with certain trees is an easy to underestimate expense. I have a property with 2 rows of eucalyptus that is ~$5k every 5 years or $1k/year to top and trim.

      I am fully in Marcus’ camp that most small unit count are not allocating enough for sustained maintenance/cap es. A while back someone that had fair amount of experience tried to debate in these forums that his arbitrarily picked maintenance/cap ex percentage was more accurate than my allocation that was derived in costs and life expectancy. The sole reason that he was making his argument was that he did not like how much the actual calculated costs projected for maintenance/cap ex. It seems like an absurd arguement. It is also absurd to use actuals until you have owned long enough to go full life cycle on everything (I have one unit that has replaced everything but is still not full lifecycle as it was not purchased new). Even 15 years of actuals is insufficient as roofs and plumbing last way longer.

      Good luck

  • Real Estate Agent · Chicago, IL · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    1d

    I 100% agree with @Dan H. ¨The issue is virtually all the high initial cash flow markets do not have good long term cash flow due to poor appreciation¨

    • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      21h

      High cash flow markets typically lack appreciation. And to make matters worse, they are usually old housing stock, which means a ton of looming capex. The long term cash flow might be there, but over a longer time frame (5+ years) capex exceeds cash flow. You could say repairs exceed cash flow, but it's really capex if you are replacing systems. So that's my point, you need appreciation to pay for that.

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    17h

    Unless he's got heavy notes on all of these, how does he not have enough principal to retire on 30 duplexes? If we give them $100k per property averages, which is pretty low anywhere in the country except for war zone ghettos, and assuming he has no notes because he's had them 40 years and they're all in tough shape, he can't retire on 2.5 million after selling them all?

    I agree with the basic premise that if you haven't already factored your capital needs when you buy, then you better have really strong cash flow. But I don't get the example guy. The more likely scenario is he ran the places like a slumlord, pocketed every dime they ever made, and now they're wrecks. Because 30 duplexes renting at $500 per side per month is $30k gross per month. You could almost do 3 roofs a month with that kind of money.

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
    • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      9h

      Probably. I don't have all the details, because it came up in the Q&A session of a free training that I do for a local REIA occasionally. It sounded like he was milking the portfolio for as long as he had it (living of the cash flow) and he did say that he had to refi properties to pay for work and was still quite leveraged after all those years. So there are probably a few things to critique here, but the main mistake he made was to buy in the hood. He had basically no appreciation, he acknowledged that. I was showing just before how the lion share of the money you make over 30 years comes from equity, meaning appreciation and principal pay off. You are right, 30 duplexes in decent Milwaukee neighborhoods like Washington Heights or Bay View should be valued at 10-12 million today and rent roll about 100k per month. Even with our property taxes, you'd be okay.

  • Property Manager · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2016 · 19 posts · 5 votes
    1h

    @Marcus Auerbach fair point, the first rehab comes from the purchase, not from cash flow. From what we see a property we fully renovated holds for around 5-10 years before it needs real work again, and in that time the 7% covers the small stuff. Turnover is also lower so we lose less on vacancy. Agree that the neighborhood matters a lot, the price you buy at decides most of it.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.