Moving appreciated real estate out of an S corp without a major tax hit?

Moving appreciated real estate out of an S corp without a major tax hit?

San Diego, CA · Member since 2017 · 106 posts · 55 votes

Our family owns a commercial rental property through an LLC taxed as an S corporation with a QSub subsidiary. The original corporation elected S status in 1995; the parent/QSub structure was established in 2022. The property came through a 1031 exchange and has substantial appreciation, low remaining tax basis and relatively low shareholder stock basis.

We want to keep the property indefinitely but move toward partnership/disregarded-entity treatment for refinancing, distributions and succession flexibility, preferably before an inheritance.

The obstacle: a liquidation or property distribution appears to trigger significant gain, potentially ordinary income under Section 1239 on the depreciable property, while any corresponding stock liquidation loss may be capital. An inherited stock-basis step-up also wouldn’t automatically increase the underlying property basis.

Has anyone successfully handled a similar situation?

- Is there a defensible current-law restructuring that materially reduces the tax cost while retaining the property?
- Could a genuine lower-tier partnership and eventual Section 754/743(b) adjustment help, or just relocate the problem?
- If retaining the S corp is the best answer for now, what estate-planning steps or pending legislation should we consider?

0Reply
389 views

Most Popular Reply

Accountant · Dothan, AL · Member since 2026 · 9 posts · 6 votes
1w

Not much here.

I would change focus to manufacture losses in other areas to offset the gains/income.

Short-term rentals, equipment purchasing, retirement deferral, cost segregation, chunking itemized deductions, etc.

See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Broker · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2021 · 560 posts · 429 votes
    1w

    Talk to a lawyer and an accountant before you move anything. I am a licensed broker in Sacramento, not your CPA. There is usually no clean tax free way out of an S corp holding appreciated depreciable property, a distribution can trigger gain and Section 1239 can make part of it ordinary income. A lower tier partnership does not erase that built in gain, it mostly moves the basis problem. If you keep the S corp for now, have you asked your CPA how a stock step up would compare to a property basis step up at inheritance? Hope this helps, DM me.

  • Simon W.Business Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Lehigh Valley PA & New York City · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 696 votes
    1w

    Noah's right that there's usually no clean exit, and I'd add the piece that makes it concrete: get two numbers side by side before anything else, the property's tax basis inside the entity and the shareholders' stock basis. The gap between them is basically the cost of moving the property out.

    Say the property is worth $3,000,000 with a tax basis of $1,000,000 after depreciation. A distribution is generally treated like a sale at fair market value, so about $2,000,000 of gain flows through to the shareholders. Part of that is usually depreciation recapture, which is taxed at higher rates than regular long term gain. The stock basis goes up by that gain, but the offsetting loss on the liquidation is generally capital, so character doesn't match up the way you'd hope.

    The estate side is the same gap in reverse. A step-up on the stock doesn't step up the building inside the corporation, so the depreciation and the built-in gain stay put. I'd ask your CPA to build that basis schedule first, because the real decision is paying the tax now versus living with the low inside basis.

    Accounting Properties LLC
    View Page
    CFO LLC
    View Page
  • Accountant · Dothan, AL · Member since 2026 · 9 posts · 6 votes
    1w

    Not much here.

    I would change focus to manufacture losses in other areas to offset the gains/income.

    Short-term rentals, equipment purchasing, retirement deferral, cost segregation, chunking itemized deductions, etc.

  • Eugenia ChetverechenkoBusiness Member
    Accountant · Chicago, IL · Member since 2026 · 26 posts · 5 votes
    1w

    Keith, I recently had similar tax planning discussions with a few real estate clients holding highly appreciated commercial properties in S corps. Definitely not an easy decision. This is one of the downsides of holding appreciated real estate in an S corp. Distributing the property or liquidating the corporation generally triggers gain as though the property were sold at fair market value, even if you intend to keep it. A lower-tier partnership may defer gain on the contribution, but it doesn't actually get you out of the S corp structure. If restructuring is important enough, I'd model the tax impact and explore available losses and other planning opportunities to help offset the tax cost before making that move.

  • Accountant · Richmond, TX · Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    6d

    Keith, you've already found the two hard parts, so I'll add a few things I haven't seen in the replies yet.

    Section 1239 only reaches the depreciable part of the property. Gain on the land isn't touched by it. On a San Diego commercial property the land can be a large share of the value, so a supportable land and building split tells you how much of the gain is really exposed to ordinary rates. Keep in mind the more-than-50% ownership test uses family attribution, so spreading the stock among relatives usually doesn't get anyone under the line.

    On the lower-tier partnership, I think it mostly relocates the problem. A 743(b) adjustment happens when a partnership interest is sold or a partner dies. If the S corporation is the partner, a shareholder's death transfers stock, not the partnership interest, so nothing inside steps up. And 704(c) keeps the built-in gain pointed at the corporation. What a real partnership can do is work as a freeze. New money, new debt and future appreciation can sit with the family's direct partnership interests instead of building up inside the corporation. The seven-year rules on contributed property (704(c)(1)(B) and 737) and the partnership anti-abuse rule mean it has to be a real business arrangement, not a first step toward pulling the building out.

    On refinancing, the reason it feels stuck is that entity-level debt doesn't give S corporation shareholders any stock basis, and a distribution above stock basis is taxable gain under 1368. A personal guarantee doesn't change that. So loan proceeds generally can't come out tax-free past stock basis. Loans from the corporation to the shareholders can work if they are real loans with a note, interest and repayment, but those get looked at closely.

    On the estate side, the stock gets a new basis at death and the building doesn't, as others said. If the stock is community property, both halves step up at the first death. The step-up pays off if the property is ever sold to an unrelated buyer and the corporation is liquidated in the same tax year, because the gain that passes through and the capital loss on the stock can largely offset. A sale to an outsider isn't a 1239 sale. That doesn't help if the plan is to hold forever, but it is why many families in your position keep the S corporation, stop adding appreciating property to it, and plan around the first death instead of paying the tax now.

    I wouldn't plan around pending legislation. And since the election dates to 1995, I'd have someone confirm whether any C corporation earnings and profits are still on the books, because rents can create a passive income problem when they are.

    This is general information, not advice on your facts. It's worth paying for a model that puts the tax today next to the cost of holding, with a real land and building allocation in it.

  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1d

    You've diagnosed it correctly, and there isn't a clean current-law fix that gets the property out with a stepped-up inside basis. The lower-tier partnership mostly relocates the problem. Dropping the property into an LLC taxed as a partnership under 721 is tax-free and does give you refinancing flexibility at the partnership level. But once that cash moves from the S corp to the shareholders, you're back to the low stock basis, and partnership debt allocated to the S corp doesn't increase shareholder basis. A 754 election doesn't help at death either, because no one is transferring the partnership interest. The S corp still holds it, the step-up happens at the stock level, and there's no 743(b) to trigger. The built-in gain just sits under 704(c) instead.

    If the goal is ultimately a step-up on the real estate itself, the usual plan is to hold the S corp until death and liquidate in the same tax year. The stock gets a basis step-up at death. The deemed-sale gain on liquidation then flows through and raises that basis further, and the liquidation produces an offsetting loss. That works cleanly on the land and on the portion of the building gain that’s capital in character. But your 1239 concern is real on the building: if the distributee is related under 1239 after attribution, that portion of the gain takes on a character the capital loss on the stock can’t fully absorb. That’s the piece worth modeling now with real numbers, including how ownership will be spread across the heirs.

    In the meantime, the drop-down may still be worth doing for flexibility on the debt side, as long as everyone understands the shareholder-level basis limit. I also wouldn't plan around a legislative fix. California adds its own layer, with the 1.5% S corp tax and the LLC fee on gross receipts, so run the state side through the model too.

    Happy to connect!

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9242 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
  • Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 0 votes
    1d

    There typically is not a clean way to move appreciated real estate out of an S-corp without a tax hit, and I would be careful with any plan that promises otherwise.

    If the corporation distributes the property, it is generally treated as if it sold the property at fair market value. That gain flows through to the shareholders, and because this is depreciable property going to related owners, Section 1239 can make a portion of it ordinary income. You may also have stock-basis issues on the way out, just as you described. A step-up in stock basis at death also does not automatically step up the property inside the S-corp the way a partnership basis adjustment can.

    So if the building is worth $2 million and the tax basis is $400,000, taking it out can put a very large gain on the shareholders’ returns in a single year. That is usually more expensive than living with a less flexible structure for a while.

    What I would do first is model the actual tax cost of leaving it alone versus distributing it, including state tax and the ordinary-income piece, and then decide whether refinancing or succession can be handled inside the current entities. Sometimes the better move is to keep the property where it is, and plan the ownership transition at the stock level, rather than forcing the real estate out just to get a partnership on the title.

    This one is fact-specific, especially with the QSub and the old 1031 basis, and it is the kind of project where a CPA and a tax attorney should look at it together before anyone records a deed. Hope this helps.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.