Lender · FL · Member since 2024 · 500 posts · 128 votes
When you're locking in a 30-year DSCR loan on a residential or small multifamily rental, how do you play the prepayment penalty?
Do you take the 3-to-5-year step-down prepay to secure the lowest interest rate and maximize day-one cash flow, or pay a slightly higher rate upfront for zero prepay so you have total freedom to sell or refinance whenever the market moves?
Curious how active buy-and-hold investors here are structuring their debt right now.
*Pre payment penalty* exactly as it’s worded you pay off the loan early you pay a penalty. Regardless of refinance or sale. Going to credit union is great if you’re going to go full doc, but not for dscr.
This is really an investor-specific question. I typically will allow for the 5-year prepayment penalty, with, of course, it scaling down by a point per year. But I do not typically plan on selling anytime soon. If you have some inkling I'm thinking you may sell, you would probably be better off paying the higher rate.
Prepayment penalties are generally reserved for refinances, not sales. I would strongly advise negotiating or finding a different lender if the pre-payment penalty applies to sales. Also consider federally chartered credit unions as they are not permitted to charge pre-payment penalties which makes them a strong banking partner to build relationships with.
*Pre payment penalty* exactly as it’s worded you pay off the loan early you pay a penalty. Regardless of refinance or sale. Going to credit union is great if you’re going to go full doc, but not for dscr.
Unpopular BiggerPockets take, but I don't understand why so many investors go straight to a DSCR lender. For loans of this size, I'd start with a community bank or credit union. In my experience, I've been able to get better rates, avoid prepayment penalties, and work with lenders who take the time to understand me, my business, and the deal.
I’ve spent 13 years building relationships with community banks. Those relationships are why I can get half the deals I do today across the finish line. As my development strategy has shifted to include more long term holds, I've undertaken a similar approach to build relationships with credit unions. In some cases, the same lender does my development financing and perm, in other instances I have designated lenders for the development piece and others for the refinances but all are true relationship based lending experiences. I can get outside of the box transactions funded with very little friction and it's not because of my balance sheet, it's entirely because of these relationships. Just one example, I needed capital quick and one of the community banks I've worked with for years approved me for a $400K unsecured line in a week. That's the power of these relationships most never realize.
I get why the DSCR route is appealing but the convenience can get expensive over time and greatly restricts your growth. Not suggesting there's never a time or place for DSCR lenders or even alternative lenders, but there's so much bad information out there that pushes investors to stick with DSCR and alternative lenders and it's the leading reason why so many investors feel like they are hamsters on a wheel, particularly when you factor in the realities of this maket we are in.
It really comes down to your actual hold timeline. If you are parking long-term cash and keeping the property for 5+ years, taking a 3-year or 5-year step-down is usually a no-brainer because zero-prepay options easily tack 50 to 100+ basis points onto your rate. But if you think you might refi or sell in the first 24 months to pull equity out or chase lower rates, paying the higher rate upfront is way cheaper than cutting a massive penalty check at closing.
Prepay penalties aren't good or bad on their own — they're a price. You're trading a lower rate for a lock-in, so the only question that matters is whether your exit falls inside the window.
Two things worth adding:
1. On most DSCR notes I've seen, the prepay clause applies to ANY payoff inside the window — sale or refi — unless the note specifically carves out a sale. Don't take anyone's word for it, read the actual prepay language before you sign. If you're flipping and the penalty hits on a sale, that's a real cost — either price it into the deal or pay for a shorter / no-penalty structure up front.
2. Match the window to your hold. Holding 5+ years, a 1- or 2-year penalty is cheap money — you'll likely never pay it. Out in 12-18 months, even a 1% penalty on the balance can eat the rate savings. Common structures are step-downs like 3/2/1, or a flat 5% of the balance for 12 months and then nothing.
So: a penalty is fine when your exit is after the window. It's a dealbreaker when your exit is inside it and it triggers on a sale. — Dan
Sagi's hold timeline is the key, so here's a way to put numbers on it. Say it's a $300,000 loan with a 5/4/3/2/1 step-down. Pay it off in year 3 and the penalty is 3%, or $9,000. The zero-prepay option costs 50 to 100 basis points more, which is $1,500 to $3,000 a year on that balance. At 100 bps you've paid about $9,000 extra by year 3, so you break even there. At 50 bps you break even closer to year 6.
On the books, a prepayment penalty on a rental loan is generally treated as interest expense in the year you pay it. Any loan costs you've been spreading over the term usually get written off at payoff too. So track loan costs separately from monthly interest, and your payoff year is cleaner.
Both options are deductible, so taxes don't change which is cheaper. What changes is timing: the penalty comes as one lump, the higher rate comes in monthly. I'd run your own hold-period scenarios with those two numbers before choosing.