Sold a rental after Oct 17? Your 1031 window ends April 15 unless you extend

Sold a rental after Oct 17? Your 1031 window ends April 15 unless you extend

Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes

Quick one that catches people every year around now.

A 1031 exchange (named after Section 1031 of the tax code) lets you sell an investment property and roll the money into another one without paying capital gains tax on the sale right then. You put it off. The basics in plain English:

  • Investment or business real estate for investment or business real estate. Not your own home.

  • 45 days after you sell to identify, in writing, what you might buy.

  • 180 days after you sell to close, or the due date of your tax return for that year, whichever comes first.

  • A qualified intermediary (an independent company that holds your sale money) has to be in the middle. If the money lands in your bank account, the exchange is blown.

  • To put off all of the tax, buy something worth the same or more and replace the debt you paid off. Cash you pull out is called boot, and boot gets taxed.

The trap

Read that third bullet again: whichever comes first. For most individuals, that return is due April 15. Count 180 days from October 17 and you land right on April 15, 2027. So if you sold an investment property after October 17 this year, your tax return due date arrives before your 180th day. Unless you file an extension, your exchange window gets cut short.

Example: sell today, November 9. Your 45th day is Christmas Eve. Your 180th day is May 8, 2027, after tax day. File the extension and you get the full window.

If the property sold out of a partnership or a multi-member LLC that files a partnership return, ask your CPA about that entity's due date. For a calendar-year partnership it's March 15, which means the cutoff for this problem is mid-September, not mid-October.

The trade I see most

Somebody owns three paid-down single-family rentals and is tired of three roofs, three water heaters and three lawns. Sell them and trade into a 12-unit. One roof. One insurance policy. One property manager. More doors, and in Louisville usually a lower price per door. Fourplexes here sold for about $84,400 a door over the last 12 months vs. about $112,500 for duplexes.

Two things to watch on that trade. Your 45-day list has to be in writing to your intermediary, and with 2+ unit buildings sitting longer right now, have backups on that list. And if the three houses were paid off, there's no old debt to replace, but every dollar you leave out of the new purchase is boot.

I'm not your CPA or your attorney. Bring them in before you list, not after you close.

For those who've traded single-family into small multifamily: did one roof and one policy actually feel easier, or did you trade three headaches for one bigger one? And for the CPAs and intermediaries on here, how often do you see someone skip the extension and lose the back end of their 180 days?

0Reply
160 views

2 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1d

    We see the extension problem every spring. The most common version is someone filing on time without extending, simply because nobody connected the April 15 deadline to an exchange that was still open. Even with an extension, if the return gets filed before the replacement closes, you end up amending to report the exchange, so it’s usually easier to extend and hold off filing until the deal is done.

    On the three-houses-into-a-12-unit trade, watch the timing across the three sales. If they’re all part of one exchange, the 45 and 180 days start from the first house that closes, not the last. Sellers who list all three at once and close them weeks apart lose more of the window than they expect. On the upside, if they finance the 12-unit, the new debt adds basis that’s treated as newly placed in service. A cost seg on the bigger building can then produce a real first-year deduction on that piece, even though the carried-over basis from the paid-off houses stays on the old schedule.

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9242 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
    • Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      1d

      Thanks, Ashish. Filing before the replacement closes is the trap I see too. For anyone who sold in late October or later, the 180-day clock and the April 15 return date land almost on top of each other, so extending and holding off on filing is the cleaner path.

      The point about new debt on the bigger building being treated as newly placed in service is a good one. A lot of Louisville investors trading a few paid-off houses into a small multifamily assume the whole basis stays on the old schedule. That's a conversation to have with their own CPA before closing, not after.

      When someone does file early and has to amend, is it mostly paperwork, or does it tend to cause real problems?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.