I’ve been wholesaling in Atlanta for about 5 months. I’ve found some success in how I’m sending deals out, but of course always want this to be improved.
I’ve tried doing the math for my investors, showing them all the different ways this deal could pan out based on strategies I know they like. Mainly just flips and LTR, sometimes co-living if they’re that kind of investor. This hasn’t really gotten any response surely because they’re just doing their own math anyway which I expect.
Has anyone had any improvement in close rate when doing something like this? I feel this second opinion on numbers is part of the value I should be providing as a wholesaler but it seems more like investors prefer I just bring the deal, and they can figure out anything to do with strategy or numbers.
Etienne, I have been on both sides of this and most active buyers are going to run their own numbers no matter what you send them. Where your math does help is in the first 30 seconds. If the price, ARV, rent and repair range are clean and easy to follow, a real buyer can say yes or no fast instead of ignoring it.
What I stopped doing was building a different case for every strategy on every deal. It takes a lot of time and most investors already know which lane they want. I send the basics done well, one solid flip case and one solid rental case if both actually fit, and I make sure the photos and access info are ready to go.
The bigger lever for me was not the presentation, it was how many real buyers saw the deal. If your list is mostly other wholesalers, even a perfect packet gets no response. Pull recent cash buyers who actually closed near that zip in the last 6 to 12 months, skip trace that list so you have good mobile numbers, and text the deal to all of them at once. That is how I learned whether a deal was really priced right. If real buyers are quiet, it is usually price, not the spreadsheet.
Keep doing the numbers, just keep them simple and honest, and spend the saved time getting the deal in front of more proven buyers.
From the buyer side I do my own math on every deal so a second set of numbers does not change much for me. What helps me say yes faster is a clean deal. Clear price, honest notes on condition, and the numbers I need to check it myself. When I have to guess at repairs or chase down details I slow down. Time kills deals on my end, so the wholesalers I answer first are the ones who make it easy to say yes. I am still learning this side of it too.
This makes sense. Things that affect the numbers so you can run them better can save more time than trying to do it for you.
Etienne, I have been on both sides of this and most active buyers are going to run their own numbers no matter what you send them. Where your math does help is in the first 30 seconds. If the price, ARV, rent and repair range are clean and easy to follow, a real buyer can say yes or no fast instead of ignoring it.
What I stopped doing was building a different case for every strategy on every deal. It takes a lot of time and most investors already know which lane they want. I send the basics done well, one solid flip case and one solid rental case if both actually fit, and I make sure the photos and access info are ready to go.
The bigger lever for me was not the presentation, it was how many real buyers saw the deal. If your list is mostly other wholesalers, even a perfect packet gets no response. Pull recent cash buyers who actually closed near that zip in the last 6 to 12 months, skip trace that list so you have good mobile numbers, and text the deal to all of them at once. That is how I learned whether a deal was really priced right. If real buyers are quiet, it is usually price, not the spreadsheet.
Keep doing the numbers, just keep them simple and honest, and spend the saved time getting the deal in front of more proven buyers.
This is good! I see a lot of people doing the text blast. Did you find this converts higher than email or calling your people that are more familiar with you? I try to warm up the list before I start texting them for deals so I don’t seem spammy
Good question. For buyers I already know and who have bought from me before, a call still converts best. They know my voice and we can talk numbers and closing timing in two minutes.
For a wider list of buyers I have not worked with yet, text has gotten me way more responses than email. Email mostly sits unread when a deal is time sensitive. A short text with price, beds and baths, rent if it is a rental, and a clear closing timeline gets a yes or no fast, and that speed matters.
Your warm up idea is smart. I would not overdo it though. One short intro text saying you wholesale in Atlanta and asking if they want to see deals in their buy box is enough. Then only send deals that actually fit what they told you. That is what keeps it from feeling spammy, not a long warm up sequence. The mix has worked best for me, calls to your proven buyers first, then a text blast to the rest of the traced list the same day.
From the buyer side, I run my own numbers on every deal, so a second set of numbers doesn't change my answer. What changes it is clean basics, fast.
I buy single-family in Memphis — under $100K, ARV $180K-$265K, 3BR+ Section 8 rent $1,395-$1,950, 1% rule as a first filter. If you send me that, with address, asking price, beds and baths, square footage, current or projected rent, and photos, I can say yes or no in minutes. If I have to dig for the basics, I move on — deal flow is the bottleneck, and I'm looking at a lot of deals.
Don't build a different case for every strategy. Send one honest set of numbers, show the rehab range, and get the deal in front of more real buyers who actually closed in that ZIP. If real buyers are quiet, it's usually price, not the presentation.
Etienne, I've bought deals from wholesalers, and I'll be honest: I put almost no weight on wholesaler estimates. That isn't personal. I've just seen too many ARVs pulled from the best sale in the neighborhood and rehab budgets that seem to assume the roof, HVAC and foundation will take care of themselves. After a few of those, I stopped reading the numbers and started skipping straight to the photos and the address.
What a wholesaler can give me that I can't get on my own is information. Tell me the age of the roof, HVAC and water heater, whether there's water in the basement, what the electrical panel looks like and anything else you saw that worried you. Send photos of the bad stuff, not just the kitchen with the best light. If you're going to include an ARV, list the comps you used so I can see whether they actually match the house. That's far more useful to me than a polished flip case and a rental case.
There's an opportunity here too. Most wholesalers inflate the numbers, so the one whose numbers are consistently conservative stands out quickly. If I look at your deals and find that your rehab estimate was a little high and your ARV a little low, I'll start opening your emails first. After a few deals like that, your estimates really do become worth something, because you've earned it. You get there by being right, not by giving buyers more scenarios.
I try to be pretty conservative with these. I think there’s also a fine line of sending rehab items to estimate cost without making it a drag or making it look bad! I kind of assume investors aren’t reading much of what I have to say about rehab anyway since they do more work than I do on homes. Once I get some flips done I think this can be gold. Thanks for this.
I think you're overthinking the strategy side a little. Most experienced investors already know what they want to do with a property, and they're going to run their own numbers regardless of what you send them.
Your job as a wholesaler is to bring them a good opportunity, provide accurate information, be upfront about the condition, and make the process easy.
That doesn't mean you shouldn't include potential strategies. I just wouldn't spend a ton of time trying to sell an investor on three different exit strategies.
I'd focus on:
Purchase price.
Realistic ARV with comparable sales.
Estimated repairs.
Pictures and access information.
Any issues that could affect the deal.
One thing I've learned is that experienced buyers don't need you to convince them a deal is good. They need you to bring them something that makes sense.
Your credibility comes from the accuracy of your numbers, not how many different ways you can make a deal look profitable.
Fair. All the deals I’ve closed have been pretty effortless. It’s actually people that never have been close to buying that I spend time convincing and going back and forth with
Totally normal seasoned investors trust their own spreadsheets, not a wholesaler's exit projections.
From analyzing thousands of distressed listings in Atlanta, the highest-converting deal sheets keep it strictly objective: Asking Price vs. live submarket $/SqFt benchmark, exact rehab tier estimate (light vs. gut), HOA/tax load, and official HUD rent baselines. Put the raw spread right in the subject line and let the buyer decide the exit strategy.