The prepay clause costs investors more than the rate ever will - how to read it

The prepay clause costs investors more than the rate ever will - how to read it

Erik EstradaBusiness Member
Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2022 · 7k+ posts · 1k+ votes

Most investors negotiate the rate and skim the prepayment clause. That clause is what actually decides what exiting the deal costs you, and it shows up in three structures:

1. Step-down (declining): A 5-4-3-2-1 schedule charges 5% of the balance if you pay off in year one, 4% in year two, and so on to 1% in year five. Common on DSCR loans.

2. Flat percentage: The same charge (say 5% of the amount prepaid) whenever you exit during the penalty years.

3. Months of interest: Pay off early and you owe a set number of months of interest - six is typical - as the penalty.

Two things investors miss:

• The LENGTH matters as much as the percentage. A 5-year penalty on a property you plan to sell in year 3 is a real cost; a 3-year penalty on a 10-year hold is nearly free. Match the penalty period to your realistic exit, not your optimistic one.

• "No prepay" isn't free. Loans without a penalty are priced higher up front (rate, points, or both). If you know you're holding past the penalty window anyway, taking the penalty usually wins.

Also watch for the carve-outs: some structures only charge on amounts prepaid above a percentage of the original balance in a 12-month period (20% is common), which matters if you plan partial paydowns.

Before you sign, run your exit math both ways: what you save on rate versus what the penalty costs if you sell or refi at your realistic exit date. The rate gets the attention; the prepay clause takes the money.

Happy to answer questions - what prepay structures are you all seeing on recent term sheets?

LuxePrivate Investments LLC 571 Reviews
0Reply
347 views

Most Popular Reply

Chris ColtonPro Member
Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 246 posts · 93 votes
2d

Erik, thank you for laying this out so plainly. I am still learning the lending side, and the part that stuck with me is matching the penalty period to my real exit, not the optimistic one. On the deals I work, I ask for the prepay terms in writing before anything moves, because that clause decides what getting out costs. I learned that lesson the expensive way on a different approval, and I wrote more on it here: https://www.biggerpockets.com/member-blogs/16509/107275-read-it-before-you-approve-it

Appreciate you posting this.

See this reply in the discussion

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 246 posts · 93 votes
    2d

    Erik, thank you for laying this out so plainly. I am still learning the lending side, and the part that stuck with me is matching the penalty period to my real exit, not the optimistic one. On the deals I work, I ask for the prepay terms in writing before anything moves, because that clause decides what getting out costs. I learned that lesson the expensive way on a different approval, and I wrote more on it here: https://www.biggerpockets.com/member-blogs/16509/107275-read-it-before-you-approve-it

    Appreciate you posting this.

  • Stacy RaskinBusiness Member
    Lender · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 535 votes
    1d

    Erik, good points made. Some investors don't realize that if there is no prepayment penalty, they are paying more for the rate or paying other fees. Also, if it's a shorter prepayment penalty, the rate is going to be higher. So a 5 year prepayment penalty term will have a lower rate compared to a 3 year prepayment with all other factors being equal such as borrower's credit score and loan LTV.

    Also planning for a realistic exit is a good point as well. A lot of investors had thought they were going to refinance down to a lower rate more quickly than rates have gone down so they ended up paying for a higher rate for a shorter prepayment term such as paying a higher rate for a one year prepayment penalty term. Since they chose a shorter prepayment term such as a one year prepayment term compared to a three year prepayment term, they are still paying the higher rate that came with the one year prepayment term. The real estate investors were not able to refinance down to a lower rates as rates haven't gone down as much as investors expected or rates haven't gone down enough to justify the expenses of the new refinance.

  • Technology · New York, NY · Member since 2026 · 78 posts · 24 votes
    1d

    Erik, the framing is right, the quantification is where deals die. A prepay penalty is not a fee, it is an option you sold the lender. Price it as reduced exit equity, not a closing cost.

    Chris, "realistic exit" needs a number. Model the penalty against the debt constant. A 7.5% coupon on 30-year amortization carries a constant near 8.4%. A 5-4-3-2-1 step-down on a $5M balance is $250K in year one, $150K in year three, roughly 3.5 points of equity, often the whole spread between entry basis and stabilized value. LTC at close and LTARV at stabilization are different denominators. If the refi tests at a 1.20x DSCR against a 1.25x floor, the penalty is not the constraint, sizing is.

    Stacy, the shorter penalty carrying a higher rate cuts both ways. Price both loans at exit. The quote is a coupon; all-in cost is coupon plus penalty spread over the hold.

    Horizontal infrastructure per pad runs the same arithmetic: carry sits where the funded balance is heaviest, not where the headline rate looks best. A two-quarter pad delay turns a 3-year penalty into a 5-year one.

    What is the break-even hold month where the lower-rate 5-year loan beats the higher-rate 3-year loan, and does that answer survive a 50 bps cap rate move?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.