Charleston, SC · Member since 2026 · 20 posts · 8 votes
Ran into a version of this again last week and figured I would throw it out here. West-side style deal, older one-story, under contract in the low 200s. Comps made the ARV feel okay. Borrower had a rehab budget of 70K. I went through their own photos with a contractor-style pencil and landed closer to 98 to 100K if they hire it out. Nothing exotic. Kitchen, baths, flooring, paint, some electrical that was going to get worse once walls opened. The 70K was more hope than scope. Curious how you all handle this when you are the one bringing the deal. Go back to the seller, cut finishes, or bring more cash? And if you are funding with hard money, how early do you want the contractor bid locked before you lock the loan?
"More hope than scope" is a great way to put it. A gap of nearly $30,000 on a deal in the low 200s can quietly eat most of the profit before the first wall is even opened, especially with electrical that you already know is going to get worse.
I'm not a flipper myself, so I'll leave the seller, finishes or cash question to the people who do this every week. What stood out to me is that you found the gap by going through the borrower's own photos room by room. If I were a borrower, I'd want that same exercise done before the offer goes in: walk every room in the photos, write a line for each item, like the kitchen, baths, flooring, paint and electrical, and put a rough number next to each one.
AI is pretty good at that first pass now. It can read the listing photos and an inspection report and turn them into a room by room scope list, so the contractor starts from a complete list instead of a hopeful total. The contractor still sets the real numbers, but nobody walks into the loan with a figure that was never tied to anything.
I don't bring more cash just to save the deal. Get a written line-item bid before the inspection period ends and before locking the loan, then rerun the all-in against your MAO. Keep 10% to 15% contingency on top, and renegotiate or walk if it no longer clears your margin.
That $30k gap usually vaporizes the entire margin on a low $200s purchase unless the ARV was insanely conservative to begin with. If they haven't closed yet, the only real play is beating the seller up for a price reduction using the contractor's actual scope or just walking away. Trying to force a $100k rehab into a $70k fantasy mid-project is how people run out of cash and end up stuck with a half-finished house.
@Ryan Cobb, in Switzerland it's the same: the number we get from photos before the visit is almost always higher than the owner's own. We try to price everything down to the smallest detail, but additional work still shows up. Unfortunately, there's no rehab without it.
And of course the client always wants to save and spend as little as possible. So it's always better to do 3 things: get offers before buying, check the materials, and find a contractor ready to do the job for the money set aside. There are always contractors. It's the clients who are afraid to lose what they already have.
As the saying goes, a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush. When you show a borrower the real number, which bird do they usually choose?
From what I see, the gap usually comes from pricing the job at DIY or "my guy" prices instead of what a hired contractor will charge, plus no line for what's behind the walls.
If the numbers still work at $100K, I'd go back to the seller first with the contractor's bid in hand. A real bid is a much stronger argument than "I think it needs more work". Cutting finishes is the last option, because it usually hurts the ARV.
And yes, I'd want the contractor walkthrough done before locking the loan, even a rough bid. Otherwise the borrower is just finding out the real number after closing.
Do you see this gap more with first-time flippers, or with experienced ones too?
Ryan, I am on the buyer side of this in San Antonio. I learned to get the real contractor number before I make the offer, not after. Once the number moves after the offer, the deal just sits while everybody reworks it. And sitting is what kills it. I would rather know it is closer to 100K up front and make my offer on that than find out later and try to save it.
I want the line-item bid before the inspection period ends, because that's the last point where the extra $30K can still go back to the seller instead of out of the borrower's pocket. It also matters more than people think with most rehab loans. Even when they advertise 100% of rehab funded, the total is usually capped at a percentage of ARV, so a budget that grows after closing often isn't covered. You're re-submitting the scope and hoping the draws stretch. Get the real number, re-run it against the ARV cap, and then decide between renegotiating, cutting finishes, or walking.
That extra $30K can change the whole deal. I’d want an itemized contractor bid and a contingency built in before finalizing financing. Then revisit the purchase price and see if the numbers still work. Additional funding may help cover a gap, but it comes with costs too. Did they end up renegotiating with the seller?
I'm on the other side of this one. I'm the guy who writes the 98.
The thing I'd offer is that the 70 and the 98 are not two estimates of the same thing. They're answers to two different questions, and that's why the gap shows up over and over at roughly the same size.
A borrower's budget is almost always organized by ROOM. Kitchen, baths, flooring, paint. That's how people see a house, it's how the photos are arranged, and it's how every room-by-room scoping exercise works, including the AI pass suggested above. The problem is that in an older house the expensive items are not in rooms. They're in SYSTEMS that run through rooms. A sewer line isn't in the kitchen. A service and panel upgrade isn't in a bedroom. A roof isn't in a room at all. So a room-organized budget is structurally biased low, and making the room list more detailed doesn't fix it, because you're adding resolution to the part that was already roughly right.
The fix is a second list, written first: roof, structure and foundation, drainage and sewer, supply plumbing, electrical service and branch wiring, HVAC, windows, exterior envelope. Price those, then do the rooms. Almost all of the 28 grand lives on the first list.
Your own sentence has the diagnosis in it, by the way: electrical that was going to get worse once walls opened. That's not something the borrower missed through optimism. It's invisible until somebody has already spent money, which is why it never lands in a pre-offer number. I'd treat it as its own line rather than as contingency. Something like "discovered conditions, electrical, allowance of X, confirmed at demo, unused balance released." A percentage contingency gets consumed by scope creep in month one and then isn't there in month three when the actual thing appears. A named allowance with a trigger survives, because everybody knows what it's for.
On your three options, I'd rank them: go back to the seller, then walk, and I'd put cutting finishes last rather than second. Here's why. You can only cut what you were going to pay for, and the overage isn't in the cuttable part. The 28 is in the electrical and the discovery. Finishes are where your ARV lives. So cutting finishes reduces the value without materially touching the cost, which widens the hole rather than filling it. And more cash doesn't fix a deal, it just means you own more of one that doesn't work.
On your last question, which I think is the best one in the post: I wouldn't lock the BID early. I'd lock the SCOPE. A bid locked against a loose scope isn't locked at all, it's just moved the argument to change orders after you've funded. Fix the scope document before the loan and let the price move inside it, because then a price change has to be explained rather than just invoiced.
The structural reason these numbers are bad is that nobody is paid to produce them. The scope gets written for free by whoever has the strongest incentive for the deal to look winnable, and a document written to WIN a job is not the same document as one written to GOVERN a job. If you have borrowers doing volume with you, paying a contractor two or three hundred dollars for a scope that is explicitly not a bid is the cheapest underwriting you'll ever buy. You'd have caught this one for the price of a lunch, before the contract rather than after.
Ryan, one thing that helps when the gap is this big is to lay the two numbers side by side line by line before deciding which one is real. In the estimate reviews I do, a gap like this is often not the same work priced differently. It is usually a few lines that exist in one bid and are missing from the other, like allowances set low, debris removal, or permit fees. Ask the contractor to confirm in writing what is included and excluded on each line. That way the borrower is comparing the same scope, not two different jobs.
Thanks Ioannis, that's exactly what we see. The gap is almost always scope, not price. The written in and out list per line is a great tip, especially for allowances. Do you find contractors push back on putting exclusions in writing, or do most go along with it?
Good question, Ryan. In my experience most contractors go along with it once they see it protects them too. A written exclusion list keeps the homeowner from assuming something was included, and it keeps the contractor from being asked to absorb work they never priced. The pushback I see usually comes when the list is handed over late, after the price is already set. If it is part of the scope from the start, it reads as part of the job, not as a change. One habit that helps is asking the contractor to write the exclusions in their own words on their quote, so both sides are looking at the same list.