Dual purchase sanity check :)

Dual purchase sanity check :)

Washington, D.C. · Member since 2026 · 2 posts · 1 vote

About 3 months ago, I started mulling over a 2nd home in the mountains of CO*. We have a market portfolio (non real estate) worth about 5 million plus our current home's equity. We live in Washington, D.C and purchased our home 28 years ago for 250k, it's now worth 1.6 approx).

I co-own a personal training business and plan to retire in 2 years.  My husband, also plans to retire in 2 years from the gov't.

I began listening to better understand STR's, MTR's etc for the CO purchase as we would only be there 4-5 weeks a year until retirement.

Recently, our 24 year old son ended a relationship with his gf and is looking for an apt in Philadelphia. I heard Henry say that Philly was a good market!

I'm thinking about purchasing a 2/2 (200-250k) in Philly PLUS a home in CO (650-800K) for cash.  The Philly place would be a (n) LTR, though we would charge a roommate rent, but not our son for about a year or so.
We would have to take the money out of the market to do cash transactions.  

I think the Philly place would be a great investment for our son, down the road - as an investor or homeowner- and CO would be mostly rental income and a place for us to visit in the summer.

Am I nuts?!!!  

* I was in CO in Oct looking at property.  I have a realtor and will be returning with my half-on-board (!) husband Dec 10th.  Thinking Evergreen, CO after eliminating other areas for multiple reasons.

1Reply
453 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Agent · Evergreen, CO · Member since 2015 · 127 posts · 74 votes
16h

@Allison Yorra

Evergreen is a great place to live! I'm originally from about 45 mins north of Philly, but have been out here for a few decades and live in Evergreen. Average close price in Evergreen is $1,155,000 at the moment. With your budget you would have to be a little further out and not in North Evergreen if you want a single family home or you could look to a condo or older townhome, but then you will have HOAs to deal with. Something to keep in mind.

STRs are definitely regulated, but it's all doable. Jefferson County, which is where the bulk of Evergreen is located, just lightened up some regulations in particular the previous need for a min of 1 acre so that plays in your favor. Evergreen also continues into Clear Creek County which has lighter regulations. You just need to complete their check list and there is a wait list. I'm a local agent and also an investor with LTRs, MTRs and STRs in Colorado and Montana.

I'd recommend you look into the county regulations for both of these counties. You said you have a agent so they should have hopefully told you this. But you never know as very few agents (even the "good ones") know much about STRs and even fewer have actual STR experience themselves. So you may have to self educate more than you would hope for unless your agent has STR experience or you find an agent that does. Anyway, good luck with it all, it's a great place to live.

See this reply in the discussion

9 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Lender · Peoria, AZ · Member since 2026 · 79 posts · 17 votes
    1d

    Hey Allison,

    Not nuts at all. One thing I'd think about before pulling money out of the market for Evergreen is that you don't have to go all cash on the Colorado place. You could finance part of it and keep more of the portfolio working, then pay it down later if you want to. How you'd document income changes once you both retire, so it's worth looking at that before the retirement date instead of after.

    Also, if the plan is mostly renting it out and visiting 4 or 5 weeks a year, that can affect whether a lender treats it as a second home or an investment property. Good to be upfront about the plan early.

    I'm a mortgage broker licensed in Arizona, California, Colorado, Kansas, Texas, and Arkansas, and I like helping investors. Happy to be a resource. No pressure at all!

    Are you set on cash for Evergreen, or open to financing part of it? And are you leaning STR or MTR up there?

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2026 · 10 posts · 7 votes
    1d

    Allison, I’d test the cash before anything else. You’d be moving about $850k to $1M out of a market portfolio into two properties, so that portfolio is the benchmark each property has to beat.

    Run each property the same way. Add up the cash in, including closing costs, repairs, and a reserve. Then count rent after taxes, insurance, repairs, vacancy, and management, plus the equity you keep at sale in about five years. For Evergreen, include the months the place sits empty while you’re away and any cleaning or management costs. Then put the same cash back into the portfolio over the same five years, after taxes on any sales. If the properties don’t beat that, the money is buying a place for your summers and your son, and that’s a fine reason. It’s just a cost, not an investment return.

    Check the tax bill on pulling money out of the portfolio before you buy. Selling appreciated holdings can create a large one, and that changes the hurdle.

  • Real Estate Broker · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2026 · 15 posts · 4 votes
    1d

    On the Philly piece, $200-250k for a 2/2 is doable but it depends a lot on the neighborhood and whether it's a condo or a rowhome, condo fees and the building's reserves can eat a lot of the rent so read those docs closely. I'd let your son help pick the area since he's the one living there, then run the numbers like he's a regular tenant so you know what it looks like once he moves out. Check the assessment on the city's OPA site too, the city reassesses and it can change your numbers. Not nuts, just make sure the Philly one works as a rental on its own and isn't only a place for your son


    Disclosure: I'm a Philly broker and used AI to help draft this.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    21h

    Allison, not nuts, but I'd start with the end in mind. You both retire in two years. What does life look like then? Is Colorado where you eventually want to live, a place you'll visit more once you're retired, or purely an income property? And is the Philly place an investment, or a way to help your son that you'd like to at least break even on?

    Each answer points somewhere different. If Colorado is the eventual home, buy the house you'd want to live in and let rental income help carry it until then, rather than buying for maximum STR returns. If it's mainly income, compare it to what that same cash earns in your portfolio today, after taking out the weeks you block for yourselves. And if Philly is mostly about your son, that's a perfectly good reason. Just call it that, so the numbers don't have to pretend.

    Two markets, two strategies, both a long way from DC, starting right as you retire, means two sets of rules, two local teams and two sets of surprises at the same time. That can work, but only if both purchases move you toward the same end state. If they don't, I'd buy the one that does first and decide on the second after you've lived with it for a year.

    I don't know Evergreen as a market, so I'll leave the local specifics to others. Whatever you buy there, check what the county and any HOA allow for short-term rentals before you commit.

  • Lender · Houston, TX · Member since 2026 · 149 posts · 44 votes
    19h

    Allison, the two purchases seem to serve different goals, so I would underwrite them separately before deciding whether to liquidate roughly $850,000 to $1.05 million from the portfolio. For Philadelphia, I would compare expected rent, carrying costs and the value of housing your son against the after-tax cost of selling investments. For Evergreen, because you expect to use it only four or five weeks a year, I would first confirm local STR/MTR rules and model it as an investment property using realistic seasonal income and operating expenses. Your planned retirement in two years also makes it worth reviewing financing while current income is still in place. I'm Nyisha with EquityNest Capital. If helpful, I can help you compare an all-cash purchase with partial financing for each property, with no pressure to move forward.

  • Lender · Irvine, Orange County · Member since 2026 · 86 posts · 49 votes
    18h

    Not nuts at all — but I'd push back on paying cash for both.

    The Philly 2-bed is the financing opportunity. As a long-term rental, a DSCR loan qualifies on the rent alone — no personal income documents — so you can finance that $200-250k and keep the money invested instead of tying it up in the property.

    One thing to decide before you buy the Evergreen place: STR vs. MTR changes the loan box. A second home you use part-time is financed differently than an investment property, so nail that down first or you'll be re-doing the financing later.

    And the tax point is real — pulling $850k-$1M out of the market has a tax bill attached. Financing the rental piece instead softens that hit and keeps your portfolio working.

    Happy to run your numbers on the Philly piece if you want — Dan

  • Real Estate Agent · Evergreen, CO · Member since 2015 · 127 posts · 74 votes
    16h

    @Allison Yorra

    Evergreen is a great place to live! I'm originally from about 45 mins north of Philly, but have been out here for a few decades and live in Evergreen. Average close price in Evergreen is $1,155,000 at the moment. With your budget you would have to be a little further out and not in North Evergreen if you want a single family home or you could look to a condo or older townhome, but then you will have HOAs to deal with. Something to keep in mind.

    STRs are definitely regulated, but it's all doable. Jefferson County, which is where the bulk of Evergreen is located, just lightened up some regulations in particular the previous need for a min of 1 acre so that plays in your favor. Evergreen also continues into Clear Creek County which has lighter regulations. You just need to complete their check list and there is a wait list. I'm a local agent and also an investor with LTRs, MTRs and STRs in Colorado and Montana.

    I'd recommend you look into the county regulations for both of these counties. You said you have a agent so they should have hopefully told you this. But you never know as very few agents (even the "good ones") know much about STRs and even fewer have actual STR experience themselves. So you may have to self educate more than you would hope for unless your agent has STR experience or you find an agent that does. Anyway, good luck with it all, it's a great place to live.

  • Lender · Cartersville, GA · Member since 2026 · 37 posts · 11 votes
    13h

    Allison, Dan's right that the Philly unit is the one to finance. I grew up in Reading and know the Philly neighborhoods. If you want a second opinion on where a 2/2 in that range rents well, and what financing it would look like, message me.

    • Washington, D.C. · Member since 2026 · 2 posts · 1 vote
      10h

      thank you David! this forum is very active :). I'm sorting through all the info people are sending my way but wanted to respond to you as THIS I understand! We are a bit limited in terms of location bc my son has commitments in Center City and no car. Yes, there is public transit that he uses but as a dancer he is frequently commuting at night so ...

      Anyway, much to mull over...

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.