I am renewing a commercial lease with an existing tenant. Their 5-5 lease will expire this year. I intending to offer a new 5-5 lease with similar rent increase rates as the past 5 years.
I started looking at LoopNet to see what current commercial rent rates are and the $/SQ/YR is about half to 2/3 what I am asking when I factor in property tax and estimate for insurance.
LoopNet asking rents are usually gross or NNN without your tax and insurance pass throughs, so that half to two thirds gap is often apples to oranges. Get 3 recent signed comps for similar SF space and price off those, not listings. A 5-5 with the same bumps as the last 5 years is fair if the tenant is solid, but I would trade a slightly lower starting rent for stronger annual bumps and a personal guarantee if you can get it. Hope this helps.
LoopNet asking rents are usually gross or NNN without your tax and insurance pass throughs, so that half to two thirds gap is often apples to oranges. Get 3 recent signed comps for similar SF space and price off those, not listings. A 5-5 with the same bumps as the last 5 years is fair if the tenant is solid, but I would trade a slightly lower starting rent for stronger annual bumps and a personal guarantee if you can get it. Hope this helps.
I wouldn’t automatically reset the rent based on LoopNet asking rents. Those listings can be pretty different from what comparable properties are actually leasing for, and you also need to compare the lease structures especially who is paying taxes, insurance, maintenance, and other expenses. Since you already have a tenant and they’ve been there for five years, I’d first look at what comparable spaces have actually leased for, not just what’s advertised. Then compare that against your current tenant’s history and the cost of replacing them. If your proposed renewal is significantly above the market, I’d want to understand why before pushing ahead. Sometimes keeping a good tenant at a slightly below-market rent can be more profitable than creating vacancy, paying leasing commissions, giving concessions and spending money to get the space ready for someone new.
comping commercial rents is not like a residential property it really is about the totality of the elements of the deal. Also have to consider the cost for them to move. but in general don't put to much weight on the loopnet asking rents unless you have clear understanding of the terms they are asking also. but in general keeping a solid tenant is worth "less than market" rent in my mind.