should I buy a new house or old house

should I buy a new house or old house

Member since 2026 · 5 posts · 0 votes

Hi Team,

I contacted an agent in Raleigh North Carolina. I shared my information and would like to buy a house for a long term rental. But I am not sure his suggestions makes sense?

1) He suggests and provides new houses which are just built and close to Raleigh.

2) I need to put down 30 - 40% to have cash flow (He said Raleigh does not have any deals which can match 1% rule) For example, he suggests to buy a house for $410k but monthly rental is only $2,200 to $2,500

3) These suburbs have schools with grade is very slow 3 or 4.

This is completely what I am thinking. I though he will find a normal house, and in a good shape. Also, it needs to close to best schools which I assume should be a good areas because school grade is over 7, 8, 9 for elementary, secondary, high school. If we find a good areas, it means it will be more easy for rental.... I am worry about his suggestions

Also, if I buy a new house, do you think I need property management. I do not think a new house will have a low maintain and they do have warranty from build for one year.

0Reply
63 views

Most Popular Reply

Erik EstradaBusiness Member
Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2022 · 7k+ posts · 1k+ votes
1h

San, your agent's numbers explain why he's telling you 30 to 40% down. At $410K with 25% down, the loan is about $307K. At around 7% on a 30-year, that's roughly $2,050 a month in principal and interest, and with taxes and insurance you're near $2,400 before any HOA. Against $2,200 to $2,500 in rent, it barely breaks even.

That's also how DSCR lenders look at it. They want rent to cover the full payment, ideally 1.0 to 1.25 times. If a property only works with 35% down, that's the market telling you the price is high for the rent.

Two things to check on new builds: whether the HOA restricts rentals or has a minimum lease term, and what the HOA dues add to the payment. An older house in a better school area at a lower price can easily cash flow better with less money down.

LuxePrivate Investments LLC 571 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Diana KhanPro Member
    Attorney · 10451 Mill Run Cir #755 Owings Mills, MD 21117 · Member since 2024 · 849 posts · 311 votes
    4h
    Quote from @San Le:

    Hi Team,

    I contacted an agent in Raleigh North Carolina. I shared my information and would like to buy a house for a long term rental. But I am not sure his suggestions makes sense?

    1) He suggests and provides new houses which are just built and close to Raleigh.

    2) I need to put down 30 - 40% to have cash flow (He said Raleigh does not have any deals which can match 1% rule) For example, he suggests to buy a house for $410k but monthly rental is only $2,200 to $2,500

    3) These suburbs have schools with grade is very slow 3 or 4.

    This is completely what I am thinking. I though he will find a normal house, and in a good shape. Also, it needs to close to best schools which I assume should be a good areas because school grade is over 7, 8, 9 for elementary, secondary, high school. If we find a good areas, it means it will be more easy for rental.... I am worry about his suggestions

    Also, if I buy a new house, do you think I need property management. I do not think a new house will have a low maintain and they do have warranty from build for one year.

    @San Le, I think your concerns are reasonable. A new home isn't necessarily a better rental investment than an older one. I'd compare both based on the purchase price, expected rent, expenses, and location. And yes, property management can still be helpful for a new home because someone still needs to handle tenants, rent collection, and maintenance. If your agent keeps showing you properties that don't match your goals, I'd have another conversation about exactly what you're looking for.

    In my experience working with previous clients as a real estate attorney and broker in Maryland, I've seen how important it is to look beyond the age and appearance of a property. For example, a newly built home may come with a builder warranty, but I'd still review what that warranty covers and check whether any HOA rules limit renting the property.

    I appreciate you sharing this, @San Le! Choosing the right rental property involves more than finding a nice house. Real estate transactions and rental property matters are a big part of my work, so I understand why you'd want to look at all your options. Wishing you the best with your search, and happy to stay connected!

  • Real Estate Agent · Kansas City · Member since 2018 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4h

    Honestly spending 410K for that monthly rent is not very attractive or worth it. There are plenty of good houses that aren't new and make more sense as an investment. You do inspections as anything else to verify mechanicals. Is this agent familiar with investors?

  • Erik EstradaBusiness Member
    Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2022 · 7k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1h

    San, your agent's numbers explain why he's telling you 30 to 40% down. At $410K with 25% down, the loan is about $307K. At around 7% on a 30-year, that's roughly $2,050 a month in principal and interest, and with taxes and insurance you're near $2,400 before any HOA. Against $2,200 to $2,500 in rent, it barely breaks even.

    That's also how DSCR lenders look at it. They want rent to cover the full payment, ideally 1.0 to 1.25 times. If a property only works with 35% down, that's the market telling you the price is high for the rent.

    Two things to check on new builds: whether the HOA restricts rentals or has a minimum lease term, and what the HOA dues add to the payment. An older house in a better school area at a lower price can easily cash flow better with less money down.

    LuxePrivate Investments LLC 571 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.