Rental Property Investor · NH · Member since 2023 · 450 posts · 423 votes
When we bought our first 2-family in Manchester, the tenants were paying $500 a month for a 3-bedroom. Market was around $1,400
That was 2022. The former owner had pretty much stopped paying attention.
A lot of new buyers see a gap like that and think "free upside." Here's what the data actually says: below-market rent is upside you have to go get, and getting it usually costs you something.
Here's how ours played out:
We renovated our own unit first (floors, paint, kitchen, bath)
I offered the upstairs tenants a raise that was still below market
They declined and moved out
We renovated, re-listed at $2,000 with heat and hot water included, and signed a tenant who stayed for years
So the rent went from $500 to $2,000. That's four times the income on that unit. And it cost us months of work, a vacancy, and a real chunk of renovation budget.
If you're underwriting a Manchester multifamily with in-place rents way under market, budget for the turnover. Don't assume the tenants stay and pay more.
Just be aware: those are 2022 numbers. Pull current Manchester rent comps before you use them on a deal today.
What's the biggest in-place rent gap you've ever inherited, and how did you close it?
Thanks for sharing this so honestly, Andrew — that $500 to $2,000 jump is a great example of why below-market rent is not free upside. The lesson I take from your story is to underwrite the property on the rent that is actually in place, not the rent you hope to get after a renovation and a turnover. That way, if a tenant decides to leave, the numbers still make sense while you work through the vacancy and repairs. I also like that you offered a below-market increase first and were ready for the possibility that the tenants would move on — that is a respectful approach, and it keeps the decision in their hands. For anyone looking at a similar deal, I would suggest checking the current lease terms, local notice rules, and recent rent comps first, then budgeting for turnover costs, vacancy, and the time a renovation really takes. It can still be a strong purchase, but the plan works best when the higher rent is treated as a goal, not a guarantee.
always great to hear whats going on back in the 603. I've taken a current tenant from $450 to $900 for a client over about 2 - 3 months, but the market rent was like $1100 so they were still getting a screaming deal and had been there like a decade so it worked out I think for everyone.