An Investment Property Can Look Great on Paper—Until You Read the HOA Documents

An Investment Property Can Look Great on Paper—Until You Read the HOA Documents

Rudy TaghiPro Member
Investor · Los Angeles California · Member since 2018 · 16 posts · 6 votes

As a California Realtor, Loan Officer, and real estate investor who owns properties in different markets, I've learned that HOA due diligence deserves just as much attention as the property's financial performance.

This is especially important when considering a condominium for short-term rental use.

A property might have an attractive purchase price, reasonable projected rental income, and desirable amenities. But before getting excited about the numbers, I want to understand the rules governing the property.

For example, an HOA may permit short-term rentals but still have restrictions regarding minimum stays, guest registration, parking, occupancy, or amenity access.

And then there's the financial side.

Monthly HOA dues are only part of the equation. I also pay attention to the association's reserves, insurance coverage, pending litigation, maintenance obligations, and potential special assessments.

One thing I've learned is that a property being legally eligible for short-term rentals doesn't necessarily mean operating one will be practical or profitable.

Local regulations, HOA restrictions, and actual operating expenses all need to make sense together.

I would rather discover a problem during due diligence than after closing.

For those investing in HOA communities, what's the biggest red flag you've encountered while reviewing an association's documents?

0Reply
161 views

Most Popular Reply

Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2018 · 30 posts · 8 votes
1d

Rudy, the one I watch for most is a rental rule that is allowed today but easy to change. Read the declaration for how many owner votes it takes to amend the leasing section, then read the last two or three years of board minutes. If the minutes keep coming back to guest noise, parking or pool complaints, a vote on minimum stays may already be on its way.

The minutes also show money problems before the budget does: deferred roof, elevator or balcony work, a big jump at the last insurance renewal, or a special assessment being discussed but not yet voted. I ask for the date of the last reserve study, not just the reserve balance.

Then there are rules that keep STRs legal but make them hard to run: guest registration several days before arrival, keys or fobs picked up from the office during business hours only, renters barred from the amenities, a fee per stay, or a requirement to use the building's own rental program. Any one of those can break a self check-in model or the turnover schedule.

Last, I check whether the master insurance policy has anything to say about transient rentals, and whether there is pending litigation, since that can also make financing harder.

(Drafted with AI help.)

See this reply in the discussion

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2018 · 30 posts · 8 votes
    1d

    Rudy, the one I watch for most is a rental rule that is allowed today but easy to change. Read the declaration for how many owner votes it takes to amend the leasing section, then read the last two or three years of board minutes. If the minutes keep coming back to guest noise, parking or pool complaints, a vote on minimum stays may already be on its way.

    The minutes also show money problems before the budget does: deferred roof, elevator or balcony work, a big jump at the last insurance renewal, or a special assessment being discussed but not yet voted. I ask for the date of the last reserve study, not just the reserve balance.

    Then there are rules that keep STRs legal but make them hard to run: guest registration several days before arrival, keys or fobs picked up from the office during business hours only, renters barred from the amenities, a fee per stay, or a requirement to use the building's own rental program. Any one of those can break a self check-in model or the turnover schedule.

    Last, I check whether the master insurance policy has anything to say about transient rentals, and whether there is pending litigation, since that can also make financing harder.

    (Drafted with AI help.)

  • Real Estate Broker · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2021 · 567 posts · 432 votes
    1d

    Rental cap with a waitlist is the one I check first. If the CC&Rs cap rentals at a set percent of units and you are behind other owners, you can close and still not be allowed to rent at all. Read the cap, the minimum stay, and the amendment vote threshold together, plus 12 months of minutes for a pending change. Tradeoff is a condo can look STR legal today and be blocked on day one by the cap, so I underwrite to owner use or long-term rent as the fallback. I am a broker in Sacramento and manage 100 plus Airbnb properties. Was there a cap in the docs you read? Hope this helps.

    • Rudy TaghiPro Member
      OP
      Investor · Los Angeles California · Member since 2018 · 16 posts · 6 votes
      3h

      Love this, thank you! That's exactly what I ran into with a townhouse community here in Palmdale, CA, while working with an investor client looking for a long-term rental.

      After digging into the CC&Rs, I went a step further and spoke directly with the HOA's governing representatives. I discovered that the community had been at its rental cap for years, with a waitlist already in place!

      So, although long-term rentals were technically permitted, the likelihood of my client actually being able to rent the property anytime soon was extremely low. We ultimately had to walk away from that opportunity.

      I can see both sides. For homeowners who prefer a predominantly owner-occupied community, rental restrictions may be appealing. But from an investor's perspective, they can be a dealbreaker.

      And here's what concerns me even more: What happens when someone buys a property as their primary residence but eventually needs to relocate and convert it into a rental?

      That's why I'm extremely cautious with HOA properties, even when my clients aren't initially purchasing them as investments. Future flexibility matters!

  • Andrew SteffensBusiness Member
    Tampa, FL · Member since 2022 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12h

    I avoid HOA's at all cost.

    • Rudy TaghiPro Member
      OP
      Investor · Los Angeles California · Member since 2018 · 16 posts · 6 votes
      4h

      lol Me too, for my own portfolio. But my clients ...

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.