How are you closing BRRRR deals in Florida right now?

How are you closing BRRRR deals in Florida right now?

Lender · Boynton Beach, FL · Member since 2026 · 266 posts · 130 votes

I fund small deals in Boynton Beach and Delray. Single family and small triplexes. Seven projects in the last three years, mostly rehab and hold. I will be honest, most deals I review die for the same three reasons. The phone number is dead. The owner moved two years ago and the skip trace is still showing the old number.

The rent is asking rent, not leased rent. You underwrite $2,500, the appraisal comes back at $2,100, and the deal is dead. And the one I see the most, the lender denies it not because the deal is bad, but because you have too many loans on other houses. They count your loans instead of looking at the income of this house. So for the guys doing BRRRR in Florida right now, especially Palm Beach and Broward, I want to ask.

What is stopping your next deal? Is it finding the deal, verifying the rent, or getting the loan to close? If you have one right now, drop it in the comments. Purchase price, rehab, what you think ARV is, and what real rent is on that street, not Zillow rent.

I will run DSCR for you if you want. I underwrite off the rent of the property, not how many loans you have on other properties. 70 to 80 percent LTV on refi, 25 percent down on purchase for strong credit.

I just want to know what is actually working now, not in 2021. What is your bottleneck right now?

4Reply
467 views

Most Popular Reply

Noah WrightBusiness Member
Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 641 posts · 185 votes
17h

The refi is where most Florida BRRRRs break, and it's usually the rent and the clock together. Run the deal at the rent the appraiser is likely to land on, not the one you hoped for. If $2,500 works and $2,100 doesn't, there was never a cushion. Then price the wait. Hard money interest, insurance and taxes keep running through seasoning, commonly 3 to 6 months before a lender uses the new appraised value, and that carry comes straight out of your cash-out. A signed lease at the rent you underwrote, in place before the appraisal, gives the refi something real to size off. A deal that only works if everything goes right isn't a BRRRR, it's a bet.

See this reply in the discussion

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 206 posts · 46 votes
    18h

    @Muyees Ayilara, good day. I am on the builder's side, working in Europe and getting ready for Florida, so I will not pose as a BRRRR investor 🙂

    One thing from our side that helps on the refi: hand the appraiser a list of every item of work done, each with a before and after photo. A new drain line or new wiring behind the walls is invisible on a walk-through, and a list like that gives the appraiser something to point to.

    In Palm Beach and Broward, do appraisers take a list like that into account, or do they go only by comps?

    • Lender · Boynton Beach, FL · Member since 2026 · 266 posts · 130 votes
      18h

      @Vladimirs Veiss good point, and you are right to do that. In Palm Beach and Broward, appraisers still go by comps first. That is the rule. Your list does not replace comps. But where your list helps a lot is on condition. If you hand them before and after photos plus a scope of work, new drain line, new wiring, new roof, new HVAC, they can justify a condition adjustment. Without that list, they walk through and see a nice kitchen and they just call it updated. With your list, they can document why your house is C2 and not C4, and that can move value.

      I tell my borrowers the same thing. Bring the list, bring invoices, bring photos. It will not make a $400k comp become $500k, but it can help you get the top of the comp range instead of the middle. Are you building new construction in Florida or doing full rehabs? Curious what you are bringing over from Europe, because new construction appraisals are a different fight than rehabs.

    • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 206 posts · 46 votes
      17h

      @Muyees Ayilara, thank you - that is a clear way to use the list.

      In Switzerland we renovate old homes, and a big building boom is starting there now, so it is worth a look for investors too 🙂

      We are bringing our experience and our product from Europe to America. The goal is simple: millions of happy people at home.

      One day we will sit on a warm island with a glass of whisky and remember how we talked about this at the very start 🥃

      On your borrowers' rehabs, which items move an appraiser from C4 to C2 most often: kitchens and baths, or the systems behind the walls?

    • Lender · Boynton Beach, FL · Member since 2026 · 266 posts · 130 votes
      15h

      @Vladimirs Veiss systems move it most. Roof, HVAC, electrical, plumbing, windows. That is what takes it from C4 to C2. Kitchens and baths help you get top value, but they do not change the rating alone if the roof and systems are old. Document both, but lead with the systems.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 641 posts · 185 votes
    17h

    The refi is where most Florida BRRRRs break, and it's usually the rent and the clock together. Run the deal at the rent the appraiser is likely to land on, not the one you hoped for. If $2,500 works and $2,100 doesn't, there was never a cushion. Then price the wait. Hard money interest, insurance and taxes keep running through seasoning, commonly 3 to 6 months before a lender uses the new appraised value, and that carry comes straight out of your cash-out. A signed lease at the rent you underwrote, in place before the appraisal, gives the refi something real to size off. A deal that only works if everything goes right isn't a BRRRR, it's a bet.

    • Lender · Boynton Beach, FL · Member since 2026 · 266 posts · 130 votes
      15h

      @Noah Wright agree. It is rent and the clock. If $2,500 works and $2,100 does not, there was no cushion. That is why I want a signed lease at the underwritten rent before appraisal. It gives everyone something real to size off.

  • Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2025 · 128 posts · 34 votes
    14h

    From the investor side, the bottleneck for me has usually been the refi, not finding the deal. I buy and hold — 17+ units across 5 deals — and the deals that worked best were the ones where I lined up the takeout lender before I bought. I ask for their seasoning rule in writing, whether they cap the loan at cost basis or appraised value, and what they need to see on rent.

    On verifying rent, I underwrite the rent I can actually prove: signed leases and deposits in the bank, not a rent roll or a listing price. A signed lease at the underwritten rent before the appraisal helps everyone size the deal off something real.

    I also plan on some capital staying in the deal. If it only works with a full cash-out, I pass. Happy to compare notes — feel free to connect.

    • Lender · Boynton Beach, FL · Member since 2026 · 266 posts · 130 votes
      8h

      @Inder Singh spot on. Lining up the takeout lender before you buy is the move. That seasoning rule and whether they cap at cost changes the whole deal. I do the same on my side, I want to see the signed lease and deposit, not a rent roll. Happy to compare notes, send me a connect.

  • Member since 2020 · 7 posts · 3 votes
    12h

    hey Muyees, the asking rent vs leased rent thing is a great point. never thought about the appraisal coming in lower like that. thanks for sharing

    • Lender · Boynton Beach, FL · Member since 2026 · 266 posts · 130 votes
      8h

      @Cameron Weston appreciate it. Yeah, that asking vs leased rent gap kills a lot of deals here in Florida. What market are you looking in?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.