Rental Property Investor · Oxford, MS · Member since 2019 · 25 posts · 9 votes
I've been looking at smaller rental packages lately instead of buying one house at a time. The cash flow can look good, but getting several properties with deferred maintenance at once is a concern. For those who've bought rental packages, did you negotiate a better price buying them together?
Nathan, packages with deferred maintenance are where you usually have the most room to negotiate. Get your own contractor through every unit before you talk price, then go back with a repair number per door instead of just saying it needs work. Sellers moving a whole package are often tired landlords, so terms can matter as much as price: a seller credit, a repair holdback, or the seller carrying part of it.
On the financing side, a package like that can usually go on one blanket loan based on the rents instead of separate loans per house, and sometimes the repair budget can be built in. Worth knowing before you make the offer so your numbers line up with what a lender will actually do.
Happy to walk through how I'd structure one, give me a call (my number's in my signature below).
Nathan, buying as a package usually does get you a better price, mostly because the seller gets one buyer and one closing instead of picking off houses one at a time. A few things from the lending side that are worth building into the offer:
Allocate the price house by house. Even on one blanket loan, the lender will value each property on its own (separate appraisals or BPOs), so one rough house can pull the whole loan amount down. If your offer already assigns a price to each address, you'll see where the deal really is.
Negotiate release terms up front. With a blanket loan, ask for release prices (commonly around 110-125% of the loan amount allocated to that house) so you can sell or refinance one property later without paying off the whole loan.
Deferred maintenance gets counted twice: once in the appraisal's condition rating and again in any repairs the lender requires. Some lenders won't fund a unit with safety or habitability issues until it's fixed, so find those houses before you set your price.
Check the actual leases and rent deposits, not just the rent roll. Packages often include below-market tenants or a couple of non-payers, and the lender will size the loan on the real rents.
Don't be afraid to drop the worst one or two houses. Plenty of sellers will still take an offer on the rest of the package.
Yes often with packages you can negotiate more. If there is deferred maintenance I would tally them up to help with negotiations. You can average the rehab per house to help justify the lower offer. For example if there is 100K needed across 5 houses that'd be 20K per house.
Yes, but the discount usually comes from the repairs, not from the bundle itself. Walk every door and price the package off your repair number, and if there's one house that's a real dog, ask them to pull it out or knock it way down rather than letting the good ones hide it. If you finance it on one blanket loan, I'd make sure there's a partial release clause so you can sell or refi a single house later without redoing the whole thing. Lender here, fwiw, and that clause is the part people forget to ask about untill it's too late.
Adding to the per-door repair point: once you have a price and a repair number for each address, it's worth running the same handful of numbers on every house on its own, then on the package. "The cash flow looks good" is usually the blended number, and the blend is exactly where one weak house hides.
Made-up round numbers, just to show the shape. Four houses, each allocated $100k:
- Houses A, B and C: rent $1,200/mo, about $500/mo for taxes, insurance, vacancy, repairs, capex and management. That's $700/mo, $8,400 a year, about 8.4% on $100k.
- House D: needs $25k of work, rent $900/mo, about $450/mo of costs. That's $450/mo, $5,400 a year, about 4.3% on $125k all-in.
- Package: $30,600 a year on $425k, about 7.2%. Looks fine on its own. Without D it's 8.4%.
So the five I'd run per door, then for the package:
1. Net operating income after a real vacancy and repair allowance, not just rent minus taxes and insurance
2. Cap rate on allocated price plus that house's repairs
3. Cash flow after the debt payment the lender will actually give you
4. Cash-on-cash return on what you put in, repairs included
5. Debt coverage, since a blanket loan sized on total rents can still be thin on one house
If one door is well below the others on most of those, that's your number to negotiate with, or the house to ask them to pull.
When you've looked at packages so far, have the sellers given you rents and expenses by address, or only as one total?
- Appraisers value each house on its own, so a package discount usually shows up as instant equity, not a lower appraisal. That helps your loan-to-value. - Ask for a blanket loan with release prices, so you can sell or refinance one house at a time without paying off the whole loan. - With deferred maintenance, a short-term bridge loan that funds the repairs, followed by a long-term rental loan once the houses are rented at market, often leaves less of your cash in the deal than buying all of them with long-term money on day one. - Check minimums. Many long-term lenders won't go below $75K to $100K per property, so the cheapest houses in a package can be the hardest to finance.
I know a good ground that does these kind of deals if you'd like a connection.
I'd be careful about evaluating a package based on the combined cash flow alone. I'd want to see the numbers for every property individually, including maintenance history, deferred repairs, leases and realistic capital improvements. One problem property can eat up a lot of the return from the others.
I'd also look at zoning, permits and any restrictions that might affect your plans for each property. Buying several at once doesn't necessarily mean they carry the same risks.
Has the seller provided property-level financials and maintenance records?
Quick take from the insurance side: get quotes on every address before you set your price. Old roofs, outdated electrical or active leaks can make a house hard to insure or require repairs first, which is one more reason to pull the worst house out. Ask about one landlord policy that schedules all the houses, so limits and renewals stay in one place.
@Nathan Shelby Packages can get you a better price, but only if you price them door by door. I'd walk every unit with a contractor, build a rehab number and a leased rent comp for each house, and add a turnover allowance, since deferred maintenance often comes with below-market rents and tenants you inherit. Ask for current leases, rent ledgers and security deposit records for every unit, and tenant estoppels if you can get them. Then decide which houses you'd buy on their own; if one or two drag the package, price those at a discount or carve them out. And check that the package hits your DSCR at today's rates on current rents, not post-rehab rents. How many doors are in the one you're looking at?