Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 214 posts · 77 votes
Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the 30-year fixed at 7.28% on Nov 19, up from 7.11% a week earlier. The Fed's October minutes, released Nov 18, said almost all participants judged further rate hikes likely appropriate. If you're lining up a BRRRR for next year, that's a reason to stress-test the refinance, not just the purchase.
How I'd set up the refi side before making an offer:
Price the refi at a real quote, not the headline rate. Investment-property and DSCR cash-out loans usually price above the Freddie Mac average, so get a lender quote and add a cushion.
Haircut the ARV. Use renovated sold comps from the last six months in the same pocket, not the best flip on the street, and assume 70-75% loan-to-value on that number.
Run DSCR at the refi rate using rent you can document with leased comps, not asking rents.
Have a "stuck" plan. If the refi only returns part of your cash, does the property still cash flow at that loan amount? If not, the deal depends on rates falling.
Budget the seasoning period. Several months of holding costs on a hard money or private loan add up fast.
A BRRRR that only works if rates drop is a bet, not a plan.
What refi rate and LTV are you underwriting for 2027 deals, and are appraisals keeping up with your ARVs?
Good way to put it. I underwrite the refi at the rate I can get quoted today, not a rate I hope shows up later. If the numbers only work after a cut, I treat it as a bet and I pass. The other thing I check now is the comps before I offer. I am watching a deal right now where the refi is stuck because there are no close comps, and that taught me the appraisal can hold up a deal even when the rent math works. I also ask myself if I can hold the property and still be fine if the refi only returns part of my cash. Every month that cash sits in a deal that cannot refi is a month it cannot do the next deal. If I cannot hold it, I do not make the offer. Still learning, but that check has kept me out of trouble.
BJ — solid framework, and the lender-side version of your point is that the refi fails on the ratio more often than on the value.
DSCR is rent divided by PITIA, and the loan amount is driven by the rent, not by the ARV. A haircut ARV protects you on leverage, but if the documented rent doesn't support the payment at the refi terms, the loan still shrinks — usually right when you're out of bridge runway. The two numbers that move the ratio most are the ones people estimate loosest: the documented rent (the lender uses the lower of the lease or the appraiser's market rent, not asking rents) and the insurance line inside PITIA. On a file I'm working now, a rural single-family rental, the value held up fine — what moved the deal was the documented rent and a higher insurance quote pushing PITIA up. The appraisal wasn't the problem; the ratio was.
A few things I'd add to your checklist:
- Get the takeout terms in writing before the bridge closes — not just a quote, but the seasoning clock (some lenders count from the deed date, some from the purchase), whether cash-out is capped at cost basis in the early months, and the prepay terms. A refi that works on paper but can't close for six months is a different deal than the one you underwrote.
- Stress the payment, not the rate. Take the written quote, then run the DSCR with the PITIA a step higher — an illustrative $150 a month higher on taxes and insurance, for example — and see whether the deal still works. If it only works at the exact quote, you're underwriting to a hope.
- On your question about appraisals and ARVs: in my experience the value usually comes in within a reasonable range of renovated comps — the surprises are condition (a low condition rating can stop the loan before the math starts) and the rent the appraiser documents. Price the repair list before the appraisal fee, not after.
Your "stuck" plan is the right instinct. The test I'd use is whether the property still cash flows at the loan amount the refi actually returns, not the one in the pro forma. If it does, the rate path is upside; if it doesn't, the deal is a bet on rates, and I'd want to know that before the offer goes in.
Good way to put it. I underwrite the refi at the rate I can get quoted today, not a rate I hope shows up later. If the numbers only work after a cut, I treat it as a bet and I pass. The other thing I check now is the comps before I offer. I am watching a deal right now where the refi is stuck because there are no close comps, and that taught me the appraisal can hold up a deal even when the rent math works. I also ask myself if I can hold the property and still be fine if the refi only returns part of my cash. Every month that cash sits in a deal that cannot refi is a month it cannot do the next deal. If I cannot hold it, I do not make the offer. Still learning, but that check has kept me out of trouble.
Underwrite at today's rate or don't underwrite it — a refi that only works after a rate cut isn't a plan, it's a lottery ticket.
One thing I'd add to your "stuck" plan: line up the takeout before the bridge closes, not after. Most DSCR lenders make you sit through a 6-month seasoning clock before they'll refinance you, which is a long time to be stuck. There are no-seasoning DSCR options out there — refi as soon as the rent history supports it, month one instead of month seven. That changes the whole math on your holding costs.
And if the refi still doesn't pencil at today's rate, an investor HELOC in second position on the property — no appraisal — can keep you from having to sell into a bad market while you wait.
Good framework overall. The investors who get hurt on BRRRRs aren't the ones who underwrite conservatively — they're the ones who underwrite the exit on hope.