Duplex with seller financing, Cash flowed for 3 Years, Got all our money back

Duplex with seller financing, Cash flowed for 3 Years, Got all our money back

Amber StoutPro Member
Lender · Tampa/Saint Petersburg, FL · Member since 2014 · 395 posts · 163 votes

3 years ago, we purchased a duplex in Florida using seller financing.

Here's the breakdown:

  • Purchase price: $260K

  • Seller financing: 6% interest, 10% down, 3 year balloon

  • Total cash wired at closing: $17,438

  • Rental income: $3,100/month

  • Mortgage payment: $1,400 + taxes/insurance

  • Bonus: Property sits on a double lot in an improving area!

Fast forward 3 years...

We just finished up refinancing the property and paying the balloon payment. The duplex appraised for $338K, at 75% LTV: Cash back to us at closing: $21,517

So not only did we collect rental cash flow over the last 3 years, but we also recovered our original cash investment (plus an additional $4K)

My biggest takeaways: seller financing is the bomb.com, especially when you have a clear exit strategy. Negotiating the terms is great and sometimes the financing structure is what makes the deal work!

I'm an active investor and mortgage broker, so I get to see both sides of these transactions. I love helping other investors think through creative acquisition strategies and refinance options.


Curious — has anyone else been using seller financing lately? What terms are you seeing sellers agree to?

3Reply
420 views

9 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Brian AsaroPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · San Diego, CA · Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 18 votes
    3d

    Hi Amber,

    How did you find the deal?

    • Amber StoutPro Member
      OP
      Lender · Tampa/Saint Petersburg, FL · Member since 2014 · 395 posts · 163 votes
      3d

      Hi Brian, he was someone in our network that was looking to list the property on market and we had interest in buying it. He was not offering seller finance so we pitched him on the benefits to him, gave him 3 options to choose from (0% down, 10%, 15%) and closed the deal. Are you actively looking for seller finance deals?

  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 259 posts · 97 votes
    3d

    Thanks for sharing this, Amber. The part that stands out to me is that he was not offering seller financing and you pitched it to him. I am still learning, but in my own looking I have found the conversation goes better when I listen for what the seller actually needs first and then see if a structure can fit that. Having a clear exit before the balloon is due is the piece I keep coming back to. Appreciate you laying out how it played out over the three years.

    • Amber StoutPro Member
      OP
      Lender · Tampa/Saint Petersburg, FL · Member since 2014 · 395 posts · 163 votes
      3d

      Thanks, Chris! We did listen to the seller and actually he had shared that he was planning on using the cash to buy a house for his daughter. We actually didn't think he would even be open to the seller financing because of that, however he really liked the numbers once we laid out the options and decided he could make it work with the 10% down option so it was definitely a win/win.

      I wasn't in the mortgage space when I had bought the property and I did NOT have a clear exit initially so that's one thing I would make sure to be clear of when buying deals and structuring the seller finance/balloon payment. It ended up working out just fine, thank goodness, but that could be a challenge if not structured properly upfront. Have you closed on any seller finance deals before?

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 646 posts · 185 votes
    3d

    It's showing up more, and the ones that work look like yours, with the exit planned before the seller ever signs. The 6% mattered less than the 3 year balloon, since the balloon is the day the property has to be worth enough to refinance. Your $338K appraisal made the 75% LTV payoff easy. The same balloon against a flat appraisal near the $260K price would have been a cash call. That's why the terms worth pushing a seller on are usually an extension option on the balloon and the right to prepay with no penalty, more than a lower rate. Most refinance lenders will also want proof every payment to the seller went out on time, so paying through a servicer or by traceable transfer saves a headache at payoff.

  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 259 posts · 97 votes
    2d

    Thanks, Amber. Not yet. I have not closed a seller finance deal. What I am doing is talking with sellers and listening for what they actually need, and your story is a good reminder to me to think about the exit before anything else. I am still learning, and that part stuck with me.

  • Jim BlackburnBusiness Member
    Lender · Florida Based (48 states Puerto Rico) · Member since 2017 · 344 posts · 130 votes
    2d

    Great outcome, Amber, and a good example of the exit being planned on day one.

    For anyone copying this, the part that decides whether the balloon refi goes smoothly is what's written into the seller note at the start:

    1. An extension option. Even a one-time 6 to 12 month extension, priced in advance, takes the pressure off if values, insurance or lending guidelines move against you right before the balloon.

    2. No prepayment penalty, so you can refi early if the numbers line up.

    3. A clean payment history. The refi lender will usually want proof of every payment to the seller, ideally 12 months of bank-drafted payments, plus a payoff letter. Payments in cash or by money order can hold up the file.

    4. How the refi will be classified. If you're taking cash out, check the lender's seasoning rules up front, since some programs look at how long you've owned the property, not just the appraisal.

    On the Florida side, I'd add getting an insurance quote before the balloon year too. A big jump in premium can change the DSCR or DTI on the refi even when the appraisal comes in strong.

    When you negotiated the 3-year balloon, did you ask the seller for an extension clause, or did the timeline just work out?

    — Jim Blackburn, NMLS #1072866

    Stairway Mortgage, a Division of NEXA Mortgage LLC598 Reviews
  • Aaron RamPro Member
    Investor · Stamford, CT · Member since 2011 · 59 posts · 20 votes
    5h

    Hi @Amber Stout , Congratulations on a great deal! Essentially nothing in at the balloon while collecting those years. Great example of how seller financing can work really well.

    This is some of the terms on my 2nd seller financed deal closed back in July. Definetly quite a few moving parts but happy it got to the finish line.

    • Property Type: 9-Unit Mixed-Use (7 Residential Apartments + 2 Commercial Units)

    • Location: Shelton, CT

    • Purchase Price: $1,750,000

    • Seller Financing: Interest-only loan with a 7-year balloon payment; 7.0% interest for the first 3 years, increasing to 7.5% for the remaining 4 years.

    • Down Payment: $500,000

      • $452,817 funded through a 1031 Exchange from the sale of two single-family investment properties.

      • $47,183 in additional out-of-pocket funds.

    • Current Rental Income: $13,375/month

    • Monthly Note Payment: $7,291

    • Monthly Operating Expenses: $4,738 (including vacancy and property management)

    • Projected Stabilized Rental Income: $20,150/month (within 6-8 months)

    • Additional Negotiated Terms: Non-recourse financing with no prepayment penalty.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.