Hotel revenue manager, now pricing short-term rentals

Hotel revenue manager, now pricing short-term rentals

Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 0 votes

Hi everyone, I’m Marvin, based in Dallas.

My background is hotel revenue management. I’m Hilton-trained and have priced a portfolio of 1,500+ rooms, so most of my career has come down to one question: what should tonight cost, and what should a Saturday three months out cost?

Earlier this year I started Yieldwright, a revenue management service for short-term rentals. Right now I price short-term rentals in Oklahoma, Texas, and Colorado, all run through PriceLabs. I only do pricing, no cleaning or guest management.

One thing I’ve noticed so far is that many owners install a dynamic pricing tool and figure pricing is handled. Those tools aim to copy what big hotels do, but a tool is only as good as its settings. It has to be tuned to your exact property in your exact market, and then managed as demand shifts. It isn’t a set-and-forget setup. That’s the same reason hotels with the best pricing software still employ revenue managers.

I’m here mostly to learn from other investors and to answer pricing questions where I can. If you own a short-term rental, what’s the hardest pricing decision you make each month?

0Reply
284 views

Most Popular Reply

Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2018 · 35 posts · 12 votes
1d

Welcome, Marvin. For me the hardest call each month is how far to drop an open weekend that's 10 to 14 days out. Hold the rate and it may sit empty. Cut it too often and repeat guests learn to wait for the discount.

Close behind that: orphan nights between bookings. A one-night Tuesday gap rarely books at full price, so I'd rather relax the minimum stay for that gap than discount the whole week.

Curious how you handle minimum-stay rules versus rate cuts when you're tuning PriceLabs. The rate side usually gets attention, but I see a lot of listings still running default min-stay settings that block those short gap bookings.

(Drafted with AI help.)

See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Andrew SteffensBusiness Member
    Tampa, FL · Member since 2022 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1d

    Welcome, and good luck!

  • Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2018 · 35 posts · 12 votes
    1d

    Welcome, Marvin. For me the hardest call each month is how far to drop an open weekend that's 10 to 14 days out. Hold the rate and it may sit empty. Cut it too often and repeat guests learn to wait for the discount.

    Close behind that: orphan nights between bookings. A one-night Tuesday gap rarely books at full price, so I'd rather relax the minimum stay for that gap than discount the whole week.

    Curious how you handle minimum-stay rules versus rate cuts when you're tuning PriceLabs. The rate side usually gets attention, but I see a lot of listings still running default min-stay settings that block those short gap bookings.

    (Drafted with AI help.)

    • Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 0 votes
      1d

      Thanks, Kent Morgan. Taking these one at a time, with the caveat that every answer shifts by market.

      The open weekend at 10 to 14 days out: how far I drop depends on how late that market books. If most bookings land inside a week, that weekend isn’t late yet and I hold. If the market books well ahead, it’s already late and I move sooner. Either way I step down in small moves to a set floor, not one big cut. That’s what keeps repeat guests from learning to wait.

      Orphan nights: I’m with you. I’d rather let the minimum drop for the stranded nights only than discount the whole week. I set the gap rule so it only applies to nights that can’t fit a normal stay, add a small discount if they still sit, and leave everything around them alone. The exception is where the cleaning cost eats most of a one-night stay. There it can be better to leave the night empty.

      Minimum stay versus rate cuts: which one I change first depends on the market, and that’s why default settings cause trouble. They’re the same everywhere. In short-trip markets I shorten the minimum before I touch the rate. In others, shortening it isn’t the answer, and I’ve had more success raising the minimum and then bringing the rate down, so the dates sell as one longer stay.

      If you ever want to talk through a specific weekend or gap on your listing, shoot me a message. Happy to take a look.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 316 posts · 162 votes
    1d

    Welcome, Marvin. I learned a bit from our revenue managers back when I worked in hotels, but doing it daily is way more nuanced than what I picked up when it wasn't my job. Pricing is now what takes the most of my time each month, more than guest messaging, so it's a good question.

    Most of my units run as a mid-term/short-term hybrid, so my hardest call usually comes at the end of a 30+ day stay. I keep a window open after each mid-term booking so the guest can extend. I handle that with minimum stays in PriceLabs instead of holding dates. Dates far out carry a long minimum. As checkout gets closer, I step it down (to 14 days, then lower) and use Orphan Days to fill what's left between bookings. Timing is the hard part. Drop the minimum too early and a 3-night stay blocks a 30-day extension. Drop it too late and the dates sit empty.

    On @Kent Morgan's open-weekend question: before I cut a rate, I check the market's booking window in PriceLabs Market Dashboards. If most guests in that market book 3-7 days out, a weekend that's 10-14 days out isn't late yet. I hold the rate and watch pacing before I make a big change. I also review pricing every week, because the settings drift as demand shifts, which is your set-and-forget point.

    Coming from hotels, how do you approach length-of-stay pricing? Do you price a 30-night stay as a discount off nightly, or build it up from what the unit would rent for long-term?

    • Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 0 votes
      1d

      Thanks, John. Stepping the minimum down as checkout approaches is the right move. How early to start depends on how late your market books. One thing that helps the timing: ask the guest about extending two to three weeks before checkout, so the step-down follows their answer and not a guess.

      On your question, it depends on the market and the month, so I use both numbers. The long-term rent is the floor. What I price against is what those same 30 nights would likely earn as short stays in that market, which hotels call displacement.

      Example: a slow month where I’d expect 50% occupancy at $150 is about $2,250, before the extra cleans. A $2,400 monthly stay beats that, even though it’s nearly half off the nightly rate. In a peak month at 80% and $220, the same nights are worth about $5,280, so that monthly rate loses badly.

      So the discount off nightly isn’t fixed. It’s whatever clears the displaced revenue for those dates in that market.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 316 posts · 162 votes
    23h

    @Marvin Braxton that's the same framework I use. Long-term rent is the floor, what the unit could gross as short stays is the ceiling, and the monthly rate lands in between. Your slow-month vs. peak-month example shows exactly why a flat monthly discount leaves money on the table.

    One thing I add to the displacement math: on a 30+ day stay I'm also covering utilities (with a cap) and a mid-stay clean every 30 days, so those go into the monthly number before I compare it to short stays.

    On the extension, I keep communication going throughout the stay, so it usually comes up in that 2-3 week window anyway. That lets the step-down follow what the guest tells me.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.