Rental Property Investor · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2018 · 15 posts · 2 votes
We have traditionally managed properties both Short Term and longer. Actually Medium term, and some long term. Software tools to manage those together are a pain. And I've had properties transition from Short, to Medium to Long...and have manage the one property like three on different packages.
What experiences have you had?
Steve
3 votes total
Do you manage more than one category, short, medium and long?
Do you use more than one software package to do that?
I started out doing mid term and filling in the gaps with short term and I am still doing that. I use Airbnb for short term and different platforms for mid term advertising (sabbatical homes) and rent collection ( apartments.com).
Steve, the switching is the part that hurts. When a unit goes from nightly to 30+ day stays, almost everything changes: house rules become a lease, utilities and cleaning move to a different schedule, rent collection works differently, and in many places lodging tax stops applying past 30 days (worth checking for your city and state).
What keeps it manageable is treating the property as one record and the rental type as a mode it is in. One owner statement, one maintenance log, one master calendar that every channel syncs to, and a separate set of templates for each mode: nightly house rules and guest messages, a mid-term lease and move-in checklist, a full lease for long-term.
On software, I would choose the tool that handles the calendar and owner accounting well for the most units, and accept a second tool for leases and rent collection on the long-term side rather than forcing one package to do everything. Carolyn's setup of Airbnb plus a separate platform for mid-term ads and rent collection is pretty common.
When a unit changes mode, a short handoff checklist helps: close the nightly calendar so nothing double-books, confirm the insurance policy and any permit fit the new use, swap the listings, and note the change on the owner statement so the numbers stay comparable.
Steve, I run most of my units as a mid-term/short-term hybrid, so the switching you're describing is built into how I operate. The calendar is set for 30+ day stays with 30-60 day minimums, and short stays only fill gaps of a few days up to two weeks.
I keep it to one stack: Jurny as the PMS, PriceLabs for pricing and minimum stays, and Turno for cleanings, with every channel on one unified calendar. It runs under $70 a month per property. PriceLabs handles the mode change. Dates far out after a mid-term booking carry a long minimum. As checkout gets closer, the minimum drops, so the gap can fill with short stays or the guest can extend. The unit never has to "move" between systems.
To your poll: two categories, short and mid-term, on one stack. I'd agree with Kent that long-term is where a second tool makes sense.
All good ways to handle it. We used to use Lodgix, Airbnb, Pricelabs, Turno, - and suffered the mode change. Throw in a couple of extra sites like travel nurse housing and there's at least 5 tools. After 25 years we've moved onto a different sort of real estate investment business in luxury development. As luck would have it, just as we exited I ran across another tool that looks like it's about to launch. One of the owners I used to do some management for and who bought some of my properties brought it up. Supposed to handle all types in modern single app. It's at trynexxus.com if you are of a mind to get a look.
I am primarily Short Term Rental - but we price all of our properties utilizing weekly and month price discounts to encourage longer stays. Obviously 7 bedroom waterfront homes will never come close to mid term rental stats, but our more affordable 1,2 and even some 3 bedroom units are pushing month long stay averages due to pricing strategies. We do not do anything differently operationally besides proper pricing adjustments. No new systems needed.
Stephen, you’ve highlighted a real challenge in property management. When a property moves between short, medium, and long-term rentals, managing it across different software platforms can create unnecessary complexity.
One practical approach is maintaining a single property record, consistent expense tracking, and centralized owner reporting, while using specialized tools for booking and lease requirements.
Disclosure: I work on CalmMonth, a new property management software platform in early access. We're focused on simplifying leases, rent collection, expenses, and owner payouts for US property managers.
Your experience is particularly interesting because it highlights how fragmented these workflows can become.
I'm curious: is your biggest frustration switching between different software platforms, keeping financial records consistent, or managing the transition between rental types?
yes we run short, medium and long term across close to 60 properties in several countries and the switching you describe is the painful bit... one flat goes from airbnb to a 3 month corporate let to a 12 month tenancy and suddenly it lives in three systems. what fixed it for us was keeping every property on one record whatever the let type. we built Hello Hosty partly for this, the short term bookings come in through the channel manager and the long term lets sit right next to them with payment schedules, rent payment reminders, expense reports and owner statements. when a place flips you change how its let, not where it lives, so the history and statements all remain in one place. if you're testing software I'd ask one question, can a single property run short and long term without being duplicated? if not you end up reconciling by hand every month end.