Airbnb Says My Listing Is a Duplicate — But I Just Bought the House. Has Anyone Ac

Airbnb Says My Listing Is a Duplicate — But I Just Bought the House. Has Anyone Ac

Rental Property Investor · Groveland, CA · Member since 2020 · 25 posts · 2 votes

I bought a vacation rental home on June 30, 2026, near Yosemite for about $550K, with a plan to renovate it into a 5-bedroom sleeping 13-15 and run it as a short-term rental. My year-one target is around $100K gross. My other cabin nearby is a Superhost listing with a 5.0 rating, so I'm not new to this.

Here's where it went sideways. The seller's old Airbnb listing for the same house stayed live after the sale, under a property manager I hired to keep the existing bookings going. The problems that got the old listing flagged — 1-star reviews, cleanliness complaints, unresponsive host — all happened under that manager, after I bought the house. I then created my own listing with completely new photos, a new title and description. Two weeks later, Airbnb flagged mine as a duplicate of the old listing and scheduled it for removal on December 28, with an appeal deadline of December 6.

I ended up deleting my own listing. The old listing is now pending removal on December 2. My plan is to renovate, then repost with new photos — but only after the old listing is confirmed gone, and after sending Airbnb an ownership-change notice first.

What I have in hand: closing documents proving the June 30 purchase, a county transient occupancy tax certificate, a county fire and life safety inspection application (inspection November 30), and a clean Superhost account. I'm also trying to get a written statement from the former manager confirming he no longer manages the property and the old listing is gone — though I'm not sure he'll cooperate.

My questions for anyone who's been through this:

  1. Has anyone actually gotten a duplicate flag reversed? What worked — the standard appeal, or did you have to escalate?

  2. Did a letter to Airbnb's executive offices help anyone?

  3. Does the old listing being fully removed clear the flag on the address, or does the flag stick to the property?

  4. What evidence mattered most in your case?

  5. What should I avoid doing before I repost?

The honest stakes: Airbnb is the engine of this property's revenue plan. Vrbo, Booking.com, and direct bookings exist as fallbacks, but if Airbnb won't host this house, the numbers get very hard and selling becomes a real conversation. I'd rather fight this properly now than find out at launch.

0Reply
274 views

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 316 posts · 162 votes
    1d
  • Real Estate Broker · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2021 · 573 posts · 433 votes
    1d

    Yes duplicates tied to the address do get reversed but removal alone doesn't always clear it. What matters most is deed plus closing docs, TOT cert in ur name and a termination letter from the old managger sent before u repost. Don't reuse old photos or copy even if new photos look similar. tradeoff is waiting until Dec 2 removal is confirmed vs reposting early and triggering it again. We manage 100 plus Airbnbs out of Sacramento and see this with ownership changes. Have u opened a Superhost support case yet with the deed attached?

  • Lender · Peoria, AZ · Member since 2026 · 91 posts · 20 votes
    1d

    Hey Ronak,

    What a frustrating spot, especially when the bad reviews weren't even on your watch. I don't have an Airbnb fix for you, but here's one financing thing to keep in mind as you plan the relaunch. If you ever want to refinance this one after the renovation, a lot of DSCR lenders want actual booking history on a short-term rental refi, and some won't use projections like AirDNA on a refi at all. So clean records under your own name, on whatever platform you land on, can really help down the road.

    I'm a mortgage broker licensed in Arizona, California, Colorado, Kansas, Texas, and Arkansas, and I like helping investors. Happy to be a resource. No pressure at all!

    Hope the appeal goes your way. Good luck with the relaunch!

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 316 posts · 162 votes
    1d

    @Ronak Shah I had a co-host client who had the exact same issue. It was a nightmare, unfortunately. I used my Superhost phone line to Airbnb to help get it worked out, and it took 2 different 3-way calls with them to finally get it switched over. He was fortunate: they required no documentation, but they did see the old listing owner had not been active, and my Superhost status really helped.

    Since you're already a Superhost on your other cabin, I'd use that same phone line rather than the standard appeal, and have your deed and closing docs ready in case they ask.

  • John UnderwoodPro Member
    Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2014 · 13k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    22h

    As someone else mentioned calling Airbnb.

    I didn't see you mention that you ever called to explain the situation with Airbnb.

    You could also go ahead and get up and running with Vrbo. I get almost all my bookings via Vrbo.

  • Member since 2026 · 10 posts · 0 votes
    8h

    the superhost line is your best bet, I'd try that before the standard appeal or any exec letter... ask them to open one case that links your closing docs, the TOT certificate and the old listing number, and get it noted that the bad reviews came from a manager after you bought. once the old listing is gone I'd ask support to confirm in writing that the address is clear before you repost, rather than assume removal fixes it. if the old manager won't give you a letter, screenshots of the old listing showing him as host help too. one thing we do across our close to 60 properties when we take a place on is keep the existing listing and get added as co host rather than start a new one, it keeps the history and avoids exactly this...worth remembering next time if the seller's listing is in decent shape.

  • Andrew SteffensBusiness Member
    Tampa, FL · Member since 2022 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3h

    This happens to me fairly often as I help many investors in Tampa acquire and then I property manage for them so we are usually the ones dealing with it. It is not just that the old listing was flagged for poor quality - this can happen if the system sees two listings at the same address and matches photos. AI is making this quicker and more efficient on the Airbnb side. Simply make a case with Airbnb support and send them the documents showing the sale and that should clear it up.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.