Violation of the lease should have served with the court (Lesson #3)Then he submitted a maintenance request for a 1/2" crack in the acrylic tub that he said was flooding the basement. 

Wood, tile, acrylic and others alternatives (done well) are impressive, durable and functional.

Since you’re keeping it long-term, I’d stay focused on tubs that can take abuse, clean easy, and don’t break the bank when one eventually needs replacing.Here’s my take:If you’ve got good bones under the bathroom floors, enameled steel or acrylic tubs are your sweet spot.

I like Acrylic prints because they not only look great, but they take the hassle out of finding a frame and are easy to hang and clean. 

Acrylic tubs tend to be a solid balance of durability and cost, and they’re lightweight.

This would require finding matching tile, which can be a challenge for a 2016 renovation.Tub Re-lining: This is an option where a new acrylic liner is custom-fitted over the existing tub.

Not cheap but reasonable prices, ~$200 for a larger framed canvas or acrylic print. 

Acrylic is lighter and fine for most rentalsWhite or light gray shaker cabinets are good enough. 

sometimes it's easier and about the same price to just rip it all out, put in a new acrylic tub & shower surround from home depot ($500), toilet ($120), and vanity ($200).  

One or two coats of 100% acrylic interior paint flat on ceiling and matte/eggshell on walls?