Can I 1031 my raw land and build a duplex to sell?

Question

My raw land is closing in the next 3-6 months in Florida. I have a potential partner with 2 vacant lots in Colorado outside of Steamboat Springs. We want to roll my 1031 money into building a duplex or SFH on each of his lots to sell. Is this possible or do we have to own and rent them out?

Dave Foster · Answer

@Michael C berry jr, Good thoughts by all on your core issues which are:

1. You cannot buy build and sell and 1031. That is not what the IRS considers productive investment intent. Your intent must be to hold not simply to construct and sell.

2. To do a 1031 you have to take title to actual real estate.

Given the price of Steamboat real estate I would imagine that you might be able to purchase a % of that property from the owner. Then you would both be tenants in common on the real estate. And you could continue to develop and build it. But you'd want to build something to hold for a year or two before you sell. Then not only will you defer the tax from this sale. You'll also defer the tax from the next sale.

Bill S. · Answer

@Michael C berry jr so another component to be concerned about is the ownership of the lots in Steamboat. The 1031 process means you need to identify the property withing 45 days of closing and close on the purchase within 180 days of identifying the property. The transaction needs to be "arms length" as well. That means your partner would likely need to sell and deed the lots to you. You could then do a business deal with them to develop the lots. If you plan to move forward with this, definitely get a qualified 1031 specialist and an tax attorney involved so that you check all the boxes and structure the deal properly.

Bill B. · Answer

It’s an investment. So you’re ok that the land isn’t producing rent.

But…you have to spend all your net proceeds. So the land has to cost as much as your sales, not the land plus the building costs, because you won’t get that don’t within the deadlines…

Then…you can’t build to sell. That’s a job, building homes to sell, not an investment. So you’d have to build the duplexes and then rent them out. Yes, you could “eventually” sell them. But then the 1031 didn’t do you much good because you’d owe taxes on both sales when you sold unless you did another 1031. The taxes don’t go away when you do a 1031, they get rolled in to your next deal.

Reach out to @Dave Foster for an expert’s opinion.

Jason Malabute · Answer

You can’t use a 1031 exchange to build and immediately sell, because that’s considered flipping, not investment. To qualify, you must buy like-kind property, hold or build-to-suit, then rent it for a reasonable time (usually 1–2 years) to show investment intent before selling or doing another 1031. The goal is to hold for investment, not resale, so you can defer capital gains tax.

Casey Owens · Answer

Hi Michael,

Good question — this is a common area of confusion with 1031 exchanges.

To qualify, the replacement property must be held for long-term investment or income-producing purposes, not for immediate resale. So if your plan is to build and then sell right away, the IRS may classify that as a fix-and-flip or dealer activity, which wouldn’t qualify for 1031 treatment.

The safer route would be to hold the duplexes as rentals for a period of time (many advisors suggest at least 1–2 years), showing clear investment intent. That way, the exchange is more likely to stand up under IRS scrutiny.

Hope that helps clarify!

Michael C berry jr · Answer

Thank you all for the information and knowledge.

Ashish Acharya · Answer

@Michael C berry jr No, you can’t use a 1031 exchange to build and immediately sell duplexes, doing so classifies the property as inventory (flipping), not as investment, which disqualifies the 1031.

To comply with 1031 rules, you must:

• Use the proceeds to acquire like-kind investment property (e.g., the Colorado lots),
• Either hold them as-is or do a build-to-suit 1031 exchange (complex, using an Exchange Accommodation Titleholder),
• Rent the new builds for a reasonable period (typically 1–2 years) to show investment intent, then
• Sell or 1031 again later.

The key test is intent to hold for investment, not resale. Building to sell directly will trigger full capital gains tax. Use a 1031-qualified intermediary and tax advisor to structure this properly.

This post does not create a CPA-Client relationship. The information contained in this post is not to be relied upon. Readers should seek professional advice.

Chris Seveney · Answer

It is my understanding you would need to have ownership in the lots - you can not do it as a loan etc.

Can I 1031 my raw land and build a duplex to sell?

Can I 1031 my raw land and build a duplex to sell?

Most Popular Reply

8 Replies