Investor · Goodyear, AZ · Member since 2015 · 29 posts · 7 votes
I have called several QI's and my lawyer, talked to my accountant. Each call I make gets me a different answer.
My 2 member LLC is going to sell the only property we own this month. My partner does not want to reinvest his half, I plan on reinvesting my half of the profits in another house.
One QI tells me that I can quit claim the title to 50/50 split between the LLC and my partner. Other QI's mention that the IRS will probably disallow the exchange because there is a holding period that will not be met if I transfer title before getting the property under contract.
I have heard many different opinions and am almost willing to pay the 20K in taxes just to be sure that I don't have a problem. Has anyone on here had success (or failure) with a drop and swap removing a partner shortly before a sale?
@Russell Fugitt, The QI's telling you to exercise caution in changing title immediately prior to a sale are giving you good advice. While there is no statutory holding period there is so much opportunity for basis shifting and unlawfully accessing what amounts to gain prior to a 1031 that if audited your exchange would have a hard time standing. There is also a secondary and mainly theoretical issue that still concerns many and that is that intent of the LLC when obtaining the other half of the property is primarily to resell it and not to hold it. That in theory disqualifies it from being part of a 1031.
A better approach and the direction we take with many clients and their legal and tax professionals is to have the LLC as the legal taxpayer for the relinquished property, complete a partial 1031 exchange into a property that the one member wants while taking boot that represents the other member's half. After the exchange is completed the LLC is dissolved by the accountants and the assets are distributed - the property to the one member, and the cash and associated tax liability to the other.
This does require burning an LLC but that's not necessarily the worst thing to do every once in a while - particularly if the members are splitting anyway.
The one QI that suggested you deed the property out of the LLC into the individual partners' names via a quit claim deed is asking you to take on too much risk. We generally refer to this as a "drop and swap" structure. This was a very popular solution years ago, but has become much more risky since 2008.
The issue is that the "real" taxpayer is the LLC, which as a two (2) person LLC is treated as a partnership for tax purposes. The two individual partners merely own partnership interests and do not own any real estate. The partnership actually owns the real estate.
One of the requirements in the 1031 Exchange world is that the taxpayer must have the intent to hold his/her/its relinquished property and replacement property for rental, investment or business use purposes. Deeding the property out of the LLC and into the individuals' names and then immediately selling and structuring a 1031 Exchange would likely be disqualified because the seller (the individual who just took title) never had the intent to hold the property for rental, investment or business use purposes. They acquired title from the partnership merely to structure a 1031 Exchange at the individual (partners) level instead of the true taxpayer (the partnership).
The IRS Form 1065 (Partnership Tax Return) was amended in 2008 and actually asks if you have dropped the property out of the partnership and then immediately sold and structured a 1031 Exchange during the last two income tax years.
There are many variations/solutions that might work. One solution outlined above requires that gain be specially allocated to the partner that is not exchanging. Special tax allocations can be tricky and problematic. I would consult with your legal AND tax advisors before completing any type of exchange here.
Exeter 1031 Exchange Services, LLC and Exeter Trust Company4.826 Reviews