San Francisco, CA · Member since 2016 · 75 posts · 26 votes
Hi folks,
We are a family of 4. We currently live in San Francisco, however we are moving to Miami, Florida next year
We would like to buy a holiday home that we could rent out when are not using it (for most of the year).
We haven't decided on whether we are doing the short-term or long-term rental route. I don't want the hassle of AirBNB management, but might consider using a really strong local property management company.
What markets should we look at? We are thinking about:
- San Diego, California
- Maui or Honolulu in Hawaii (it seems really expensive). We have the $$ but the rental yield seems poor.
You might consider doing AirBNB but co-host, or is that what you meant by doing property mgt? With a long term rental, you don't necessarily need a pm.
As for which market, I don't really know since you'd have to investigate what appears to be both rental options (what about medium term??), your risk tolerance, etc. to determine the best case.
If budget no issue, and time is available for long(er) commute the answer is Hawaii. Other question is what is your seasonality like?
Scottsdale is primo winter, dead summer. Miami, for example, is in demand for winter, mildly for summer. So when do you plan to use it as a holiday home(winter break, summer break)? If you want to keep it completely open, then yes best bet is still Hawaii. Otherwise, look at Asheville, the Catskill Mountains, Blue Ridge Georgia. If you're seasonal look at Angel Fire, NM, or the Colorado mountains. You might be able to get into the game in the Smokies if these come down.
We are a family of 4. We currently live in San Francisco, however we are moving to Miami, Florida next year
We would like to buy a holiday home that we could rent out when are not using it (for most of the year).
We haven't decided on whether we are doing the short-term or long-term rental route. I don't want the hassle of AirBNB management, but might consider using a really strong local property management company.
What markets should we look at? We are thinking about:
- San Diego, California
- Maui or Honolulu in Hawaii (it seems really expensive). We have the $$ but the rental yield seems poor.
- Saint Petersburg?
- Turks and Caicos?
Anywhere you might suggest?
As someone that has rentals in San Diego, the San Diego city counsel is very landlord unfriendly. California is also LL unfriendly.
Ca has statewide rent control. The issue is not the maximum allowed increase, it is the rights rent control provides the tenants. Lease duration means nothing. In addition CA proposed a 15% STR tax in addition to standard occupancy tax. Patrons staying in hotel would pay 15% less tax if this had passed than those staying in an STR.
San Diego is even more LL unfriendly than the state. San Diego had the most protective tenant protection Covid restrictions in the nation. You could not evict if they were not paying and were distorting the unit. San Diego’s rent control restrictions exceed the state restrictions. For STRs, San Diego implemented a quota. Many long time STRs failed to obtain a permit.
If you choose San Diego, expect increasingly unfriendly landlord regulations.
You said you want to buy a holiday home that you can rent out when not using it. If you go the long-term route, you will only be able to use it when the place is vacant as your tenants will have the rights to use the property during the term of the lease. STR properties are a lot easier because you can just block off time on the calendar when you intend to use the property.
As for locations, I agree with @V.G Jason if you go the STR route. Hawaii has year-round tourism. The only thing that changes is that we see a change in the demographics during the summer months, with more families coming over when kids are out of school. For an LTR, it is a lot harder to make the numbers work in today's market. That being said, there is a shortage of housing and always people looking to rent.
Ultimately, it depends on how much you want to spend. There are markets where your $ will go further but you may not see a good ROI.