Help with strategy: Buy/hold MFH in high-priced regions for cash-flow

Help with strategy: Buy/hold MFH in high-priced regions for cash-flow

Investor · Oakland, CA · Member since 2012 · 33 posts · 40 votes

Hello BiggerPockets -

I’m new to real estate and am starting to model out numbers. I’m in brainstorming mode right and would appreciate any input.

:: GOALS ::
In five years time, replace my salaried income with RE income, where I am no longer trading my time for money and giving me freedom to pursue my own interests. If I can accelerate this, all the better.

:: BACKGROUND AND RESOURCES ::
I am based in Los Angeles and have around 50k earmarked for real estate investment. I have full time salaried job. Great credit score, other personal reserves. Private money via family is available down the line.

My boyfriend and I have just completed a major renovation of a triplex he owns out of state. Since we are based in Los Angeles will be remotely managing that and another MFH. He’s owned/managed these for many years, so we are fairly familiar with the numbers at this point.

:: VALUES AND PREFERENCES ::
We would prefer to invest in Los Angeles city, as the boyfriend and I could be doing the networking, scouting, rehab and initial PM ourselves (him more full-time). We both enjoy being on the ground, getting our hands dirty, and we have a knack for finding/building wonderful things on very tight budgets. As such, investing out of state/city is seems to be a less desirable option.

Pride of ownership is also important to us, and we are strong with aesthetics, so we would like to add value by creating charming aesthetically-pleasing properties.

We would owner occupy in the property most advantageous to achieving goals, fine with moving a few times.

:: POSSIBLE STRATEGY ::
A strategy I’m considering is buy-and-hold in Los Angeles, starting with residential. Would love to move into the commercial/mixed-use space as my experience grows. We could use same strategy as previous two - buy an under-priced fixer upper MFH in an up-and-coming neighborhood, add value, rent out, cash-flow, hopefully (not betting on it) have properties appreciate. Hopefully use existing equity to finance future investments.

Plugging my numbers into various spreadsheets however, I’m having a tough time having the numbers work well in my favor as a cash-flow operation for Los Angeles.

With 20% down, I can afford in the 200-240k range, with around 10-15k in rehab costs. The only MFH priced in that range are duplexes in C areas. I’m already eyeing a few up-and-coming pockets.

Market rents in C area 1 bedroom are around $1000, but with rent control, I’ve seen listings as low as $650 (would not consider those).

So that means:
- Average duplex purchase price + financed rehab: 200k + 10k
- Cash outlay: 42k down + 3.5k closing costs
- Assuming market rents: $1k per unit: $2,000 monthly gross
- Monthly expenses would be roughly 30% (doing own PM): Less $600
- Mortgage - 30 year fixed at 4.2%: Less $851
MONTHLY PROPERTY CASHFLOW: $549
# of similar doors to replace monthly income: 26

Obviously, should I go forward with this plan, it would have to be much more fleshed out and researched. Financing and rent control (all of Los Angeles city), are major considerations that would need to be grappled with.

Thoughts? Some questions:
1. Considering my goals, values, and resources, what other strategies should I consider to complement or replace this one?
2. Regarding the above strategy - what factors am I missing/ should I be considering?
3. Am I on target with these numbers? Are these kinds of numbers workable as a buy hold investment strategy?

Thanks for any insight you can offer.

0Reply
67 views

8 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Lake City, CO · Member since 2012 · 118 posts · 15 votes
    13y

    Hi Jenny, I'm certainly not the numbers guy or have the experience that some have on this site but I am looking in different areas for buy & hold or buy to rent properties. I see that you would prefer the local area but also see some issues that you have brought up. Have you considered buying to rent with appreciation? Or condos that have HOA fees, takes care of the PM issue somewhat and if in good areas the renters can be better vetted. There are some pretty hot areas out of California that are much cheaper with better cash flow and very good appreciation rates, Austin, Tx being one. I'm also getting into the Las Vegas area and it seems to be hot there as well. But sometimes this comes from the RE agents and local chamber trying to sell the area. Also closer to where you live. I don't mind sharing what I have found with you but it would be better if we hooked up via PM to discuss.
    I do know that this subject has been covered here on BP and the general overall thought is from what I can determine is it's hard to get the cash flow from high end properties due to cost. The mid to lower end properties tend to do better even though that's not what your looking to do and typically a lot more work. Anyway sounds like you know what your doing and if I can help just hit me up via a PM.

    Chuck

  • Rental Property Investor · Mercer Island, WA · Member since 2008 · 22k+ posts · 14k+ votes
    13y

    Jenny Y., you say several things that distrub me greatly:


    later

    and then

    That first quote "trading my time for money" is, mostly, guru hogwash. They sell you a dream that real estate will generate money with no effort of your own. Its just that - a dream. The second quoted statement breaks this. PM'ing isn't a lot of work, but it is work. You discount the 50% down to 30% (too optimistic, I would never go below 35% even with self management). But you are EARNING that extra 20% (or 15%) by, guess what, trading time for money!

    Then you throw away some of your returns by saying you want to create "charming aesthetically-pleasing properties". Make no mistake, that will cost you real money out of your real pockets. The best returns are going to come further down the food chain. To accelerate your first goal, follow the money.

    I do put in a "mostly" because it is possible to accumulate enough money to generate enough return to provide a living. Bank CD's currently pay around 2%. So, if you want $100K a year in income, you simply need $5 million in bank CDs to generate that income. Real estate will (probably) do better than that. A 10% return (which is what I get for your sample below) is probably reasonable. So, that means you need $1 million. If you could push that return to 20%, you would need only $500,000.

    My analysis of your example deal.

    Purchase: $200,000
    Rehab: $10,000 (that seems low, that might pay for paint and carpet)
    Loan: $160,000 (20 % down, no you can't finance the rehab at any reasonable rate)
    Gross scheduled rents: $2000
    Payment $782 (4.2%, 30 year fixed)
    expenses, capital, vacancy: $700 (35%, assumes you're willing to do PM)
    cash flow: $517
    Total cash invested $50,000
    Cash on cash return: 12.4%

    Now, that's not a bad deal. If your goal is $100K in income, you would need 16 such deals and a total of $805K in cash.

    You can do much better in other parts of the country, though. So, my first piece of advice is simple - move. Lots of people move for jobs. I've done it three times in my life: MO to Houston to Bakersfield and finally here to Denver. There are lots of places in this country your can pay a half as much for the same amount of rent. At $100K for this amount of rent, everything else the same, your cash on cash is 36%. That means you need only $275,000 to reach $100,000 a year in income.

    If you want to stay in LA, look for cheaper properties. Head out to the Inland Empire and see what deals are like there. Reconsider this "pretty property" goal vs. your income goal and decide which really matters. I'd like to own pretty buildings, too. But I like making money more.

    Second recommendation is that you figure out how to pump more cash into the deal. I don't mean cash borrowed from your family. That has to be paid back. So, it doesn't count toward your goal. As with any investment, this is all about cash on cash. That means you need to put cash into the investment to generate returns.

    Lets go back to the time for dollars piece. You say you're willing to self manage. Say you do want $100K in income. With deals like you describe, even with self management, you need 16 such properties, 32 units total. With 32 units, you will almost always have a turnover or two in process. Even if you avoid vacancies (a few days between tenants is almost inevitable for cleaning and repairs), you are still doing showings. My rough rule of thumb is that I have to take 50 calls and show a property to 10 groups of people to get a good tenant. If you turn over your properties once a year, that's a total of 1600 calls per year, and 320 groups of people in your properties per year. Now, I only do showings at a specific property once per week and get all the callers there at once. But I figure it takes three or four showings and then a lease signing. With 32 units that means you're doing several showings each and every week and doing a lease signing (a several hour process) two or three times a month.

    OTOH, turn this over to a PM and its costing you big time. Your cash on cash drops down to 5.2%, you need 38 properties rather than 16 and you need $1.9 million in cash. In exchange you really do get rid (mostly) of that "time for dollars" piece. You will still have to deal with the manager(s) at times and you still have all your tax accounting to do.

    One more kicker in your play. You're assuming 4.2% 30 year mortgages. That's available right now for your first few properties. If you find the right banker, and are well qualified and have other income, perhaps as many at 10. But beyond that, and very likely before that, you'll be looking at commercial loans. That rate should be about the same, maybe slightly higher. But the term will be much shorter. Fifteen years seems to be common. The folks I know here who own lots of properties get 15 year loans. With a 15 year note, everything else the same and assuming self management, your cash on cash return falls to 2.4% and the property generates only $1200 a year in true cash flow.

    Sorry for typos, no time to proofread, have to jet.

  • Contractor · New York, NY · Member since 2012 · 30 posts · 12 votes
    13y

    Correct on the 15 year loan at 4.2% bringing the cash on cash down to 2.4%. Are you sure the people you know are doing full amortized loans at 15 years? Most the people I know are doing Interest only loans at that range and interest rate... IO for the first 5-10 years then amortizing afterwords. By then ,the place has already paid itself off.

    Under the FRM IO circumstance, you get something along the lines of $1,440 cashflow after debt service and a monthly NOI of $740, which is a roughly 18% cash on cash which is pretty good to me for LA.

    As far as I can tell, she is going in at a 7.5% cap rate, which is a lot higher than what I see in other metro areas (NY, Miami), so I can't see how she'd be doing too bad on it unless she is really overdoing her projections (which appears to be the case). Most people in NYC/MIA dream of 7.5% cap rates for such little reno work.

  • New York City, NY · Member since 2012 · 253 posts · 7 votes
    13y

    Hey Jenny Y. what other areas besides LA are you looking at investing in properties?

  • Landlord · San Diego, CA · Member since 2012 · 129 posts · 49 votes
    13y

    I haven't checked out all of the details of your math, but I'm having a hard time seeing how you can take $50,000 using a "buy and hold" strategy to create a revenue stream sufficient to make a living off of within five years - especially if you're living in high-priced Los Angeles. You're going to need some significant cash coming in to be able to buy properties and I don't see where you have that laid out in your mini-business plan.

    More realistically, you'll create a nice little nest egg to augment your existing income and then in 10 to 20 years live off of your real estate investments (sooner if the market goes through another bubble and you're able to sell, later if it doesn't).

    The other option is to fix and flip so that you can cash out and use the cash to keep building your investment capital. That's not my area of expertise though so I'll let others speak to that.

  • Rental Property Investor · Mercer Island, WA · Member since 2008 · 22k+ posts · 14k+ votes
    13y

    Yes, fixed rate, fully amortized 15 year notes. Interest rates fluctuate, but they're around that 4.2% number. These are mostly single families or duplexes like Jenny Y. describes, not what I would consider true multi families. I'm not sure what terms this particular lender offers for 5+ multi families. I do know other folks, like Joel Owens, have mentioned commercial loans amortized for 15 or 20 years with a five year balloon. Thats in the ballpark of what we were able to get last year on a mini-storage refi.

    I assume you mean that with the IO loan and saying the "place has already paid itself off", the owner is pumping all the cash flow back to paying off the principal. Otherwise, after the 5-10 year IO period, the balance on the note is exactly the same as when you started. Now, you convert to an amortizing note at whatever the interest rate is in 5-10 years. I would bet that's a higher rate than you can get right now. So, I think its better to lock in a long term fixed rate now rather than betting on low rates in the future.

    These folks buying with these IO loans assuming things will work out in the future may be in for a rude suprise. We came very close to losing the mini-storage, which was also on a five year balloon from the original purchase in 2007. Conditions in 2012 were much worse than we foresaw. The refi was very difficult and was a cash in refi with a non-trivial sum of cash required to get it done.

  • Contractor · New York, NY · Member since 2012 · 30 posts · 12 votes
    13y

    By pay itself off, I meant that by the time you reach a balloon payment, you'd have refinanced the original investment out, while also making a compounded return from the reinvestment of the cashflows made over that time period.

    I personally wouldn't spend a penny on principal payments right now. The current market conditions suggest putting the least amount of money into reducing the note balance in order to maximize liquidity of funds. Why on earth would I want to convert liquid cashflow into a physical asset?

    There is high chance of a long-term (10 year) trend in the US of moderate to high inflation. With high inflation, the fixed debt gets washed out by the inflation. Your relative fixed cost of capital drops significantly while your potential income increases with inflation.

    The money is better invested in growing cashflow as interest rates rise until they return to normal rates in future (around 10% in the next decade). At that point, principle payments could potentially yield more return on your cashflow than investing in more property.

    Cash(flow) is king in today's economy. Any equity you have in a property today is a liability (your hard earned money placed in vehicle that may get wiped out in the next debt crisis/default/whatever). If house values suddenly drop again, I'd have had enough cashflow growth to still give me a strong return on my original investment. They can take the property, and I'll be happy with my large returns that I had generated up until that time.

  • Investor · Oakland, CA · Member since 2012 · 33 posts · 40 votes
    13y

    Thanks all, this is really helpful.

    I am indeed aware that it takes ongoing work to build, grow and maintain a portfolio of assets. To be clearer, my objective is to direct more and more of my energy into building/maintaining my own wealth-producing systems, rather than being wholly dependent on my salary (which, incidentally, is earned by creating wealth-producing systems for others).

    And got it - if I want the biggest bang for my buck in the cash-flow game, Los Angeles is DEFINITELY not the place to be. However, Los Angeles is where our careers/industries are, which we both are committed to, so these two priorities will just have to be at odds with one another for a while. I’d imagine this scenario is very similar to committed to careers tying them to NYC or SF.

    I’ll definitely start looking at other regions to invest in. Two prospective spots off the top of head are Inland Empire and Portland Oregon. Inland Empire is within a reasonable drive to do my own scouting, rehab, and PM. However, I’m aware that a lot of inventory is disappearing quickly (for one, being acquired in bulk by large-scale Wall St investors), so one of many challenges would be finding a niche that’s not attractive to them.

    Portland, my boyfriend already has property, in addition to a trusted team already in place. Need to research if this is enough to warrant passing up other geographies (if I’m looking outside of California anyhow).

    Will look at fix and flip as possibility to boost investment capital, but again, I suspect the opportunities for me exist outside of California.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.