BRRR Poll Question: With break even cash flow, Yay or Nay?

BRRR Poll Question: With break even cash flow, Yay or Nay?

Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 95 posts · 32 votes

Hey all!

Hypothetical but very a real question:

With little to no money to start your REI career.

If you could perform the BRRR strategy, factoring in ALL EXPENSES. Cap Ex., Vacancies, Etc...

And broke dead even to begin a deal, in a price point of 500K with (historical likelihood) for 4-5% yearly appreciation.

Do you do the deal?

Thanks in advance, have a great day all!

3Reply
477 views

Most Popular Reply

Joe VilleneuvePro Member
Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
10y

No.  The fact you have very little money to start is even more of a reason not to waste it

See this reply in the discussion

179 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Allen Thomas:

    Emphatic NAY! When there are vacancies, evictions, and major expenses (Roof, HVAC, etc.), you will lose money. Don't do it. 

     This is what @Ryan Rogers stated, "

    factoring in ALL EXPENSES. Cap Ex., Vacancies, Etc...

    And broke dead even to begin a deal, in a price point of 500K with (historical likelihood) for 4-5% yearly appreciation." 

    Do the facts change your opinion?

  • Real Estate Agent · Austell, GA · Member since 2014 · 232 posts · 74 votes
    10y

    Nope. Definitely not enough wiggle room. No one can ever account for ALL EXPENSES. We all just hope for the best. The better the deal, the more likely you are to turn a profit annually regardless of the issues that pop up. Speaking from personal experience, it's impossible to plan for things like the day when your homeowner's insurance company tells you that you must have an arborist remove a tree from your yard... 

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:
    Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:
    Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
    Originally posted by @Jennifer L.:

    The traditional investors here advise against negative or 0 cash flow. There are scenarios where this does make sense, however.

    Let me take a look at the numbers here:

    ARV in year 2018 (payoff) $650,000
    Original Buy in year 1999                     $340,000
    Negative CF of $10.4k/year x 15 yrs    $156,000
     

    If my assumptions are accurate, I don't see anything possitive here.  

    I never see any good reason for negative cash flow.

    Joe, you will not have negative cash flow over the holding period of a property in CA.

    Here at the initial $340,000 purchase price and assuming a common price-to-rent ratio of .7% then her rents would be in the ballpark of $2380 a month.  As the property appreciated to $700,000 ( a $360,000 windfall!!!) then assuming the same price-to-rent ratio 0f .7% then the rent has increased to $4,900 a month or an increase of $2,520 a MONTH!  

    So the lesson here is that price-to-rent ratio is pretty meaningless unless you have appreciation. Cash flow is only icing on the cake. That same Indy $50,000 place with it's 2% PTR ratio means the place is hopefully still only collecting $1,000 rent. Inflation and CapEx is eating your cash faux.

     Her numbers...not mine.

    I don't see where she detailed her cash flow over the  years,  It seems you assumed a figure.  Of course she is turning a corner in her cash flow where she will be netting over $30,000 which she can turn into $540,000 in CASH and still have almost $40,000 a year in appreciation and the incremental rent increases.

     "When I refi'd the difference in payments was $400/ month".  Her quote.  She originally mentioned it was a negative cash flow when she refi'd from "break even".. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Austell, GA · Member since 2014 · 232 posts · 74 votes
    10y

    And the appreciation is virtually irrelevant if you end up with a net loss in cash flow. With that type of money you could get into multiple GOOD deals. Just sayin'...

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Allen Thomas:

    And the appreciation is virtually irrelevant if you end up with a net loss in cash flow. With that type of money you could get into multiple GOOD deals. Just sayin'...

    What type of money?  The OP is controlling a $500,000 asset with ZERO in to it!  Yeah I know, more facts. Go back and read the original post.

  • Investor · Las Vegas and Tulsa · Member since 2014 · 123 posts · 200 votes
    10y
    I wouldn't do it. Too much risk and not enough "probable" upside. I have a simple rule: I invest for cash flow and speculate for appreciation. Both are OK, but you need to be clear with yourself whether you are investing or speculating. I look for cash flow first. This fictional deal has none. Combined with it being a SFR, which can sit vacant between tenants, or even worse having a deadbeat tenang in there. What if it takes you 3 months to get rid of a bad tenant? Then it takes another month and $15k to repair the damage after the tenant. Do you have the reserves to carry the property through that? It would be better if it was a fourplex, so you would have some income left from the other units. Appreciation usually comes in two "flavors:". Hope and pray or forced. This hypothetical seems to rely entirely on the hope and pray appreciation. Even if an area has traditionally appreciated at a certain rate, there have been ups and downs over that time and your timing becomes crucial. Right now, values have appreciated a lot in your market for a period of several years. I interpret this to mean that you're definitely not buying it at the bottom. It's a much greater chance that you are buying at or near the top. Too many negatives here. If there's a forced appreciation play here, it would be different, but it would turn it into a flip as it is a SFR. With MFR, forced appreciation would come through increased NOI, or in other words increased cash flow. Then, you would have options whether to sell or refinance and take cash out. As some of the other people on this thread have already mentioned, there might be a time, place and investor for a deal like this, but it's definitely not a newbie without significant capital resources. Just my $.02 Erik
  • Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 66 posts · 25 votes
    10y

    @Ryan Rogers

    I would.

    but insure that you are saving enough or can make those monthlies.

    My first property was a down VA, 15% below market, did all the work on the in my free time, rented it when I moved a year later.

    BRRRR Out of that one into a condo a friend wanted to sell. The condo was at 250 after expenses, and the money that was out of the first left me with about 125 free, but I had done all CAPEX.

    Risky?  Know your risk and manage it.  If I was, expanding aggressively or a full time investor at the time I probably would have found a better buy.

  • Rental Property Investor · Fort Wayne, IN · Member since 2016 · 258 posts · 177 votes
    10y
    Ryan Rogers I would require a property without a cash flow unless I have enough money to support it and wait only for the appreciation which is again speculation only.
  • Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 95 posts · 32 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Erik Nowacki:

    I wouldn't do it. Too much risk and not enough "probable" upside. I have a simple rule: I invest for cash flow and speculate for appreciation. Both are OK, but you need to be clear with yourself whether you are investing or speculating.

    I look for cash flow first. This fictional deal has none. Combined with it being a SFR, which can sit vacant between tenants, or even worse having a deadbeat tenang in there. What if it takes you 3 months to get rid of a bad tenant? Then it takes another month and $15k to repair the damage after the tenant. Do you have the reserves to carry the property through that? It would be better if it was a fourplex, so you would have some income left from the other units.

    Appreciation usually comes in two "flavors:". Hope and pray or forced. This hypothetical seems to rely entirely on the hope and pray appreciation. Even if an area has traditionally appreciated at a certain rate, there have been ups and downs over that time and your timing becomes crucial. Right now, values have appreciated a lot in your market for a period of several years. I interpret this to mean that you're definitely not buying it at the bottom. It's a much greater chance that you are buying at or near the top. Too many negatives here.

    If there's a forced appreciation play here, it would be different, but it would turn it into a flip as it is a SFR. With MFR, forced appreciation would come through increased NOI, or in other words increased cash flow. Then, you would have options whether to sell or refinance and take cash out.

    As some of the other people on this thread have already mentioned, there might be a time, place and investor for a deal like this, but it's definitely not a newbie without significant capital resources.

    Just my $.02

    Erik

     Thanks Erik!  Just an FYI this property would have zero vacancy(seriously) with the area.  Curious if that changes your mind.  

  • Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 95 posts · 32 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Kay Kay Singh:

    Ryan Rogers
    I would require a property without a cash flow unless I have enough money to support it and wait only for the appreciation which is again speculation only.

     Question for everyone stating that investing for appreciation long term (20-30 years) is speculating.

    If you invest in Markets like New York, San Fran, San Diego, LA, Miami, DC, Chicago Etc...

    Do you really consider the properties never appreciating??? I understand the logic being on the safe side and wanting cash flow. But the question being if you can BRRR into a property with ZERO out of pocket you still wouldn't do the deal?

    Thanks all!

  • Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 95 posts · 32 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Michael Hayworth:

    I have done this a couple times. But I wouldn't do it if I didn't already have adequate capital.

    I've got 2 properties where I paid cash for them at auction, did reno, and raised the value enough that when I refinanced them, even at 75% LTV, I was basically left owning the house with no cash outlay. Rents on those properties were basically break-even or very small cash flow, but that's figuring in all real expenses, including a repair reserve.

    I don't mind a non-cash-flow property if a tenant is paying my mortgage and building my equity in the place, and if I have it for free. But I have plenty of cash reserve that if the AC, roof & water heater all took  a **** the same month, I could cover it.

    I really wouldn't recommend doing this on a first property or with low cash on hand.

     Mike I appreciate the input.  So you like the play if you have more capital for repairs if there's a catastrophic CAPEx situation?  My calculations are for CAPEx in total.  But your saying if something TERRIBLE happens?  If this area I would unlikely deal with evictions or vacancies so I've taken that off the table.  I know it's possible, but this area not likely.

    Ryan

  • Investor · Las Vegas and Tulsa · Member since 2014 · 123 posts · 200 votes
    10y

    @Ryan Rogers There's no such thing as zero vacancy!  If you are using a zero vacancy as the basis for your calculations, you are setting yourself up for failure in this business.  Keep in mind that there are two kinds of vacancies, physical and economic.  You are NEVER going to be able to avoid either or both of these over a long period of time.   

    As I pointed out, at some point you will rent your house to a professional tenant.  He's well dressed, speaks well and has good references.  After you receive the first months rent and deposit, the second month's check will bounce, followed by many excuses, deaths in the family etc.   You buy the first couple of excuses because they are credible sob stories (and you haven't heard them before...).  Once you start the eviction process, you find out that the tenant knows all of the inns and outs of the local eviction laws, postpones the hearing (perhaps over another death in the family...), claims habitability issues in the house (that he caused), requiring another hearing in a months time etc.  By the time you actually get the deadbeat out, you're out 90+ days of rent.  If you're lucky, there's not too much damage to the house, but you will end up painting and replacing the carpet.    This is known as economic vacancy, there's someone in the unit, but you are not receiving rent.  There's a small percentage of tenants that fit into this category, but if you rent units for long enough, you will step on one of these landmines eventually.  If you have been in the business for 30 years and have 100 units when you do, it's not that big of a deal.  However, if it happens to be your first tenant after you bought your first property, a $500K house with no money down, it can be an absolute disaster.

    As to your next question about not counting on appreciation.  I have owned multifamily properties in San Diego since 1999, enough time to see some ups and downs in the market.  I count on cash flow and forced appreciation, never on market appreciation.  I can control cash flow and forced appreciation but I have no control at all over the market in general.   What is the point in speculating that in 20 years, my portfolio might be worth twice of what I paid for it?  A "feel good" exercise?   It's so far out and with so many variables that the number becomes irrelevant. 

    I like to focus on the here and now.  What is this building worth today?  Can I buy it for less than what I think it's worth?  If I have to pay full value, can I negotiate favorable terms on the financing?  Once I own the property, the focus is on what can I do to improve the cash flow from the property?  What can I do to keep it from deteriorating?  What can I do to make it look better?  Can I raise the rents?  All improvements can be checked against the potential increased cash flow by dividing the cash flow with the prevailing cap rate in the area.  For example: It will cost me $10K to rehab an apartment; I can raise the rent by $200/month after the rehab; increased cash flow is $2,400/month; cap rate in the area is 10%; $2,400/.10 is $24,000.  So, if I put in $10K, my building will increase in value by $24K; that's a good return and I would probably do it.

    If you are projecting long term increases in value in order to compare your investment with the stock market, you are missing a crucial differentiation, real estate is not a passive investment.  You need to manage the property, or manage your manager.  You need to stay on top of maintenance, drive by the property on a regular basis and make sure it's still standing and that the curb appeal is preserved.  If you buy the house today, expecting not to touch it and have it be worth $1M in 20 years, you're in for a surprise...

    Market appreciation happens, but don't count on it.   Use it to your advantage when possible, sell properties when the market hits a high, buy properties when the market crashes.  Looking at long term value charts can be helpful, but don't forget that there are many external factors that can affect the appreciation trends, such as inflation, quantitative easing and demographic trends.

    Let me finish by making an analogy between learning to invest in real estate and learning to swim. You can start by jumping in at the deep end and hoping you figure everything out before you drown. Some people have actually done it, survived and done very well for themselves. Another alternative is to start in the shallow end and gradually increasing your depth as your skills and comfort level improves. Your chances of survival and success will dramatically improve, even if it's not as exciting as the first option. Buying a $500K SFR, with no money down and no cash flow, hoping for appreciation is the equivalent of trying to learn to swim by going to the pool in the middle of the night, with no life guard, not knowing if there's even water in the pool, jumping in at the deep end and hoping you figure it out before something bad happens.

    Start at the shallow end my friend, it won't be as exciting, but chances are that you will still be here in 20 years.

    Erik

  • Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2016 · 9 posts · 8 votes
    10y

    Just to bring things into sharp focus...

    Who is taking the risk here?

    Here are a list of all the ppl involved who will be paid in full for their services.

    Your Bank (wire charges)

    Your Agent and Broker 6%

    The Seller

    Mortgage Broker

    Mortgage underwriter

    Escrow officers

    Termite company

    Home inspection company

    A slew of other maintenance/repair companies you nor I can think of right now

    Management company 3% of your 1st year rental income (to locate and verify tenant)

    Your tenant (although not paid they will receive full value for their rental payment)

    Answer: You are taking the risk.

    The list of services above are taking no risk (apart from the mortgage underwriter), yet they all receive compensation.

    Why wouldn't you?

  • Investor · Miami, FL · Member since 2015 · 66 posts · 9 votes
    10y

    @Ryan Rogers

    Hey man sounds like you really want to pull the trigger on this one. If your really risk adverse go for it man. Just make sure you are ready for whatever might happen. Have an open mind while of course being positive that it might go south. I think we are on the verge of another real estate collapse. That's why I wouldn't do it right now. The 50% rule, if the market does crash and that 500,000.00 property loses value to 275,000.00 - 300,000.00 make sure you can withstand that. Having said that in those markets that your talking about value will ALWAYS go up againg. The key is staying alive when something really bad like loosing half of the value of your property happens. Which even in those markets it does. History dosent lie, its a cycle.

  • Real Estate Agent · San Diego, CA · Member since 2015 · 3 posts · 1 vote
    10y

    I agree with Joe V, Erik N and what Joe A just said. I don't know the Boston market, but here in San Diego we had a huge crash but values have been coming back pretty quickly in most neighborhoods. Rents never went down during the crash, and they have been going way up in the past couple of years. 

  • San Diego, CA · Member since 2015 · 273 posts · 226 votes
    10y

    can I ask how everyone is defining cash flow?  What % down is assumed?

  • San Diego, CA · Member since 2015 · 273 posts · 226 votes
    10y

    to clarify, I realize in this case the question was posed for $0. But for all seasoned investors how do you define cash flow vs down payment?

  • Joe SplitrockPro Member
    Moderator
    Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes
    10y

    @Ryan Rogers I didn't read all the responses, but to answer your question, no. When you are relying on future appreciation, you are speculating. There are signs that we are headed towards the top of the market. Just ask yourself if the market crashes the day after you make this purchase, would you survive?

  • Scranton, PA · Member since 2016 · 201 posts · 44 votes
    10y

    I don't do appreciation (in  my market of Scranton).  I believe cash flow is king.  appreciation (can't be proven, just hoped for) is icing on the cake

    Locally I get 15-20% after maintenance/vacancy/management pads and all costs are calculated (10% each)

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y

    Here's what I posted in another thread that addresses APPRECIATION, rent growth and cash flow for those of you that need a real life example.  "

    The thing is that you don't hope and pray for appreciation. You put on your businessman pants and calculate your appreciation rate just like you would your rental rates, vacancy rate, expense rate. Oh, you don't calculate those? You just use whatever is posted on the internet. Bad move.

    Anyway I just saw sales from two of my building in the paper last week. One is a smaller unit than mine that sold for $440,000. I bought for $204,000 in 2003. I figure I could sell for $460,000+. The other one I bought in 1978 for $35,000 and the $500,000 sale is identical to mine. The 2008 property I bought for a little over $500,000 had an identical unit sell last month for $900,000!. Paid retail for all three and all three were cash flow negative. So over $900,000 in the equity bank.

    Now back in the 00's there was a local real estate company that was aggressively courting long time Honolulu owners to 1031 to the Mainland for CASH FAUX! His kids moved to the Mainland so I guess they needed the business. I warned anyone that I knew that was considering it. I have flyover experience from being a Realtor in KY and investing in Vegas. Well Honolulu stayed pretty stable and returned to the normal doubling in value every ten years. Everyone that I know that did the exchanges have regretted it as their tenants are 100% opposite of their experience in Honolulu. They have experienced vacancies and repairs and maintenance issues that they never had in Honolulu and their rents AND values DECREASED.

    So because I invest for profit, NOT cash faux and know my appreciation rate I am up in rents and over a million in appreciation."

  • Investor · Las Vegas and Tulsa · Member since 2014 · 123 posts · 200 votes
    10y

    @Sarah D. Perhaps you need to clarify your question.  They are related, but only to the effect that a larger downpayment increases your cash flow.  

    I define cash flow as the amount of cash I receive from a property each month, net of all operating expenses, interest and amortization.  I.e. what's left in the bank at the end of the month.  A larger downpayment means a smaller loan, which means less interest and amortization, which in turn improves cash flow.

    Erik

  • Investor · Mason, MI · Member since 2014 · 151 posts · 152 votes
    10y

    We started buying apartments in mid Michigan in 2003.  We stared with a four plex and are now up to 81 units.  I assume no appreciation whenever I invest and focus solely on cashflow.  I have all my buildings bank financed and my equity position is quite strong after 13 years on one loan, 10 on another, 6 on another and 5 on another.  We are still only around 25% equity on the two we purchased last year.  

    Cashflow allows me to maintain, upgrade, improve, handle risk, etc., etc., It allows me to run my business.  Cashflow also means all the other bills are being paid i.e, mortgages, taxes, utilities, insurance, etc., etc. 

    If you follow this recipe, one day you will wake up to discover, in a relatively short period of time (10 years), that your balance sheet is good and that the funds you used to achieve such a thing were provided by a tenant...or 81 tenants.  

    Oh, and I should mention - ALL my properties have appreciated in value since I purchased them.  My point is, I never buy banking on appreciation.    

    For me, cashflow is everything and the only thing.

  • Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 95 posts · 32 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Erik Nowacki:

    @Ryan Rogers There's no such thing as zero vacancy!  If you are using a zero vacancy as the basis for your calculations, you are setting yourself up for failure in this business.  Keep in mind that there are two kinds of vacancies, physical and economic.  You are NEVER going to be able to avoid either or both of these over a long period of time.   

    As I pointed out, at some point you will rent your house to a professional tenant.  He's well dressed, speaks well and has good references.  After you receive the first months rent and deposit, the second month's check will bounce, followed by many excuses, deaths in the family etc.   You buy the first couple of excuses because they are credible sob stories (and you haven't heard them before...).  Once you start the eviction process, you find out that the tenant knows all of the inns and outs of the local eviction laws, postpones the hearing (perhaps over another death in the family...), claims habitability issues in the house (that he caused), requiring another hearing in a months time etc.  By the time you actually get the deadbeat out, you're out 90+ days of rent.  If you're lucky, there's not too much damage to the house, but you will end up painting and replacing the carpet.    This is known as economic vacancy, there's someone in the unit, but you are not receiving rent.  There's a small percentage of tenants that fit into this category, but if you rent units for long enough, you will step on one of these landmines eventually.  If you have been in the business for 30 years and have 100 units when you do, it's not that big of a deal.  However, if it happens to be your first tenant after you bought your first property, a $500K house with no money down, it can be an absolute disaster.

    As to your next question about not counting on appreciation.  I have owned multifamily properties in San Diego since 1999, enough time to see some ups and downs in the market.  I count on cash flow and forced appreciation, never on market appreciation.  I can control cash flow and forced appreciation but I have no control at all over the market in general.   What is the point in speculating that in 20 years, my portfolio might be worth twice of what I paid for it?  A "feel good" exercise?   It's so far out and with so many variables that the number becomes irrelevant. 

    I like to focus on the here and now.  What is this building worth today?  Can I buy it for less than what I think it's worth?  If I have to pay full value, can I negotiate favorable terms on the financing?  Once I own the property, the focus is on what can I do to improve the cash flow from the property?  What can I do to keep it from deteriorating?  What can I do to make it look better?  Can I raise the rents?  All improvements can be checked against the potential increased cash flow by dividing the cash flow with the prevailing cap rate in the area.  For example: It will cost me $10K to rehab an apartment; I can raise the rent by $200/month after the rehab; increased cash flow is $2,400/month; cap rate in the area is 10%; $2,400/.10 is $24,000.  So, if I put in $10K, my building will increase in value by $24K; that's a good return and I would probably do it.

    If you are projecting long term increases in value in order to compare your investment with the stock market, you are missing a crucial differentiation, real estate is not a passive investment.  You need to manage the property, or manage your manager.  You need to stay on top of maintenance, drive by the property on a regular basis and make sure it's still standing and that the curb appeal is preserved.  If you buy the house today, expecting not to touch it and have it be worth $1M in 20 years, you're in for a surprise...

    Market appreciation happens, but don't count on it.   Use it to your advantage when possible, sell properties when the market hits a high, buy properties when the market crashes.  Looking at long term value charts can be helpful, but don't forget that there are many external factors that can affect the appreciation trends, such as inflation, quantitative easing and demographic trends.

    Let me finish by making an analogy between learning to invest in real estate and learning to swim. You can start by jumping in at the deep end and hoping you figure everything out before you drown. Some people have actually done it, survived and done very well for themselves. Another alternative is to start in the shallow end and gradually increasing your depth as your skills and comfort level improves. Your chances of survival and success will dramatically improve, even if it's not as exciting as the first option. Buying a $500K SFR, with no money down and no cash flow, hoping for appreciation is the equivalent of trying to learn to swim by going to the pool in the middle of the night, with no life guard, not knowing if there's even water in the pool, jumping in at the deep end and hoping you figure it out before something bad happens.

    Start at the shallow end my friend, it won't be as exciting, but chances are that you will still be here in 20 years.

    Erik

     Erik, 

    I appreciate the in depth analysis and logic!  I like the swimming analogy.   Thank you!

  • Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 95 posts · 32 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Douglass Benson:

    We started buying apartments in mid Michigan in 2003.  We stared with a four plex and are now up to 81 units.  I assume no appreciation whenever I invest and focus solely on cashflow.  I have all my buildings bank financed and my equity position is quite strong after 13 years on one loan, 10 on another, 6 on another and 5 on another.  We are still only around 25% equity on the two we purchased last year.  

    Cashflow allows me to maintain, upgrade, improve, handle risk, etc., etc., It allows me to run my business.  Cashflow also means all the other bills are being paid i.e, mortgages, taxes, utilities, insurance, etc., etc. 

    If you follow this recipe, one day you will wake up to discover, in a relatively short period of time (10 years), that your balance sheet is good and that the funds you used to achieve such a thing were provided by a tenant...or 81 tenants.  

    Oh, and I should mention - ALL my properties have appreciated in value since I purchased them.  My point is, I never buy banking on appreciation.    

    For me, cashflow is everything and the only thing.

     Douglass!  Thank you for your input and congrats on your success!  Love hearing that story! :)

  • Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 95 posts · 32 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    Here's what I posted in another thread that addresses APPRECIATION, rent growth and cash flow for those of you that need a real life example.  "

    The thing is that you don't hope and pray for appreciation. You put on your businessman pants and calculate your appreciation rate just like you would your rental rates, vacancy rate, expense rate. Oh, you don't calculate those? You just use whatever is posted on the internet. Bad move.

    Anyway I just saw sales from two of my building in the paper last week. One is a smaller unit than mine that sold for $440,000. I bought for $204,000 in 2003. I figure I could sell for $460,000+. The other one I bought in 1978 for $35,000 and the $500,000 sale is identical to mine. The 2008 property I bought for a little over $500,000 had an identical unit sell last month for $900,000!. Paid retail for all three and all three were cash flow negative. So over $900,000 in the equity bank.

    Now back in the 00's there was a local real estate company that was aggressively courting long time Honolulu owners to 1031 to the Mainland for CASH FAUX! His kids moved to the Mainland so I guess they needed the business. I warned anyone that I knew that was considering it. I have flyover experience from being a Realtor in KY and investing in Vegas. Well Honolulu stayed pretty stable and returned to the normal doubling in value every ten years. Everyone that I know that did the exchanges have regretted it as their tenants are 100% opposite of their experience in Honolulu. They have experienced vacancies and repairs and maintenance issues that they never had in Honolulu and their rents AND values DECREASED.

    So because I invest for profit, NOT cash faux and know my appreciation rate I am up in rents and over a million in appreciation."

     Keep Crushing it Bob!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.