Indianapolis Vs. Memphis: Rental Market Showdown

Indianapolis Vs. Memphis: Rental Market Showdown

Rental Property Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2015 · 212 posts · 116 votes

Hello Everyone!

I'm a first-time investor looking to invest in a buy-and-hold SFH that has stable cash-flow in an A to B- neighborhood (any appreciation would be a plus, of course!). I'm looking for properties in the 60-80k range and narrowed down my markets to Memphis and Indianapolis. After some research, I found that both have stable and growing economies, a healthy list of available properties, and good job growth. Each market also has their fair share of "bad" neighborhoods and properties. So my question for you is: which market would you recommend for a first-time investor to jump into? Which zip codes would you recommend? What experiences have you had in these two markets?

Any feedback would be much appreciated. Thank you in advance!

0Reply
188 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 147 posts · 97 votes
10y

interesting showdown. I invest in both of these markets and I love both. I don't think you can find A-B class properties at 60-80k in both markets and especially if you plan to buy from turnkey companies. But I may be wrong and will let the turnkey guys to weigh in. Since the numbers are very similar, My best advise to you is to focus your time on researching the property management company that will manage your property as this factor can make or break your return on investment. I purchased two properties from two different turnkey companies in Memphis. The property that I purchased at a higher priced and at a lower rent (76k at $800) performed  better than the property I purchased at a lower price with a higher rent (62k at $925) why? Mainly because of the quality of the property management company that did a better job rehabbing the property, better job screening a tenant and overall better job managing the asset. 

Good luck

See this reply in the discussion

54 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2013 · 210 posts · 149 votes
    10y

    @Ali Boone

    Tell me which areas are good investments and which are bad for buy and hold? Which areas should someone really stay away from? You know neighborhoods, streets, etc. 

    Are there any good areas to do fix/flips?  If yes, where? 

    What areas do you consider to be up and coming? 

  • Registered Nurse (ICU) · San Jose, CA · Member since 2014 · 496 posts · 332 votes
    10y
    Snehann Kapnadak Listen to Steve Lehman. He is "boots on the ground" in that market and helped me get my start over a year ago. He is a great resource and asks for nothing in return.
  • Real Estate Coach · Venice Beach, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    10y

    @Account Closed

    Not sure I follow. Your title says you are an agent/broker in Indy, so are you quizzing me? I assume you know these things if you are a broker there. Or am I totally missing something?

  • Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2013 · 210 posts · 149 votes
    10y

    @Ali Boone

    First, I find it interesting how you dance around questions instead of just answering them. In the past few days I have seen you do this quite consistently throughout some other threads. 

    Second, if you are able to provide your opinion on which city is better then the other then I am interested in your knowledge of a such city. You must know these cities for you to from an opinion. 

    Third, you are encoarging people to contact you about the Indy market. That tells me that you know this market. Instead of just contacting you why not show people why they should contact you.  

    Please answer my questions that I have provided in my previous post. 

  • Investor · Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2015 · 130 posts · 102 votes
    10y

    I agree with @Ali Boone's post. The team you work with is much more important than the market.

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2009 · 477 posts · 304 votes
    10y

    Let me beat the dead horse. Indy is a good market..

    A to B- properties are going to be in the 80-120k range, but you can get some newer properties in that price range.. My investors and I have had really good luck with the far east side, east of German Church. Recommend 3+ bedrooms 2+ baths 2000+ sq ft... They should rent for $1200+

    Things to bear in mind, it's very easy to get your General Contractors license in Indy, so be aware of that. There's a lot of bad contractors out there.. We get hit up every week/month with long distance investors who have been fleeced. I think that would go for any market though..

    As someone else said it's all about the property management!  We work with lots of national and international investors. We do video's and tons of pictures. I am surprised more PM's aren't on that band wagon.. You need to know what state your properties are in... Seems like every week I get calls from investors who just don't know what is happening with their properties and haven't for several months. This as well goes for any market... 

    Another point about property managers, is look for all the hidden fees.. Are they getting paid even if your unit isn't rented? One of my clients sent me a PM agreement from a competitor.. There was just a ton of fees, and I couldn't see what their motivation was to get the unit rented period.. This PM company kept all late rent fees, and pet fees, etc.. Sure they had a low rate overall, but they more than made up for it.

    Lastly as someone else said you need to check your comps.. Indianapolis is very much street to street on values... I can show you where 1 block ads twice the value. Some of the guys advertising properties on here have a tendency to inflate ARV's(After Repaired Values). Either they are intentionally misleading, or they are horrible at their job... Call local Realtors or Property Managers to get second and third opinions on values. I charge $5 per comp, and that gets you quarter mile radius of properties that are active, pending and sold in last year, plus 2 years of history for rentals within quarter mile(that went through the MLS)... What I am saying is that, it shouldn't be tough or expensive to get multiple comps for a property you are looking at....

    Lastly, get out of analysis paralysis... Pick a spot and go with it... Or start calling property managers in your area and see if you get a good vibe/feel for them and then pick that spot and go with it! haha

  • Rosemead, CA · Member since 2015 · 25 posts · 10 votes
    10y

    Since we're on the topic of property managers, is it expected that the property manager will also have a contractor? Or does one have to look for a property manager and contractor?

    Trying to absorb as much info as possible.

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    10y

    @Jonathan Tea for most of the routine maintenance things, they only need a handy man but they should have a contractor to handle larger tenant turn overs.

  • Investor · Seattle, WA · Member since 2011 · 253 posts · 112 votes
    10y

    My PM has 7 maintenance guys who handle everything from HVAC to roofs to turns.  Good maintenance guys are key to keeping tenants happy and units in good shape!  

  • Real Estate Coach · Venice Beach, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    10y

    @Account Closed

    Sorry you feel that's what I do. I don't answer in a lot of detail to every single question I know an answer to, unless specifically asked to do so (when someone legitimately wants certain information...not when asked to be tested like you did). The reason for this is because I just flat don't have the time to spill my guts about everything I know to every question in these forums. I'd be typing for days. So, I answer generically to start, if asked to specify, I will, but to be honest most of the time people ask me to provide more details it's via PM. And you can ask any of them, I answer fully and I back up what I say in the forums. 

    Sorry again you feel I beat around the bush, but asking me questions to quiz me really isn't the way to approach me about how you feel.

  • Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2013 · 210 posts · 149 votes
    10y

    @Ali Boone

    Just so you understand that I was not quizzing you, I am calling you out. You know little to nothing about the Indy market. Your continued avoidance to answer questions is proof to this. The real reason you don't answer my questions is because it will show your lack of knowledge about the Indy market and you won't take on someone who is actually in the market. It's people like you that are dangerous to newbie investors because you talk behind the scenes, instead of out in the open forum,  and then sales pitch them on your properties in areas you know nothing about. You are nothing more then a promoter who makes a commission on whatever property you sell in whatever city. You are a "Jack of all cities, Master of none!" 

    You have props to push. This is why I have been seeing you talk on the Chicago threads and now this one for Indy.  Speaking of Chicago there was a direct question that was posed to you by an out of state BP member which was about property taxes and you danced around that question to. Apparently from your last post it would have taken you "DAYS" to answer that one. I mean you do have 3K plus posts, you write blogs and articles. I really don't think writing is much of a problem for you but I could be wrong. 

  • Rosemead, CA · Member since 2015 · 25 posts · 10 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Mike D'Arrigo:

    @Jonathan Tea for most of the routine maintenance things, they only need a handy man but they should have a contractor to handle larger tenant turn overs.

    Thanks @Mike D'Arrigo!

  • Real Estate Coach · Venice Beach, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    10y

    @Account Closed

    Again, I'm sorry you feel this way. I'm not sure how not answering every single question in extensive detail is proof that I don't know what I'm talking about. I'm happy to give as much detail as anyone wants or asks for specifically.

    For sure, I will never know as much about one market as someone like yourself who only works in that one market and it's your full-time gig. I do work in several markets, but I can easily answer all of the questions you are saying I can't answer.

    You are very welcome to hold onto your opinion about me and I apologize for any future posts I put out that might irritate you.

  • Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2013 · 210 posts · 149 votes
    10y

    @Ali Boone

    Lol! Since you can answer my questions so easily then answer them. 

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    10y

    @Snehann Kapnadak  @Ali Boone  well to get back on track.

    @Account Closed  one benefit of INDY over Memphis is double taxation.. if you own property in the city of Memphis you pay city tax and county tax .. so one must be very cautious of this.. as property tax's are one thing you can't mitigate with better management better properties etc.

    And for a shameless plug on Brie's site you can take properties from each market ( since we are talking one VS the other) and plug them in side by side and compare the operating expenses from each and draw your own conclusion. one of the great things of turn key reviews.. this is were you can find some good numbers to make your comparisons when your talking one markets over another.

    However its still my humble opinion as one who has worked almost all the Turn key markets that they are somewhat interchangeable.. simply because the PP to rent ratios are about the same. and the renter demographic is the same.. so it comes down to the team.. that will manage your tenant base. 

  • Real Estate Coach · Venice Beach, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    10y

    @Account Closed

    Steve, I have the equivalent of about 3 full-time jobs going on right now. I'm barely keeping up with client emails much less BP forum responses. If you were someone actually needing this information or trying to buy or whatever, I would totally spend the time to answer everything. But you are an Indy expert, you are purely testing me because you already know all the answers, and proving you wrong will benefit me absolutely none. If I wasn't so busy with other things, sure, all day long I could tell you everything I know. 

    You are free to accuse me of dodging your questions (I wouldn't expect different). Anyone else is welcome to message me and ask me directly if they want to know more info about Indy and the specifics. And, I'll even give you this, if someone does and I end up responding in detail to them, I'll copy and paste my answer here for you! :) Otherwise, sorry, not into the games.

  • Rock Hill, SC · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 597 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Ali Boone:

    @Account Closed

    Again, I'm sorry you feel this way. I'm not sure how not answering every single question in extensive detail is proof that I don't know what I'm talking about. I'm happy to give as much detail as anyone wants or asks for specifically.

    For sure, I will never know as much about one market as someone like yourself who only works in that one market and it's your full-time gig. I do work in several markets, but I can easily answer all of the questions you are saying I can't answer.

    You are very welcome to hold onto your opinion about me and I apologize for any future posts I put out that might irritate you.

    Ali I see you are not the only this guy, has some thing to say to.

    I guess some people are just louder then most.

    Steve I actually read quite a few of her post, she sharing experiences. While teaching some folks.

    Alex

  • Rental Property Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2015 · 212 posts · 116 votes
    10y

    Hey Everyone,

    Sorry for the late reply, had to fix my (soon to be retired!) laptop.

    @Account Closed Thanks for the advice. My goal is to become a little more familiar with the statistics first and then follow your recommendation and speak to more people who have properties in those markets. Will look into those 3 providers too. Thanks again.

    @Lee Smith Solid advice. Yeah I def have to change my criteria to fit my price range. I've heard Indy is an interesting street-to-street type of market so thanks for the recommendation of the far east side. And yeah I'm hoping I do my research and find a good PM where I won't have to worry about contractors over charging me or anything. Will keep that in mind though.

    @Jay Hinrichs Hmmm never thought of it from a tax perspective but this is interesting. Haha I'll check out Brie's site once I narrow down my list of properties. So is there a team in particular that you recommend?

    @Ali Boone and @Account Closed, I'm just going to let this one go. Thanks for contributing though! 

  • Rental Property Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2015 · 212 posts · 116 votes
    10y

    Thanks again for everyone who's helped on this post. After doing a little bit more research, I think I'm leaning more towards Indy than to Memphis. Both seem like great markets, but Indy seems more up my alley in terms of growth (and stability as well). Both seem like very "boring" markets haha, which is great for an out-of state investor like me. I especially like the fact that there are a lot of colleges in Indy, and being a recent grad myself, I think I'm attracted to markets where there are colleges nearby that will "feed" students into contributing to the local economy.

    Would love to hear more from other out-of-state investors who've invested in Indy, and from anyone else who has something to share. Thanks again!

  • Professional · Noblesville, IN · Member since 2014 · 222 posts · 66 votes
    10y

    @Snehann Kapnadak I'd be glad to share my experience with the market in Indianapolis.  It's been a very stable market over the long haul for me personally.  Most recently we have been enjoying both appreciation and increasing rents which is a good place to be.  You should come out and get on the ground and see what you think!  I'd be glad to show you around sometime.  

  • Investor · Redmond, WA · Member since 2016 · 267 posts · 110 votes
    7y

    How is Memphis doing now? Is the planned downtown revitalization a really happening? Do you think it will be a impact  

  • American Fork, UT · Member since 2017 · 175 posts · 76 votes
    7y

    @Rudy Manna Memphis is a great market to own property in. The downtown area is constantly being updated. The difficult part of Memphis is finding honest and ethical managers.

  • Property Manager · Memphis, TN · Member since 2019 · 28 posts · 15 votes
    7y

    @Rudy Manna Memphis is constantly growing and currently a great market to get into. Let me know if you have any questions about the area!

  • Investor · Vacaville, CA · Member since 2016 · 433 posts · 249 votes
    7y

    Good stuff happening in Memphis for sure!  The future is bright!

  • Investor · Redmond, WA · Member since 2016 · 267 posts · 110 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Koleton Daley:

    @Rudy Manna Memphis is a great market to own property in. The downtown area is constantly being updated. The difficult part of Memphis is finding honest and ethical managers.

     How is the growth scenario in Memphis? Population seems flat..Are there any key drivers that can drive growth in 2-3 years?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.