Which city in San Francisco bay area should i start

Which city in San Francisco bay area should i start

San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 16 votes

Hello bay area dwellers,

I have been thinking of getting started in real estate by investing in a (MFR) in the bay area. I crunched some numbers to come up with cities that offer highest rent/price ratio (in theory) when looking from high level.

I have only included BART cities in the east bay to limit my search to fewer markets. I have not included Oakland as I think that it's own beast with may sub-markets. Following is a compilation of data I came up with by using city-data.com.

Pittsburg, Richmond, Hayward, Concord and San Leandro seem to be viable options for cities with median price ratio below $500,000, with Pittsburg offering highest rent/price ratio and no rent control. Rent control rules for all these cities are as follows:

Pittsburg - None

Richmond - Multi-unit homes (including duplexes) built before 1995 are rent controlled. Single family homes, certain small second units (“granny units”), and rental of a room within a home are NOT controlled.

Hayward - A landlord must own at least five units in the City of Hayward for the Hayward Rent Ordinance to apply. a tenant who rents a single family home after January 1, 1996 cannot be covered by the rent protection

Concord - No

San Leandro - No rent control. But rent review board ordinance applies to complexes with three or more units

Of course, good and bad deals can be found in each of the above cities. But, would love to know what others think on the ease of finding good MFR deals in any of the above markets? Any suggestions on how to chop up Oakland neighborhoods will also be appreciated so I can add it to the table above.

Thanks much!!

8Reply
332 views

Investor-friendly agents in San Francisco, CA

See the agents BiggerPockets members work with in San Francisco, CA.

Most Popular Reply

J. MartinPro Member
Rental Property Investor · Oakland, CA · Member since 2011 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
9y

@Atish Shah,

With your target GRM and desire for low-crime, good-school district areas, you sort of want the best of both worlds - high cash flow, and a good area likely to have strong single family home appreciation. And I want to be rich and famous. But we both have to struggle with reality hehe You would either need to go somewhere else, or decide which is more important to you (or at least compromise).

Like @Brian Burke is saying, you're looking at single family home prices, but trying to buy more than one unit. You probably need to go even further than what Brian is saying, and compare how much in rents you can get with $X00,000 of a multi-unit building in city 1, vs city 2, vs city 3, etc. Or just call up an agent that deals with them, and they should be able to give you a range of GRM's. CBRE and other commercial real estate brokerages also publish data on GRMs for large multifamily in different cities. You will have a higher GRM for 4-unit buildings and under than for large multifamily, but I think the proportions across different cities will be similar - as a place to start.

If you can get a vacant 4 unit in Richmond, you might be able to get close to 1% / 8-9 GRM(ish). Maybe in Vallejo also, but that's getting further out, and the city's all f**ked up after the BK and high taxes. (Richmond could be going that way too though! lol) @Diane G., play nice with the other kids in the sandbox ;) Atish is trying to learn. I could still buy under a 10 GRM today (especially after some transitioning). @Arlen Chou did the same last year in Oakland, when everyone said it couldn't be done.  Given, they aren't in Silicon Valley... 

@Arlen Chou

See this reply in the discussion

57 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Realtor · San Francisco Bay Area, CA · Member since 2016 · 123 posts · 48 votes
    9y

    @Account Closed  Thank you so much for showing me around!  Your 8-unit is a beauty and I'm shocked that the previous owner did most of the upgrade and you still got it for a good price.  Next time, show me the SJSU building and maybe your friend's 12-unit too ;)

  • San Francisco Bay Area · Member since 2015 · 196 posts · 181 votes
    9y

    @Atish cool data!  Let's meet up n talk shop about oakland. 

    @Nick thanks for posting the link on that retail center I was wondering what that was

  • CA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    @Account Closed

    can I ask what % payment on your 6- and 8- units? 

  • San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 16 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Brian Burke:

    Interesting data...but I wonder how useful it is. If one community has a high number of sales of high-end homes it's median price will skew higher. Those high-end homes aren't typically in the rental pool so there wouldn't be a correspondingly high rental rate to skew the median rent in tandem with the price. 

    For example, in Santa Rosa the median price is $625,000 as of May 2017. But investors don't typically buy $625,000 houses to rent out (in Santa Rosa). Most would tend to buy in the $350K to $500K range. So comparing the price to rent ratio against the median is misleading. 

    The real question would be to compare rents at a specific price point. In other words, what does a $500,000 house rent for in Pittsburg, Hayward, etc.  Then you can get a more accurate ratio...and the result may or may not surprise you. 

    Thank you Brian. That makes complete sense. I will run the numbers as you suggested.

  • San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 16 votes
    9y

    @J. Martin

    Thank you for chiming in. Actually, if you read my post, I never mentioned about good school districts/low crime and cash flow. I understand that's difficult in our market (I won't say impossible) to achieve both. The topic of Hayward/Castro Valley school just came up in conversation. lol

    What you and Brian suggested totally makes sense!!

  • San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 16 votes
    9y

    @Nick James that looks like a great deal, of course only after a lot of sweat equity was put in. I would be up for acquiring a property needing extensive rehab. I will send you a pm. Let's continue the conversation there. And, thanks for offering to help me out!!

  • Investor · Oakland, CA · Member since 2016 · 13 posts · 15 votes
    9y

    @DG A., you are welcome. I too was curious what all the construction was about.

    @Atish Shah, no problem at all. I'm always excited to share what I know!

  • Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Diane G.:

    @Account Closed

    can I ask what % payment on your 6- and 8- units? 

    Diane,

    For the 6-unit we just bought, it's on a bridge loan at 4% IO for 18 months with a 3-yr balloon. The payment is 31.4% of monthly gross rent. Once partially stabilized, we'll do a cash out refi and get about 50% of our equity out of the deal. If we go with a portfolio lender, it's normally a 5/1 ARM with a 10-year balloon on a 30-year amo. If we go with an agency bank like Chase, there's no balloon. Basically, the loan will float after 5 years.

    Looks like the monthly payment is between 42-44% on our other buildings. Hope to get all building fully stabilized or close to it within 2.5-3 years. That's when we'll go back to the bank, do another cash out refinance and get the rest of our equity out of the deal.

    We're wrapping up a loan with FRB right now. This is our trial run on this loan product. We're cashing out $300k in equity and our monthly payment dropped by about $200. Current loan balance is $572k at 3.05% fully amortized. New loan is 875k at 3.2% IO for 10 years. Loan payment goes from $2,564 to $2,333. Zero points but we have to pay for closing costs. 

    Each bank specializes in a certain loan product. It's one of the key components in real estate acquisitions. @Anthony Addessi also finances his stuff from FRB. He says he gets a slightly better rate from FRB than me, but I don't feel bad. 

  • CA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y
    Thanks @ Minh Le
  • San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 16 votes
    9y

    Very well said @Arlen Chou, I totally agree with you. Good food for thought!!

    @Account Closed, sorry I did mean median rent

    @Jen L., do keep us posted when pull the trigger

  • San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 16 votes
    9y

    Thank you @Account Closed, will keep pursuing the "impossible"

  • CA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y
    @ Minh Le - if you come across MFH that you are not interested that is under $2m, let me know????
  • Rental Property Investor · SF Bay Area · Member since 2016 · 234 posts · 103 votes
    9y
    Minh Le thanks for sharing your knowledge and experience to the community and those just starting out like myself, much apprecIated. Do you have time to grab lunch or dinner (on me) in the next few weekends or Friday after work? Will appreciate an hour of your time to get insight on Bay Area REI. Thanks in advance, I'll pm you as well! Cheers :)
  • Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    9y

    @Fernando E., 

    Thanks for the tag. Dinner is typically a no. Lunch is a maybe. Weekends are always bad. As much as I don't work very hard, it seems like I always have things to do. ;)

    @Diane G., the cash out refinance completed in late June. Cashed out $294k. The friend closed on her 12-unit building earlier this month. She got 3.6% for a 5/1 ARM on her building with no points. Appraisal came in $50k higher than the contract price. In this market? Just made it a little sweeter for her as she and her hubby are really happy with the purchase.

    A couple units turned over last month, which gave us a chance to increase the rents to fair market on another building. This made another building exceed the 1% rule, and we still have 2 more units that are below market. That's the thing I love about our market. The rent growth is phenomenal. Two buildings are at 0.94% and 0.97%. Hope to get them to 1% sometime next year when we turnover the last couple of units. 

    Our market is for the patient investors and those who know where to look for value. No need to chase those OOS properties which look good on paper, but nothing other than a bottomless pit. 

    Just wrapped up talking to our lender Chase on a refinance. Initially, I thought we could cash out $350k-$400k. He came back and said we can cash out $460k based on his analysis. If appraisal comes back favorable, we can cash out $560k. DSCR is not the issue. What's not to love about our market? The cash out money is tax-free/deferred too, and Chase will also waive the prepayment penalty. Who said you can't have your cake and eat it too? What's the point of having your cake and can't eat it? You can have both.

    I LOVE OUR MARKET! I should probably shut up and let others go OOS so there's less competition. (Evil laugh)

  • CA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    @minh le

    But that "5 year ARM" thing is why I could not pull the trigger on MFH....Lol

    With my existing rental properties, always fixed rates... used to be 30 year fixed, now 20 year fixed... So I ALWAYS know worst case sceniro....

    With commercial loan, you have to jump thru the hoops every 5 years... What if economy takes a down turn, vacancy is 40% WHILE you are in between jobs, then what? foreclosure?

    I may sound super conservative, but as we all know, one misstep can wipe it all out....

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    9y
    Diane G. What I've done/do on my 5 year loans (I have lots) is every few years ask for a modification. I just had my bank "renew" two 5 year loans that were 2.5 and 3 years old. They reset my clock. Both are 4.75%. They know I could refi with another bank and get 4.25-4.5 so they were happy to keep the loans on their books. I was happy to have my 5 year clock reset. Since they are 20 year am notes (which can still provide good cash flow in houston) by the time they expire (if I still have them) a giant chunk of principle will have been paid down. Although I've been getting "5 year loans" for 10 years I've never had one expire and now that I just renewed my two oldest, my next oldest is just 1.5 years
  • CA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    @ cody L. = interesting..  I did not know you could do that....Thanks for sharing..

  • Hadar OrkibiPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · USA / NZ · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 812 votes
    9y

    @Cody L. have you been on the podcast yet?  if not they should get you on. 

    @Mindy Jensen this guy have wealth of knowledge and experience. 

    I think Cody have a lot he can share and enrich our knowledge.

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    9y
    Hadar Orkibi I wouldn't be a great guest. I think much of my advise runs counter to most people here. also I'm not trying to self promote. I'm happy just answering questions when I can.
  • Rental Property Investor · SF Bay Area · Member since 2016 · 234 posts · 103 votes
    9y

    @Account Closed you're a very busy man :) If you don't mind, I hope to ping you for you thoughts on bay area investments, will very much appreciate your opinion. Thanks in advance, cheers! 

  • Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Diane G.:

    @ cody L. = interesting..  I did not know you could do that....Thanks for sharing..

    Hi Diane,

    It's the lack of knowledge that scares folks. Once you understand how commercial loans work, you won't go back to residential loans. You heard that right.

    As @Cody L. mentioned above, commercial loans are negotiable and quite flexible. Based on my experience, commercial loans are 3, 5, 7 and 10/1 ARM with a 10-year balloon if you go with portfolio lenders while there's no balloon with agency banks like Chase. Basically, your loan will become adjustable after year 5. In general, there's prepayment penalty. However, if you refinance with them after 2 years, the prepayment penalty will be waived as they want to keep your loan on their book.

    My partner and I don't fit in the W-2 box so we don't qualify for residential loans, but we can almost name our terms with our commercial lenders. It's quite cool when you can go into a bank and literally underwrite your own loans. Can't do that with residential loans.

    Competition for MF loans is fierce in our market so banks tends to put their best foot forward to compete for your business. That's not the case with residential loans. Each lender specializes in a niche. You just have to know which lender to go to get the loan you need. 

    Real estate is a puzzle. Know which agents who have the best deals in your market; know which sellers to buy from; know which lender to finance your deal from; and know which buyers to sell to. Good deals don't tend to see daylight.

    @Fernando E., regardless of what type of investment you want to get into, find your niche. Riches are in the niches. Otherwise, you'll be ordinary like all other investor wannabes. You'll be at the mercy of the market when you're paying retail prices and/or don't have multiple exit strategies. 

    Best of luck.

  • CA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    interesting.. thank you @Account Closed

    now you just have to pass me some off-market deals that you are not interested....

  • Rental Property Investor · SF Bay Area · Member since 2016 · 234 posts · 103 votes
    9y

    @Account Closed thank you for the advice, I'll continue to grow & expand my knowledge and network so I can focus on a specific market niche! Hope to see you guys around in the REI meet up in the bay area, Cheers!

  • Rental Property Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    OMG I actually agree with something @Diane G. wrote- her concern with commercial loans. 

    Yes they can be flexible products but what you guys are forgetting is that during the 2008-10 Great Recession you couldn't get your bank to renew your loan for the life of you. LOTS, And I mean LOTS of people lost commercial properties during that time (even class A safe and solid properties in prime Bay Area markets) if they had to refi their loan during that time. 

    Now there are ways to mitigate that risk. You can get a 3,5,7,10/30, so worse case you go adjustable and may hit your cap. I believe caps are ~11-12%. Is that right @Account Closed ? (Or at least they were a decade ago.) Or you could do a 15/15, but then your payment is quite high from the get go. Ballon payment loans are the risky ones if we have an outlier problem in the financial markets. Basically the loan situation is another variable you need to deal with in commercial, where with 2-4, especially if you really keep them long term, you lock that 30yr fixed and forget about it. 

    So let's say you get a 10/30. The risk then is that you work hard for 10 years, grow your rents nicely, and if you're stuck with a higher interest rate down the road you basically wipe out all that rent gain, which would really suck. Basically, the banks are happy to refi you up the ting yang when rates are low and their is plenty of liquidity. The risk is dealing with that when those factors aren't there, and you will need to deal with them down the road, and they could significantly impact your future cash flow, or even your ability to get another loan. And then your only choice is to sell the property. And of course property values are systematically down in that scenario, and then you're really pissed off and f*ucked due to market conditions. BUT, the next guy buying from you will probably be happy he's getting a great deal at the bottom of the market. You want to be that guy, not the guy forced to sell to him!

    But ultimately you're always taking some risk when growing your RE asset base. Especially if you're refinancing to pull cash out and buy another property. The key is knowing when to stop! Of course with MF you don't need to rely on personal income, but you do need serious cash assets for the down payment and reserves. In my case, 2-4's, soon I'll show enough income from the properties to make another purchase if I want to. So that gives me a certain safety factor of not over leveraging. But personally I'm not doing that, as I think the economy is in precarious time polically. While I don't think we will encounter another Great Recession, I wouldn't be surprised if some strange black swan event has some adverse effect on RE, and I don't want my numbers to be tight. I saw lots of people get ruined by the Great Recession, and commercial loans was just one aspect of that. So I personally prefer to take that variable off the table. 

  • Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    9y

    @Amit M.,

    I'm glad you and @Diane G. finally could agree on something. LOL! 

    Please let me repeat this: "It's the lack of knowledge that scares folks." Had I possessed the knowledge I now have, I wouldn't have seated on the sidelines and waited for a decade before I went all in in 2009. Fortunately, things have worked out.

    Let me ask you this question, how many MF loans (5+ units) went into default during the Global Financial Crisis? I was a trustee sale buyer so I got to witness it with my own eyes. Hardly any. The ones that went into default were 1-4 units. I saw some shopping centers and vacant land went into foreclosure too, but hardly 5+ units made it to the courthouse steps.

    With respect to balloon payment, there's NO balloon payment if you go with the bigger/agency banks. With portfolio lenders such as FRB where a 10-year balloon payment is the norm, the maximum LTV is 65% at the moment and they're talking of reducing it to 60% LTV given where we are in the cycle of the market. Basically, there's built-in safety factor because the banks are in the business of lending, not foreclosing.

    Let me ask you another question. Would you rather have $1M in your bank account and have $1M mortgage on your 5+ unit building at 3.25% with a 5-year fixed and a 10-year balloon, or would you rather have no money in the bank and own the asset free and clear? The interest rate cap is normally your interest rate plus 6% or thereabouts. If we enter a recession/depression, where do you think interest rates would be? Don't you think cash would be king at that time? Wouldn't having $1M in liquidity give you the leverage to renegotiate your loan terms with your lender, or go shopping for better deals?

    Real estate is about control, leverage and liquidity. You'll have to model your real estate investments to fit your life circumstance. 30-year fixed mortgages come at a premium cost. Knowing what I know now, I can confidently say I would never get another 30-year fixed mortgage ever again. Of course, that's just me.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.