The Coming Death of Airbnb

The Coming Death of Airbnb

Investor · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2017 · 11 posts · 22 votes

I have had a number of investors that have been excited to take advantage of airbnb with their rental properties and their own homes. Numerous clients of mine and aquaintances have already cashed in on airbnb. Properties that would normally bring in $1,200 a month are now receiving that in a matter of days. To further the frenzy, the Twin Cities will host the 2018 Super Bowl, nothing seems sweeter than getting $10,000 or more for one week's rent in February in Minnesota. 

I am all for capitalism and this is exactly what makes America great, however don't plan on cashing in on airbnb for the long-term. Despite the thousands of ecstatic owners that have used this great platform to earn new wealth, there are those that are being hurt by it. Airbnb directly injures hotels business. I know, you're not shedding tears for Paris Hilton and her pals, but owners that are currently cashing in on airbnb are already feeling their wrath. 

New York City, recently adopted legislation to ban any rentals shorter than 30 days. Airbnb spent $10 million fighting the legislation and then dropped a lawsuit after the city promised to only pursue the property owners and not Airbnb. In February, the New York Post reported that Hank Fried and a Real Estate Broker, Tatiana Cames, were collectively fined $17,000 for 17 violations. They are required to pull their Airbnb listings and will have the $1000 violation increased to $5000 each and then $7,500 each for a third violation. 

Similar bans have happened in Colorado, San Antonio, and Santa Monica. Hotels are the big ugly Gorilla that will cause problems for Airbnb, but they aren't the only problem that is surfacing. In Minneapolis, in 2010 the city collected $61 Million in revenue from the extra tax that they add to hotels. Couple this with the additional tax revenue that will be aversely affected by Airbnb, and the same folks that govern rentals will be looking to kill Airbnb because of the lost revenue. Restaurants, are losing revenue, along with downtown areas, as many of the Airbnb units are removed from the more densely populated areas. Once again, this will hurt large cities revenue sources.

Finally,  in large cities and vacation areas, voters will push Airbnb out of their communities. Politicians will respond to home-owners that vote, and many of them will complain about the tenants that are in the short-term Airbnb units. As a rental property owner, I know that it can be difficult to deal with tenants that are loud or disruptive to neighbors, this issue will be out of hand for many airbnb owners. After all, what are the consequences for a tenant that is in the property for two days, and then leaves the morning after they have kept the neighbors up all night. 

I am not against Airbnb, but I feel the end of this great revenue source is near.

7Reply
237 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Agent · Colorado | stan.store/JamesCarlson · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
9y

@Jason Reed

I think typewriters, hardback encyclopedias and, more recently, taxi cabs might have something to say about the staying power of disruptive technologies. An interesting take on Airbnb, for sure, but one I completely disagree with. More and more, people around my age or younger (and even older) are looking to Airbnb instead of hotels. Full kitchen and living space, outside the hotel district, often cheaper price? That is quite appealing to people. Right or wrong, what the market wants, the market usually gets.

There is no broad brush painting of cities' Airbnb laws. New York and San Francisco have certainly tried to ban all or portions of this industry. Take a quick look at the Airbnb site, and you'll see that's not working so well.

The laws are a patchwork of political positions across the country. Just 100 miles apart, three cities here in Colorado offer a perfect example of the variety of regulation. Liberal Boulder has very restrictive laws that, in certain scenarios, only allow you to host for parts of the year and only in your owner-occupied primary residence. A little further south in only slightly-less liberal Denver, the rules also restrict it to your primary residence, but tenants can also Airbnb and anyone who's legally doing it can do it all year round. Travel an hour south to conservative Colorado Springs and property rights rule. That city has no restrictions on short-term renting a property or properties. I've talked to the planner who oversees this stuff, and they have no plans to restrict that.

(BTW, I know the Airbnb and short-term rental laws quite well here, and I don't know of any "ban" on Airbnb in Colorado.)

To your other points:

  • Some restaurants may be losing out, but others are winning. Airbnb tends to take visitors to the non-hotel districts where local restaurants are capitalizing off an influx of new visitors. 
  • And any argument that can be made about a short-term tenant can be made about a long-term tenant. A bad STR tenant is gone in a few days. A disruptive LTR tenant is there for a year.

There are certainly downsides to Airbnb -- both to a city and to a landlord and neighborhood. But on the whole, I think Airbnb is a wonderful evolution of the accommodations market, and I don't see it going anywhere.

See this reply in the discussion

38 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Grand Junction, CO · Member since 2017 · 207 posts · 201 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Jason Reed:

    Finally, to the uneducated person from South Carolina, I am not in Canada, and we are much more advanced in Minnesota than you may know, and I am not being negative. 

     He was directing his statement to Thomas from Canada.  Please reread since you are claiming someone as being uneducated.

  • Investor · Moscow, ID · Member since 2017 · 107 posts · 76 votes
    9y

    I'd argue that you are more likely to see changes to AirBnB - stricter rules, maybe even a tax, or something like that rather than an outright death.

    The supply will become more and more saturated and profit margins will become slimmer in most areas. But will likely remain profitable when well ran for the foreseeable future.

    Still, always smart to have an exit plan.

  • Manvel, TX · Member since 2014 · 309 posts · 127 votes
    9y

    @Timothy Church, we live about 40 miles from Galveston and are not in a flood zone, thankfully.   How does flood insurance impact profitability in Galveston?  I would think the rates would be pretty steep!

  • Rental Property Investor · Arlington, TX · Member since 2016 · 706 posts · 611 votes
    9y

    I definitely see your concern. I personally don't think this will happen. Airbnb has already put in several safe guards by collecting occupancy taxes on city and states behalf. As long as they are getting their cut I don't think this will be a problem. I think the hotel industry has more to be fearful about than Airbnb because Airbnb is now paying the same taxes as the hotels but offering more services. You mean to tell me I can get a room or an entire apartment cheaper than a hotel with a full kitchen, cooking utensils, BBQ grills, and a host that will help me with anything that I need. I think I'll go the Airbnb route. Airbnb is definitely here to stay. Taxi companies did their best to get rid of Uber and it didn't work. Turo is about to be doing the same against the car rental companies. I think the share economy is just in its beginning stages. 

    As far as the cities that are opposed to Airbnb and don't allow it then the exit strategy to Airbnb is corporate rentals. I had to turn one of my Airbnb's into a corporate rental and it pays just as much as airbnb but with much less turn over and work.

  • Troy GandeeBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Charleston, SC · Member since 2013 · 795 posts · 454 votes
    9y

    I don't think Airbnb is a train that be stopped easily. The major players of the shared economy are some of the highest valued businesses out there right now. I know my wife and I almost always stay in an airbnb when we travel and I have plenty of peers that do the same. In SC, we do have an accommodations tax within Airbnb now. The hotel industry was trying desperately to snuff Airbnbs here and their main argument was the lack of taxation, so we've now introduced a tax to the transaction that the State will see and hopefully that argument will be squelched. The city of Charleston has also created a small overlay for short term rentals in the downtown area, which has frustrated a lot of people, but they're still thriving in that area. We're actually in the process of setting our detached garage up to be a short term rental. A lot of people in our Neighborhood in Park Circle (North Charleston) do it and so far, there is no barring of them. Most people seem not to mind. 

  • Chicago, IL · Member since 2017 · 12 posts · 6 votes
    9y

    Totally agree with @James Carlson here - Millennials and more travelers, in general, are choosing Airbnb as an alternative. In 2015, the average age of an Airbnb guest (not host) was 35. The average host age is actually older. There is definitely pushback from many hotel companies who recognize it as a disruptor, but some hotel companies are even emulating Airbnb in their strategic plans. Bottom line is that the demand for home-sharing is clearly there. Airbnb has even discussed expanding into localized tours and experiences beyond just lodging, something that cruise lines have implemented for some time now. 

    As has been mentioned, it comes down to the specific city market. New York and San Francisco (both major hotel markets with high housing demand) will inevitably have that push back, but there are many cities that actually work with Airbnb to promote tourism. It's not a perfect product, and hotels aren't disappearing anytime soon. Airbnb still needs to address quality standard and safety concerns. To that end, Airbnb isn't going away either. 

    @Thomas S. to your point of people just buying hotels, a demand that hotels haven't been able to quite fully address yet is the fact that Airbnb offers its travelers the opportunity to travel to less traditionally focused tourism areas. For example, there are plenty of hotels in Manhattan, but for someone who wants an "off-the-beaten-path" experience in Woodside in Queens, it doesn't make sense financially for hotels to invest in larger-scale hotels if the demand is micro - something that a few Airbnb's could meet. 

    @Chris Armstrong There are also some opportunities to invest in hotels without having to pay for a hotel outright. Hotel crowdfunding - and real estate crowdfunding - have been around for awhile as well, offering opportunities to investors who are looking to get into larger scale projects but can't attain the leverage they need if they were working alone. 

    Overall, I think that there's definitely significant overlap in the lodging market between hotels and Airbnb, but there's also quite a bit the market that traditional hotels satisfy more effectively than Airbnb (and vice versa). It really comes down to the specific city and region. If anything, Airbnb could be a healthy push to hotel companies to evolve. 

  • Investor · Roche Harbor, WA · Member since 2016 · 3 posts · 4 votes
    9y

    @Thomas S.

    I have to agree with @Chris Armstrong, if not in tone at least in content.  I own 10 Airbnb condos (legal, non-conforming) in a 40 unit complex.  Upon purchasing them, I rehabbed them to bring them up to the quality expectations of my guests and they are now the 10 finest units in the complex.  The tenant quality level of my guests exceeds the general tenant quality of the complex.  My guests are typically quiet couples, up to families of 4, with discretionary income and an abundance of courteousness.  As a result, the other owners have begun rehabbing their own places with the net result of much higher rents (up to 40% over 2 years) for the long term rentals, better clientele throughout, and overall improvement of the complex and grounds.

    I'm not presuming that my experience is everyone's.  I am, however, disagreeing with your assertion that vacation rental property hurts surrounding home/condo owners.  Yes, I undermine the "hotel" industry by offering a better product for 50-80% less--which allows my guests to stay in town longer and spend their money on other establishments,  as well as affording an opportunity for some people to visit our resort community who would otherwise be priced out of the market.

    I pay both sales and lodging tax (actually collected and remitted by Airbnb).  I pay business taxes monthly.  I am inspected by the Bureau of Labor and Industries. And I believe that vacation rental owners should be required to meet all the regulations placed upon the hotel industry (with a goal of reducing them upon everybody) so that no individual or business is advantaged over its competitors at a governmental level.

    Within those parameters, individual property owners should be able to exercise their property rights, and free-market capitalism should be allowed to do its magic by determining the supply and demand value of rental properties.  A surprising amount of bad information is furthered by those who resent the success of others--usually with a cry for a government ban on freedom.

  • Real Estate Agent · Galveston, TX · Member since 2015 · 255 posts · 219 votes
    9y
    Leigh Ann Smith The cost of insurance eventually just becomes another number you have to work with. It is required on any financed property and the rates are set by the government. It's as guaranteed as death and taxes. You just have to make sure that any deal you analyze take it into account with a conservative estimate. Margins can still be great with it!
  • Realtor · Charleston, SC · Member since 2016 · 229 posts · 159 votes
    9y

    @Jason Reed 

    I appreciate the comment but before you go casting stones around here make sure you have the correct context of the situation and conversation. Seems like we lost you in the fine print, which, in your area of expertise is really important.  

  • Realtor · Charleston, SC · Member since 2016 · 229 posts · 159 votes
    9y

    Just to set the record straight. It was not just Thomas who sent me into the melt down but rather the large amount of people who continuously try to shut out the little guy. I constantly see people who are vehemently opposed to smaller entities making a profit. I get so sick of it also because this is a capitalistic society in which we live and for the most part people love capitalism....until it threatens their existence or their operations. No one likes government intervention (prohibitive regulations) for the most part while they are building themselves up, but once they are up an running the idea of a threat from a disruptive technology has people crying and claiming it isn't fair the little guys can do this or that. We let me just tell you that life isn't fair. The thing that sets apart winners from cry baby losers are those who find a way to make it work and hustle hard every day to build their empire. Its really sad that some people don't see the beauty in that either. By taking the chance away from the little guy you are crushing capitalism. End rant 

    @Tim Daniels

    @Tim Daniels

    @Troy Gandee did you all purchase the craftsman style house in park circle off of Pittman street with the detached garage unit behind it? It was on the market for a total of like 1 day before it had an offer. I believe it was listed for 135k. 

  • Troy GandeeBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Charleston, SC · Member since 2013 · 795 posts · 454 votes
    9y

    @Chris Armstrong no. We bought one on Crawford in March. I didn't buy it specifically for the garage. I was going to put my office in there because there was already a full bath, but we decided we could probably do very well making it a short term rental. I'm still in the middle of renovating it. It was in awful shape.

  • Real Estate Broker · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2014 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y

    I don't see this as the death of Airbnb but the death of hotels. A buddy of mine just had an Airbnb sharing a room in a grandma's house. She cooked him eggs, bacon, hash browns, and served it with homemade orange juice. He went for a run and on his return found that she'd tidied his room, folded his clothes, and hat a big glass of sun tea waiting for him. 

    I view Airbnb like Uber. With Uber I can go to a place I'm not familiar with, meet someone local, get recommendations on what to do, and feel more "at home" with a ride waiting for me. 

    Hotels on the other hand while they have a certain "charm" I know less and less people (in my age group) actually using them. 

    I'm going to Columbia (South America) later this year with some friends and we didn't even look at hotels. Sure they'll put up a fight... But they won't win. 

  • Investor · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2016 · 12 posts · 3 votes
    9y

    @Travis Dawson I totally agree with you. Someday we'll look back and say... "hey remember when there weren't any taxes or rules on airbnb?!" But yeah, I really don't think it's going away and I definitely wouldn't advise anyone to run their numbers or bank on airbnb income exclusively.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.