Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
Well, I guess we (collectively) are going to see how smart Robert Kiyosaki is, at least when it comes to predictions. On a news program he makes the bold prediction that real estate & the stock market are going to crash hard in October because of money velocity and money printing. The whole interview is below, but his predictions come about the 4:30 minute mark or so. The host prompts him several times for what, if anything, is the trigger for this and he demurs.
Of course, he's looking forward to it because, in his words, "I get to make a lot of money". He also advises taking most/all of your free money and putting it into gold, silver and bitcoin right now (that title is off on the video). He says it's going to be the biggest crash in world history (his words).
Now that I've grabbed you with the clickbait title :) - what do *you* think? Major RE crash in October like Kiyosaki says?
@JD Martin I agree with him in VERY broad terms. The stock and real estate markets just don’t make sense right now, and some sort of correction is coming. Is that next week or next month? I don’t think so. Next year . . . more likely. But who knows. My crystal ball has never worked very well for me.
People have been saying theres going to be a crash for the past 5 years. It's tough to time the market. Buy good fundamental real estate that cash flows and have cash reserves.
Great point - "stock market of course has much greater velocity than real estate vis a vi crashing and rising from what i have seen.. But as it relates to real estate its just not possible for an entire market to crash in one month's time.. you can't even get title work done these days in less than few weeks.. :) Foreclosures take months and months if not years and years."
In New York State that is especially true, both closings & foreclosures take a long time.
History repeats itself, but often not in the exact same way. The politicians in power will want to act in a way the doesn't let the economy crash, because a bad economy hurts their chances of re-election. That will probably be the biggest factor in whether they change interest rates or the tax code. If the "infrastructure" bill passes (I use quotes because who knows what's actually in these bills, allegedly the "covid" bill was only 9% covid related) then spending more & incurring even more debt after that will be more difficult.
As a guy who has a lot of respect for RK I wish he wouldn't make these predictions. They are generally wrong and it is a little embarrassing. It gives his detractors lots of ammo to under mind his overall message that the system is not made to help out people working hard, being smart is well and good but knowing the rules of the game and how it is played is much more important.
I have been saying we are due for a crash for ten years and I believe it now more than ever. I do think there will be hell to pay for printing money out of thin air.
Full disclosure no one pays me to make predictions and I am smart enough not to take any of my own advice! LOL
@JD Martin I know many say Kyosaki has said this many times, but I can’t write off his predictions. It is a matter of probabilities not certainties….as George Gammon (Rebel Capitalist) always points out.
I don’t see many indications that the economy is rock solid, that’s for sure.
Government mandates and lockdowns don’t appear to be going anywhere, and supply chain issues are getting worse. High inflation, increased money supplies and endless social assistance programs aren’t going to make investors feel any warmer inside.
writing is on the wall with our fiscal policies recently. It is impossible to tell when a downturn will occur. But, the stock market is not going to give good returns for the foreseeable short-term future IMHO. Also, Have we really changed the lending practices of 2008? Once inflation hits faster than appreciation (can we say this is happening now?) we will see an increase of supply to the market driving down prices. Tough for some to pay mortgage/rent with $10 gallon of milk and no job. Hiring signs are everywhere and now we are firing even more workers with the vaccine mandates without unemployment benefits. Taxes will be increasing on businesses and will be passed on to the consumer. Money printer running out of ink. People will be struggling soon. If you see a Rosy picture you may be sheltering in place too long.
After All this..long-term..I'm always bullish. But, do I have cash on the side and bitcoin. Yes.
I agree with what he is saying. The policies in place by the current administration are disastrous. Pray they don't get this fiscal policy through. That said, we are currently facing Stagflation which is missing one key piece, high unemployment. However, stock market correction will not be on cheap money. It was on Evergrande in China. They have missed their payment and this will crush China Real Estate and investment into US Market. We don't know the ramifications yet.
Not sure about Gold and silver falling, bitcoin been watching and looking for another leg down. RE - don't see massive default in the housing market, fantastic debt to value ratios. Very strong. Stocks looking at a correction. Going shopping...
This moron has been calling for a crash for 30 years. It’s the same old song and dance….say something inflammatory to get attention and interviews, and push your book during those interviews. The only bold piece of what he is saying in that interview is to predict the month and year as if he has a crystal ball. It’s absolute trash and I’m not afraid to say so.
I am and will always be a huge RK fan. RDPD changed my life, I’ve read it 4-5 times, have had my son read it and enjoy all of his books. With that said he is a CAPITALIST and in his recent interviews, podcasts etc states that even more than he ever has in the past. His latest book is “The Capitalist Manifesto”. He knows exactly what he is doing and makes millions doing so as like i said he knows exactly what he is doing and does not care what anyone thinks. He’s been extremely bullish on silver and gold over the past few years and it would not surprise me if he’s got a stake in numerous gold companies or he’s just simply trying to increase demand to increase the value of the gold he holds in his portfolio. Whatever the motive he’s doing it to make more money and he will. The man has built an incredible brand recognized worldwide and has sustained that success for over what 25 years.
If a guy is so good at predicting financial events, he would be managing a trillion dollars on Wall Street vs spewing BS to the young, broke and the naïve. Ask RK to face off with a wall street money manager who really knows a thing or two about forecasting, RK wont show up. Ask RK to debate a CFO or CIO or a CEO or a major corporation, he would decline knowing he wont be able to hold a candle in that debate. RK will even fear to debate a bunch of HBS or Wharton MBA candidates But then ask RK to talk to a bunch of financially illiterate people, RK will show up and hold court. Someone said it well, this guy wrote half of a decent book 25 years ago but in todays world he is irrelevant. So how does he stay relevant? By spewing BS. Remember he DOES not make his money investing, he makes his money selling books and videos and seminars.
I'm not necessarily trying to back Kiyosaki and his predictions (I have no idea what they are and haven't watched the video. I'll take everyone's word), but I will say that my own personal opinion is that we keep borrowing our way out of downturns. It's pretty difficult to have a market dump when you keep injecting it with trillions of dollars. However, at some point, I'd think that would lead to inflation. I think it's miraculous how many trillions our economy has absorbed without inflation since 2008. At some point, that's gotta end, no? Maybe not as I've been wrong so far...
Regardless, I'm still buying just in case inflation hits, cuz I don't see rents dropping at that point...
Inflation:) Take home prices and how they have skyrocketed over the past 3 years and especially the past 12 months. Even the crappiest of hoods in the country have appreciation double digits. Today there are more 'investors' borrowing way out of their league to join the "FIRE" movement. Happened in 2008. Lots of "Investors" who read Rdpd went broke in a big way.
Is trouble coming? Yes it is but not because uncle Robert says it is. The fundamentals will tell you that trouble is coming. What has saved us so far is the massive tech economy which keeps churning out massive productivity gains and capital efficiency + growing imports from China and other countries. That has what has helped the economy absorb the inflation to some extent.
I'm not necessarily trying to back Kiyosaki and his predictions (I have no idea what they are and haven't watched the video. I'll take everyone's word), but I will say that my own personal opinion is that we keep borrowing our way out of downturns. It's pretty difficult to have a market dump when you keep injecting it with trillions of dollars. However, at some point, I'd think that would lead to inflation. I think it's miraculous how many trillions our economy has absorbed without inflation since 2008. At some point, that's gotta end, no? Maybe not as I've been wrong so far...
Regardless, I'm still buying just in case inflation hits, cuz I don't see rents dropping at that point...
A real estate crash takes about 1 year. The first step is a large increase in inventory on the market and/or a steep decline in sales. Most sellers will still try to sell for top dollar and keep their price up with only small price reductions. A lot of people just decide not to sell when they don’t get the expected price, only few extreme desperate sellers will drop more to sell quickly. At the end of 2006 houses suddenly stopped selling and inventory increased but prices maxed out in 2007 and didn’t drop much until a year later.
Like a broken clock is right twice a day! RK has called for a cash 54 times in the last 10 years. This video is only interesting because the anchor is attractive. Outside of that Kiyosaki continues to spew BS that makes the pros laugh at him like they always do. But that said Kiyosaki has a huge following among the young, broke and the naive. People who will pay their hard earned money for his books and lectures. I won’t be surprised if he is coming out with another book and this is part of the promo. But hey as long as there is widespread financial illiteracy in the world, guys like Kiyosaki will continue to prosper and amass wealth.
Yep I think this interview is the promo for his new book
I haven’t drank the kool-aid (millenials, look up Jim Jones-mass murderer) on Kiyosaki predictions. Its seems like a feeble attempt to stay relevant or promote his stuff. I lost everything in 2008. Now I buy defensively and have 2 to 3 pivots or exit strategies ready for market shifts.