What beats apartment syndication returns for passive income?

What beats apartment syndication returns for passive income?

Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2017 · 69 posts · 64 votes

Say I am an accredited investor and I want to allocate $500k for a type of investment that should be capital preserving; completely passive; and generates $100k annually in income.  In general that's a tough row to hoe, as the classic truly passive income flows almost never get near 20%.  But it does seem like even (relatively) conservative apartment syndication deals do hit that mark, over time.

Here's my thinking.  I take my $500k and I invest it into apartments in an investment ladder, with $100k invested each year.  That could be one property at $100k or two at $50k each.  Each year I invest $100k more until after year five, all of my cash is in between 5 and 10 apartments.

A typical deal, from what I've seen, may return 8% annually in dividends and 175% (including initial investment) during a sale in year 5.  That's a 2.1x multiplier.  This is what it looks like to me:

The 8% isn't a lot and it will increase to only $40k a year when all $500k is in play.  But on year 5, I get the original $100k back plus an extra $75k, leaving my annual return at $115k -- just above my target.  I then take my returned capital from year 1 and invest it again.

After this, there's always my one or two properties from 5 years earlier going up for sale, and so my annual return will stay at $115k (22%) indefinitely, until I finally stop the ladder.

When that happens, I will temporarily have an extra $100k each year for 5 years.

On the surface, this seems like it beats pretty much all other truly passive investments for annual income generation.   Therefore:

1. What am I missing?

and

2. What is better than this?

8Reply
429 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2015 · 764 posts · 953 votes
9y

@Kurt Granroth

It's a great plan and I'd like to add a little more insight.

I'm doing the same thing but have come to the conclusion that I need to average my return on equity (NOT CoC) to ~12%. So... if I want 1.2m in passive income (I'm a 10x kind of guy) I need to work hard to earn $10,000,000 (1.2m divided by 12%) in equity. How do I do this?

1: Grow an operating business or income stream that generates excess cash flow (for me it's a property management and syndication business). For you it might be a day job, new biz venture, etc. 2: Invest the cash into income producing assets that generate the best risk adjusted return while greatly protecting hard earned principal (for me it's workforce apartments in great locations, with long term, fixed rate debt). 3. Reinvest distributions and refinance liquidity events from these projects into new income producing assets. Simple formula that takes a lot of discipline and a ton of perspiration to execute.

Looking forward to connecting. 

See this reply in the discussion

77 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · North Richland Hills, TX · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Kurt Granroth:

    The question I asked to start this thread was "What beats apartment syndication returns for passive income?" and it's far to consider if index funds in the stock market fit that bill.  I do have precisely one data point in that regard, now, as my very first deal has sold. Now that its cycle has completed, I have final numbers that can be compared to alternate options.

    In particular, what if I had used the initial capital to invest in VTSAX, the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index. That is as "passive" as you can get. In the alternate timeline, I simply collect the dividends rather than re-invest them and sell the stock on the same day as the MFA deal closed. Here are the results:

    MFA
    Multiple:
    1.32x
    Annualized CoC: 11.24%

    VTSAX
    Multiple: 1.51x
    Annualized CoC: 17.5%

    So, yeah, in this specific case, the stock market easily beat the syndication for passive returns.

    Yes, I do get that the stock market returns are largely due to the inexplicably bullish 2020, whereas MFAs all tended to do relatively poorly that specific year. This deal was also considered somewhat under-performing which is why it was even sold so early, and so doesn't necessarily (hopefully) reflect the rest of my portfolio. I also still have tax benefits from the MFA including the 1031 where I'm pushing my sale proceeds plus the remaining excess passive losses that should be shielding me in the future. And finally, this is literally just one data point out of what will be many data points, so I really can't read anything meaningful from it.

    Still... VTSAX for the commanding win, this time.

    It's as "apples to oranges" as it gets! You cannot cherry-pick a single MFA investment and compare it with a basket of 5000+ stocks. You need to have statistically comparable baskets.

    E.g. 500 MFAs over 50 states vs. S&P 500. Otherwise, anything can be proven or disproven with this kind of comparison.

  • Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2017 · 69 posts · 64 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Nick B.:

    E.g. 500 MFAs over 50 states vs. S&P 500. Otherwise, anything can be proven or disproven with this kind of comparison.

     Well, yeah. As I said, it's only one data point -- specifically only 1 of my 6 MF investments and my entire pot is only on year 3 of a 5 year plan. This cannot "prove" anything whatsoever and in any way.

    It is a data point, though, and the very first one I have that I can do any kind of comparison with... hence this comparison. I have every confidence that the rest of my investments will out-perform this one.

  • Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2017 · 69 posts · 64 votes
    5y

    Well! I am a little embarrassed, but it seems that I misread the emails about the sale of above-referenced MFA. The 1.32x multiple I stated as the overall earning was actually just the sale multiple.

    Here is the actual comparison:

    MFA
    Multiple:
    1.52x
    Annualized CoC: 18.0%

    VTSAX
    Multiple: 1.51x
    Annualized CoC: 17.5%

    Far from being resoundingly trounced by the stock market, my underperforming MFA deal actually eeked out a win. Practically speaking, those results are so close as to consider them a wash... but if counting actual dollars earned, there will be a few more in the MFA pile than in the VTSAX pile.

    Worth noting, too, that I haven't paid a penny of taxes on the MFA deal and won't for some time, since I am 1031ing it, an option not even available on VTSAX.

    So yeah, still just one data point and still cannot prove anything whatsoever, but I''ll admit to liking that even an investment that performed notably under expectations still managed to beat the stock market.

  • Specialist · Santa Ana, CA · Member since 2020 · 25 posts · 16 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Mike Lorence:

    Should I do a podcast episode to delve more into the topic on this thread?

     Sounds like a great idea, Mike. Let me know when this episode comes out!

  • Investor · Durham, NC · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 691 votes
    5y

    I agree with @Jeff Greenberg. There is not a plethora of deals like these, so make sure to set your expectations accordingly. Also, projections can be strong indicators but real estate investments always come with risk, and nothing is set in stone. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Boca Raton, FL · Member since 2019 · 70 posts · 42 votes
    5y

    Got it, Steven.  Thanks!

  • Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2017 · 69 posts · 64 votes
    4y

    I now have another (early) sale in my 5-year ladder so let's look at some more real (but simplified) numbers and see how accurate the predictions were.

    This syndicate touted the following projections in their pitch:

    Projections
    Hold: 6 years
    Total ROI: 124.7%
    Annual ROI: 20.7%
    Multiple: 2.24x

    The property didn't make it the full 6 years but rather sold at roughly 3.3 years. To match the predictions, we'd expect numbers similar to these:

    Adjusted Projections
    Hold: 3.3 years
    Total ROI: 68.3%
    Annual ROI: 20.7%
    Multiple: 1.67x
    Projected Profit on $50k investment: $33.5k

    Here's how it actually did:

    Real Results
    Hold: 3.3 years
    Total ROI: 60.9%
    Annual ROI: 18.7%
    Multiple: 1.61x
    Actual Profit on $50k investment: $30.4k

    So it did under-perform (as all of my investments to date have), but only by a little, so that's not too bad.

    The bulk of my investments are still in the stock market, so how would I have done if I had invested in VTSAX instead?

    VTSAX
    Total ROI: 64.1%
    Annual ROI: 19.7%
    Multiple
    : 1.64x
    Profit on $50k investment: $32k

    Okay! We've all seen how the stock market is hitting record highs on a regular basis and yep, this does mean that I would have done better had I invested in VTSAX rather than this deal. C'est la vie!

    And while it's very clear by now that my initial assumptions in the beginning of this thread were wildly unrealistic, let's fact check them anyway, since I did sell my very first two investments from Year 1 of my ladder, one year in advance.

    Projected Year 4
    Invested: $400k
    Distributions
    : $32k (8%)
    Sale Profit: $75k (75%)
    Total Cash: $107k

    Actual Year 4
    Invested: $400k
    Distributions
    : $23k (6%)
    Sale Profit: $32k (32%)
    Total Cash: $55k

    And the distributions aren't event remotely steady, for all sorts of reasons, including the fact that the deals that started this year only have a partial year to pay out and even then, very few actually hit their target the first (or even second) year.

    Finally, here's what my projected distributions since 2018 look like versus what I actually got. Note that this year's distributions only reached as high as they did because the two sales included back porting the 8% preferred.

  • Member since 2021 · 217 posts · 190 votes
    4y

    What you are missing is that if your return and preservation assumptions were dependable, none of the rest of us would waste our time/ effort with much else.

    It ain't gonna be any where near that easy, sorry.

  • Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2017 · 69 posts · 64 votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    What you are missing is that if your return and preservation assumptions were dependable, none of the rest of us would waste our time/ effort with much else. 

    Hey David. I'm not sure what you mean by "[my] return and preservation assumptions were dependable"? 

  • Syndication Expert and Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2016 · 591 posts · 808 votes
    4y

    This was a great thread to go back and read. I'm hoping all who were thinking about investing into MF back 4 years ago did so into good deals with good sponsors. We did ( w/ @Ivan Barratt and others) and have been syndicating our own deals for the past few years now as well. The deals we invested in over the last 4 years many of which are coming full cycles are hitting 2-3.5x returns. 

    Who knows what the next few years will hold but with everything being expensive, MF real estate is still a great asset class to be invested in (we just closed on another 114 units last week). 

  • Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4y

    @Kurt Granroth

    No matter if your projections worked out they way you thought or what the S&P did I think you'll do well in your investing journey over the long term since you have the psychological make up that few investors do: 

    1. you put your investing thesis to paper and in a public forum to boot, which makes it hard to have rose colored glasses when looking back in hindsight; both for failure and success. 

    2. You put your plan into action: seems trivial, but not a lot of ppl do that. 

    3. You benchmark your plan against your most valuable alternative to test for opportunity cost. 

    4. You willingly admit when you got it wrong and learn from them. 

    Impressive stuff that I have no doubt will serve you well in the future. 

    Best of Luck!

  • Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2017 · 69 posts · 64 votes
    4y

    I had the third sale in my portfolio and if I characterize the first sale as a solid but uninspiring single and the second sale as a walk, then this one is an out-of-the-park home run!! Considering that I originally thought that my next sale would be the one with such low expectations that even breaking even would be a win at this point and getting this instead is a trip!

    Following the format of my previous posts on the sales...

    The syndication pitch was like so:

    Projections
    Hold: 5 years
    Total ROI: 95%
    Annual ROI: 19%
    Multiple: 1.95x
    Projected Profit on a $50k investment: $48k

    The property didn't make it even close to the full 5 years but sold after only 14 months!! Matching the predictions to such a small time-frame is a curious task, but let's do it anyway:

    Adjusted Predictions
    Hold: 14 months
    Total ROI: 22%
    Annual ROI: 19%
    Multiple
    : 1.22x
    Projected Profit on a $50k investment: $11k

    Here's how it actually performed:

    Real Results
    Hold: 14 months
    Total ROI: 80%
    Annual ROI: 69%
    Multiple
    : 1.80x
    Actual Profit on a $50k investment: $38k

    It crushed the projections! The annual return doesn't look like a real number and even the total return is within spitting distance of the 5-year projected return but after only a little more than a year! Wow!

    As before, let's compare this to a "what if" I had invested this into VTSAX instead.

    VTSAX
    Total ROI: 9.8%
    Annual ROI: 8.4%
    Multiple
    : 1.10x
    Profit on $50k investment
    : $4.9k

    The very short time frame plus the abysmal year stocks are having this year (which makes an outsized impact on the performance since the time frame is so small) and the stock market had no chance this time around. If it was fair to compare when the stock market was flying high, though, then it's far to compare when it's... not.

    I will freely admit that my FOMO instincts kick in with returns like this and I think "I should have invested $400k into this instead of $50k and then my return would have been $320k instead of 'just' $38k!!" and better believe that a part of me is pushing to invest a notably higher amount with this sponsor in their next deal. But... no. This is just not my style. Even in infinite alternate universes, there are very few to none where I would have invested more than $50k with this particular sponsor and I'm even at least a little hesitant to 1031 this with them since that just continues the high risk train.

    And that's the key. I am a moderately conservative investor who tries to focus on deals that have contingency plans in place if everything goes catastrophically south -- that is, maybe I won't make any money but I definitely don't ever want to lose money. This particular sponsor is shooting for the moon with every deal and they are phenomenally successful (this deal is par for the course for them) because the market they are in is currently completely insane -- it's not possible to not be successful in this market now. It's exhilarating riding this current wave and I do plan on continuing it for at least one more round, but I very much don't want to be on this same ride when it does inevitably start crashing down!

  • Rental Property Investor · Oakland, CA · Member since 2021 · 15 posts · 15 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Kurt Granroth:

    I had the third sale in my portfolio and if I characterize the first sale as a solid but uninspiring single and the second sale as a walk, then this one is an out-of-the-park home run!! Considering that I originally thought that my next sale would be the one with such low expectations that even breaking even would be a win at this point and getting this instead is a trip!

    Following the format of my previous posts on the sales...

    The syndication pitch was like so:

    Projections
    Hold: 5 years
    Total ROI: 95%
    Annual ROI: 19%
    Multiple: 1.95x
    Projected Profit on a $50k investment: $48k

    The property didn't make it even close to the full 5 years but sold after only 14 months!! Matching the predictions to such a small time-frame is a curious task, but let's do it anyway:

    Adjusted Predictions
    Hold: 14 months
    Total ROI: 22%
    Annual ROI: 19%
    Multiple
    : 1.22x
    Projected Profit on a $50k investment: $11k

    Here's how it actually performed:

    Real Results
    Hold: 14 months
    Total ROI: 80%
    Annual ROI: 69%
    Multiple
    : 1.80x
    Actual Profit on a $50k investment: $38k

    It crushed the projections! The annual return doesn't look like a real number and even the total return is within spitting distance of the 5-year projected return but after only a little more than a year! Wow!

    As before, let's compare this to a "what if" I had invested this into VTSAX instead.

    VTSAX
    Total ROI: 9.8%
    Annual ROI: 8.4%
    Multiple
    : 1.10x
    Profit on $50k investment
    : $4.9k

    The very short time frame plus the abysmal year stocks are having this year (which makes an outsized impact on the performance since the time frame is so small) and the stock market had no chance this time around. If it was fair to compare when the stock market was flying high, though, then it's far to compare when it's... not.

    I will freely admit that my FOMO instincts kick in with returns like this and I think "I should have invested $400k into this instead of $50k and then my return would have been $320k instead of 'just' $38k!!" and better believe that a part of me is pushing to invest a notably higher amount with this sponsor in their next deal. But... no. This is just not my style. Even in infinite alternate universes, there are very few to none where I would have invested more than $50k with this particular sponsor and I'm even at least a little hesitant to 1031 this with them since that just continues the high risk train.

    And that's the key. I am a moderately conservative investor who tries to focus on deals that have contingency plans in place if everything goes catastrophically south -- that is, maybe I won't make any money but I definitely don't ever want to lose money. This particular sponsor is shooting for the moon with every deal and they are phenomenally successful (this deal is par for the course for them) because the market they are in is currently completely insane -- it's not possible to not be successful in this market now. It's exhilarating riding this current wave and I do plan on continuing it for at least one more round, but I very much don't want to be on this same ride when it does inevitably start crashing down!

    I was in that deal too. They completely crushed it out of the park! I’m looking forward to the next one 
  • Real Estate Syndicator · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 907 votes
    4y

    In theory this sounds great!  And it is definitely possible.  I would also bake in an X factor of some deals not performing to expectation.  Not all deals are steady and stable cash flow.  That being said, at a macro view, real estate is one of the safest bets you can make.  I suggest connecting with at least 5 different syndicators.  That way you increase the deal flow you see.

  • Paul MoorePro Member
    Commercial Real Estate Fund Manager · Lynchburg, VA · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4y

    Congratulations @Kurt Granroth. It sounds like you have really followed through with your plan and I am happy for you.

    The problem with multifamily right now is that it has passed out of the investing realm and into the speculating realm in many cases. I am thrilled that you and so many others have made a lot of money over a lot of years. But in many cases, not all, the prices have been bid up so much that investors are baking in future appreciation into their current numbers. In other words, they are assuming it will keep going up and up. But trees don't grow to the sky. And hope is not a good business strategy. If I was doing multifamily, I would look for deals that have intrinsic value. Latent untapped value that can be harvested by a new operator. If you cannot find, I would look at other investment types. This was exactly my story, in fact. After writing a book about multifamily investing in 2016, I ventured into the realm of self storage and mobile home parks because of the high number of mom and pop operators leaving a lot of intrinsic value to be harvested. Other asset types like RV parks may be even better. That's my two cents! Congratulations again and happy investing.

  • Don SpaffordPro Member
    Investor · Idaho Falls, ID · Member since 2016 · 935 posts · 629 votes
    4y

    Where I am putting my money now as a passive investor is in RV Campground Resorts. Much higher cash on cash returns and equity multiples. Averaging 15-20% cash on cash and 3x multiple. And the added benefit that you can go there and have fun. Create great lasting memories with your family other than just cleaning out apartments with your kids.

  • Rental Property Investor · Dillsburg, PA · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 14 votes
    4y

    @Kurt Granroth This has been a really neat long term post to read through and digest. I am glad you came back to it and updated the results.  I had not even started any kind of real estate investing four years ago.  20 months ago I bought my first property a pretty much turnkey townhouse during the earlier stages of the pandemic. I thought it was a bunt single, which has now turned into a single with a stolen base.  I invested into a syndication shortly thereafter and the returns have been consistent and solid. We will see about the disposition.  To continue growing my friend and now business partner we purchased a 52-unit apartment complex 14 months ago and it is performing well.  Looking to potentially get into more syndications as they are backed by a hard asset and not by fiat money like the stock market. (Although, I have money in the market and also with my 401K, but another topic).  I like the premise of taking capital and laddering into syndications, provided the Syndicator is reliable and has a great track record. Although, with potential rate hikes, recession and/or stagflation one needs to be very careful.

  • Kenneth VeigaPro Member
    Member since 2018 · 13 posts · 2 votes
    4y

    Solid commentary about the syndication, I have been slow in RE investing since Covid, But the syndication has been working out slowly but steadily. The fiat money stock market has gone all bear, and the future has storm clouds that impact all investments, however it is not necessarily a economic hurricane or tornado.

  • Rental Property Investor · St. Paul, MN · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4y

    Great updates on the investments that you made. Overall, I would say that all deals ended up doing well. Even the one you call a walk, is really a double or triple in the overall investment market. Most investment classes, including stocks don't hit those returns over the long run. You should have invested in my deals though - we beat those returns:) (well not the 14 month flip)
     

  • Cincinnati, OH · Member since 2020 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4y

    @Kurt Granroth, this thread is great, I hope you continue to update it.  There are two pieces that I am always curious about: first is perceived risks, whether those be asset, location or sponsor risk.  I see a lot more decks with class C/D assets in Class C/D areas being pitched as b-/c+.  I know a lot of this is subjective, and I tend to be a cynic, but calling a market 90 minutes (in clear traffic) outside of Atlanta, an Atlanta suburb does not fly.  

    Secondly, the hold period.  Your latest deal sounds like it did really well financially.  BUT, now what...  You have reinvestment risk in, as Paul calls it, a speculative market.  And with current inflation, every day you sit around trying to find the next deal is money out of pocket.  

    An analysis I would like to see is from capital placed and earning vs capital placed and earning. Take your recent deal that exited, and you have those returns.  Continue tracking how your stock market investment would perform all the way through when you can start receiving proceeds on your next deal.  Point being, if the market keeps climbing, versus you having to sit on that cash for the next 12 months searching for the next deal, earning 0% interest, what does that do to your overall return.  Of course, this assumes your money is sitting in checking or savings to be available when the next deal comes around.

  • Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2017 · 69 posts · 64 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Evan Polaski:

    @Kurt GranrothSecondly, the hold period.  Your latest deal sounds like it did really well financially.  BUT, now what...  You have reinvestment risk in, as Paul calls it, a speculative market.  And with current inflation, every day you sit around trying to find the next deal is money out of pocket.  

    An analysis I would like to see is from capital placed and earning vs capital placed and earning. Take your recent deal that exited, and you have those returns.  Continue tracking how your stock market investment would perform all the way through when you can start receiving proceeds on your next deal.  Point being, if the market keeps climbing, versus you having to sit on that cash for the next 12 months searching for the next deal, earning 0% interest, what does that do to your overall return.  Of course, this assumes your money is sitting in checking or savings to be available when the next deal comes around.

    Ah, that is an interesting analysis to make. Of the three exits I've experienced, two have been 1031s and one was a shift into a fund from the same GP (couldn't 1031 it) so all three were transferred from "returned" to "replaced" as quick as could be expected. I do also have a pretty steady pipeline already (and one that is growing) of potential new deals so I'm not sure what the maximum my cash would be sitting might be. Maybe 3-4 months?

  • Investor · Port Hueneme, CA · Member since 2018 · 23 posts · 9 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Don Spafford:

    Where I am putting my money now as a passive investor is in RV Campground Resorts. Much higher cash on cash returns and equity multiples. Averaging 15-20% cash on cash and 3x multiple. And the added benefit that you can go there and have fun. Create great lasting memories with your family other than just cleaning out apartments with your kids.

     Hi Don, who are you investing with passively to get into this niche? Sounds interesting, the first time I've heard of this? DM me if that's more appropriate. 

  • Don SpaffordPro Member
    Investor · Idaho Falls, ID · Member since 2016 · 935 posts · 629 votes
    4y

    @Jacob Rosenkranz Happy to share. It is with Happy Camper Capital.

  • Specialist · Carolina Beach, NC · Member since 2016 · 390 posts · 496 votes
    4y

    Love this update @Kurt Granroth thanks for doing it. 

    I also love your original plan and that's along the lines of what I'm doing for my LP investments. If I can get an annual cash flow of 6-8% on the deals in which I'm a Limited Partner, that's a pretty great passive return for my living expenses, plus the returns from dispositions or refinance allows it to grow each cycle. 

    Please keep us posted about your future deal performances.

  • Real Estate Syndicator · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2018 · 903 posts · 1k+ votes
    4y

    You are not wrong. This has been the case for the last 8-10 years. The only thing is those numbers have been based on a market in expansion. At present 12%-16% are for more realistic for a 5 year projection. If a group is giving you the 20% projection return in five years today, ensure that the exit cap rate and exit interest rate projection of a buyer match up. With interest rates rising, a new buyer will of course be buying different in 5 years.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.